Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Ltd (No 4) [2017] FCA 456

Appeal from: Application for extension of time: Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Ltd & Anor [2016] FCCA 989
File number: NSD 920 of 2016
Judge: LEE J
Date of judgment: 5 May 2017
Catchwords:

COSTS – application for third party costs order against solicitors where an application for an extension of time to appeal orders made by the Federal Circuit Court was dismissed by another Judge of the Court - lack of reasonable basis for conspiracy allegation – award of indemnity costs

EVIDENCE – General - admissibility of findings in previous judgment where respondents to costs application are non-parties – consideration of the application of s 91(1) of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), s 58(3)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), ss 91(1), 92, 93, 93(c), Pt 3.5

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 43, 43(3)(f), Pt VB, 37N(4), 37M, 37N(2)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 36.05

Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2015 (NSW), r 21.4

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Olex Australia Pty Limited [2017] FCA 222

Australian Wool Innovation Ltd v Newkirk [2005] ATPR 42-053; [2005] FCA 290

Colgate-Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Limited (1993) 46 FCR 225

Flinn v Flinn [1999] VSCA 134

Hughes Trueman Pty Limited v Young [2017] FCCA 468 Hughes Trueman Pty Limited v Young (No. 2) [2017] FCCA 601

Latoudis v Casey (1990) 170 CLR 534

Levick v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2000) 102 FCR 155

Macteldir Pty Limited v Roskov [2007] FCAFC 49

Margo Young v Brendan King & Anor [2017] HCASL 28

Mitry Lawyers v Barnden [2014] FCA 918

Modra v State of Victoria (2012) 205 FCR 445

National Mutual Life Association of Australasia Limited v Grosvenor Hill (Queensland) (Formerly Hillier, Parker (Queensland) Pty Limited) (2001) 183 ALR 700

R v Associated Northern Collieries (1911) 14 CLR 387

Re Condor Blanco Mines Ltd (No. 3) [2017] NSWSC 65

Symphony Group PLC v Hodgson [1994] QB 179

Talacko v Talacko [2014] VSC 328

White Industries (Qld) Pty Ltd v Flower & Hart (1998) 156 ALR 169

Young v Hones [2017] HCASL 27

Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Limited (No. 3) [2017] FCA 235

Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Limited [2016] FCCA 989 Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Limited (No. 2) [2017] FCA 87

Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1176

Young v King (No 9) [2016] NSWLEC 4

Young v King (No. 11) [2017] NSWLEC 34

Young v King [2016] NSWCA 282

Yu v Cao (2015) 91 NSWLR 190

Date of hearing: 27 April 2017
Date of last submissions: 28 April 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 59
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant did not appear
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr S Gray
Solicitor for the Respondents: Kennedys
Solicitor for the Respondents to Interlocutory Application…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 456
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves the application by two respondents for an order for the solicitors representing the applicant, Mrs Young, to pay their costs on an indemnity basis in relation to an application for an extension of time to appeal filed on 9 June 2016. The application was made to the Federal Circuit Court. The legal issues before the court included whether the allegation of conspiracy was reasonable and if the application for costs was supported by evidence. The court also considered the admissibility of findings from previous judgments, particularly in relation to non-parties.

The court found that there was no reasonable basis for the allegation of conspiracy made by the solicitors in the application for an extension of time. This conclusion was based on the lack of evidence supporting the conspiracy claim. Additionally, the court found that the allegation of conspiracy was part of a broader pattern of misconduct by the solicitors, which justified the award of indemnity costs. The court examined the application of section 91(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) and determined that the evidence from previous judgments was admissible in this case.

The court ordered that the solicitors, Leonardo Carlo Muriniti and Robert Duane Newell, jointly and severally pay the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the application for an extension of time, including the costs of the interlocutory application, on an indemnity basis. The court also granted liberty to the respondents to apply to extend the costs order if 'L C Muriniti & Associates' is found to be a legal entity.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leonardo Carlo Muriniti and Robert Duane Newell jointly and severally pay the costs of the respondents of and incidental to the application for an extension of time filed by the applicant on 9 June 2016 (including the costs of the interlocutory application filed on 21 November 2016) on an indemnity basis.

