MacNeall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

MacNeall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2016] AATA 975 (25 November 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers

2015/4469 & 2016/3913

Re

Denis MacNeall

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member CR Walsh &
Professor J Quinlivan, Member

Date 25 November 2016
Place Perth

The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

....(Sgd)..........................................................

Senior Member CR Walsh

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – applicant holds a private pilot licence, a commercial pilot licence and an air transport pilot licence – applicant applied to the respondent for a Class 1 medical certificate and a Class 2 medical certificate - whether respondent’s decision not to issue the applicant with a Class 1 medical certificate is the correct and preferable decision – whether the respondent’s decision to issue the applicant with a Class 2 medical certificate, subject to the condition “Holder to fly with safety pilot only”, is the correct and preferable decision – decisions under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Act 1988 – s 9A

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 – reg 11.056 - reg 61.410(1) – reg 61.415(1) – reg 61.415(2) – reg 67.010 – reg 67.015 – reg 67.150 – reg 67.155 – reg 67.180

CASES

Commins and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 1330

Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21
Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952
Randazzo and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2012] AATA 266
White and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2008] AATA 543

Window v Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 525

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member CR Walsh &
Professor J Quinlivan, Member

25 November 2016

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr MacNeall was born in 1945 and is currently 71 years of age.

  2. Mr MacNeall holds a private pilot licence, a commercial pilot licence and an air transport pilot licence.

  3. Broadly, the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (the CASR) require the holder of a private pilot licence, a commercial pilot licence or an airport transport licence to also hold a current Class 1 medical certificate or Class 2 medical certificate, issued by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA), to be authorised to exercise the privileges of the relevant licence: refer to regs 61.410(1) and 61.415(1) and (2) of the CASR.

  4. On 3 December 2014, Mr MacNeall applied to CASA for a Class 1 medical certificate.

  5. On 23 July 2015, CASA wrote to Mr MacNeall notifying him of its decision to refuse to issue him with a Class 1 medical certificate (the Class 1 Medical Certificate Decision).  The Class 1 Medical Certificate Decision states:

    Medical history and current medical status

    On the basis of the available evidence, I have determined that you have an established medical history of multi-vessel coronary artery disease with evidence of moderate reversible ischaemia and post stress left ventricular dysfunction.

    Applicable medical standard

    The medical standard applicable to your application for a Class 1 Medical Certificate is Medical Standard 1. set out in Table 67.150 of the CASR.

    …

    Due to this medical condition,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MacNeall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 975
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr MacNeall applied to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) for a Class 1 and a Class 2 medical certificate. CASA decided not to issue a Class 1 medical certificate and to issue a Class 2 medical certificate subject to the condition that he fly only with a safety pilot. Mr MacNeall sought review of these decisions before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether CASA's decision not to issue a Class 1 medical certificate was the correct and preferable decision, and whether the decision to issue a Class 2 medical certificate subject to the condition "Holder to fly with safety pilot only" was also the correct and preferable decision.

The Tribunal considered Mr MacNeall's medical history, which included obstructive coronary disease, ischaemic cardiomyopathy, aortic stenosis, and left ventricular systolic dysfunction. CASA determined that these conditions presented an unacceptable risk of inflight incapacitation due to the potential for sudden onset of chest pain, shortness of breath, or loss of consciousness. CASA applied an acceptable annual risk percentage of 1% for Class 1 certificate holders and 2% for Class 2 certificate holders, and assessed Mr MacNeall's risk of acute incapacitating events to be between 3.5% and 5% per annum. The Tribunal affirmed CASA's decision not to issue a Class 1 medical certificate, finding that the risk was too high. However, the Tribunal found that the condition "Holder to fly with safety pilot only" adequately ameliorated the risks to air safety for a Class 2 medical certificate, provided specific operational requirements were met, such as side-by-side seating, dual controls, and the wearing of a shoulder restraint harness.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr MacNeall holds a private pilot licence, a commercial pilot licence and an air transport pilot licence. On 13 May 2016, he applied to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) for a Class 1 medical certificate and a Class 2 medical certificate. CASA assessed Mr MacNeall’s medical history and current medical status, which includes obstructive coronary disease, moderate ischaemic cardiomyopathy, mild aortic stenosis, and moderate overall left ventricular systolic dysfunction. Based on this assessment, CASA concluded that Mr MacNeall did not meet the medical standards for a Class 1 medical certificate. CASA determined that Mr MacNeall’s medical condition presented an unacceptable risk of inflight incapacitation, which could interfere with his ability to safely exercise the privileges of a pilot’s licence. As a result, CASA decided to issue Mr MacNeall a Class 2 medical certificate, subject to the condition that he must fly with a safety pilot only. This condition includes specific operational requirements to mitigate the risks associated with Mr MacNeall’s medical condition.

