Whitlam v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:    Whitlam v. Australian Securities & Investment Commission  [2003]  NSWCA 183

FILE NUMBER(S):
40709/02
41057/02

HEARING DATE(S):             27, 28, 29 and 30 May 2003

JUDGMENT DATE:               10/07/2003

PARTIES:
Nicholas Richard Whitlam - appellant
Australian Securites & Invesment Commission - respondent

JUDGMENT OF:      Hodgson JA Ipp JA Tobias JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:             Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):        ED 4421/01

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:   Gzell J

COUNSEL:
Mr. R.J. Ellicott QC with Mr. A.J.L. Bannon SC and Mr. J.H. Stephenson for appellant
Mr. M.A. Pembroke SC with Mr. J.W.J. Stevenson for respondent

SOLICITORS:
Watson Mangioni, Sydney for appellant
ASIC, Sydney for respondent

CATCHWORDS:
APPEALS - Questions of fact - Whether appellable error
CORPORATIONS - General meetings - Votes of members - Chairman appointed proxy - Chairman fills out and lodges, but does not sign, poll paper - Votes counted - Whether chairman failed to vote - Whether breach of Corporations Law s.250A.
CORPORATIONS - Directors - Duties of directors - Director appointed proxy for members - Whether action pursuant to proxy appointment an exercise of a director's powers or a discharge of a director's duties
PROCEDURE - Pleading - Surprise - Natural justice - No allegation by respondent of possible bases for finding as to directors' duties - Whether Court should itself formulate and determine such bases

LEGISLATION CITED:
Corporations Law 1998, ss.180(1), 232, 250A, 1317E, 1317S
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss.180(1), 250A, 1317E, 1317S
Supreme Court Rules Pt.15, rr.7, 13

DECISION:
1. Appeal allowed with costs, and cross-appeal dismissed with costs. 2. Orders of primary judge set aside. 3. In lieu thereof, proceedings dismissed with costs. 4. Application for leave to appeal dismissed, with no order as to costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40709/02
CA 41057/02

HODGSON JA
IPP JA
TOBIAS JA

Thursday 10 July 2003

WHITLAM  V.  AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION

HEADNOTE

FACTS
The case involved allegations of breaches of the Corporations Law 1998 (the Law) by the appellant, the President of NRMA, in connection with the 1998 NRMA Annual General Meeting (AGM) and a board meeting of the NRMA Insurance Group Limited (NIGL) of 11 August 2000.

The 1998 AGM
The appellant, as chairman of the 1998 AGM, received proxy votes. According to the rules applicable to the meeting, a proxy vote would only constitute a valid vote if it had been signed. Mr Whitlam filled out but did not sign the poll paper with respect to 3,973 votes against resolution 6. Resolution 6, which the appellant supported, proposed amendments to the Articles of Association of NRMA concerning the remuneration of directors. However, following receipt of legal advice, the 3,973 votes were counted and the resolution was defeated.

The primary judge held that the omission to sign the poll paper was a deliberate and premeditated action. He held that it constituted a failure to vote as required by s250A(4)(c) of the Law. Further, he held that this was a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Whitlam v Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWCA 183
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a decision of a primary judge regarding alleged breaches of the *Corporations Act 2001* (Cth) by the appellant, Mr Whitlam. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) had brought proceedings against Mr Whitlam, alleging contraventions of his duties as a director and of section 250A of the *Corporations Act*. The dispute centred on Mr Whitlam's actions concerning a general meeting, specifically his appointment as a proxy for members, his filling out and lodging of a poll paper without signing it, and alterations to draft minutes.

The court was required to determine whether Mr Whitlam had breached his duties as a director under section 180(1) of the *Corporations Act*, and whether he had failed to vote in accordance with section 250A by not signing the poll paper. A further issue was whether the primary judge was obliged to make a declaration of contravention of section 180(1) even if the matter was considered trivial and the proceedings should not have been brought, or if section 1317S permitted relief from such a declaration. The court also considered whether it should formulate and determine bases for findings as to directors' duties when no such allegations had been clearly pleaded by ASIC, raising questions of natural justice and surprise.

