CHURCHES and SHIRE OF COLLIE

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   CHURCHES and SHIRE OF COLLIE [2019] WASAT 76

MEMBER:   MS L EDDY, SENIOR MEMBER

HEARD:   11 AND 12 JUNE 2019

WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS FILED ON 26 JUNE

DELIVERED          :   24 SEPTEMBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   DR 21 of 2019

BETWEEN:   DAVID CHURCHES

Applicant

AND

SHIRE OF COLLIE

Respondent


Catchwords:

Town Planning - Development application - Land use classification - Whether transport depot - Whether car park and motor vehicle repair uses - Whether separate storage use - Consistency in decision making - Previous approval in relation to same land

Legislation:

Environmental Protection (Noise) Regulations 1997
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), cl 67, Sch 2, reg 10(4)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1), s 257B
Shire of Collie Local Planning Scheme No. 5, cl 4.3.2, cl 4.4, cl 4.4.1, cl 4.4.2, cl 5.11.4, cl 5.11.4(a), cl 10.2, Pt 2, Sch 1, Sch 2
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27

Result:

Adjourned

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr C Wallace
Respondent : Mr A Roberts

Solicitors:

Applicant : Lavan Legal
Respondent : McLeods

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

APP Corporation Pty Ltd and City of Perth [2011] WASAT 132

Associated Provincial Picture Houses Limited v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223

BGC (Australia) Pty Ltd and Shire of Murray [2010] WASAT 180

Chiefari v Brisbane City Council [2005] QPLER 500

Churches and Shire of Collie [2015] WASAT 23

Consolidated Realities Pty Ltd v Baulkham Shire Council (1964) 10 LGRA 120

Dilatte & Anor v MacTiernan [2002] WASCA 100

Garvey and City of Wanneroo [2014] WASAT 73

Gay and City of South Perth [2017] WASAT 94

Hanson Construction Materials Pty Ltd and Town of Vincent [2008] WASAT 71

Humich and City of Gosnells [2008] WASAT 298

Marshall v Metropolitan Redevelopment Authority [2015] WASC 226

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li & Anor [2013] HCA 18; (2013) 249 CLR 332

Mustac v Medical Board of Western Australia [2007] WASCA 128

Ord Irrigiation Cooperative Ltd v Department of Water [2018] WASCA 83

Puma Energy Australia and City of Cockburn [2016] WASAT 36

Rossi and City of Bayswater [2010] WASAT 33

Segal v Waverly Council [2005] NSWCA 310

Swanhill Enterprises Pty Ltd and City of Perth [2011] WASAT 65

The Bethanie Group Pty Ltd and City of Stirling [2016] WASAT 6

West Coast Enterprise Pty Ltd and Shire of Exmouth [2007] WASAT 316

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. In October 2018, Mr David Churches (applicant) applied for development approval under the Shire of Collie's (Shire or respondent) Local Planning Scheme No. 5 (Scheme or LPS 5) to use his property at Lot 51 Patstone Road, Collie (site) for what he describes as a transport depot (proposed development). Pursuant to s 252(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act), the applicant sought review of the deemed refusal of the proposed development in the Tribunal. Following an invitation to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CHURCHES and SHIRE OF COLLIE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASAT 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Churches and Shire of Collie was heard by the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dispute involved the Shire of Collie's decision to deny Churches' development application for land classified under the Collie Local Planning Scheme as a Transport Depot. The applicant sought to develop the site for various uses, including a car park, motor vehicle repair services, and storage. The Shire argued that these uses were inconsistent with the land's classification as a Transport Depot.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Shire's decision was unreasonable. The Court was required to determine if the Shire had exercised its discretion improperly by failing to consider relevant factors or by taking into account irrelevant considerations. The Court also needed to assess whether the Shire's decision was inconsistent with its previous approval of a similar application for the same land. The Court examined whether the Shire had acted in accordance with sound town planning principles and whether its decision-making process was capricious or arbitrary.

