YXVZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

YXVZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2020] AATA 4802 (27 November 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2020/0071      

Re:YXVZ  

APPLICANT

Child Support RegistrarAnd  

RESPONDENT

And

FQNP

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Mr S. Webb, Member

Ms F. Hewson, Member

Date:27 November 2020

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review the objection decision under s 87AA(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

..........[sgd]..............................................................

Mr S. Webb, Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CHILD SUPPORT – care percentage decision for each parent of a child during a period – objection lodged by one parent more than 28 days later – objection allowed – delayed lodgement not prevented by special circumstances – no discretion to vary date of effect imposed by statute – no application for AAT first review - application by other parent for AAT first review of care percentage decision – decision substituted with no change to date of effect – application for AAT second review – Tribunal has no jurisdiction in respect of special circumstances decision.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 25, 29, 29AA, 29AB, 43
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 Pt 5, Div 4, Subdiv B, ss 5, 54B, 54C
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 ss 4, 80A, 87, 87AA, 89, 91, 92, 95E, 95N, 96A

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond [1990] HCA 33
Child Support Registrar v MQMV [2019] FCA 1171
Kerford and Secretary, Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs [2009] AATA 148

ZGCJ and Child Support Registrar [2020] AATA 4481

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr S. Webb, Member
Ms F. Hewson, Member

26 November 2020

  1. This application arises from a dispute between parents of a child who is now an adult (the child). The applicant (YXVZ) and the other party (FQNP) shared care for the child. The dispute is about care percentage decisions in respect of a past care period in 2018.

  2. As with so many cases of this kind, there are issues of sensitivity involved. We will tread carefully when dealing with such matters, and we will not refer to each party and those involved by name, applying pseudonyms to protect their privacy. There are also issues of money in the background – care percentages are applied when calculating the amount of a parent’s child support obligation, and they are applied when calculating Family Tax Benefit (FTB) payments and overpayment debts. None of those matters are presently before this Tribunal.

  3. In the course of proceedings an issue has arisen in relation to the Tribunal’s jurisdiction to determine the date of effect should it decide to vary or set aside the decision under review. The issue arises from a decision of the Child Support Registrar (Registrar)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read YXVZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4802
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a dispute between YXVZ and FQNP regarding child support arrangements for their child. The core of the dispute involved a series of decisions by the Child Support Registrar concerning the percentage of care each parent provided for the child, particularly in the period following the child turning 18 and completing high school. The case came before the Tribunal for a second review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on first review.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the AAT's decision on first review constituted a "care percentage decision" for the purposes of the Tribunal's second review jurisdiction, and consequently, whether the Tribunal had the power to review that decision. The Tribunal was required to interpret the definition of "care percentage decision" as it appears in section 4(1) of the Registration Act and consider its application to decisions made under various provisions of the Assessment Act, including those relating to the date of effect of objections.

The Tribunal reasoned that the definition of "care percentage decision" is broad and not confined to decisions made under a specific subdivision of the Assessment Act. It noted that the definition encompasses decisions that "wholly or partly" "involve" a determination of a person's percentage of care for a child. Applying this broad interpretation, the Tribunal concluded that the AAT's decision on first review, which altered the care percentages for the child, fell within the scope of a "care percentage decision" and was therefore susceptible to a second review by the Tribunal. The Tribunal also considered section 87AA of the Registration Act, which deals with the date of effect of objections to care percentage decisions, indicating its relevance to the broader context of care percentage determinations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Who may apply for review