The Full Court found in favour of Mr Whitlam on several grounds. It held that he had not breached his duty as a director concerning alterations to draft minutes, nor was he shown to have been motivated by personal gain in supporting a particular resolution, noting he would have received less remuneration if it had passed. Crucially, the court determined that Mr Whitlam had not breached section 250A because he had, in fact, voted, and his failure to sign the poll paper did not result in those proxy votes not being counted. The court also noted that the alleged deliberate conduct was not sufficiently established, as concealment would have been impossible or self-defeating, and the evidence would not meet the standard for criminal charges. Furthermore, the court emphasised that natural justice requires serious misconduct allegations to be precisely formulated, and it was inappropriate for the court to formulate such bases for the first time after extensive hearings.

Consequently, the appeal was allowed with costs, and the cross-appeal was dismissed with costs. The orders of the primary judge were set aside, and the proceedings were dismissed with costs. The application for leave to appeal was also dismissed, with no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs, and cross-appeal dismissed with costs. 2. Orders of primary judge set aside. 3. In lieu thereof, proceedings dismissed with costs. 4. Application for leave to appeal dismissed, with no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Second, there is the question whether the primary judge was obliged to make a declaration of breach of s.180(1), where, in the primary judge’s view, the matter was trivial and the proceedings should never have been brought. It was put for the respondent that s.1317E made it obligatory for a court satisfied of a contravention of s.180(1) to make a declaration of contravention. For the appellant, it was submitted that s.1317S authorised the Court to relieve the appellant wholly from a liability to which he would otherwise be subject, including a liability to have declared against him a contravention of s.180(1). Again, we need not determine this question. CONCLUSION It follows from what we have said that, in our opinion, the appeal should be allowed with costs, the decision and orders of the primary judge should be set aside, and the proceedings should be dismissed with costs. We do not think an application for leave to appeal was necessary, and we would propose to dismiss that application, with no order as to costs. The result is not entirely satisfactory. On the one hand, we are not able to find that the appellant did not deliberately fail to sign the poll paper. On the other hand, the effect of dismissing the proceedings is to rule out the possibility that the appellant will, by reason of the subject events, be subject to being precluded from being a director of a corporation or corporations; and this could be considered as not being in the public interest in circumstances where the question of whether or not the failure to sign was deliberate has not been properly determined. However, the following considerations are relevant.1.We have found, in the appellant’s favour, that he was not shown to have breached his duty as director by reason of the alterations to the draft minutes.2.We have also found that he was not in breach of s.250A of the Law, because he did in fact vote.3.We have found in the appellant’s favour that he was not shown to have been motivated by considerations of personal gain in his support of Resolution 6.4.The appellant would in fact have received less remuneration if Resolution 6 had been passed.5.The appellant’s failure to sign the poll paper did not result in the relevant proxy votes not being counted.6.The deliberate conduct alleged against the appellant could not have been effectual unless the failure to sign was noticed: that is, not only was no object of financial gain or actual financial gain established, but also concealment of the failure would have been impossible or self-defeating.7.The evidence would not have been sufficient to establish guilt on the standard applied to criminal charges.8.Although proceedings such as these are meant, inter alia, to protect the public from persons unfit to act as directors, they are adversary proceedings, and natural justice requires that charges of serious misconduct be precisely formulated.9.The conduct alleged against the appellant was serious, but it was not shown to have been conduct in his capacity as a director; and in any event the allegation was not in our opinion such as would justify further proceedings against the appellant, in which the respect in which he was alleged to have been exercising his powers as a director, or discharging the duties of his office of director, would for the first time be precisely formulated by the respondent (after 12 days of hearing at first instance and 4 days of hearing on appeal).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established