JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
TITLE OF COURT : THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)
CITATION: HAYDEN LEIGH WHITE IN HIS CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATOR OF PORT VILLAGE ACCOMMODATION PTY LTD (IN LIQ) -v- ACN 153 152 731 PTY LTD (IN LIQ) [2018] WASCA 119
CORAM: MURPHY JA
MITCHELL JA
ALLANSON J
HEARD: 9 MARCH 2018
DELIVERED : 23 JULY 2018
FILE NO/S: CACV 59 of 2017
BETWEEN: HAYDEN LEIGH WHITE IN HIS CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATOR OF PORT VILLAGE ACCOMMODATION PTY LTD (IN LIQ)
Appellant
AND
ACN 153 152 731 PTY LTD (IN LIQ)
First Respondent
HICKORY GROUP PTY LTD
Second Respondent
ON APPEAL FROM:
Jurisdiction : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Coram: MASTER SANDERSON
Citation: WHITE & TEMPLETON -v- ACN 153 152 731 PTY LTD (in liq) [2017] WASC 52
File Number : COR 19 of 2016
Catchwords:
Corporations law - Insolvency - Alleged unfair preference payments and alleged uncommercial transaction - Where alleged unfair preference payments received by one company and correspondingly paid to parent company - Corresponding payments said to be in discharge of debts owed by payee to parent company - Liquidators' claim to recover corresponding payments made from payee to parent company - whether parent company had established a defence concerning no suspicion of insolvency - Primary court found defence established but by reference to incorrect statutory provision - Whether error vitiates primary judgment
Corporations law - Insolvency - Proper construction of defences under s 588FG(1) and s 588FG(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Corporations law - Insolvency - Whether parent company receiving payments from payee received a 'benefit' 'because of' the alleged insolvent transactions
Legislation:
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 588FF, s 588FG
Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA), s 58, s 59
Result:
Appeal allowed
Category: A
Representation:
Counsel:
| Appellant | : | Mr B Dharmananda SC & Ms C V Wren |
| First Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Second Respondent | : | Mr J Thompson SC & Mr R J S French |
Solicitors:
| Appellant | : | Clayton Utz |
| First Respondent | : | No appearance |
| Second Respondent | : | B2B Lawyers |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Beckwith v The Queen (1976) 135 CLR 569
Burness v Supaproducts Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 893; (2009) 74 ACSR 1
Buzzle Operations Pty Ltd (in liq) v Apple Computer Australia Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 109; (2011) 81 NSWLR 47
Calin v Greater Union Organisation Pty Ltd [1991] HCA 23; (1991) 173 CLR 33
Chappel v Hart [1998] HCA 55; (1998) 195 CLR 232
Cook's Construction Pty Ltd v Brown [2004] NSWCA 105; (2004) 49 ACSR 62
Cussen v Commissioner of Taxation [2003] NSWSC 841; (2003) 47 ACSR 107
Cussen v Commissioner of Taxation [2004] NSWCA 383; (2004) 51 ACSR 530
Deane v The City Bank of Sydney [1904] HCA 44; (1904) 2 CLR 198
Dean‑Willcocks v Commissioner of Taxation [2008] NSWSC 1113
Gedeon v Commissioner of New South Wales Crime Commission [2008] HCA 43; (2008) 236 CLR 120
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read White v ACN 153 152 731 Pty Ltd (in liq) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] WASCA 119
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether an error in the primary court's application of the statutory provisions concerning the defences to unfair preference claims would necessitate the setting aside of the primary judgment and ordering a retrial. The primary court had found that Hickory Group had no suspicion of insolvency, but the error was identified in the reference to the wrong statutory provision. The liquidators argued that this error vitiated the primary decision, while Hickory Group contended that the error did not affect the outcome since the primary court's findings on the relevant elements were essentially correct. The appeal court needed to determine the extent to which errors in legal reasoning affect the validity of a judgment and whether the identified error was vitiating.
The appeal court held that ordinarily, an appellate court would not set aside a judgment solely based on an error of law unless the error was critical to the decision. The court considered the principles established in Sydney Water Corporation v Caruso and Ord Irrigation Cooperative Ltd v Department of Water, which suggested that an error is vitiating if there is a reasonable possibility that it influenced the primary decision. However, the court also noted that a new trial would not be ordered if it would inevitably lead to the same outcome as the primary court's decision. Given that the primary court's findings on the key elements of the defence were correct, the appellate court concluded that the error in citing the wrong statutory provision did not vitiate the primary judgment. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the primary judgment was upheld.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
At least ordinarily, an appellate court would not exercise its power to set aside a judgment where an error of law appears in the primary court's reasons, unless the error is one upon which the decision depends. The relevant cases were examined in Sydney Water Corporation v Caruso.[141] In Caruso there was a difference of opinion between Allsop P and Tobias JA as to who bears the burden of persuasion of the existence of vitiating error and what that entails. The third judge, Sackville AJA, expressed no concluded view on that matter.[142] In Ord Irrigation Cooperative Ltd v Department of Water,[143] this court preferred the approach of Allsop P in the context of an appeal under s 105 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). In that case, an error was found to be vitiating where there was a reasonable possibility that the primary decision was influenced by legal error. It is unnecessary to further consider the differences in opinion for the resolution of this appeal.[141] Sydney Water Corporation v Caruso [2009] NSWCA 391.[142] See Caruso [25] ‑ [26] (Allsop P); [135] ‑ [136] (Tobias JA); and [191] ‑ [199] (Sackville AJA).[143] Ord Irrigation Cooperative Ltd v Department of Water [2018] WASCA 83 [130] ‑ [131], [137]. A related principle is that an appellate court would not, at least generally, order a new trial if it would inevitably result in the making of the same order as that made by the primary judge in the first trial.[144] The exercise of the court's jurisdiction to order a new trial ultimately depends upon the demands of justice.[145] [144] Stead v State Government Insurance Commission [1986] HCA 54; (1986) 161 CLR 141, 145; Deane v The City Bank of Sydney [1904] HCA 44; (1904) 2 CLR 198, 213.[145] Calin v Greater Union Organisation Pty Ltd [1991] HCA 23; (1991) 173 CLR 33, 39; McLennan v McCallum [2010] WASCA 45 [90] ‑ [91]. The exercise of an appellate court's jurisdiction in this regard is also to be considered in the context of the rules of court which allow a respondent who seeks to uphold the primary court's decision on a ground not relied on by the primary court, to file a notice of contention to that effect.[146][146] Part 5, r 33(4)(a)(ii), (4)(c) and (7) of the Supreme Court (Court of Appeal) Rules 2005 (WA). Hickory Group contends, in effect, that no error can be shown with respect to the master's reasoning and findings in relation to the elements of s 588FG(2). Accordingly, as the same elements are contained in s 588FG(1)(b), the master's erroneous reference to s 588FG(2) is, Hickory Group contends, immaterial. Hickory Group contends that in that event, the liquidators have failed to establish a vitiating error and are not entitled to orders setting aside the master's judgment and for a retrial. Alternatively (and this is really the other side of the coin), Hickory Group relies on par 2 of its notice of contention that the master's judgment should be upheld on the basis of his findings in relation to the elements of s 588FG(2).