KOGON and CITY OF VINCENT

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   KOGON and CITY OF VINCENT [2019] WASAT 75

MEMBER:   MR S WILLEY, MEMBER

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   2 OCTOBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   DR 281 of 2018

BETWEEN:   BOAZ KOGON

Applicant

AND

CITY OF VINCENT

Respondent


Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Change in use - Interpretation of planning scheme - Land use classification - Innominate use - Short term accommodation - Airbnb - Consideration of policy - Heritage issues - Consideration of amenity - Compatibility of the proposed use with its context - Relevance of recommendation of professional staff in the exercise of discretion - Relevance of other approvals issued by the City

Legislation:

City of Vincent Local Planning Scheme No 2, cl 8(d), cl 9(a), cl 9(b), cl 16, cl 18(4), cl 38, Table 1
Heritage Act 2018 (WA), Pt 3
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 5
Metropolitan Redevelopment Authority Act 2011 (WA)
Metropolitan Region Scheme, cl 30(1)
Planning and Development (Local Planning) Regulations 2015 (WA), reg 8(1)(c), reg 10(4), Sch 1, cl 38, Sch 2, cl 1, cl 61, cl 61(2), cl 61(2)(e), cl 67, cl 67(b)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 241(1), s 257B(2), Pt 5
SPP 7.3 Residential design codes ­ Volume 1
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 24, s 27, s 31, s 60(2)

Result:

The application for review is dismissed

Summary of Tribunal's decision:

Boaz Kogan (the applicant) applied to the City of Vincent (City) in order to use his dwelling at 8 Moir Street Perth for the purposes of temporary accommodation (short term dwelling).  The City refused the application and the applicant applied for a review of that decision.
The Tribunal reviewed the proposal having regard to the relevant planning framework and found that while the land was appropriately located, in a broad sense, for temporary accommodation uses the immediate context of the land was purely residential. The proposal would result in the introduction of a commercial land use which would be surrounded by premises used for permanent residential purposes. 
The Tribunal found that whilst the land was within a heritage area, because the application was only for a change of use and no physical works were proposed, the proposal raised no issues from a heritage standpoint. The Tribunal found that the provision of one car parking bay would be sufficient having regard to the proximity of the land to the Perth CBD and a wide range of public transport options.
Having considered the evidence, the Tribunal found that the proposal would not be consistent with the immediate residential context as it would result in a commercial use being surrounded by residential premises.  The Tribunal found that the manner in which temporary accommodation is used differs in intensity from residential uses and that amenity impacts, in the form of noise, were likely to result.
While the applicant put forward a detailed and considered noise management plan, the Tribunal was not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read KOGON and CITY OF VINCENT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASAT 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Kogon and the City of Vincent involved a dispute over a development application submitted by Kogon to change the use of a property for short-term accommodation, specifically for Airbnb rentals. The City of Vincent initially rejected the application, but Kogon appealed to the Western Australian State Administrative Tribunal (SAT). The central legal issues in the case revolved around the interpretation of the planning scheme, the classification of the land use, and the compatibility of the proposed use with its context. The tribunal needed to consider various factors, including the policy considerations, heritage issues, and the amenity impacts of the proposed use.

The tribunal reviewed the planning reports submitted by the City of Vincent's officers, which recommended approval of the proposal. However, the tribunal found that these reports did not adequately address the amenity impacts of the proposed use, particularly in relation to noise. The tribunal also considered the principle established in Dalla Riva, which suggested that while the officer's report to the planning authority should not be given weight in the exercise of discretion by the tribunal, the reasoning applied in the professional report could be considered as an expression of how the planner would exercise the discretion. Ultimately, the tribunal found that the City officers' planning reports were superseded by the evidence provided to the tribunal by Mr Hockley. The tribunal retained its discretion in making the final decision despite considering the various planning considerations.

In its decision, the tribunal emphasised that the term 'due regard' required only that proper, genuine, and realistic consideration be given to the various planning considerations set out in clause 67 of the deemed provisions. The tribunal concluded that regardless of its findings on each of these matters, it retained a discretion in relation to the ultimate decision it was required to make. The tribunal found in favour of Kogon, allowing the development application and permitting the change of use for short-term accommodation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In APP Corporation Pty Ltd and City of Perth [2011] WASAT 132; (2011) 77 SR (WA) 198 the Tribunal at [151] referred to the decision of the former Town Planning Appeal Tribunal in Dalla Riva (Australia) Pty Ltd v Town of Vincent [2004] WATPAT 4 (Dalla Riva) where it was stated (at [35] ­ [36]) that:35.It is suggested that no weight ought to be attached to the planning officers' recommendations. Whilst it is true that that is what they are, namely recommendations, it is equally true that they represent the considered recommendations of professionally trained and engaged employees.36.It is accepted, without demur, that of course the decision at all times remains the Respondent's. When, however, the matter is addressed by the Tribunal on appeal there is proper scope to consider the reflective advice provided to the Respondent in the course of its consideration on and deliberations about the relevant application. It is in no way determinative of the matter before the Tribunal but nevertheless represents a matter to which regard ought to be had as a matter to be considered in the determination of this appeal. To the extent to which there is discretion and therefore an element of judgment, the views expressed on such matters by qualified planners are of assistance to the Tribunal. The analysis in Dalla Riva has been cited in a number of Tribunal decisions such as Aydogan and Town of Cambridge [2006] WASAT 122; Murphy & Anor and Town of Vincent [2006] WASAT 322; (2006) 46 SR (WA) 122; Forsyth and City of Fremantle [2006] WASAT 361; (2006) 48 SR (WA) 86 and Driscoll and Shire of Augusta­Margaret River [2008] WASAT 219. The principle that is said to arise from Dalla River needs to be carefully understood. Dalla River cannot be interpreted as suggesting that the officer's report to the planning authority is to be given weight in the exercise of discretion by the Tribunal. That simply cannot be the case especially where the relevant officer is not called to give evidence. In my view, Dalla River merely stands for the proposition that a review body may consider the reasoning that was applied in the professional report that was presented to the planning authority as an expression of how that planner would exercise the discretion. To me, read in context, Dalla River does not put the matter any higher than that. In this instance, the City officers' planning reports that recommended approval to the Proposal have been overtaken by the evidence provided to the Tribunal by Mr Hockley. Nevertheless, I have read the officers' reports recommending support for the Proposal (and which form part of the s 24 Bundle). In my view these planning reports do not address the question of the amenity impacts of the Proposal in relation to noise in sufficient detail. The various planning considerations set out in cl 67 of the deemed provisions do not serve to displace the discretion that is to be exercised in relation to permissible, discretionary or innominate uses. The term 'due regard' requires only that I give 'proper, genuine and realistic' consideration to such matters: City of South Perth v ALH Group Property Holdings Pty Ltd [2016]WASC141 at [46] (Martino J). Regardless of my findings in relation to each of these cl 67 matters, I retain a discretion in relation to the ultimate decision I am required to make.