Malcolm CJ considered the principles of unreasonableness as articulated in Associated Provincial Picture Houses Limited v Wednesbury Corporation and subsequent cases. His Honour noted that inconsistency in decision-making, particularly by the same authority regarding the same land, could lead to capricious decisions. The Court found that the Shire had failed to consider relevant matters and had acted inconsistently with its previous decision on the same land, leading to the conclusion that the decision was unreasonable. The Shire's actions brought the decision-making process into disrepute and did not reflect a disciplined approach aligned with sound town planning principles.

The Court ordered the matter to be adjourned, likely to allow for further submissions or reconsideration of the development application by the Shire in light of the Court's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Adjourned

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In commencing consideration of whether the decision in question was unreasonable, Malcolm CJ cited Associated Provincial Picture Houses Limited v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223 (Wednesbury), two earlier cases in relation to the proper exercise of a statutory discretion, and some cases where the approach in Wednesbury had been followed, including in the context of town planning: Dilatte, at [51]-[56]. At this point, Malcolm CJ pointed out that the matter before the Court in Dilatte was not a merits based review, but rather concerned prerogative writ applications, where the two main grounds of review are the doctrines of jurisdictional error and ultra vires. His Honour went on to describe where a decision-maker has failed to take into account a relevant consideration or has taken into account an irrelevant consideration as one of a range of circumstances in which the doctrine of ultra vires may be invoked: Dilatte at [57]. His Honour then said at [58] and [61] (citations omitted):These cases are aspects of unreasonableness because they lead to inconsistent and capricious decisions, although decision by local authorities are not binding precedents and each application must be considered on its own merits. Decisions in other cases, and the consequences of the decisions in them may be relevant and may be taken into account.…Inconsistency has the potential of bringing the decision making process into disrepute because it suggests that the decision is arbitrary, rather than one made in accordance with a disciplined approach reflecting the application of sound town planning principles and consistent with commonly accepted notions of justice. In Dilatte at [62], Malcolm CJ explained (citations omitted):The determination whether there has been inconsistency between successive decision depends upon a comparison of the circumstances in each case and, in particular, to those relevant to each decision. The comparison obviously involves questions of fact and degree. The test is that ordinarily there would need to be "a similarity, if not a virtual duplication of circumstances and conditions to establish the basis for a complaint of inconsistency". Decisions by a council with respect to planning applications made by the same applicant in respect of the same land should ordinarily be consistent. For example, it is not open to a planning authority simply to change its mind about the merits of a particular application and withdraw a consent or approval previously made and communicated, even if the consent or approval has not been acted upon by the applicant. So, it seems from the reasons in Dilatte, that it can be understood that a lack of consistency when making a planning decision is potentially a basis for finding a decision maker had been unreasonable in exercising the decision-making discretion. The concept from Dilatte, described by the Tribunal as 'consistency in decision making', has been applied in the Tribunal in a number of planning cases subsequent to the Dilatte decision: BGC (Australia) Pty Ltd and Shire of Murray [2010] WASAT 180; Swanhill Enterprises Pty Ltd and City of Perth [2011] WASAT 65 (Swanhill); APP Corporation Pty Ltd and City of Perth [2011] WASAT 132; Garvey and City of Wanneroo [2014] WASAT 73; The Bethanie Group Pty Ltd and City of Stirling [2016] WASAT 6; Gay and City of South Perth [2017] WASAT 94. The same concept has also been expressed as a reflection of orderly and proper planning by the Tribunal: Hanson Construction Materials Pty Ltd and Town of Vincent [2008] WASAT 71 (Hanson); Rossi and City of Bayswater [2010] WASAT 33. In Hanson at [54], the Tribunal said:In circumstances where the planning framework is the same and the circumstances have not changed in any substantial way, it is in the interests of orderly and proper planning that planning decisions in relation to a site are made in a consistent way.