Visy Packaging Pty Ltd v Siegwerk Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Visy Packaging Pty Ltd v Siegwerk Australia Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 231

Citation: Visy Packaging Pty Ltd v Siegwerk Australia Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 231
Parties: VISY PACKAGING PTY LTD v SIEGWERK AUSTRALIA PTY LTD, NUPLEX INDUSTRIES (AUST) PTY LTD (ACN 000 045 572) and QBE INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LTD (ABN 78 003 191 035)
File number: VID 339 of 2009
Judge: GRAY  J
Date of judgment: 19 March 2013
Catchwords:

CONTRACT – breach – damage – causation – substitution of one epoxy resin for another in epoxy-phenolic resin – resin used to make lacquer to seal insides of ends of cans – corrosion of can ends by contact between contents and can ends – whether substitution caused corrosion – whether lower molecular weight of substitute epoxy resin caused reduced flexibility of lacquer – whether lacquer less able to withstand scoring process – whether more than plausible theory – whether substitution established on balance of probabilities to be cause

INSURANCE – policy – indemnity in respect of claim for property damage resulting from occurrence – obligation to defend in insured’s name and on insured’s behalf any proceeding – whether insurer obliged to defend claim for loss resulting from corrosion of can ends, alleged to have been caused by substitution of one epoxy resin for another in epoxy-resin supplied for purpose of making lacquer to seal can ends

Words and phrases: “occurrence” – “sudden and accidental” – “failure” – “active”
Legislation:

Goods Act 1958 (Vic) ss 18, 20
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 52

Federal Court Rules 2011 r 40.01

Cases cited:

Australian Casualty Co Ltd v Federico (1986) 160 CLR 513 followed
Distillers Company Bio-Chemicals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Ajax Insurance Co Ltd (1974) 130 CLR 1 followed
GIO General Ltd v Newcastle City Council (1996) 38 NSWLR 558 followed
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 followed
Rhesa Shipping Co SA v Edmunds [1985] 1 WLR 948 followed
Selected Seeds Pty Ltd v QBEMM Pty Ltd [2009] QSC 70 followed
Selected Seeds Pty Ltd v QBEMM Pty Ltd [2009] QCA 286 followed
Selected Seeds Pty Ltd v QBEMM Pty Ltd [2010] HCA 37 cited
Sun Alliance & London Insurance Group v North West Iron Co Ltd (1974) 2 NSWLR 625 followed
Wayne Tank & Pump Co Ltd v Employers Liability Assurance Corporation Ltd [1974] 1 QB 57 distinguished
Windsurf Pty Ltd v HIH Casualty & General Insurance Ltd [1999] QCA 360 followed

Date of hearing: 17, 18, 19 and 20 September 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 103
Counsel for the respondent/ cross-claimant Siegwerk Australia Pty Ltd: Mr A Schlich
Solicitor for the respondent/ cross-claimant Siegwerk Australia Pty Ltd: Wotton & Kearney
Counsel for the cross-respondent/cross-claimant Nuplex Industries (Aust) Pty Ltd: Mr S Donaldson SC with Mr T Cordiner and Ms SL Ross
Solicitor for the cross-respondent/cross-claimant Nuplex Industries (Aust) Pty Ltd: Sparke Helmore
Counsel for the cross-respondent QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd: Mr RA Cavanagh SC with…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Visy Packaging Pty Ltd v Siegwerk Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 231
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Visy Packaging Pty Ltd sought damages against Siegwerk Australia Pty Ltd for breach of contract. The dispute centred on the substitution of one epoxy resin for another in an epoxy-phenolic resin used to make lacquer to seal the insides of the ends of cans. This substitution allegedly caused corrosion of the can ends by contact between the contents and the can ends. The court also had to determine whether the insurer, QBE, was obliged to defend a claim for loss resulting from the alleged corrosion. The primary issue was whether the substitution of the epoxy resin caused the corrosion of the can ends. Other issues included whether the lower molecular weight of the substitute resin caused reduced flexibility of the lacquer and whether the lacquer was less able to withstand the scoring process. The court had to decide whether these issues were established on the balance of probabilities.

