Wylie v The ANI Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Wylie v The ANI Corporation Limited [2000] QCA 314
PARTIES: THOMAS JOHNSTON WYLIE
(plaintiff/respondent)
v
THE ANI CORPORATION LIMITED  ACN 000 421 358
(defendant/appellant)
FILE NO/S: Appeal No 4092 of 1999
DC No 2999 of 1996
DIVISION: Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING: General Civil Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON: 4 August 2000
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 5 April 2000
JUDGES:

McMurdo P, Thomas JA, Ambrose J

Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDER: Appeal dismissed with costs to be assessed.
CATCHWORDS:

EMPLOYMENT LAW – THE CONTRACT OF SERVICE AND RIGHTS, DUTIES AND LIABILITIES AS BETWEEN EMPLOYER AND EMPLOYEE – THE CONTRACT OF SERVICE GENERALLY – FORMATION AND CONSTRUCTION - Whether implied term in employment contract for employee to carry out employment with due care and skill – employee’s obligation to take reasonable care for own safety – whether employee breached implied term

EMPLOYMENT LAW – THE CONTRACT OF SERVICE AND RIGHTS, DUTIES AND LIABILITIES AS BETWEEN EMPLOYER AND EMPLOYEE – REMEDIES UPON BREACH – AGAINST EMPLOYEE – Whether employer entitled to be indemnified by employee for damages caused by employee’s negligence – consideration of application of Lister v Romford Ice & Cold Storage in Australia

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE – DAMAGE – CAUSATION – GENERALLY

EMPLOYMENT LAW – THE CONTRACT OF SERVICE AND RIGHTS, DUTIES AND LIABILITIES AS BETWEEN EMPLOYER AND EMPLOYEE – LIABILITY OF EMPLOYER FOR INJURY TO EMPLOYEE AT COMMON LAW – SAFE SYSTEM OF WORK – GENERALLY – Whether the employer’s breach caused employee’s injuries – where failure by employer to provide safe system of work

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE – QUALIFICATION OF GENERAL RULE - “LAST OPPORTUNITY”

EMPLOYMENT LAW – THE CONTRACT OF SERVICE AND RIGHTS, DUTIES AND LIABILITIES AS BETWEEN EMPLOYER AND EMPLOYEE – LIABILITY OF EMPLOYER FOR INJURY TO EMPLOYEE AT COMMON LAW – CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE – Whether contract damages could be reduced for employee’s contributory negligence – Astley v Austrust Ltd considered

Law Reform Act 1995 (Qld), s 10

A R Griffiths & Sons Pty Ltd v Richards [2000] 1 Qd R 116, considered
Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Limited (1987) 9 NSWLR 310, considered
Alford v Magee (1951-1952) 85 CLR 437, considered
Astley v Austrust (1999) 161 ALR 155; (1999) 73 ALJR 403, considered
Banque Keyser SA v Skandia (UK) Insurance [1990] 1 QB 665, considered
BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire Council (1977) 52 ALJR 20, considered
Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (1982) 149 CLR 337, considered
Country Limited v Girozentrale Securities [1996] 3 All ER 834, considered
Davies v Mann (1842) 10 M & W 546, 152 ER 588, considered
Grayson Ltd v Ellerman Line Ltd [1920] AC 466, considered
Heskell v Continental Express Ltd [1951] All ER 1033, considered
Kelly v Alford [1988] 1…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wylie v The ANI Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] QCA 314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wylie brought an action against The ANI Corporation Limited seeking damages for injuries sustained in a workplace accident. Wylie was operating an overhead crane when a bolster swung against him, causing injury. The District Court found that Wylie's employer had not provided any training or a safe system of work, and Wylie himself had acted negligently. The trial judge held that Wylie's employer was liable for negligence and Wylie was 50% contributory negligent. The judge granted Wylie full damages for breach of contract, applying Astley v Austrust Ltd, and dismissed the employer's claim to reduce damages for Wylie's contributory negligence. The employer appealed, arguing that Wylie's negligence was the true cause of his injuries and that the employer's breach was not the cause. The employer also argued that the court should not apply the contemporary test of causation in negligence when the cause of action is for breach of contract.

