White and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2008] AATA 543

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )   

)    No: 2007/1230

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION        )   

ReJoseph WHITE

Applicant

And    Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Respondent

DECISION

TribunalProfessor GD Walker, Deputy President, and Dr MEC Thorpe, Member

Date27 June 2008

PlaceSydney

DecisionThe decision under review is affirmed.

.................[sgd].............................

Professor GD Walker
  Deputy President

CATCHWORDS – whether applicant meets the medical standard for the issue of a class 2 medical certificate – if applicant does not meet the medical standard, whether the extent to which the applicant fails to meet that standard is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation – whether any conditions could be imposed upon a medical certificate that would ameliorate the threat posed to air safety by the applicant’s failure to meet the class 2 medical standard – appropriate diagnosis for applicant is a disturbance of consciousness for which there is no satisfactory medical explanation – found to be a real risk to the safety or air navigation – no conditions could be imposed to ameliorate risk – decision under review affirmed.

…

RELEVANT ACT/S:

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (the Act): 3, 9A, 20AB, 31

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act): 25, 37

…

CITATIONS

Re Window and Civil Aviation Safety Authority (1999) 56 ALD 316

Re Commins and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 1330

Re Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21

Re Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952

…

AUTHORITIES

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (CAR): 5.04

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (CASR): Part 67, Table 67, .155, .180, .195

…

OTHER REFERENCES

Gordon E & Devinsky O, Alcohol and Marijuana: Effects on Epilepsy and Use by Patients with Epilepsy" in Epilepsia (2001) Vol 42, No 10 p 1266-1272.

Zagnon P and Albano C, Psychostimulants and Epilepsy"in Epilepsia (2002) Vol 43, SUP 2 p 28-31.    

REASONS FOR DECISION

27 June 2008

Professor GD Walker, Deputy President, and

Dr MEC Thorpe, Member

Basic facts

1.      The applicant Mr Joseph White was born in 1975 and is currently aged 32.  On 12 September 2006, he was examined by a designated aviation medical examiner (DAME) for the purposes of his application to the respondent for a class 2 medical certificate.  On 20 October 2006, the applicant was issued with a student pilot (aeroplane) license.

2.      The following month he began flight training at Sydney Aerobatics School (also known as Red Baron Flight Training (Exhibit A2).  As the name implies, the course has a special emphasis on developing student skills in aerobatic manoeuvres.

3.      The applicant has accrued over 50 hours of dual flying in the school’s ab initio course.  He has not yet flown solo.

4.      On 15 February 2007, on the basis of the outcome of the DAME examination and further specialist medical evidence, a delegate of the respondent made the reviewable decision refusing the applicant a class 2 medical certificate (T pp31-32).

5.      The applicant sought review of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read White and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] AATA 543
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Joseph White, sought review of a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to refuse him a class 2 medical certificate. The tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant met the medical standard for the issue of a class 2 medical certificate, whether the extent to which the applicant failed to meet that standard was likely to endanger the safety of air navigation, and whether any conditions could be imposed upon a medical certificate that would ameliorate the threat posed to air safety by the applicant’s failure to meet the class 2 medical standard. The tribunal concluded that the appropriate diagnosis for the applicant was a disturbance of consciousness for which there was no satisfactory medical explanation, and which may recur. The tribunal found that the extent to which the applicant failed to meet the medical standard was likely to endanger the safety of air navigation. The tribunal found that no conditions could be imposed that would ameliorate the threat to air safety. The decision under review was affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Mr Joseph White, was born in 1975 and is currently aged 32. In September 2006, he applied for a class 2 medical certificate from the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to support his student pilot license, which he obtained in October 2006. He began flight training at Sydney Aerobatics School in November 2006. On February 15, 2007, CASA refused his application for a class 2 medical certificate, a decision which was subsequently affirmed. Mr White sought a review of this decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The key facts leading to the refusal of the medical certificate include Mr White's history of marijuana use, culminating in two significant incidents. In 2002, he was hospitalised for three days following a grand mal seizure, which doctors attributed to his marijuana use. After abstaining from the drug for three years, he experienced another incident in 2005, where he lost consciousness, the nature of which remains undetermined. Medical experts have been unable to definitively diagnose or explain this event.

Mr White initially applied for a review of CASA's decision to refuse his application for a class 2 medical certificate. This review was unsuccessful, leading him to apply for further review by the AAT. The AAT heard the case on April 29, 2008, with Dr Christopher Ward representing the applicant and Mr Joe Rule representing CASA. The AAT considered the evidence and submissions from both parties before affirming the original decision by CASA.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant meets the medical standard for the issue of a class 2 medical certificate.
2. If not, whether the extent to which the applicant fails to meet that standard is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation.
3. If so, whether any conditions could be imposed upon a medical certificate that would ameliorate the threat posed to air safety by the applicant’s failure to meet the class 2 medical standard.

Held
1. The tribunal held that the applicant does not meet the medical standard for the issue of a class 2 medical certificate.
2. The tribunal held that the extent to which the applicant fails to meet the medical standard is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation.
3. The tribunal held that no conditions could be imposed upon a medical certificate that would ameliorate the threat posed to air safety by the applicant’s failure to meet the class 2 medical standard.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The tribunal was tasked with determining whether the applicant met the medical standard for the issue of a class 2 medical certificate, whether the extent to which the applicant fails to meet that standard is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation, and if so, whether any conditions could be imposed upon a medical certificate to ameliorate the threat posed to air safety. The tribunal concluded that the applicant does not meet the medical standard for the issue of a class 2 medical certificate because of a history of seizures and a disturbance of consciousness for which there is no satisfactory medical explanation. The tribunal was reluctant to label the applicant as having epilepsy but found that the 2002 event was consistent with grand mal epileptiform seizures culminating in status epilepticus. The 2005 event was less clear, but the tribunal found that there was a real and not fanciful risk of another seizure. The tribunal concluded that the extent to which the applicant fails to meet the medical standard is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation because of the potentially catastrophic consequences of a seizure occurring during flight. The tribunal found that no conditions could be imposed upon a medical certificate that would ameliorate the threat to air safety because of the lack of certification from a specialist that the applicant is free from problematic use of alcohol and marijuana, and because the nature of a convulsive seizure would mean that even the presence of a safety pilot would not eliminate the risk of a seizure-induced loss of control. The tribunal therefore affirmed the decision under review. The tribunal relied on the Civil Aviation Act 1988, the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988, and the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998, as well as relevant case law and medical evidence. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that a history of seizures and a disturbance of consciousness for which there is no satisfactory medical explanation may prevent an applicant from meeting the medical standard for the issue of a class 2 medical certificate, and that the potentially catastrophic consequences of a seizure occurring during flight may endanger the safety of air navigation. The tribunal followed prior authority in finding that a small risk may suffice to trigger the need to take appropriate action to address the risk when issues of air safety are under consideration. The tribunal departed from the applicant’s submissions that there was a satisfactory explanation for his loss of consciousness and that he was at no higher risk than any other member of the population of any seizure event.