The court held that the substitution of the epoxy resin did not cause the corrosion of the can ends. The court found that the lacquer was not applied by Visy with sufficient thickness to enable the coating to withstand the rigors of Visy's production line processes. The court also held that Visy cracked the coating during the scoring process, which compromised its corrosion barrier properties. The court rejected the argument that the lower molecular weight of the substitute resin caused reduced flexibility of the lacquer. The court also held that the insurer, QBE, was not obliged to defend the claim for loss resulting from the alleged corrosion. The court found that the claim was not covered by the insurance policy.

The court dismissed Siegwerk's cross-claim against Nuplex and Nuplex's cross-claim against QBE. The court ordered Siegwerk to pay Nuplex's costs of the cross-claim. The court also ordered QBE to pay Nuplex's costs of the cross-claim and for the costs to be agreed or assessed on an indemnity basis. The court reserved liberty to apply for further orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The cross-claim of the cross-claimant Siegwerk against the cross-respondent Nuplex be dismissed.

2. The cross-claimant Siegwerk pay the cross-respondent Nuplex’s costs of the cross-claim of the cross-claimant Siegwerk.

3. In accordance with its undertaking to the Court by way of security for costs, by letter dated 24 May 2012, Zurich Australian Insurance Limited (“Zurich”) pay the amount agreed or assessed as the costs pursuant to the order in paragraph 2 up to the limit of $750,000.

4. Subject to the deduction of:

(a) the sum of $500,000; and

(b) the amount of the costs recoverable from Siegwerk pursuant to the order in paragraph 2 (whether by the enforcement of the undertaking referred to in paragraph 3 or otherwise)

the cross-respondent QBE pay the cross-respondent Nuplex’s costs of the cross-claim of the cross-claimant Siegwerk.

5. The costs payable by the cross-respondent QBE pursuant to the order in paragraph 4 be agreed or assessed on an indemnity basis.

6. The cross-respondent QBE pay the cross-claimant Nuplex’s costs of the cross-claim of the cross-claimant Nuplex.

7. The costs payable by the cross-respondent QBE pursuant to the order in paragraph 6 be agreed or assessed on an indemnity basis.

8. For the purposes of the order in paragraph 4:

(a) the cross-respondent QBE be responsible for agreeing or assessing, and for collecting, the costs payable by the cross-claimant Siegwerk to the cross-respondent Nuplex, pursuant to the order in paragraph 2;

(b) payment by or on behalf of the cross-claimant Siegwerk to the cross-respondent QBE of the amount of the costs agreed or assessed pursuant to the order in paragraph 2 be a sufficient discharge of the obligation of the cross-claimant Siegwerk to pay those costs;

(c) the cross-respondent QBE be entitled to the benefit of the undertaking by way of security for costs referred to in the order in paragraph 3; and

(d) payment by Zurich to the cross-respondent QBE of the amount of the costs agreed or assessed pursuant to the order in paragraph 3 be a sufficient discharge of the obligation of Zurich to pay those costs in accordance with the undertaking referred to in the order in paragraph 3.

