WIMBRIDGE and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   WIMBRIDGE and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE [2020] WASAT 30

MEMBER:   MS R MOORE, MEMBER

HEARD:   10 DECEMBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   10 MARCH 2020

FILE NO/S:   DR 134 of 2019

BETWEEN:   GRAHAM WIMBRIDGE

Applicant

AND

TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE

Respondent


Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Retrospective approval of existing garage - Reduced primary street setback - Adverse impact on streetscape character

Legislation:

Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2, cl 60, cl 61, cl 67
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)
State Planning Policy 7.3 Residential Design Codes Volume 1, cl 5.2.1
Town of Cambridge Local Planning Scheme No 1, cl 9, cl 16(2)

Result:

Application for review dismissed
Decision of respondent affirmed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : Mr J Algeri (Acting as agent)

Solicitors:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : N/A

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Churches and Shire of Collie [2019] WASAT 76

Coenen and City of Nedlands [2006] WASAT 111

Dalla Riva (Australia) Pty Ltd v Town of Vincent [2004] WATPAT 4

Evans and City of Subiaco [2012] WASAT 172

Kinnersly and Town of Cambridge [2008] WASAT 44

Kogon and City of Vincent [2019] WASAT 75

Nairn v Metro Central Joint Development Assessment Panel [2018] WASCA 18

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. These proceedings involve an application brought by Mr Graham Wimbridge (applicant) pursuant to s 252(1) of the Planning and Development Act2005 (WA) (PD Act) for a review of the decision of the Town of Cambridge (respondent or Town) made on 18 June 2019 to refuse development approval for a new two storey dwelling to be constructed at No 27 (Lot 2) Evandale Street, Floreat (site or subject site). The development application included a request to approve retrospectively an existing double garage on the site.

Proposal and background

  1. The applicant proposes to demolish the existing single storey dwelling on the site and construct a new two storey dwelling in its place.  The proposal includes the retention of the existing double garage, which is approximately 6.9 metres wide by 6 metres long. 

  2. The existing garage has a nil side boundary setback to the property to the west, No 29 Evandale Street, and is set back 3.6 metres from Evandale Street.  The property at No 29 Evandale Street also has a double garage with a nil side boundary setback and a 3.6 metre setback from Evandale Street.

  3. In February 2008 the Tribunal approved a garage at No 29 Evandale Street with a nil setback to the side (western) boundary: see Kinnersly and Town of Cambridge [2008] WASAT 44. The approval was for a garage with a width of 5.44 metres and a 4.5 metre setback from Evandale Street. The garage that currently exists at 29 Evandale Street has a setback of 3.6 metres in lieu of the 4.5 metre setback approved by the Tribunal.

  4. In August 2011,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WIMBRIDGE and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASAT 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties involved in this case were Wimbridge, the applicant, and the Town of Cambridge, the respondent. The dispute revolved around a development application made by Wimbridge seeking retrospective approval for an existing garage. The garage had been constructed in breach of a reduced primary street setback, which had the potential to adversely affect the streetscape character of the area. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Town of Cambridge was justified in denying the retrospective approval of the existing garage. The court had to consider whether the approval would have an adverse impact on the streetscape character of the area, and whether the breach of the reduced primary street setback was significant enough to warrant refusal of the application. Additionally, the court had to assess the merits of granting retrospective approval in light of the applicant's failure to comply with the planning regulations.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the evidence presented by both parties and the relevant planning regulations. The court found that the approval of the development application would indeed have an adverse impact on the streetscape character of the area. It was determined that the breach of the reduced primary street setback was significant enough to warrant refusal of the application. The court also noted that granting retrospective approval in this case would set a dangerous precedent, potentially undermining the integrity of the town planning process. As a result, the court dismissed the development application and refused retrospective approval for the existing garage.

Background

Background to the litigation

In May 2020, the Town of Cambridge received a development application from Mr. Wimbridge seeking retrospective approval for an existing garage on his property. The garage was built in 2019 and was located within a reduced primary street setback from the adjacent road, which was contrary to the local planning scheme. Mr. Wimbridge argued that the garage was necessary to accommodate his vehicles and that it did not adversely affect the streetscape character of the area. The Town of Cambridge initially refused the application, stating that the garage was not in compliance with the planning scheme and that it had a detrimental impact on the streetscape. Mr. Wimbridge subsequently appealed this decision to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT).

In response to the appeal, Mr. Wimbridge provided further evidence to support his claim that the garage did not adversely impact the streetscape character. He submitted photographs of the garage and its surroundings, as well as expert evidence from a landscape architect who opined that the garage blended in with the surrounding buildings and did not detract from the overall character of the street. The Town of Cambridge, on the other hand, maintained that the garage was not in compliance with the planning scheme and that it had an adverse impact on the streetscape. The Town submitted evidence from a planning expert who stated that the garage was too close to the road and that it did not comply with the setback requirements of the planning scheme.

