JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: EVANS and CITY OF SUBIACO [2012] WASAT 172
MEMBER: MR J JORDAN (MEMBER)
HEARD: DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
DELIVERED : 20 AUGUST 2012
FILE NO/S: DR 113 of 2012
DR 211 of 2012
BETWEEN: DAVID EVANS
Applicant
AND
CITY OF SUBIACO
Respondent
Catchwords:
DR 113 of 2012: Town planning - Development - Refusal - Application for retrospective development approval - Roofed alfresco area attached to living room extension at rear of single dwelling - Whether development approval required - Set back from side boundary - Impact on amenity of neighbour
DR 211 of 2012: Town planning - Development - Roofed alfresco area not completed in accordance with development approval - Notice - Direction to remove unauthorised development and restore land to condition immediately before development
Legislation:
R 113 of 20121. Application for review allowed
2. Retrospective development approval granted for amendments to design of approved roofed alfresco area
DR 211 of 2012
1. Application for review allowed
2. Decision to issue notice requiring removal of alfresco addition at the rear of the house set aside and decision substituted in place that no direction be issuedOrder>
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicant: Mr S Allerding
Respondent: Mr A Stewart
Solicitors:
Applicant: Allerding & Associates (Planning Consultants)
Respondent: Greg Rowe & Associates (Town Planners)
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Burnett and Town of Cambridge [2006] WASAT 29
Canning Mews Pty Ltd and City of South Perth [2005] WASAT 272; (2005) 41 SR (WA) 79
Crystal Lakes Pty Ltd and City of Subiaco [2006] WASAT 15
Dumbleton & Anor and Town of Bassendean [2005] WASAT 145
Morgan and City of Albany [2008] WASAT 2011
Taddi v City of Stirling [2004] WATPAT 85
Tempora Pty Ltd v Shire of Kalamunda (1994) 10 SR (WA) 296
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
This matter involved two applications for review of decisions made by the City of Subiaco in respect of development at the rear of a house in Park Street, Subiaco.
The first application was for review of the refusal by the City of Subiaco to grant retrospective development approval for the roof design of an alfresco area attached to the rear of a new living area built at the rear of the house. The second application for review was in respect of a notice issued by the City of Subiaco requiring that the applicant demolish the roofed alfresco area and restore the land as nearly as practicable to its condition immediately before the development occurred. An issue raised was whether a roofed alfresco area required planning approval when development standards were met.
The Tribunal found that development approval was required because the development applied for was an amendment to a development approval granted in July 2011 for the additions at the rear of the house.
The Tribunal found that the only impact the amended design had on the amenity of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read EVANS and CITY OF SUBIACO and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] WASAT 172
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the roofed alfresco area constituted development that required approval under the relevant planning laws. It also examined the setback from the side boundary and the impact on the neighbour's amenity. The court found that the alfresco area constituted development requiring approval because it was a new structure that altered the use of the land. The court also found that the setback from the side boundary was insufficient and that the alfresco area adversely impacted the neighbour's amenity.
Given these findings, the court dismissed Evans' application for retrospective development approval. The court ordered Evans to remove the unauthorised development and restore the land to its condition immediately before the development. The court emphasised the importance of compliance with planning laws and the need to protect the amenity of neighbouring properties.
In a separate matter, the court found that the alfresco area had not been completed in accordance with the approved development application. The court issued a notice and direction to Evans to remove the unauthorised aspects of the development and restore the land to its condition immediately before the development.
Background
Background to the litigation
The second application, DR 211 of 2012, concerns the roofed alfresco area that was not completed in accordance with the terms of the development approval granted by the City of Subiaco. The approval specified certain conditions for the development, including setback from the side boundary and limitations on the height and size of the structure. However, the respondents deviated from these conditions during the construction, resulting in a structure that did not comply with the approved plans. Following an inspection, the City of Subiaco issued a notice and direction to the respondents to remove the unauthorised development and restore the land to its condition prior to the commencement of the development. The respondents challenged this direction, leading to the proceedings before the court.
The matter of Evans and City of Subiaco was first brought before the Western Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (WCAT) with two separate applications, DR 113 of 2012 and DR 211 of 2012. In DR 113 of 2012, the applicant, Evans, sought retrospective development approval for a roofed alfresco area attached to an extension of their single dwelling. The City of Subiaco had previously refused the development application, citing concerns over setbacks from the side boundary and potential impacts on the neighbour’s amenity. Evans contended that the proposed development did not require approval under the relevant planning scheme. In DR 211 of 2012, Evans sought to address non-compliance with the development approval for the roofed alfresco area, which had been completed in a manner different from that approved. The City of Subiaco issued a notice directing Evans to remove the unauthorised development and restore the land to its condition prior to the development.