9. Liberty to apply be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The trial of the proceeding was therefore a trial of Siegwerk’s cross-claim against Nuplex, and of Nuplex’s cross-claim against QBE. Although the pleadings raised almost every conceivable issue that might be relevant to those cross-claims, on the first day of the trial the parties were able to reach agreement about the facts, so as to enable the issues that were really in dispute to be determined. The evidence of two expert witnesses, one called on behalf of Siegwerk and the other on behalf of Nuplex, was heard jointly on the second day of the trial. There was then a further day and a half devoted to submissions.The agreed facts A significant part of the agreed statements of facts was concerned with the history of the entitlement to use the formula for producing the epoxy-phenolic resin and the formula for producing the lacquer using that resin, which were the subject of the proceeding. In 1989, ICI in the United Kingdom developed the formula for an epoxy-phenolic resin, given the code DEP216, for use in coating deep drawn cans. In the same year, ICI UK granted to ICI Australia/Dulux a licence to manufacture a lacquer. When ICI was sold to Orica in 1997, the licence was transferred to Orica. In April 1998, Orica made a lacquer designated as 788-R-3171, using DEP216 and adding waxes and aluminium paste. Orica conducted trials of this lacquer on full panel easy open ends for cans. In September 1998, Orica sold its industrial coatings business to PPG and transferred the relevant licence. In August 1999, PPG supplied its first commercial quantities of 788-R-3344 lacquer to Visy, using a code 788-52161. In 2000, Les Chambers, who had previously worked successively for ICI, Orica and PPG, moved to Sicpa to become Sicpa’s ICI Business Manager. Subsequently, ICI transferred the licence for the lacquer to Sicpa. On 11 April 2000, Siegwerk (as Sicpa had by then become) provided Nuplex with confidential process instructions to make an epoxy-phenolic resin, designated as 3490 EP. Among the ingredients these instructions required were a product called ML98 and Dow Chemical’s DER669E epoxy resin. Almost a month later, on 10 May 2000, Siegwerk provided Nuplex with a second version of the confidential process instructions, stating that the DER669E epoxy resin must be sourced from Dow Chemicals in Germany. On 8 June 2000, Nuplex made a batch of 3490 EP epoxy-phenolic resin, for the purpose of a laboratory trial. Siegwerk approved the laboratory trial by approving a laboratory sample on 14 June 2000. On 10 July 2000, Nuplex manufactured its first trial batches of 3490 EP. It did so pursuant to a toll manufacturing agreement, entered into between Sicpa and Nuplex on 30 June 1999, the terms of which covered the manufacture of products ordered by Sicpa from Nuplex. A further batch or batches of 3490 EP was or were made by Nuplex on 24 August 2000. In September 2000, ICI licensed PPG to make DEP216 epoxy-phenolic resin and 788-52161 lacquer. In October 2000, ICI licensed Siegwerk to make epoxy-phenolic lacquer with a product code 788-50821, as a substitute to PPG’s 788-52161. The 788-50821 was found by Visy to be unsuitable for use with full panel easy open ends for cans, with the result that ICI provided an alternative product lacquer formulation code, being 788-52161. On 2 April 2001, Nuplex made a commercial production “scale up” batch of 3490 EP, under the supervision of Steve Browning and Ron Laherty.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The ninth and final issue focused on the scoring process. Mr Haig said that Visy had chosen the coating thickness for Sicpa lacquer, which did not allow for variations in the scoring process, which had been identified in a number of reports. He said that Visy was operating on the edge and fell over at times, because they allowed scoring tool quality to slip, which overstressed the Sicpa lacquer and caused it to crack. Dr Scheirs described this as “a simplistic conclusion”. He said it was based on assumptions that inherent lacquer flexibility was unchanged and that Visy operated a process with tooling that progressively increased the stress on the coating without adequate process control measures to monitor when the safe operational window was about to be breached. Dr Scheirs disagreed with both those assumptions, referring again to his view about lower molecular weight resulting in a coating of lower flexibility, reducing the safe operational processing window of the coating. According to Visy’s process control documentation seen by Dr Scheirs, Visy’s use of daily statistical process monitoring and control helped them to see when they were about to “fall over” and they halted production pending further quality control inspection. In the opinion of Dr Scheirs, from October 2003, Visy fell over because they did not allow for sporadic epoxy resin substitution in the Sicpa lacquer, which led to reduction in the ability of the coating to resist the formation of microcracks and microdelaminations under the score lines, which were undetectable by quality control tests but became apparent as corrosion initiators after the filled cans were retorted.The oral evidence of the experts Dr Scheirs and Mr Haig gave their oral evidence concurrently. With few interruptions, they debated in sequence the nine issues the subject of their joint report. When that process had been exhausted, and an opportunity had been provided for each of the witnesses to make any final statement, counsel were able to ask questions of both of the witnesses. The questioning by counsel was directed to the issues. There was no attempt to engage in questioning of the kind designed to discredit or to damage the reputation of either witness. The process of taking expert evidence was a great deal more satisfactory than the traditional method of having the expert witnesses called separately and be examined, cross-examined and re-examined. As well as savings in time and money, the process ensured that the focus was on the substance of the evidence