MMZG and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

MMZG and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 2619 (30 July 2021)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/4450

Re:MMZG

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndZVSD

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member P Ranson

Date:30 July 2021

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal sets aside the decision in AAT1 and in substitution decides for the period 28 November 2018, and until a change of circumstances warrants a change (but no earlier than 31 January 2021), the care percentage of the Daughter is 41% to MMZG and 59% to ZVSD commencing on 28 November 2018.

.........[SGD].......................................................

Member P Ranson

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)-16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords
CHILD SUPPORT – care percentage decision – where parents agree as to percentage of care – where objection filed outside 28 day period – whether Tribunal prevented from considering date of effect – whether special circumstances prevented lodging of objection within time – special circumstances shown – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 

Child Support (Registration & Collection) Act 1988

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Cases

Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

YXVZ and Child Support Registrar [2020] AATA 4802

Secondary Materials

Guides to Social Policy Law, Child Support Guide, Version 4.57, released 1 July 2021

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member P Ranson

30 July 2021

BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant (MMZG) and the Other Party (ZVSD) are the separated parents of a daughter was born in 2008 (the Daughter). Her care has been shared between her parents since separation. The care is mostly in accordance with court orders made in 2012, viz, 58/42 in favour of ZVSD, but sometimes more to ZVSD depending on MMZG’s prevailing circumstances. ZVSD and MMZG both provide a home for the Daughter when she is in their care. MMZG is the Daughter’s father, and ZVSD is the Daughter’s mother.

  2. The orders of the then Federal Magistrates Court concerning care of the Daughter, made in 2012, required MMZG to have five nights of care per fortnight during school terms and half the school holidays. In practice, the parents applied those orders with the first five nights for MMZG commencing in the first week of a new school term regardless of whether his time in the proceeding school holidays was the first or second half. That results in a care determination of 58% to ZVSD and 42% to MMZG.

  3. In addition to the child support implications that arise from the appropriate percentage of care, ZVSD and MMZG both claimed FTB at different times and in different percentages, which are affected by the assessed care. The earlier years’ care percentages are relevant to this decision in that the parents acted in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MMZG and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 2619
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review of a child support care percentage decision, brought before the Tribunal by MMZG against the Child Support Registrar. The dispute arose from a care determination made by Centrelink on 20 September 2019, which altered the care percentages to 61% for ZVSD and 39% for MMZG. MMZG lodged an objection to this decision on 12 November 2019, claiming his percentage should be 43%. This objection was initially disallowed, leading MMZG to seek a review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether it had the power to consider an objection lodged outside the statutory 28-day period, and if so, whether special circumstances existed that prevented MMZG from lodging his objection within the prescribed time. Additionally, the Tribunal was required to determine the correct care percentages and the date from which these percentages should take effect, given the parties' agreement on the actual care arrangements.

The Tribunal found that MMZG had indeed lodged his objection outside the 28-day timeframe. However, applying section 87AA(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth), the Tribunal determined that special circumstances were present. These circumstances arose from MMZG receiving multiple decisions from Centrelink simultaneously, making it unreasonable to expect him to adequately assimilate the information and prepare objections within the standard period. Consequently, the Tribunal granted an extension of time for the objection. Furthermore, the parties ultimately agreed that the care percentages were 41% for MMZG and 59% for ZVSD, and that this arrangement commenced on 28 November 2018.

