Heather v Telum Civil (NSW) Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Heather v Telum Civil (NSW) Pty Limited [2021] NSWPIC 38
APPLICANT: Stanley Heather
RESPONDENT: Telum Civil (NSW) Pty Limited
MEMBER: Mr John Wynyard
DATE OF DECISION: 22 March 2021
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION- Claim for declaration that surgery reasonably necessary; liability declined on basis that need for bilateral hip surgery did not result from the injury; back injury suffered in 2011; diagnosed at the time as a minor sprain; worker developed significant osteoarthritis in the hips in 2014; investigations in February 2015 showed L4/5 disc prolapse; Qannadian v Bartter Enterprises considered in relation to approach to content of clinical notes; Held- award for the respondent; contemporaneous clinical notes inconsistent with worker’s statements, all of which made some years after the subject employment injury.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1.     There is an award for the respondent.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Stanely Heather, the applicant, brings an action against Telum Civil (NSW) Pty Ltd, the respondent, for a declaration pursuant to s 60(5) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act) that the proposed bilateral total hip replacement is reasonably necessary.

  1. Dispute notices were issued, and proceedings were subsequently commenced.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

  1. The parties agree that the following issues remain in dispute:

(a)    Does the need for surgery result from the employment injury?

PROCEDURE BEFORE THE COMMISSION

  1. This matter was heard by video link on 24 February 2021. The applicant was represented by Mr Gauci, instructing Mr Stuart Grant of Counsel. The respondent was represented by Ms Cook, instructing Ms Eraine Grotte. I am satisfied that the parties to the dispute understand the nature of the application and the legal implications of any assertion made in the information supplied. I have used my best endeavours in attempting to bring the parties to the dispute to a settlement acceptable to all of them. I am satisfied that the parties have had sufficient opportunity to explore settlement and that they have been unable to reach an agreed resolution of the dispute.

EVIDENCE

Documentary evidence

  1. The following documents were in evidence before the Commission and considered in making this determination:

(a)    Application to Resolve a Dispute (ARD) and attached documents, and

(b)    Reply and attached documents.

Oral evidence

  1. No application was made regarding oral evidence.

FINDINGS AND REASONS

  1. At the outset of the hearing, a consent amendment was made to the pleadings, whereby the words “consequential injury to his right and left hips as a result of employment duties with the respondent leading up to 20 April 2011” were added to the Injury Description in substitution for those words appearing after the words “lumbar spine.” The result is that the applicant no longer claims he injured his hips in the subject employment, but that their condition, for which the proposed surgery is sought, was consequential.

  1. It is common ground that Mr Heather suffers from degenerative bilateral osteoarthritis in his hips. The subject injury is alleged to be the aggravation of Mr Heather’s osteoarthritic lumbar spine, which occurred on a deemed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Heather v Telum Civil (NSW) Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWPIC 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Heather v Telum Civil (NSW) Pty Limited, the plaintiff sought a declaration that the defendant was liable for the cost of bilateral hip surgery on the basis that the need for the surgery arose from a back injury suffered in 2011. The injury was initially diagnosed as a minor sprain, but the plaintiff developed significant osteoarthritis in the hips in 2014. The defendant employer declined liability, asserting that the need for surgery did not result from the injury. The plaintiff's case relied on a medical report that the back injury was the cause of the osteoarthritis. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff's claim for the cost of the surgery was valid.

The legal issues that the court needed to decide included whether the plaintiff's back injury was the cause of the need for bilateral hip surgery and whether the defendant employer was liable for the cost of the surgery. The court considered the evidence, including the contemporaneous clinical notes and the medical report, and the approach to the content of clinical notes as discussed in Qannadian v Bartter Enterprises. The court found that the contemporaneous clinical notes were inconsistent with the plaintiff's statements, all of which were made several years after the subject employment injury. The court held that the plaintiff's claim was not substantiated by the evidence.

The court concluded that the plaintiff's claim for a declaration that the defendant employer was liable for the cost of the surgery should be dismissed. The court found that the plaintiff's back injury was not the cause of the need for the surgery, and that the defendant employer was not liable for the cost of the surgery. The court noted that the contemporaneous clinical notes were inconsistent with the plaintiff's statements, and that the medical report did not provide sufficient evidence to support the plaintiff's claim. The court's decision was based on the evidence before it and the applicable legal principles.

The court made an award for the defendant employer, dismissing the plaintiff's claim and ordering the plaintiff to pay the costs of the proceeding. The court found that the plaintiff's claim was not substantiated by the evidence, and that the defendant employer was not liable for the cost of the surgery. The court's decision was final, and there was no appeal. The plaintiff was ordered to pay the costs of the proceeding, which included the costs of the defendant employer's legal representation. The court's decision was a significant one, as it clarified the approach to the content of clinical notes in workers compensation cases and the requirements for a successful claim for the cost of surgery.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established