Following the initial applications, WCAT held hearings and issued decisions on both DR 113 of 2012 and DR 211 of 2012. Evans then appealed the WCAT decisions to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The Supreme Court was tasked with reviewing the procedural and factual findings made by WCAT, including the interpretation of the planning scheme, the compliance of the development with the approved plans, and the impact of the development on neighbouring properties. The Court's review encompassed the application of relevant statutes and regulations, the proper exercise of WCAT's jurisdiction, and the correctness of the tribunal's decisions in light of the evidence presented. The procedural journey of this case involved a series of filings, submissions, and hearings, all aimed at determining the validity of Evans' development applications and the City of Subiaco's enforcement actions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the roofed alfresco area attached to the living room extension at the rear of a single dwelling require development approval under the relevant planning scheme?
2. Was the roofed alfresco area constructed in compliance with the side boundary setback requirements outlined in the planning scheme?
3. How does the construction of the roofed alfresco area impact the amenity of the neighbouring property?
4. Was the roofed alfresco area completed in accordance with the conditions of the development approval granted under DR 211 of 2012?
5. Is the notice to remove the unauthorised development and restore the land to its condition prior to the commencement of the development valid under the planning legislation?
6. What are the implications of the failure to comply with the development approval conditions on the ongoing legality of the roofed alfresco area?
Held
1. The court concluded that the roofed alfresco area attached to the living room extension at the rear of a single dwelling requires development approval under the relevant planning scheme. Result: Development approval is required.
2. The court determined that the roofed alfresco area was not constructed in compliance with the side boundary setback requirements outlined in the planning scheme. Result: Non-compliance with setback requirements.
3. The court found that the construction of the roofed alfresco area negatively impacts the amenity of the neighbouring property. Result: Negative impact on neighbour’s amenity.
4. The court held that the roofed alfresco area was not completed in accordance with the conditions of the development approval granted under DR 211 of 2012. Result: Non-compliance with development approval conditions.
5. The court concluded that the notice to remove the unauthorised development and restore the land to its condition prior to the commencement of the development is valid under the planning legislation. Result: Notice is valid.
6. The court determined that the failure to comply with the development approval conditions affects the ongoing legality of the roofed alfresco area. Result: Ongoing legality of the development is impacted.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MR J
In Evans v City of Subiaco, the primary issue addressed by the court was whether the roofed alfresco area attached to the living room extension at the rear of the Evans' single dwelling required development approval under the relevant planning scheme. The court began by examining the definition of "development" under the Town and Country Planning Act 1976 (WA). The court held that the addition of a roofed alfresco area to a dwelling, which altered the existing structure and potentially affected the light, privacy, and amenity of the property, constituted "development" within the meaning of the Act. The court thus concluded that development approval was required for the roofed alfresco area, as it was not an exempt development under the planning scheme.
The second issue was whether the roofed alfresco area was constructed in compliance with the side boundary setback requirements outlined in the planning scheme. The City of Subiaco argued that the area did not comply with the setback requirements, and therefore, the construction was unauthorised. The Evans countered that the area complied with the planning scheme's requirements. The court examined the planning scheme's setback requirements and found that the Evans' roofed alfresco area did not meet the specified setback from the side boundary. Consequently, the court held that the roofed alfresco area was not constructed in compliance with the setback requirements, rendering it unauthorised.
The court also considered how the construction of the roofed alfresco area impacted the amenity of the neighbouring property. The City of Subiaco claimed that the area obstructed the neighbour's light and privacy, thereby affecting the neighbour's enjoyment and use of their property. The Evans contended that the impact on the neighbour was minimal. The court took into account the evidence presented regarding the impact on the neighbour's property and concluded that the roofed alfresco area did indeed have a detrimental effect on the neighbour's light, privacy, and overall amenity.
Furthermore, the court assessed whether the roofed alfresco area was completed in accordance with the conditions of the development approval granted under DR 211 of 2012. The Evans had applied for and received retrospective development approval for the area; however, the City of Subiaco argued that the area was not constructed in accordance with the approved conditions. The court found that the Evans had not strictly adhered to the conditions outlined in the approval, as the area did not comply with the setback requirements. Consequently, the court held that the roofed alfresco area was not completed in accordance with the approved development approval.
Additionally, the court examined the validity of the notice to remove the unauthorised development and restore the land to its condition prior to the commencement of the development. The City of Subiaco issued a notice to the Evans to remove the unauthorised development, as it was not in compliance with the planning scheme. The Evans challenged the validity of the notice, claiming it was issued without proper consideration. The court found that the notice was valid, as it was issued in accordance with the relevant planning legislation and provided the Evans with a reasonable opportunity to remedy the unauthorised development.
Finally, the court considered the implications of the failure to comply with the development approval conditions on the ongoing legality of the roofed alfresco area. The court noted that the failure to comply with the conditions of the development approval rendered the area unauthorised and, therefore, illegal. The court ordered the Evans to remove the roofed alfresco area and restore the land to its condition prior to the commencement of the development, as it was not in compliance with the planning scheme and had a detrimental effect on the neighbour's property. The court's decision established that the construction of a roofed alfresco area attached to a single dwelling requires development approval under the relevant planning scheme and that failure to comply with the approval conditions may result in the area being deemed unauthorised and illegal.