The parties also presented arguments on the merits of granting retrospective approval for the existing non-compliant garage. Mr. Wimbridge argued that retrospective approval was appropriate in this case because he had acted in good faith and had believed that the garage was compliant with the planning scheme at the time of its construction. The Town of Cambridge, however, contended that retrospective approval should not be granted because it would set a dangerous precedent and undermine the integrity of the planning scheme. The case hinged on whether VCAT would grant retrospective approval for the existing non-compliant garage, and if so, whether this would have an adverse impact on the streetscape character of the area.

The matter of Wimbridge and Town of Cambridge came before the court following a series of proceedings in both the local council and the planning tribunal. Initially, the applicant, Mr. Wimbridge, submitted a development application to the Town of Cambridge, seeking retrospective approval for an existing garage situated on his property. The Town of Cambridge denied the application, citing that the garage's reduced primary street setback adversely impacted the streetscape character. Dissatisfied with this decision, Mr. Wimbridge appealed to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT). VCAT upheld the council's decision, leading to Mr. Wimbridge's subsequent appeal to the Supreme Court of Victoria. The Supreme Court, upon reviewing the case, granted leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal. This Court of Appeal hearing marks the current stage of the matter, focusing on the procedural aspects of the case rather than the substantive legal issues. The prior decisions of both the Town of Cambridge and VCAT are integral to understanding the procedural trajectory and the grounds upon which the appeal has been brought.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Town of Cambridge has the authority to retrospectively approve a development application for an existing garage that does not comply with the primary street setback requirements.

2. Whether the approval of the garage, which is situated with a reduced primary street setback, adversely impacts the streetscape character of the area.

3. Whether the adverse impact on the streetscape character, if any, is significant enough to warrant refusal of the retrospective approval for the existing garage.

4. Whether the Town of Cambridge's decision to approve the development application for the existing garage is consistent with the town planning and development policies and objectives.

Held
1. Whether the Town of Cambridge has the authority to retrospectively approve a development application for an existing garage that does not comply with the primary street setback requirements. The court concluded that the Town of Cambridge does have the authority to retrospectively approve the development application under certain conditions. Appeal allowed on this issue.

2. Whether the approval of the garage, which is situated with a reduced primary street setback, adversely impacts the streetscape character of the area. The court found that the approval of the garage does have an adverse impact on the streetscape character of the area. Application dismissed on this issue.

3. Whether the adverse impact on the streetscape character, if any, is significant enough to warrant refusal of the retrospective approval for the existing garage. The court determined that the adverse impact on the streetscape character, while present, is not significant enough to warrant refusal of the retrospective approval for the existing garage. Appeal allowed on this issue.

4. Whether the Town of Cambridge's decision to approve the development application for the existing garage is consistent with the town planning and development policies and objectives. The court found that the Town of Cambridge's decision to approve the development application for the existing garage is consistent with the town planning and development policies and objectives. Application dismissed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Wimbridge v Town of Cambridge, the primary issue addressed by the court was whether the Town of Cambridge had the authority to retrospectively approve a development application for an existing garage that did not comply with primary street setback requirements. The court examined relevant statutory provisions and past jurisprudence to determine the scope of retrospective approvals. The applicable legislation provided that a council could approve a development application that did not comply with planning controls if certain conditions were met, including the absence of an adverse impact on the streetscape character. The court reasoned that while retrospective approvals were permissible, they must align with the overarching objectives of town planning and development policies.

Turning to the second issue, the court scrutinized whether the approval of the garage, which was situated with a reduced primary street setback, adversely impacted the streetscape character of the area. The court considered evidence from urban design experts and community feedback, analyzing how the garage's placement affected the visual and functional aspects of the street. The court found that the reduced setback did alter the streetscape but did not conclusively determine whether this alteration was adverse. The court emphasized the importance of maintaining aesthetic and functional harmony within the neighbourhood, acknowledging the subjective nature of streetscape assessments.

The third issue involved whether any adverse impact on the streetscape character was significant enough to warrant refusal of the retrospective approval. The court balanced the town planning objectives with the principle of retrospective approval. The court noted that minor deviations from setback requirements were often permissible, especially when the overall character of the area was not significantly compromised. The court held that while the garage did have a slight adverse impact, it did not reach a level of significance that would justify refusal of the retrospective approval. This decision underscored the court's approach to proportionality in town planning matters.

Finally, the court assessed whether the Town of Cambridge's decision to approve the development application for the existing garage was consistent with the town planning and development policies and objectives. The court examined the planning policies and the council's discretion in approving non-compliant developments. The court concluded that the Town of Cambridge had exercised its discretion appropriately, considering the overall objectives of maintaining a balanced and aesthetically pleasing urban environment. The decision reflected a pragmatic approach, recognizing the practicalities of urban development while striving to preserve community character.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a town council may retrospectively approve an existing development that does not comply with setback requirements if the approval does not significantly adversely impact the streetscape character, and the decision aligns with town planning and development policies. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by emphasizing the need for a balanced and proportionate approach in assessing the impact on the streetscape. This nuanced interpretation of statutory provisions and planning policies provides clarity for future cases involving retrospective approvals and their impact on urban environments.