Background

Background to the litigation

It is these matters alone that we will deal with in this interlocutory decision.Facts The following facts arise from the materials before the Tribunal and are established to our reasonable satisfaction. In the child support assessment period from 19 December 2017 to 22 May 2018, the following care percentages applied in respect of the child: YXVZ – 73 percent; FQNP – 27 percent.[1][1] T6 folios 37-38. On 17 May 2018, the child turned 18. YXVZ applied for an extension of child support arrangements while the child completed high school. This was accepted by the Registrar and notices extending child support to 23 November 2018 were issued.[2] A new Child Support Assessment notice was issued, extending the care percentages to 23 November 2018: YXVZ – 73 percent; FQNP – 27 percent.[3][2] T5 folios 24-26.[3] T5 folios 27-29. On 5 June 2018, FQNP informed the Registrar that the child was 100 percent in his care from 23 May 2018.[4] On 6 June 2018, the Registrar sent a notice to YXVZ, setting out this information and inviting comment.[5][4] T22 folio 263.[5] T4. On 29 June 2018, the Registrar notified YXVZ of a change in the care percentage in respect of the child from 23 May 2018: YXVZ – 0 percent; FQNP – 100 percent.[6] This is the ‘original decision’ in the present dispute.[6] T6 folios 35, 40-41. On 23 November 2018, the child completed high school and the child support ‘care period’ came to an end. In the period from 7 December 2018 to 13 May 2019, it appears that YXVZ contacted, or was contacted by, the Child Support Agency in respect of care percentages for the child.[7] [7] See T22 folios 269-275; T9 refers. On 13 May 2019, YXVZ objected to the Registrar’s care percentage decision of 29 June 2018 and lodged an objection by email dated 20 May 2019.[8] [8] T11. On 29 July 2019, the Registrar allowed the objection, reinstating the previously applicable care percentages for each parent: YXVZ – 73 percent; FQNP – 27 percent.[9] Importantly, the Registrar decided that this change would have effect to the child support assessment from 13 May 2019, being the date of YXVZ’s objection. This resulted in no change to the assessment of child support in the period from 23 May 2018 to 23 November 2018, when the child support obligation in respect of the child came to an end.[9] T16 folio 124. This notwithstanding, FQNP objected to the care percentages determined in the Registrar’s decision[10] and supplied additional information.[11][10] T22 folios 283-285.[11] T17, T18 and T19. On 28 August 2019, FQNP made an application for AAT first review of the Registrar’s care percentage decision – this is recorded in a brief written record of the application.[12] We understand that the application was made orally, by telephone. [12] T20. On 12 November 2019, the first review Tribunal made the following decision –The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and, in substitution, decides that the care percentages for [the child] from 23 May 2018 are 30% for [YXVZ] and 70% for [FQNP].This decision has effect from 13 May 2019.[13] [13] T2 folio 4.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The term ‘care percentage decision’ is defined in s 4(1) of the Registration Act – care percentage decision means a decision as to the particulars of an administrative assessment, or as to the particulars of a notional assessment, to the extent that the decision involves (wholly or partly): (a) a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under a provision of Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act; or (b) a determination relating to a person that has effect, under section 54K of that Act, as if it were a determination made under such a provision. We note in passing that the term ‘administrative assessment’ is given meaning in s 5(1) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Assessment Act) and refers to an assessment under Part 5 of that Act, whereas the term ‘notional assessment’ is given meaning under s 146E of the Assessment Act, which is not presently relevant. As can be seen from the definition, a ‘care percentage decision’ is one made under Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act or s 54K of that Act in Subdivision D of Part 4, which deals with applying percentages of care determined under the A New Tax System (Family Assistance) Act 1999 for child support purposes. Essentially, a decision of this kind requires consideration of the arrangement and provision of care, the pattern of care and changes in care for a child (and related matters) during a care period. This includes the determination of days to which the particular care percentages apply, under s 54B or s 54C of the Assessment Act. Furthermore, a ‘care percentage decision’ is a ‘decision as to the particulars’ of an assessment that ‘wholly or partly’ ‘involves’ a determination of a person’s percentage of care for a child. The words ‘wholly or partly’ and ‘involves’ convey a broad scope that is not confined to a decision made under Subdivision B of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Assessment Act.[17] In resolving this issue, we are guided as much as we are bound by what Flick J decided in MQMV’s case at [46] –To be susceptible to “second review” the decision of the Tribunal on “first review” does not have to be one made exclusively under Subdiv B but rather be one which “involve[d] (wholly or partly) ... a determination made under a provision of Subdivision B...”…[17] MQMV v Child Support Registrar [2019] FCA 1171 at [45]. For the purposes of s 96A(b) of the Registration Act and the Tribunal’s second review jurisdiction, there is a question whether a decision under s 87AA(2) is a decision of this kind – a ‘care percentage decision’. 87AA Date of effect of objections relating to care percentage decisions that are allowed (1) If: (a) a person lodges, under section 80A, an objection to a care percentage decision; and (b) the objection is lodged more than 28 days or, if the person is a resident of a reciprocating jurisdiction, 90 days after notice of the care percentage decision was served; and (c) the Registrar decides (the review decision), under section 87, to allow the objection in a way that has the effect of varying the determination to which the care percentage decision relates, or substituting a new determination;the date of effect of the review decision is the day on which the person lodged the objection. (2) If the Registrar is satisfied that there are special circumstances that prevented the person from lodging the objection within the period referred to in paragraph (1)(b), the Registrar may determine that subsection (1) applies as if: (a) in a case where the person is a resident of a reciprocating jurisdiction—the reference to 90 days in that paragraph were a reference to such longer period as the Registrar determines to be appropriate; or (b) otherwise—the reference to 28 days in that paragraph were a reference to such longer period as the Registrar determines to be appropriate. (3) If: (a) the Registrar decides to make a determination under subsection (2) in relation to a person; or (b) the Registrar decides not to make such a determination in relation to a person;the Registrar must give written notice of the decision to each person affected by the decision. (4) The notice must: (a) set out the reasons for the decision; and (b) include a statement to the effect that, if the person is aggrieved by the decision, application may be made, subject to this Act and the AAT Act, to the AAT for review of the decision. (5) A contravention of subsection (4) in relation to a decision does not affect the validity of the decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established