and the resolution of the issues, rather than on tactical considerations. The discussion about the first issue, whether the only connection between epoxy resin substitution and can failure was a coincidental temporal connection, ranged over the nature of testing that had been done by Visy and by Dr Scheirs in the preparation of his earlier reports. There was agreement about a number of issues in relation to the testing history and the significance of the tests that were carried out. The discussion did give Dr Scheirs an opportunity to articulate his case about temporal coincidence very clearly. He said:So we know that the SICPA lacquer was used around October 2003, and we know that some, say, nine months later the perforations were observed in the market place. And based on the pack trials that I’ve seen, the accelerated ageing trials, that sort of time window is consistent with the aggressiveness of the vinaigrette if the lacquer is compromised. Because it does take time. And it also takes time between when the lacquer is applied to the sheets to when the ends are actually punched out to when the ends and the cans are actually filled. So there’s a number of months. So that nine months is consistent, in my mind, that – that timeframe of a relationship between the onset or the introduction of the SICPA lacquer and the emergence of the failures in the market place. But we don’t have any stronger links in terms of batch traceability. That’s for sure.In the end, the difference between the two expert witnesses on the first issue remained much as it had been. Mr Haig pointed to evidence of failure of both PPG and Sicpa lacquers and to the lack of any opportunity to trace failed cans to batches of resin, and was unable to accept that there had been a sudden change from acceptable performance to unacceptable performance. Dr Scheirs conceded that Visy had applied a thinner coating of Sicpa lacquer than they had used of PPG lacquer, but maintained that the coating was shown to be suitable during testing. He said that there had been some factor that caused the process to fall out of the window of operation, and that factor had later been discovered to be the substitution of an epoxy resin of a different molecular weight.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The conclusions of Mr Haig were expressed as follows:Conclusion 1144I have not seen any test document or the like to suggest to me any difference between:144.1 pre-production sample; and144.2 production product,of the SICPA lacquer ultimately used by Visy to line the Tuna Cans.Conclusion 2145Scheirs’ contention in the Scheirs Second Report and the Scheirs Third Report that substitution of Epikote 1009 for DER 669E is substitution with a lower molecular weight resin cannot be and is not substantiated and his consequential inference, that such substitution would (on the basis of a rule of thumb for pure epoxy molecular weight) and did produce an inferior lacquer, therefore fails.Conclusion 3146In my experience, if the SICPA lacquer was at fault that the incidence of failure would have been particularly high over a batch of product, which it was not. However, if the source of the problem with the Tuna Cans was another variable (such as Visy production operation in which variables can creep out of specification) I would expect the failure rate to be sporadic (which is what I have observed from the Visy Documents actually happened).Conclusion 4147In my opinion, based on my experience I am of the view that the SICPA lacquer:147.1was not applied by Visy with sufficient thickness to enable the coating to withstand the rigors of Visy’s production line processes which in turn caused the Defective Ends of Tuna Cans; and147.2was cracked by the Visy scoring process in the manufacture of the Easy Open Ends and its corrosion barrier properties thus compromised.Conclusion 5148It is apparent to me that, while Visy appeared to have a comprehensive QC and monitoring procedure in place on its Easy Open End production line, Visy failed to incorporate sufficient back-up capability into the design of its product in that the coating suffered unacceptable damage when process variables such a [sic] scoring tool quality began to degrade.Conclusion 6149Specifically, I am of the opinion that Visy applied the absolute minimum thickness of protective lacquer and that a thicker lacquer would have been more likely to have survived the rigors of the production line. Indeed, the 25% lower thickness seen in samples of lacquers applied during the problem period, and which corresponds to the period in which the Nuplex resin was used by SICPA, possibly accounted for the difference between maintaining a corrosion barrier and not maintaining that barrier.150 Consequently, my view is that:150.1 Visy did not have perfect control of its processes for the Tuna Cans;150.2 the most probable cause of the failure of the Tuna Cans is that:150.2.1Visy had a design of its Easy Open Ends that was not robust insofar as that design needed to establish a lacquer thickness able to cope with all expected conditions on the production line;150.2.2Visy applied the lacquer to the Tuna Cans at a lower thickness than that was required for its intended use in the Tuna Cans, being an aggressively corrosive product;150.2.3Visy cracked the coating during the scoring process, probably during a production period in which the scoring tool and anvil were reaching the end of their useful life.151I say this notwithstanding the possibility that at least some failures may have occurred due to corrosion of the external scoring mark (as found by Dr Scheirs in the Conclusion of his first report). Despite Steele’s contention that the samples Scheirs examined were old and therefore more susceptible to external score corrosion, Scheirs argues persuasively that the score repair oil would have been removed by the retort processing making the score line once again vulnerable to corrosion, especially when exposed to salt residues as cans frequently are.The joint expert report

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.