Whittingham v Commissioner of Railways (WA)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read
46 CLR 22

WHITTINGHAM

THE COMMISSIONER OF RAILWAYS (W.A.) RESPONDENT.

RESPONDENT,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Workers' Compensation-Injury sustained during lunch hour-Accident to eye by

cricket ball hit by other employee-Whether accident arose 'out of or in the course of the employment-Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 (W.A.) (No. 69 of MELBOURNE,

1912-No. 40 of 1924), sec. 6.'

During the luncheon interval the appellant was strolling on a recreation SYDNEY,

ground attached to the workshops at which he was employed, and owned by the respondent, when he was struck in the eye with a cricket ball, hit probably by one of his fellow-workers who were playing cricket there. As a result of the accident the appellant lost his right eye.

Held, by Rich, Starke and Dixon JJ. (Evatt and McTiernan JJ. dissenting), that the appellant was not entitled to compensation under sec. 6 of the Workers' * The Workers' Compensation Act

the worker is acting under the em- 1912-1924 (W.A.), by sec. 6 (1), provides

ployer's instructions, is caused to a that " If in any employment personal

worker, his employer shall injury by accident arising out of or in

liable to pay compensation " &. the course of the employment, or whilst

46 CLR 23

Compensation Act 1912-1924 (W.A.), as the accident arose neither out of nor **in the course of " his employment.

Per Exatt J.: The accident arose "out of the employment. Per McTiernan J. The accident arose in the course of " the employment. Decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia (Full Court) affirmed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

This was an appeal by Robert Whittingham from the judgment of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which set aside an award of the Local Court of Perth in favour of the appellant granting him compensation under the Workers' Compensa- tion Act 1912-1924 of Western Australia in respect of an accident which occurred while he was an employee of the Commissioner of Railways for Western Australia and which was alleged to have arisen out of or in the course of his employment.

The following statement of facts is taken from the judgment of Northmore A.C.J. in the Supreme Court There is no dispute on the facts. The appellant is the Commissioner of Railways and the respon- dent was employed by him as a machinist at the Midland Junction Workshops. His hours of work were from 7.30 to 11.54 a.m. and from 12.36to 5 o'clock p.m. During the luncheon interval, that is, between 11.54 and 12.36, work in the shops ceases and it is optional for the men either to have their lunch on the premises or to go elsewhere for it. Attached to the workshops and owned by the appellant is a recreation ground upon which it is customary for some of the workers to play games, including cricket, during the luncheon interval. Upon the day of the accident the respondent, having eaten his lunch, was strolling on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Whittingham v Commissioner of Railways (WA) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1931] HCA 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the High Court of Australia from the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The appellant, Robert Whittingham, sought compensation under the Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 (WA) for the loss of an eye sustained when he was struck by a cricket ball during his lunch break. Whittingham was employed as a machinist by the Commissioner of Railways (WA). The accident occurred on a recreation ground owned by the Commissioner and attached to the workshops, where it was customary for employees to play cricket during their lunch interval. The Local Court of Perth had initially awarded compensation, but this decision was overturned by the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the accident, which occurred during the appellant's voluntary lunch break while he was strolling on his employer's recreation ground, arose "out of or in the course of" his employment as defined by section 6 of the Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 (WA). This section provided for compensation if an injury by accident arose either "out of" or "in the course of" employment, or whilst the worker was acting under the employer's instructions, a disjunctive formulation differing from the cumulative requirements of the English Act.

A majority of the High Court, comprising Rich, Starke, and Dixon JJ., held that the accident did not arise out of or in the course of Whittingham's employment. Their reasoning focused on the fact that the lunch interval was not considered time worked, and Whittingham was on the premises for his own convenience and pleasure, not performing any duty or engaging in an activity incidental to his service. They applied principles established in cases such as *Pearson v. Fremantle Harbour Trust* and *Charles R. Davidson & Co. v. M'Robb*, emphasizing that the accident must have a sufficient connection to the actual performance of the employee's duties. In contrast, Evatt and McTiernan JJ. dissented. Evatt J. found the accident arose "out of the employment," arguing that the employer's premises had become a place of special danger due to the customary practice of playing cricket, and that the Western Australian Act's disjunctive wording extended coverage to such risks. McTiernan J. concluded the accident arose "in the course of" the employment.

The High Court, by a majority of three to two, dismissed the appeal. The orders of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which had set aside the award of compensation, were affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Robert Whittingham, employed as a machinist at the Midland Junction Workshops of the Commissioner of Railways in Western Australia, was injured during his luncheon break when he was struck in the eye by a cricket ball. The incident occurred on the recreation ground attached to the workshops, which was owned by the Commissioner. Whittingham lost his right eye as a result of the accident and sought compensation under the Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 of Western Australia, claiming that the accident arose out of or in the course of his employment. The Local Court of Perth initially awarded Whittingham compensation, but this decision was later reversed by the Supreme Court of Western Australia. Whittingham appealed to the High Court of Australia.