The Tribunal set aside the objection decision and substituted it with a new decision reflecting the agreed care percentages of 41% for MMZG and 59% for ZVSD, effective from 28 November 2018.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal has considered all the material supplied to it and the oral evidence of the MMZG and the ZVSD. Not all the evidence is referred to at length in this decision. That does not mean it has not been considered in determining the outcome. It is sometimes unnecessary to canvass all aspects, arguments, and history of a case.THE FACTS AND EVIDENCEOrders of the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia On 13 September 2012, the then Federal Magistrates Court of Australia made orders concerning the care of the Daughter. Those orders specified, inter alia, the Daughter would live with ZVSD unless she was ‘spending time with’ MMZG. Once she attended school, the Daughter was to spend five nights per fortnight during school terms with MMZG and half of the school holidays. The parents abided by these orders and as discussed above at [‎4] they mutually agreed the five nights during school terms for MMZG would always commence in the first week of the new school term regardless of who had care of the Daughter during the last week of the previous holidays. This results in a theoretical pattern of care of 58% to ZVSD and 42% to MMZG.Agreed changes to the pattern of care MMZG’s evidence is the care arrangement discussed above applied until 28 November 2017 after which, and for a specific time period, he was not able to maintain that level of care and the percentages were changed by the Respondent to 63% to ZVSD and 37% to MMZG. MMZG unsuccessfully challenged this decision which applied until 28 November 2018. From 28 November 2018 MMZG says he was able to resume the care arrangements contemplated by the court orders and notified Centrelink to revert to 58% to ZVSD and 42% to him. According the Respondent’s SFIC, on 17 December 2018 MMZG notified Centrelink there had been a change in care such that the 58:42 arrangement should be reinstated saying the care percentages should be the same as when the court orders were followed from 2015 to 2017. It is possible Centrelink misunderstood MMZG when he said there had been no change of care and the percentages should revert to those of court orders as interpreted by the parents as Centrelink, at that time, refused to make the change because they said there was no change of care. Subsequently, on 20 September 2019, Centrelink made a new care determination which reflected that the care of the Daughter had changed on 28 November 2018. That determination changed the care to 61% to ZVSD and 39% to MMZG (the 2019 Care Decision). MMZG objected to that decision on 12 November 2019 claiming his percentage should be 43% (the 2019 Care Objection). His objection was disallowed on 16 April 2020 and so MMZG applied to the AAT1 for a review of that decision. On 12 June 2020, the AAT1 affirmed the objection decision after which MMZG applied to the General Division of this Tribunal for a further review.Calendars of care Both parents provided calendars of care for the Daughter for the period 28 November 2018 to approximately February 2021. MMZG did so in his first submission however it was unclear to the Tribunal exactly what his markings referred to. MMZG was asked to further clarify the matter, and did so.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The 2019 Care Decision was dated 20 September 2019. Section 163(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (the Evidence Act) provides a letter sent by pre-paid post from a Commonwealth agency is presumed to have been sent on the fifth business day following the date of the letter, viz, 30 September 2019.[7] Section 160(1) of the Evidence Act allows seven working days for delivery of a letter to a specified address in Australia.[8] Delivery of the 2019 Care Decision to MMZG in Cairns is presumed to be 9 October 2019.[9][7] The letter was sent from the Melbourne office of Centrelink. There was a public holiday in Melbourne on 27 September 2019.[8] A working day means a day that is not a Saturday or a Sunday or a public or bank holiday in the place to which the postal article was addressed.[9] Monday 7 October 2019 was a public holiday in Queensland. MMZG submitted he received the 2019 Care Decision on 10 October 2019 amongst a bundle of letters containing nine separate decisions. The Tribunal notes that the Applicant’s submission is broadly in line with what is expected under the statutory timeframes outlined above. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary, the Tribunal accepts all 12 letters were received together on 10 October 2019. 28 days from 10 October 2019 is 7 November 2019. The 2019 Care Objection is dated 6 November 2019. However, it was received by the Department on 12 November 2019, that is, outside the statutory 28-day time period allowed for objections. That alone, however, does not mean that further time cannot be afforded to MMZG. Section 87AA(2) of the Collection Act permits the Tribunal to determine an objection period longer than 28 days if the decision maker is satisfied that special circumstances prevented MMZG from lodging the objection within the 28 day period.Are there any special circumstances? Given s 87AA(2)(b) of the Collection Act allows 28 days to object to a decision, the Tribunal considers it unreasonable to expect 12 letters, including nine decisions, to be adequately assimilated and objections prepared within 28 days, given the abundance of information which arrived at one time. That is particularly so when an individual receiving only one decision would be afforded the same amount of time. Accordingly, the Tribunal finds there are special circumstances and grants an extension of time to 12 November 2019 for MMZG to formally object to the 2019 Care Decision, which means his 2019 Care Objection was received within the requisite timeframe.When did the change of care commence? It is uncontroversial MMZG contacted the then Department of Human Services on 17 December 2018 and advised there had been a change in the pattern of care, being a return to the previous care arrangements as set out in the court orders, albeit his description of the change may have been confusing to the officer at Centrelink with whom he spoke. Given that the parties now agree as to the percentage of care, and when that change took place, the Tribunal finds that MMZG’s contact was a notification to the Registrar that a change of care had taken place.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Subsequently, on 20 September 2019, Centrelink made a new care determination which reflected that the care of the Daughter had changed on 28 November 2018. That determination changed the care to 61% to ZVSD and 39% to MMZG (the 2019 Care Decision). MMZG objected to that decision on 12 November 2019 claiming his percentage should be 43% (the 2019 Care Objection). His objection was disallowed on 16 April 2020 and so MMZG applied to the AAT1 for a review of that decision. On 12 June 2020, the AAT1 affirmed the objection decision after which MMZG applied to the General Division of this Tribunal for a further review.Calendars of care Both parents provided calendars of care for the Daughter for the period 28 November 2018 to approximately February 2021. MMZG did so in his first submission however it was unclear to the Tribunal exactly what his markings referred to. MMZG was asked to further clarify the matter, and did so. At the hearing, the differences in calendars of care was canvassed by the Tribunal with the parties. It became apparent both parents had completed their calendar based on the nights the Daughter should have been in their overnight care rather than the actual nights of overnight care. Mostly, but not always, the actual and the theoretical are the same. MMZG made the point he was sometimes away for work purposes when the Daughter was to be with him, and he could arrange for the Daughter to stay with friends. ZVSD refuses to accept that arrangement stating the Daughter must be with her if she cannot be with her father. The Tribunal considers that position to be consistent with the court orders which say at clause (4):‘That the child live with the Mother at all times other than those that the child is spending time with the Father pursuant to orders (5), (6) and (7) herein.’ In any event, the Tribunal analysed both calendars and came to a preliminary view that the percentages of care were 41% to MMZG and 59% to ZVSD. These percentages were arrived at by rounding down the result if less than 50% and rounding up if the result if more than 50%. The Tribunal asked both MMZG and ZVSD whether they accepted those percentages applied between the dates 28 November 2018 to 31 January 2021. Both parties ultimately agreed that was the case. The Tribunal notes that there was some expectation that the care between the parties may change in late January 2021, because the Daughter was due to begin secondary schooling. It was anticipated that she would have one additional week of school holidays per year. Though that issue is not before the Tribunal, it remained open to MMZG and ZVSD to update the Respondent as to the shared care of the Daughter once that change took place. It may be that the cost percentage changes as a result, but that is not an issue that the Tribunal is required to consider. Given that the allocation of care of the Daughter as 41% to MMZG and 59% to ZVSD was no longer in dispute between the parties, and that the Tribunal is satisfied that the care percentage is correct, the Tribunal now turns to the issue of when the percentage of care decision comes into effect.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established