Acernus Aero Limited v Vincent Aviation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2012-485-113 [2013] NZHC 595

UNDER  Section 256 of the Property Law Act 2007 and High Court Rule 7.53

BETWEEN  ACERNUS   AERO   LIMITED   a   duly incorporated company having its registered office  at  level  6,  Woodward  House,  188

Lambton  Quay,  Wellington,  Charter  Air

Service Operator

Plaintiff

ANDVINCENT AVIATION  LIMITED  a duly incorporated company having its registered office at 95 Tirangi Road, Rongotai, Wellington, Air Transport Operator

Defendant

Hearing:         11-13 February 2013

Counsel:         J Toebes and J Grant for Plaintiff

J Scragg and P Higbee for Defendant

Judgment:      26 March 2013

JUDGMENT OF MILLER J

Introduction

[1]    Acernus Aero owns a Cessna Citation 510 Mustang jet aircraft, registration ZK-MUS.    It  is  the second  such Cessna that  Acernus  has  owned.    They were successively involved in the events that led to this litigation, but nothing turns on the identity of the aircraft at any given point in time, so I will not normally distinguish

between them.

ACERNUS AERO LIMITED v VINCENT AVIATION LIMITED HC WN CIV-2012-485-113 [26 March 2013]

[2]    The first Cessna arrived in New Zealand on 12 February 2008.   It and later ZK-MUS were hangared at the premises of Vincent Aviation, which are situated at Wellington Airport, until February 2011.   Acernus paid $1,666.67 plus GST per month for hangarage.  Vincent also maintained the aircraft at Acernus’s expense.

[3]    The aircraft was substantially put to work transporting Acernus’s principals, Mike Garnham and Andrew Fawcett, and their associates.  But Acernus also wanted to charter it.  That required that it be entered on an air operator’s certificate (AOC) issued under rule 119, in accordance with Part 135 of the Civil Aviation Rules (NZ) (this is known as a Part 135 certificate).  Vincent agreed to add the aircraft to its own certificate.  That was done on 27 July 2010. Until March 2011 both parties chartered the aircraft, sharing revenue on an agreed basis.

[4]    On 12 November 2010 Vincent proposed to increase hangarage fees to $8,000 per month.  Acernus did not agree.  Vincent sent Acernus a notice of termination by letter of 22 December 2010, and in February 2011 it acted, removing the aircraft from its hangar complex.   On 18 February it told Acernus that the existing arrangement was not satisfactory and gave notice that the aircraft would be deleted from its AOC on 31 March.

[5]    These actions led to some acrimonious negotiations.  On 8 April 2011 Vincent told Acernus that it would accept $7,000 per month, comprising $3,000 for rent and

$4,000 for use of Vincent’s AOC.  Acernus did not respond, but it continued to use hangar space and to charter the aircraft.  It made no payments at all after May 2011.

[6]    On 1 December 2011 Vincent gave notice of termination, and on 19 January

2012 it terminated summarily for non-payment of $101,788.88.

[7]    It was until trial in dispute that on termination Acernus was in fact in arrears of hangarage payments.  I was told at the end of the trial that a sum of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Acernus Aero Limited v Vincent Aviation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 595
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Acernus Aero Limited sued Vincent Aviation Limited in the High Court of New Zealand for various breaches of contract and other claims arising out of the termination of a business relationship between the two companies. Vincent had provided hangarage and administrative services to Acernus for its Cessna Citation 510 Mustang jet aircraft. The primary dispute was over the nature of the arrangement between the parties, the reasonableness of the termination notice, and the validity of certain charges made by Vincent. The court found that the arrangement was a bailment rather than a lease or licence. Consequently, the notice period requirements for leases or licences did not apply. The court also determined that Vincent was entitled to charge Acernus for hangarage and AOC fees based on the reasonable notice given. However, Acernus was not liable for third-party charges incurred by Vincent on charters. Vincent's claims for additional sums for hangarage and AOC fees were partially successful, while its claim for damages for lost charter revenue failed. The court dismissed Acernus's claims for relief against forfeiture and wrongful termination. Vincent was awarded $7,510.95 in costs.