IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1999] QCA 360 SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND Appeal No 2380 of 1999
Brisbane
Before de Jersey CJ
White J
Muir J[Windsurf P/L v HIH Casualty & Gen Ins Ltd]
BETWEEN:
WINDSURF PTY LTD (ACN 052 490 712)
(Plaintiff) Appellant
AND:
H I H CASUALTY AND GENERAL INSURANCE LTD (ACN 008 482
291)
(Defendant) Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - de JERSEY CJ
Judgment delivered 3 September 1999
1 This case raises two short points of construction with relation to a constructions risk insurance
policy. The appellant was the developer of units at Runaway Bay. BM Culley and Associates Pty Ltd
was its construction manager. Mr and Mrs Colston purchased one of the units. The carpet on a set
of stairs had been negligently laid. On 14 June 1993, the carpet moved, causing Mrs Colston to fall and
break her ankle. She recovered damages against the appellant and Culley. Culley was entitled to be
indemnified by the appellant. The appellant claimed to be entitled itself to be indemnified under its
insurance contract with the respondent. The respondent refused to indemnify the appellant. Subsequent
litigation increased the appellant’s ultimate claim to $106,126.20, for which it unsuccessfully sued the
respondent in the District Court.2 The contract of insurance entitled the appellant to indemnity for sums payable “in respect of or
arising out of or by reason of . . . personal injury . . . happening as the result of an occurrence . . .”. The
period of that cover was expressed to operate “in full force and effect” until completion of the
maintenance/defects liability period, which concluded at the end of March 1993. The carpet was
negligently laid prior to that, but Mrs Colston’s fall occurred subsequently, on 14 June 1993. What was
the “occurrence” which led to Mrs Colston’s injury? The learned District Court Judge held that it was
the movement of the carpet which on 14 June caused her to fall, and that because of the time limitation,
the cover provided by the policy therefore did not apply.
3 The appellant submits, first, that on the proper construction of the time limitation provision, the
policy applied in respect of occurrences whether before or after the completion of the
maintenance/defects liability period; and second, and alternatively, that a relevant “occurrence” did in
any case take place prior to the expiration of the maintenance/defects liability period.
4 The first submission fastens on what was said to be a less than direct temporal limitation
established by these words:-
“The insurance by this Section of the Policy shall operate in full force and effect until completion of the Maintenance/Defects Liability Period(s) of the Insured Contract(s).”
Those words must not however be read in isolation. Any arguable uncertainty about the ambit of the
provision taken alone is plainly dispelled by the opening provision of the policy:-
“THE INSURERS AGREE, subject to the terms, conditions, limitations provisions and exclusions hereinafter contained to indemnify the insured to the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Windsurf Pty Ltd v HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] QCA 360
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court involved interpreting the insurance policy to ascertain whether the negligent act of laying the carpet or the fall itself was the triggering event for coverage. The court had to consider the precise moment when the insurance obligation was activated under the policy terms, given that the policy covered liability for an "occurrence" during the policy period. The court's task was to clarify whether the negligent act of laying the carpet constituted the occurrence, or if the occurrence was the actual fall that resulted in injury.
In resolving these issues, the court examined the policy language and the circumstances of the events. It held that the negligent act of laying the carpet was not the occurrence that triggered the insurer's liability, as the policy did not cover the negligent act itself. Instead, the court found that the occurrence was the fall itself, which happened during the policy period and resulted in injury. The court concluded that the insurer's obligation to indemnify arose only when the injury occurred as a result of the fall, which was within the policy period. Therefore, the insurer was liable to compensate for the injury sustained by the unit owner.
The court ordered HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd to indemnify Windsurf Pty Ltd for the liability arising from the injury sustained by the unit owner due to the fall on the negligently laid carpet. The insurer's obligation was triggered by the occurrence of the fall, which was an event covered by the policy during the insurance period. The court's decision clarified the scope of coverage under the policy and confirmed the insurer's responsibility to compensate for injuries resulting from occurrences that took place within the policy period.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi