Commins and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Administrative

Appeals

Tribunal

 

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2004] AATA 1330

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2004/1303

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )

Re

Aidan Commins

Applicant

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Professor GD Walker, Deputy President

Date14 December 2004

PlaceSydney

Decision

The application under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 for an order to stay the decision of the respondent made on 22 September 2004 is refused.

..............................................

Professor GD Walker
  Deputy President  

6.      Dr Porges also enclosed a medical report from a urological surgeon, Dr Timothy Nicholson, dated 28 May 2004, addressed to Dr Porges, stating that the applicant had had no problems from kidney stones within the past two years and stating, inter alia, that “I am happy to send a note to Dr James Ross at CASA saying that it is extremely unlikely he will have problems from the stones”.

7.      On 22 September 2002, CASA notified Mr Commins that it considered the new information did not give any reasons why the restrictions were inappropriate and affirmed the decision. 

8. On 11 October 2004, Mr Commins lodged an application for a review of that decision by the tribunal, together with an application for a stay order under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (“the Act”).  On 20 October 2004, CASA made representations to the tribunal that it opposed the stay application stating inter alia:

CASA has decided that a medical certificate to be issued to Mr Commins should be accompanied by a condition requiring that Mr Commins fly as or with a co-pilot.

This is because CASA has decided that Mr Commins’ medical condition (Kidney stones) is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation if Mr Commins were allowed to fly without a copilot.  The kidney stones may cause sudden renal colic.  If Mr Commins were to be affected by sudden renal colic while piloting an aircraft, the copilot would be able to take control of the aircraft.

CASA relied in particular on the assessment of Dr Timothy Nicholson, Urological Surgeon, in the attached letter of 28 May 2004 to CASA’s Dr James Ross, about “the tiny stones he has present in both kidneys”.  Dr Nicholson said:

“I estimate a 95% chance that these tiny stones will not cause sudden renal colic and a 5% chance that they will within the next year.”

That is CASA’s reason for insisting on the “co-pilot” condition.  For the same reason, CASA opposes the application for a stay.

…       

CASA’s assessment is that without the “co-pilot” condition Mr Commins does not satisfy the legislative test for the issuing of a medical certificate.  Without the “co-pilot” condition, to allow Mr Commins to pilot an aircraft is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation (Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998, paragraph 67.180(1)(e)(ii)).

9.      At the hearing of this stay application, the applicant appeared in person and the respondent was represented by Greg Parkin, solicitor, of the Office of Legal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commins and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] AATA 1330
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Commins, applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a stay of a decision made by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority that his medical certificate should be accompanied by a condition that he fly as or with a co-pilot. The Tribunal considered the application under section 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether the application for a stay should be granted. In determining whether a stay should be granted, the Tribunal examined whether the applicant would suffer prejudice if the stay was not granted, whether the respondent would suffer prejudice if the stay was granted, and whether the applicant's application had prospects of success. The Tribunal also considered the risk to the public and safety concerns.

The Tribunal found that the applicant's application might have some prospects of success, but that there would be no hardship to the respondent if a stay were granted. The Tribunal found that whilst the applicant would suffer inconvenience and added expense, there was no evidence that he could not manage his business or conduct his business. The Tribunal found that the risk to the public could not be regarded as insignificant and that safety concerns weighed against the grant of a stay. The Tribunal found that a stay was not necessary to ensure the effectiveness of the hearing.

The application for a stay of the decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority is refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 for an order to stay the decision of the respondent made on 22 September 2004 is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Commins, holds a pilot's license and is required to obtain a medical certificate to maintain his license. On 22 September 2004, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) issued a decision that Commins' medical certificate must be accompanied by a condition that he fly as or with a co-pilot. This decision followed an examination of Commins' medical condition and an assessment of the risks to public safety. Commins sought a stay order to prevent the implementation of CASA's decision pending the outcome of a hearing into his application for review of that decision. The application for a stay order was based on the potential prejudice to Commins if the stay was not granted, the potential prejudice to CASA if the stay was granted, and the prospects of success of the application.

The matter came before the court as an application for a stay order under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The application was made in relation to a decision of CASA dated 22 September 2004. The court considered relevant legislation, including the Civil Aviation Act 1988 and the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998, as well as previous cases such as Re Griffiths Grif-Air Helicopters Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Authority, Re Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority, and Re Window and Civil Aviation Safety Authority. The court also considered the case of United States v Carroll Towing Co in its assessment of the risks to public safety and the prospects of success of the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there will be prejudice to the applicant if the stay is not granted.
2. Whether there will be prejudice to the respondent if the stay is granted.
3. Whether the application has some prospects of success.
4. Whether a stay is necessary to ensure the effectiveness of the hearing.
5. Whether the risk to the public can be regarded as insignificant and whether safety concerns weigh against the grant of a stay.

Held
1. The court held that there will be no prejudice to the respondent if the stay is granted.
2. The court held that there will be prejudice to the applicant if the stay is not granted, although it found that the applicant could manage his business without it.
3. The court held that the application has some prospects of success.
4. The court held that a stay is not necessary to ensure the effectiveness of the hearing.
5. The court held that the risk to the public cannot be regarded as insignificant and that safety concerns weigh against the grant of a stay.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the application for a stay order under section 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, considering whether the applicant would suffer prejudice if the stay was not granted, whether the respondent would suffer prejudice if the stay was granted, the prospects of success of the application, the necessity of a stay to ensure the effectiveness of the hearing, and the risks to public safety. The court noted that while the applicant might face inconvenience and added expense, there was no evidence that he could not manage his business without the stay. Conversely, the respondent would not suffer any prejudice if the stay were granted.

Regarding the prospects of success, the court found that the application had some prospects of success. However, it considered that a stay was not necessary to ensure the effectiveness of the hearing, as the applicant could still manage his business without the stay. The court emphasised the importance of public safety and found that the risk to the public could not be regarded as insignificant. The safety concerns were a significant factor against granting the stay, particularly in light of the statutory obligations under the Civil Aviation Act 1988 and the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998.

The court referenced previous cases such as Re Griffiths Grif-Air Helicopters Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Authority (1993) 31 ALD 375, Re Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21, and Re Window and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 525, which established precedents concerning the balance between operational needs and public safety in the context of civil aviation. The court also considered the principles from United States v Carroll Towing Co (1947) 159 F 2d 169 regarding the burden of proof in safety-related matters. Based on these considerations, the court concluded that the risk to the public outweighed the potential benefits of granting the stay, leading to the refusal of the stay application.