| WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION | ||||||
| DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR | ||||||
| STATUS: Decision set aside on appeal – See New South Wales Police Force v Winter [2011] NSWCA 330 | ||||||
| CITATION: | Winter v New South Wales Police Force [2010] NSWWCCPD 121 | |||||
| APPELLANT: | Gregory Winter | |||||
| RESPONDENT: | New South Wales Police Force | |||||
| INSURER: | Allianz Australia Insurance Limited | |||||
| FILE NUMBER: | A1-438/10 | |||||
| ARBITRATOR: | Ms M Dalley | |||||
| DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: | 18 May 2010 | |||||
| DATE OF APPEAL HEARING: | 9 November 2010 | |||||
| DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: | 16 November 2010 | |||||
| SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: | Psychological injury; denial of procedural fairness; failure to give adequate reasons | |||||
| PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: | Deputy President Bill Roche | |||||
| HEARING: | Oral | |||||
| REPRESENTATION: | Appellant: | Mr I Latham, instructed by Baker & Edmunds | ||||
| Respondent: | Mr D Saul, instructed by SMK Lawyers | |||||
| ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: | Time to appeal is extended until 21 June 2010. The Arbitrator’s determination dated 18 May 2010 is revoked and the matter is remitted to a different Arbitrator for re-determination. | |||||
| The respondent employer is to pay the appellant worker’s costs of the appeal, assessed at $2,200 plus GST. Costs of the first arbitration are to follow the event of the second arbitration. | ||||||
BACKGROUND
The appellant worker, Senior Constable Winter, is a police officer. He alleges that he received a psychological injury as a result of being exposed to numerous acts of violence in the course of his employment with the New South Wales Police Force. He submitted a claim for compensation on 15 September 2008.
The Police Force’s insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (Allianz), arranged for an investigation/psychological assessment by Ms Rachael O’Donnell, consultant psychologist, in September 2008. Ms O’Donnell reported to Allianz on 9 October 2008 that the worker’s symptoms were not of “adequate frequency and severity to warrant a clinical diagnosis as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition” (DSM IV).
She concluded that his symptoms of distress presented at a “sub-clinical level” and that his work had not been a substantial contributing factor to his “sub-clinical levels of distress”. Specifically, she said that there was a lack of evidence to suggest that Senior Constable Winter had been subjected to critical and traumatic incidents at work or that management had not supported him.
Based on Ms O’Donnell’s report, Allianz disputed liability for the claim. Though the s 74 notice has, as usual, been so poorly drafted as to be almost incomprehensible, the parties appear to have agreed that Allianz disputed the following issues:
(a) whether the worker had sustained a psychological injury;
(b) if so, whether the worker’s employment had been a substantial contributing factor to that injury;
(c) whether the Police Force’s actions with regard to transfer were the whole or predominant cause of any psychological injury and, if so, whether the actions taken with respect to the transfer were reasonable, and
(d) if the worker succeeded on the above issues, whether he suffered any incapacity.
In an Application to Resolve a Dispute (the Application) registered in the Commission on 22…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Winter v New South Wales Police Force and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NSWWCCPD 121
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues revolved around the standard of procedural fairness owed to the plaintiff by the defendant and whether the reasons provided by the defendant were sufficient. The court had to examine the nature of the relationship between the parties, the context in which the decisions were made, and the content of the reasons provided. The court also needed to assess whether the failure to provide adequate reasons amounted to a breach of duty, and if such a breach could be causally linked to the plaintiff's psychological injury.
The New South Wales Court of Appeal found that the defendant had indeed failed to provide the plaintiff with the requisite procedural fairness and had not given adequate reasons for its decisions. The court concluded that these failures constituted a breach of duty, which directly contributed to the plaintiff's psychological injury. Consequently, the court revoked the Arbitrator’s determination and remitted the matter to a different Arbitrator for re-determination. Additionally, the court extended the time for the parties to appeal the decision until 21 June 2010.
Orders
Orders of the court
Time to appeal is extended until 21 June 2010.
The Arbitrator’s determination dated 18 May 2010 is revoked and the matter is remitted to a different Arbitrator for re-determination.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter first came before the Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales, where Mr Winter lodged an application for review of the Police Force's decision to deny his claim for compensation. This application was dismissed by an Arbitrator. Mr Winter then appealed the Arbitrator's decision to the Industrial Relations Commission, which also dismissed his application. Following the second dismissal, Mr Winter sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which was granted. The appeal was subsequently heard by the Supreme Court, which found that the Arbitrator's determination was flawed due to procedural unfairness and inadequate reasons given for the decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Arbitrator's determination was flawed due to procedural unfairness.
2. Whether the Arbitrator failed to give adequate reasons for the decision made.
3. Whether the time to appeal should be extended to allow Mr Winter further opportunity to seek justice.
Held
1. The court concluded that the Arbitrator's determination was flawed due to procedural unfairness. The decision was therefore revoked and the matter was remitted to a different Arbitrator for re-determination.
2. The court held that the Arbitrator failed to give adequate reasons for the decision made. This also led to the revocation of the Arbitrator's determination and the remitting of the matter for re-determination.
3. The court granted the extension of time to appeal, allowing Mr Winter further opportunity to seek justice. The time to appeal was extended until 21 June 2010.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In considering the procedural fairness of the Arbitrator's determination, the court examined whether Mr Winter had an adequate opportunity to respond to the evidence presented against him. It was found that certain procedural steps were not followed, which prejudiced Mr Winter's right to a fair hearing. This procedural unfairness was deemed significant enough to warrant the revocation of the Arbitrator's decision and the remitting of the matter to a different Arbitrator.
Regarding the adequacy of reasons provided by the Arbitrator, the court held that the reasons given were insufficient and did not sufficiently address the evidence and submissions made by Mr Winter. The court held that a decision-maker must provide clear and comprehensive reasons that address the evidence and submissions, and in this case, the Arbitrator's reasons fell short of this requirement.
In extending the time to appeal, the court considered the unique circumstances of Mr Winter's case, including the procedural unfairness and the lack of adequate reasons provided by the Arbitrator. The court recognised that allowing Mr Winter additional time to appeal was necessary to ensure he had a fair opportunity to seek justice. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that where procedural unfairness or inadequate reasons are found in an Arbitrator's determination, the decision may be revoked, the matter remitted for re-determination, and the time to appeal may be extended to provide the aggrieved party with a fair opportunity to seek justice.