McClymont and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

McClymont and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2019] AATA 5429 (17 December 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:         2019/0397

Re:Malcolm McClymont

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D K Grigg

Date:17 December 2019

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

................................[Sgd].......................................

Member D K Grigg

Catchwords

CIVIL AVIATION – conditional Class 2 Medical Certificate – medical standards – glaucoma condition – examination of medical evidence – applicant does not meet the relevant medical standard – likelihood of risk to air navigation safety – whether any safety relevant conditions can be imposed on the licence – decision of the respondent affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth)

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth)

Cases

Bolton and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2013] AATA 941

Commins and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 1330

Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21

Judges and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2012] AATA 587

Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952

Re Window and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 525

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D K Grigg

17 December 2019

BACKGROUND

  1. This matter concerns the Civil Aviation Safety Authority’s (“CASA”) refusal to issue


    Mr McClymont, the Applicant, with a Class 2 Medical Certificate as a result of his glaucoma condition.

  2. In April 2014 Mr McClymont applied for an Aviation Class 2 Medical Certificate.[1]

    [1]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T4, page 14, Application for Aviation Medical Certificate – Declaration dated 30 April 2014.

  3. On 19 May 2014 CASA granted Mr McClymont a class 2 aviation medical certificate subject to the condition that “Reading Correction to be available whilst exercising the privileges of this license”. The certificate was valid until 30 April 2016.[2]

    [2]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 17 – 18, Letter from CASA to Mr McClymont enclosing aviation medical certificate class 2 dated 19 May 2014.

  4. On 10 August 2015 Mr McClymont was examined by Dr Denis Stark, Ophthalmic Physician and Surgeon. Dr Stark reported that Mr McClymont has evidence of chronic simple glaucoma but that his total field loss is virtually zero. Dr Stark recommended that he continue using Xalacom drops to control his glaucoma.[3]

    [3]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T7, page 19, Report of Dr Denis Stark dated 10 August 2015.

  5. On 16 March 2016 Mr McClymont again applied for an aviation medical certificate class 2.[4]

    [4]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T8, page 21, Application for Aviation Medical Certificate dated 16 March 2016.

  6. On 13 May 2016 CASA granted Mr McClymont a class 2 aviation medical certificate with the condition that “Reading Correction to be available whilst exercising the privileges of this license”. The certificate was valid until 16 March 2018.[5] CASA also advised that it was placing him on audit to monitor the progress of his condition and, when his medical certificate was due for renewal in two years’ time, CASA would require…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McClymont and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 5429
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr. McClymont against a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to refuse him a conditional Class 2 Medical Certificate. The dispute centred on whether Mr. McClymont's diagnosed glaucoma condition, specifically his bilateral visual field loss, meant he failed to meet the relevant medical standards for safe air navigation. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was tasked with determining this issue.

The Tribunal was required to consider three key questions. Firstly, whether Mr. McClymont met the medical standards for a Class 2 Medical Certificate as prescribed by the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations (CASR). Secondly, if he did not meet these standards, whether the extent of his failure was "likely to endanger the safety of air navigation" under regulation 67.180(2)(e)(ii) of the CASR. Finally, if a risk to safety was established, the Tribunal had to determine whether any conditions could be imposed on his licence under regulation 11.056 of the CASR to mitigate that risk.

The Tribunal's reasoning was heavily influenced by the expert medical evidence provided by CASA's appointed optometrist, Mr. Gibson, and an ophthalmologist, Dr. Fitzgerald. Their evidence indicated significant visual field loss in both of Mr. McClymont's eyes, including defects within 20 degrees of the visual axis and a severely compromised central superior quadrant in his right eye. This evidence was largely unchallenged by Mr. McClymont, who presented no contrary medical opinion. The Tribunal applied the principle from previous cases, such as *Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority*, that even a small risk to air safety may necessitate action, and that the assessment of likelihood is not purely statistical but involves weighing safety requirements against the applicant's interests. The Tribunal found that Mr. McClymont's visual impairment presented a more than remote risk to air navigation safety, and that the proposed imposition of a safety pilot condition was uncertain to adequately ameliorate this risk, as a safety pilot might not be aware of the subtle limitations of Mr. McClymont's vision.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed CASA's decision to refuse the conditional Class 2 Medical Certificate. The Tribunal concluded that Mr. McClymont did not meet the relevant medical standards and that the extent of his failure was likely to endanger the safety of air navigation, with no sufficiently effective conditions able to be imposed to mitigate this risk.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