Whittingham's employment hours were from 7:30 a.m. to 11:54 a.m. and from 12:36 p.m. to 5:00 p.m., with a 42-minute lunch break in between. During this break, work in the workshops ceased, and employees were free to either eat their lunch on the premises or leave. It was customary for some workers to play cricket on the recreation ground during the lunch hour. On the day of the accident, Whittingham had finished his lunch and was strolling on the recreation ground when he was struck by a cricket ball, likely hit by one of his fellow workers who were playing cricket. This resulted in the loss of his right eye.

The High Court considered whether the accident arose 'in the course of' Whittingham's employment. The majority of the Court, represented by Rich, Starke, and Dixon JJ., held that the accident did not occur in the course of Whittingham's employment, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dissenting opinion, presented by Evatt and McTiernan JJ., argued that the accident did arise in the course of Whittingham's employment, allowing his appeal.

Whittingham v Commissioner of Railways (WA) was an appeal by Robert Whittingham from the decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which set aside an award by the Local Court of Perth granting him compensation under the Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 of Western Australia for an injury he sustained while he was an employee of the Commissioner of Railways for Western Australia. The Full Court held that the accident did not arise out of or in the course of his employment. Whittingham now appealed to the High Court. The High Court found that the accident did not arise in the course of employment as the injury occurred during the lunch break which was not considered time worked and Whittingham was not engaged in any activity related to his employment when he was injured.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the injury sustained by the appellant during his employment with the Commissioner of Railways?
2. Did the injury arise 'out of' the employment of the appellant?
3. Did the injury arise 'in the course of' the employment of the appellant?
4. Does the Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 (W.A.) require the injury to arise both 'out of' and 'in the course of' the employment to entitle the appellant to compensation, or is it sufficient if the injury arises either 'out of' or 'in the course of' the employment?
5. Was the presence of the appellant at the location where he was struck by the cricket ball sufficiently connected to his employment to consider the injury as arising 'in the course of' the employment?

Held
1. The injury sustained by the appellant was not during his employment with the Commissioner of Railways. The accident occurred during his lunch break, which was not considered as time worked.
2. The injury did not arise 'out of' the employment. The court found that the accident was not related to the nature of the employment or the obligations, conditions, or incidents of the employment.
3. The injury did not arise 'in the course of' the employment. The appellant was not engaged in any activity related to his employment at the time of the accident and was merely strolling for his own purposes.
4. The Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 (W.A.) requires the injury to arise either 'out of' or 'in the course of' the employment to entitle the appellant to compensation. It is not necessary for the injury to arise both 'out of' and 'in the course of' the employment.
5. The presence of the appellant at the location where he was struck by the cricket ball was not sufficiently connected to his employment to consider the injury as arising 'in the course of' the employment. The court concluded that the injury did not arise 'in the course of' the employment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Whittingham v Commissioner of Railways (WA), the High Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the injury sustained by the appellant during his employment with the Commissioner of Railways qualified for workers' compensation under the Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 (W.A.). The court had to address several key issues to arrive at its decision.

Firstly, the court examined whether the injury occurred during the appellant's employment. The facts established that the appellant was indeed employed by the Commissioner of Railways as a machinist. However, the injury occurred during the luncheon interval, a period when work ceased, and it was optional for the employees to remain on the premises or leave for lunch. The court concluded that the injury took place during the employment period, albeit not during active work hours.

Secondly, the court deliberated on whether the injury arose 'out of' the employment. The majority opinion held that the injury did not arise 'out of' the employment, as the nature of the injury did not have a direct connection to the duties of the machinist. The dissenting opinion, however, argued that the injury arose 'out of' the employment because the appellant was on the employer's premises and exposed to the risks inherent in the employment environment.

Thirdly, the court had to determine whether the injury arose 'in the course of' the employment. The majority opinion found that the injury did not arise 'in the course of' the employment, as the appellant was not performing any duties or activities incidental to his employment at the time of the accident. The dissenting opinion, on the other hand, concluded that the injury did arise 'in the course of' the employment because the appellant was on the employer's premises, waiting to resume work.

Fourthly, the court considered whether the Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 (W.A.) required the injury to arise both 'out of' and 'in the course of' the employment to entitle the appellant to compensation, or if it was sufficient if the injury arose either 'out of' or 'in the course of' the employment. The majority opinion held that under the Act, it was sufficient if the injury arose either 'out of' or 'in the course of' the employment.

Lastly, the court assessed whether the presence of the appellant at the location where he was struck by the cricket ball was sufficiently connected to his employment to consider the injury as arising 'in the course of' the employment. The majority opinion found that the connection between the appellant's presence at the location and his employment was too remote to consider the injury as arising 'in the course of' the employment.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that for an injury to qualify for workers' compensation under the Workers' Compensation Act 1912-1924 (W.A.), it must arise either 'out of' or 'in the course of' the employment, but not necessarily both. In this particular case, the injury did not arise 'in the course of' the employment, and thus the appellant was not entitled to compensation. The court distinguished prior authority by emphasizing the need for a sufficient connection between the employment and the injury for it to be considered as arising 'in the course of' the employment.