Mr MacNeall applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for a review of CASA's decision not to issue him a Class 1 medical certificate and to issue him a Class 2 medical certificate subject to the condition of flying with a safety pilot only. The AAT heard the matter and issued a decision affirming CASA's decisions. Mr MacNeall then appealed to the Federal Court of Australia, which also affirmed the AAT’s decision. The appeal to the High Court of Australia was subsequently dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 7 July 2016, CASA wrote to Mr MacNeall notifying him of its decision to issue him with a Class 2 medical certificate subject to the condition “Holder to fly with safety pilot only” (the Class 2 Medical Certificate Decision). The Class 2 Medical Certificate Decision states:Medical history and current medical statusOn the basis of the available evidence, I have determined that you have an established medical history of obstructive coronary disease with significant residual ischaemia despite CABD and PCI, moderate ischaemic cardiomyopathy with evidence of prior infarction, mild aortic stenosis, and moderate overall LV systolic dysfunction.Medical Standard…The medical standard applicable to your application for a Class 2 Medical Certificate is Medical Standard 2, set out in Table 67.155 of the CASR.…Due to your medical condition … I have decided that you do not meet the above sections of the Medical Standard.As you do not meet the Medical Standard, I may only grant you a … Class 2 Medical Certificate if I am satisfied that the extent to which you fail to meet the applicable medical standards is not likely to endanger the safety of air navigation.Risks to air safetyYour condition presents an unacceptable risk of inflight incapacitation, because it may cause the following symptoms or side effects which would interfere with your ability to safely exercise the privileges of a pilot’s licence:· sudden onset of distracting or disabling chest pain;· sudden onset of distracting or disabling shortness of breath (dyspnoea);· loss of consciousness (syncope).I have therefore decided that there is a real and substantial risk that these symptoms will interfere with your ability to safely pilot an aircraft and therefore create an unacceptable risk to the safety of air navigation.Conditional CertificateWhile it is acknowledged that the determination of likelihood of risk under Part 67 of the CASR is not a purely statistical or mathematical task, CASA makes use of annual absolute risk percentages of acute incapacitating events in order to assist in determining whether such an event is ‘likely’ for the purposes of regulation 67.180. An acceptable annual risk of 1% for class 1 certificate holders is applied. For Class 2 certificate holders an acceptable risk of 2% is applied. This approach is described in the extract from Ernsting’s Aviation Medicine 4th Edition page 554 to 559 attached.The evidence available to CASA would indicate that your annual absolute risk percentage of acute incapacitating events is in the range of 3.5 to 5% per annum. This clearly is a magnitude of absolute risk greater than what would be considered for any class of medical certificate.…With respect to your Class 2 Medical Certificate, I have concluded that imposing the following operational limitation “with safety pilot only” would adequately ameliorate the risks to air safety posed by your medical condition …The special condition “Holder to fly with safety pilot only” is associated with a number of requirements that include, among others, that the aircraft flown must be configured with side by side seating in the cockpit, the aircraft being flown must have dual flying controls and that the pilot with the special condition must wear a shoulder restraint harness at all times when occupying a control seat. The Australian Transport Safety Report AO-2008-021 which relates to the collision with terrain of a tandem seat aircraft in 2008 clearly demonstrates why these conditions are required.DecisionI have therefore decided to …issue you with a Class 2 Medical Certificate subject to the condition “with safety pilot only”.(Emphasis added.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court reviewed the decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977. The court examined CASA's assessment of the applicant's medical history and current medical status, which included obstructive coronary disease, moderate ischaemic cardiomyopathy, mild aortic stenosis, and moderate overall left ventricular systolic dysfunction. These conditions were considered to present an unacceptable risk of inflight incapacitation, which could lead to symptoms such as sudden onset of chest pain, shortness of breath, and loss of consciousness. Given the risks, CASA determined that the applicant did not meet the medical standard for a Class 1 medical certificate. The annual absolute risk percentage of acute incapacitating events for the applicant was assessed to be between 3.5 to 5% per annum, exceeding the acceptable risk of 1% for Class 1 certificate holders and 2% for Class 2 certificate holders. Therefore, the court upheld the decision not to issue a Class 1 medical certificate.

In relation to the issuance of a Class 2 medical certificate with the condition "Holder to fly with safety pilot only", the court noted that CASA's decision was based on a thorough assessment of the risks involved and the measures needed to mitigate them. The condition included requirements such as side-by-side seating in the cockpit, dual flying controls, and the use of a shoulder restraint harness. The court accepted CASA’s reasoning that these conditions adequately mitigate the risks to air safety, as demonstrated by the evidence and authorities provided, including the Australian Transport Safety Report AO-2008-021. Consequently, the court found that CASA's decision to issue a Class 2 medical certificate with these conditions was the correct and preferable decision. The binding legal principle established is that in cases where an applicant’s medical condition poses a significant risk to air safety, the issuing authority may impose conditions on a Class 2 medical certificate to mitigate those risks.