The court considered whether an implied term existed in the employment contract for Wylie to carry out his duties with due care and skill. The court held that such an implied term existed, and that Wylie's breach of this term caused his injuries. However, the court held that the employer's breach of its own contractual obligation to provide a safe system of work also caused Wylie's injuries. The court held that Wylie's employer was liable for damages for its breach of contract, and that Wylie's contributory negligence could not reduce the employer's liability. The court held that Astley v Austrust Ltd meant that the employer could not reduce its liability for its breach of contract because of Wylie's contributory negligence.

The appeal was dismissed. The court held that Wylie's employer was liable for the full amount of damages awarded by the trial judge. Wylie's employer was ordered to pay Wylie's costs of the appeal and the application for leave to appeal. The costs of the appeal were to be assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs to be assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion Since Astley, where an employee suffers injury in the workplace caused by the employer's breach of contract of employment, damages will no longer be able to be reduced because of the employee's contributory negligence. The commendable spirit of modern workplace health and safety legislation[53] requires that employer and employee cooperatively work together to develop and maintain a safe workplace. It is not inconsistent with that spirit to require workers to be accountable for their own negligence consistent with their tortious obligations and apportionment legislation. The effect of Astley goes well beyond cases involving personal injury in the course of employment. But it is for the legislature, not the courts, to consider whether the law should be changed to reflect the position generally thought to exist before Astley.[53]See, for example, Workplace Health and Safety Act 1995 (Qld), the Second Reading Speech Queensland Parliamentary Debates vol 332, 22 March 1995, 11231-11232, Schiliro v Peppercorn Child Care Centres Pty Ltd [2000] QCA 18 [24], [25], [31]; Workcover Queensland Act 1996 ss 6 and 312-314 and 1996 Queensland Acts Explanatory Notes, 720 at 727 and 840. I would dismiss the appeal. I note the appellant has already been ordered to pay the respondent's costs of this appeal and of the application for leave to appeal. The appeal should be dismissed with costs to be assessed. THOMAS JA: The plaintiff brought an action in the District Court for damages sustained by him in an accident at work on 1 July 1994. He was operating an overhead crane. He operated the controls in such a way that a bolster hanging from the crane swung against him causing personal injury. The learned trial judge found that there was no training or instruction given to the plaintiff and no system implemented in relation to the safe operation of the crane. His Honour was also of the view that the plaintiff unnecessarily and negligently put himself in a very dangerous position. In the result his Honour held that insofar as the action was one of damages for negligence, the defendant employer was guilty of negligence and the plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence which he assessed at 50 per cent. The plaintiff's pleading, as is common in such cases, was based upon "breach of contract and/or negligence". Insofar as the action was based upon breach of contract, his Honour, in reliance upon Astley v Austrust Ltd[54] held that no deduction was available for any contributory negligence of the plaintiff, and in the result granted judgment for the plaintiff for the full amount of damages assessed ($40,347) and a further sum for interest and costs.[54](1999) 73 ALJR 403; [1999] HCA 6, 4 March 1999. Before giving judgment the learned trial judge refused the defendant's application to amend the defence to plead an implied term in the contract of employment, namely: On the appeal, however, Mr Keane QC for the appellant employer did not seek to support the above somewhat diffuse implied term, or the counterclaim. Instead he submitted that the respondent employee owed a contractual obligation to carry out his duties with due care and skill, and formulated the employee's duty as one to use reasonable care in the course of his duties. He submitted that having regard to the nature of the breaches found to have been committed by both parties, his Honour should have found that the true cause of the plaintiff's damage was his own lack of care rather than that of his employer. In short his principal submission was that the breach by the employer was not the cause of the plaintiff's damages. He further submitted that the contemporary relatively undemanding test of causation in negligence cases[55] which developed after the apportionment legislation does not apply when the cause of action is for breach of contract[56]. [55]March v Stramare (E & MH) Proprietary Limited (1990-1991) 171 CLR 506.[56]ibid pp 511-514; Heskell v Continental Express Ltd (1950) 1 All ER 1033, 1047.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established