2. Liberty to the respondents to apply by 4:15 pm today to extend the costs order made in order 1, in the event ‘L C Muriniti & Associates’ is a legal entity.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Added to this is a further development that has resulted in the Special Costs Application being heard before me. On 10 April 2017, an order was sought that Bromwich J “recuse himself from hearing and determining” the Special Costs Application (in fact, notwithstanding her bankruptcy, Mrs Young was listed as the “applicant”). Bromwich J dismissed this application on 21 April 2017, however, his Honour, in any event, “independently recused himself”. PROCESS AND EVIDENCE The interlocutory application filed by the respondents (being an engineer retained by Mrs Young who participated in a conclave in the L&E Court held in relation to the drainage dispute and his employer) seeks an order in the following terms: [O]rder that:a. the law practice of L.C. Muriniti & Associates (Muriniti & Associates):b.Leonardo Carlo Muriniti, a legal practitioner, the solicitor on the record for the Applicant, and the Principal of the law practice L.C. Muriniti & Associates (Mr Muriniti); and/orc.Robert Duane Newell, a legal practitioner employed by Muriniti & Associates (Mr Newell),indemnify the First and Second Respondents against any costs payable by them in relation to the Application for Extension of Time filed on behalf of the Applicant on 9 June 2016 (the Application), including on the indemnity basis, pursuant to section 43 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and rule 40.07 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). An application for leave (raised for the first time on the morning of the hearing) to pursue alternative orders that would have provided that the bankrupt Mrs Young pay the respondents’ costs (with or without an indemnity from the Solicitors) was ultimately not pressed. Of course, those aspects of the interlocutory application that sought relief against Mrs Young were, upon her bankruptcy, stayed by reason of s 58(3) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). For reasons I will come to, it is important that there be clarity as to what is and what is not before me on the Special Costs Application. Both the respondents and the Solicitors agreed, at the outset of the hearing, that the evidentiary material to which Bromwich J was expressly taken at the hearing on 21 July 2016 (which led to the Principal Judgment) and the transcript of that hearing were before me. I have reviewed that material. The respondents, as the moving parties, relevantly tendered additional material directed at demonstrating that shortly after the filing of Mrs Young's notice of motion in the L&E Court on 20 August 2015 (L&E Costs Application), there was correspondence from Kennedys, who acted for the respondents, referring to various allegations made in the L&E Costs Application and: (a) relevantly reminded the Solicitors that an unwarranted allegation of fraud, when there is no sufficient factual basis, would constitute serious misconduct and would trigger what was described as the “jurisdiction” to award indemnity costs and personal costs orders; and (b) invited the Solicitors to withdraw the allegations of fraud, conspiracy and serious misconduct.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is unnecessary for me to detail the long running controversy spanning six courts which has, as its genesis, a drainage dispute between neighbours. This has already been done by others including Sheahan J in Young v King (No 9) [2016] NSWLEC 4 at [3] - [11], Bromwich J in Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1176 (Principal Judgment) at [8] - [28], and Emmett AJA in Young v King [2016] NSWCA 282 at [28] - [85]. Before I come to the substance of the Special Costs Application brought against L C Muriniti & Associates (LMA), Mr Muriniti (the solicitor for the applicant (Mrs Young) and principal of LMA) and Mr Newell (who is described as an employed solicitor of LMA) (collectively, the Solicitors), I should summarise developments since the delivery of the Principal Judgment:(a)on 19 October 2016, the Court of Appeal of New South Wales dismissed an application for leave to appeal against an unsuccessful attempt by Mrs Young to set aside consent orders made in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales (L&E Court): Young v King [2016] NSWCA 282;(b)on 9 December 2016, an application was filed in the High Court on behalf of Mrs Young for an order to show cause in relation to a decision of the Federal Circuit Court (Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Limited [2016] FCCA 989) and the refusal of an extension of time to file a notice of appeal from that decision, being the Principal Judgment;(c)on 9 February 2017, Bromwich J refused an application for the adjournment of a hearing of an application for a stay of the Special Costs Application: Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Limited (No. 2) [2017] FCA 87;(d)on 1 March 2017, the High Court refused a second application for special leave from an earlier Court of Appeal Judgment: Young v Hones [2017] HCASL 27 and an application for an extension of time for special leave from the October 2016 Court of Appeal decision (see a. above): Young v Brendan King & Anor [2017] HCASL 28; (e)on 10 March 2017, Bromwich J refused an application by the Solicitors (and Mrs Young) to adjourn the Special Costs Application: Young v Hughes Trueman Pty Limited (No. 3) [2017] FCA 235;(f)on 23 March 2017, a sequestration order was made by the Federal Circuit Court against the estate of Mrs Young and a stay of that sequestration order was refused: Hughes Trueman Pty Limited v Young [2017] FCCA 468 and Hughes Trueman Pty Limited v Young (No. 2) [2017] FCCA 601;(g)on 27 March 2017, Sheahan J ordered the Solicitors to pay, jointly and severally (and on an indemnity basis), the costs incurred by some of the 18 named respondents who had previously successfully resisted an application filed by Mrs Young for indemnity costs in her favour against Mr and Mrs King (who were parties to the original drainage dispute) and 16 non-parties including the present respondents: Young v King (No. 11) [2017] NSWLEC 34;(h)on 12 April 2017, a notice of appeal was filed in this Court from the sequestration order and related orders made by the Federal Circuit Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.