CASA’s principal submission is that, based on the medical evidence, Mr McClymont’s bilateral visual field loss is such that:(a)he has bilateral defects within 20 degrees of the visual access;(b)he has severely compromised visual field in the Right central superior quadrant; (c)he has unknown visual field losses beyond 40 degrees from fixation; (d)he fails to meet medical standards 2.1(b), 2.2, 2.31, 2.32 and 2.33; and(e)there are no suitable conditions which could be placed on his certificate.EvidenceMr David Prossor Mr Prossor is a Flight Instructor Grade 1. Since 2000, he has conducted approximately 266 flight reviews and has been flying since 3 May 1964. On 14 February 2018 Mr Prossor conducted a flight review with Mr McClymont. Mr Prossor told the Tribunal that in his assessment:[34]“Mr McClymont had no issues at all in landing…I asked you to do various manoeuvres. We did some storming manoeuvres, we did some steep turns, we did some under the hood work where you’re limited to flying with a hood over the gentleman’s face so that he can only fly on the basic instruments in front of him…I found he had no issues with that…… We did a practice forced landing, and I was happy that he could put the aeroplane on the ground in a clear patch there. We also conducted what is called an engine failure after take-off.”[34] Transcript, page 7, lines 12, 21 – 23, 28, 30 – 33. In Mr Prossor’s opinion:[35]“While Mr McClymont may have less than perfect vision in his left eye he has shown…in a practical field check that he is capable and able to conduct safe flight and that his pre existing flight experience would make up for any perceived shortcomings in his ability to fly safely.”[35] Exhibit 1, Statement of Mr David Prossor dated 1 June 2019, page 4. Mr Prossor says he did not notice any deficiencies that may have been caused by his vision during that flight, although he acknowledged that he did not take any assessment or measurement of Mr McClymont’s visual field at the time of the test.Mr Malcolm McClymont Mr McClymont said the testing conducting by Flight Instructor David Prossor involved:(a)over five landings at two different airstrips;(b)different aircraft configurations;(c)carrying out stalls and recovery, and steep turns onto prescribed headings without gaining or losing excessive altitude;(d)undergoing 0.2 hours of flight under simulated instrument conditions where he was required to turn onto prescribed headings and climb and descend to prescribed altitudes while flying solely by reference to the aircraft’s instruments; and(e)his vision outside the aircraft being blocked by special goggles. Mr McClymont submitted that, in relation to his current flying ability, the testing conducted by Mr Prossor showed that:(a)he could safely land the aircraft on every landing without any intervention;(b)his “ability to judge approach angle, flare height and rate and the actual touchdown were unimpaired by my vision defects despite Dr Fitzgerald and Mr Gibson saying I would be unable to carry out those tasks.”[36];(c)the manoeuvres undertaken would not have been possible if his vision impeded my view of the instruments;(d)he had “no deficiencies in [his] abilities attributable to my eyesight” and, therefore(e)there was “no likelihood of such an accident or incident suddenly occurring”.[36] Applicant’s Final Submission dated 22 September 2019.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal notes Mr Gibson’s acknowledgement that the images in his report are only representative of what Mr McClymont’s impaired vision based on his application of the known data. Conclusion on Risk It is apparent from the medical evidence that Mr McClymont’s condition places him, and potentially others, at a more than remote risk. The Tribunal notes that Mr McClymont presented no medical evidence or opinion to contradict the opinions of Dr Fitzgerald or Mr Gibson. No medical evidence was led by Mr McClymont. The experts’ opinions are essentially unchallenged. Both Dr Fitzgerald and Mr Gibson came to the same conclusion regarding the seriousness of Mr McClymont’s vision impairment and the associated risk to safe air navigation. While Mr Prossor expressed the view that Mr McClymont’s condition posed little risk, Mr Prossor is not medically qualified and cannot give a qualified opinion on the risks associated with someone with Mr McClymont’s visual impairment. Although Dr D’Mellow did not perform the appropriate test for CASA’s purposes, Dr D’Mellow did specifically note that Mr McClymont has “significant loss in his left eye”. The evidence of Dr Fitzgerald and Mr Gibson is consistent as follows:(a)Mr McClymont may have been able to obtain a medical licence to drive but this has no bearing on the standards required for the issuance of a Class 2 Medical Certificate by CASA;(b)Mr McClymont has significant field loss in both eyes;(c)Mr McClymont passed his assessment with Mr Prossor but this does not mean the risk is remote;(d)Mr McClymont’s visual field loss may result in collision with other traffic (or birds) and present difficulties on landing; and(e)Mr McClymont may not be aware of the extent to which he cannot see things of relevance to air safety. CASA’s overarching obligation is to regard the safety of air navigation as the most important consideration in the exercise of its powers and the performance of its functions. To this end, the Tribunal finds that the extent to which Mr McClymont fails to meet the Medical Standard is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation.[63][63] CASR r 67.180(2)(e)(ii). The next issue for determination is whether any condition, such as the Safety Pilot Condition, can be imposed which would ameliorate the threat to the safety of air navigation.IMPOSITION OF A SAFETY RELEVANT CONDITION The only safety relevant condition proposed was that of a safety pilot. Mr Gibson says Mr McClymont should not fly alone, and that a well-trained co-pilot “might mitigate this risk but would need to be well prepared”. During the hearing Mr Gibson:(a)acknowledged that he is not a pilot and that whether a safety-pilot condition would appropriately ameliorate the risk posed, was a decision for CASA;(b)said he was “not in a position to judge”;(c)then said “I’m qualified to that opinion but I don’t know what the regulations are and what CASA’s attitude [is] - I said might mitigate this risk but would need to be well-prepared”;[64](emphasis added)(d)indicated that any impairment in terms of flight path and control of the aircraft might be subtle and potentially missed by a safety pilot “unless he was aware of the fact that there were some limitations to his vision that the second pilot may not be aware that Mr McClymont and miss some detail”.[65][64] Transcript, page 63, lines 42 – 44.[65] Transcript, page 49, lines 23 – 25.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21 (“Hall”) Deputy President RP Handley said at paragraph 45:“As the Tribunal stated in Re Windows (supra), the assessment of what is "likely" cannot be based on statistical likelihood. In this context, it is a matter of weighing up the requirements of air safety with the applicant's interest in the safe exercise of the privileges and performance of the duties associated with holding a private pilot's licence. … When issues of air safety are under consideration, a small risk may be sufficient to trigger the need to take appropriate action to address the risk. This was the case here.”(emphasis added) The CASR do not specifically prescribe any particular level of risk. The Tribunal noted this in Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952, and, after referring to Re Window and Hall, said:“[65] Whether Mr Mulholland has a high risk or a low risk of losing consciousness while flying an aircraft is simply irrelevant. The fact is that he has a risk of incapacitation which is significantly different to the remainder of the aviator population who do not suffer from syncope or any other safety-relevant medical condition. In our view the risk of incapacitation is real and not an imaginable or fanciful risk nor is it a remote risk.”ISSUES FOR THE TRIBUNAL The issues for determination by the Tribunal are:(a)does Mr McClymont meet the medical standard for the issue of a Class 2 Medical Certificate as set out in Table 67.155 of the CASR; if no,(b)is the extent to which Mr McClymont fails to meet the relevant medical standard “likely to endanger the safety of air navigation” within regulation 67.180(2)(e)(ii) of the CASR; and, if yes,(c)can any conditions be imposed under regulation 11.056 of the CASR which would ameliorate the threat to the safety of air navigation.DOES MR MCCLYMONT HAVE AN ESTABLISHED MEDICAL HISTORY OR CLINICAL DIAGNOSIS OF A SAFETY-RELEVANT CONDITION: ITEM 2.1, TABLE 67.155 CASA contends that Mr McClymont does presently have a safety-relevant condition (a visual field deficit) and that he does not meet the requisite medical standard and therefore the refusal to grant a Class 2 Medical Certificate is appropriate. The term “condition” is not defined in the CASR. However, as noted by Deputy President PE Hack SC in Bolton and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2013] AATA 941 (“Bolton”), at [28]:“Given that “safety-relevant” is defined in reg 67.015 of the CASR by reference to “a medically significant condition” it must be used in the sense of a state of health.” Mr Gibson, Optometrist, was engaged by CASA to consider the Mr McClymont’s vision test results and to consider the safety risks association by Mr McClymont’s vision status. Mr Gibson provided a report on 4 April 2019 and gave evidence at the hearing. Mr Gibson reported that based on the medical test results available, Mr McClymont has:[32] (a)overlapping visual field loss in each eye but much worse in the left eye;(b)bilateral defects within 20° of the visual axis;(c)a severely compromised visual field in the Right central superior quadrant; and(d)unknown visual field losses beyond 40° from fixation.[32] Exhibit 7, Report of Mr Tony Gibson dated 4 April 2019.