SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
PARTIES:
QBE INSURANCE LTD ACN 000157899
(applicant)v
MGM PLUMBING PTY LTD ACN 056644136
(respondent)FILE NO/S:
SC No 762 of 2002
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court Townsville
DELIVERED ON:
19 February 2003
DELIVERED AT:
Townsville
HEARING DATE:
5 February 2003
JUDGE:
B W Ambrose J
ORDER:
I make the following declarations –
1. Each occurrence of property damage to an individual property as a result of alleged defective waterproofing works performed by MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd and particularised by Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd which forms part of the claim by Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd against the respondent is a separate occurrence under the relevant policies of insurance which MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd held at material times with QBE Insurance Ltd.
2. MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd is obliged to pay the $300 excess to QBE Insurance Ltd on each and every claim particularised by Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd which falls under the relevant policy of insurance held by MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd with QBE Insurance Ltd.
I order that MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd pay the standard costs of QBE Insurance Ltd to be assessed.
Liberty to apply with respect to the order for costs.
CATCHWORDS:
INSURANCE – Public Liability – Products liability – Construction of policy – application for declarations – consideration of use of words “occurrence” and “event” in policy – whether single excess payable for series of incidents resulting in damage or excess payable for each incident of damage
Distillers Co (Bio-Chemicals) (Aust) Pty Ltd v Ajax Insurance Co Ltd (1973-1974) 130 CLR 1, considered
Windsurf Pty Ltd v HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd [1999] QCA 360, consideredCOUNSEL:
M A Fellows for the applicant
A J Taylor for the respondentSOLICITORS:
Quinlan Miller & Treston for the applicant
Roberts Nehmer McKee for the respondent
AMBROSE J: The applicant insurer (QBE) seeks declarations against the respondent insured (MGM) concerning their respective rights and obligations under policies of insurance MGM held with QBE during the period of two years being 9 April 1997 to 9 April 1998, and 9 April 1998 to 9 April 1999.
At all material times MGM carried on business in Townsville described in the policies as “plumbing and fibreglass sealant services and building renovations”.
Within the period of insurance to which I have referred MGM sub-contracted with a building contractor Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd (“Glenwood”) to install waterproof membranes in bathroom areas of about 47 houses that were being built and/or renovated by Glenwood in the Townsville area.
In an action commenced against MGM in 1999 Glenwood alleges that MGM negligently installed the waterproofing membranes to which I have referred and as a consequence when the bathrooms were used water escaped into areas of the dwelling houses which apparently Glenwood was called upon to rectify and repair which it did.
Glenwood alleges that it has already cost something…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance Ltd v MGM Plumbing P/L and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] QSC 27
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues revolved around the construction of the insurance policy, particularly the interpretation of the terms “occurrence” and “event.” The court needed to determine whether the series of incidents resulting in property damage constituted a single occurrence for which a single excess was payable, or whether each incident of damage constituted a separate occurrence with its own excess. This interpretation directly impacted the obligations of the insured party, MGM Plumbing P/L, in relation to excess payments and the insurer's, QBE Insurance Ltd, coverage obligations.
The court examined the wording of the policy and the context in which the terms “occurrence” and “event” were used. It concluded that each instance of property damage resulting from the alleged defective waterproofing works constituted a separate occurrence, necessitating a separate excess payment for each incident. The court found that the policy language supported the interpretation that multiple incidents, even if related, were separate occurrences. Consequently, the court ruled that MGM Plumbing P/L was obliged to pay the $300 excess to QBE Insurance Ltd for each claim particularised by Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd.
The court made the following declarations: each occurrence of property damage to an individual property resulting from the alleged defective waterproofing works is a separate occurrence under the relevant policies of insurance held by MGM Plumbing P/L with QBE Insurance Ltd, and MGM Plumbing P/L is obliged to pay the $300 excess to QBE Insurance Ltd on each and every claim particularised by Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd. Additionally, the court ordered that MGM Plumbing P/L pay the standard costs of QBE Insurance Ltd to be assessed, with liberty to apply for costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
I make the following declarations –
1. Each occurrence of property damage to an individual property as a result of alleged defective waterproofing works performed by MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd and particularised by Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd which forms part of the claim by Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd against the respondent is a separate occurrence under the relevant policies of insurance which MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd held at material times with QBE Insurance Ltd.
2. MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd is obliged to pay the $300 excess to QBE Insurance Ltd on each and every claim particularised by Glenwood Homes Pty Ltd which falls under the relevant policy of insurance held by MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd with QBE Insurance Ltd.
I order that MGM Plumbing Services Pty Ltd pay the standard costs of QBE Insurance Ltd to be assessed.
Liberty to apply with respect to the order for costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi