Daniel Bolton and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

[2013] AATA  941

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/3717

Re

Daniel Bolton

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President PE Hack SC

Date 23 December 2013
Place Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and a decision substituted not to cancel the applicant's class 1 and class 2 medical certificates.

.......................[sgd]…........................

Deputy President PE Hack SC

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – cancellation of medical certificates – skull fracture – extradural haemorrhage – risk of posttraumatic seizures – whether applicant meets medical standard – whether applicant has safety-relevant condition – whether applicant suffering from safety-relevant effects of head injury – whether likely to endanger safety of air navigation – decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998, regs 67.150, 67.155, 67.180(2)(e)

CASES

Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President PE Hack SC

23 December 2013

Introduction

  1. The applicant, Mr Daniel Bolton, is a commercial pilot by occupation.  In March 2013 he was assaulted.  His skull was fractured but he has made a good recovery from that injury.  The respondent, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA), was concerned that the skull fracture, together with an associated haemorrhage, put Mr Bolton at risk of experiencing posttraumatic seizures, also referred to as posttraumatic epilepsy, and neurocognitive deficits such that there was an unacceptable risk to the safety of air navigation if he continued to fly.

  2. On 5 July 2013 CASA decided to cancel[1] Mr Bolton’s class 1 and class 2 medical certificates issued to him pursuant to Pt 67 of the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) (the CASR). Without those certificates Mr Bolton may not lawfully perform the duties authorised by his licence, whether as a commercial pilot or otherwise.

    [1]The document described in the index to the s 37 documents as the reviewable decision records a decision “to refuse to issue… a Class 1 & 2 Medical Certificate…” (exhibit 1, page 9) however the document sent to Mr Bolton (exhibit 1, page 3) describes the decision as one to cancel those certificates. Despite that, it is common ground that the decision was one to cancel.

  3. Mr Bolton seeks a review of the decision of 5 July 2013.

  4. I have come to the conclusion that cancellation of Mr Bolton's medical certificates is not warranted and that he should be permitted to fly, and to fly commercially.  I explain my reasons below.

    Background

  5. The factual background is not in dispute.  Mr Bolton is 23 years of age.  He is fit and healthy.  He is the holder of a Commercial Pilot (Aeroplane) Licence and, prior to the incident in March 2013, had been employed for more than two years as a pilot flying single-engine aeroplanes out of Airlie Beach in Queensland.  In the early hours of 10 March 2013 he was with friends when he was punched in the right side of his head.  He says that he did not lose consciousness and that he can recall the entire…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Daniel Bolton and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 941
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Daniel Bolton and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) were involved in a dispute regarding the cancellation of Mr Bolton's medical certificates, which would have prevented him from flying commercially. Mr Bolton, a commercial pilot, had sustained a skull fracture after being punched in the head. Despite undergoing surgery and making a full recovery, CASA sought to cancel his medical certificates due to concerns about potential long-term neurological effects.

The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether Mr Bolton met the medical standards set forth by CASA, which require that a pilot have no safety-relevant conditions or effects from a head injury. This involved determining whether Mr Bolton's injury and its aftermath posed a risk that would compromise his ability to fly safely. Additionally, the court had to assess the expert medical evidence presented by both parties to determine Mr Bolton's fitness to fly.

The court found that Mr Bolton did not have any safety-relevant conditions or effects from his head injury. Dr Cameron, a consultant neurologist, testified that Mr Bolton had made a complete recovery and had no symptoms suggesting neurological consequences or risk of post-traumatic epilepsy. Although Dr Somerville concluded that Mr Bolton had an increased risk of seizures due to the depressed skull fracture and extradural haematoma, the court found that this did not constitute a safety-relevant condition. The court also noted that there was no evidence of impaired consciousness or cortical injury, and that Mr Bolton's risk of seizure was low. Consequently, the court ruled that Mr Bolton met the medical standards required to fly commercially.

Based on the findings, the court decided that Mr Bolton's medical certificates should not be cancelled, allowing him to continue his career as a commercial pilot.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I have come to the conclusion that cancellation of Mr Bolton's medical certificates is not warranted and that he should be permitted to fly, and to fly commercially. I explain my reasons below.Background The factual background is not in dispute. Mr Bolton is 23 years of age. He is fit and healthy. He is the holder of a Commercial Pilot (Aeroplane) Licence and, prior to the incident in March 2013, had been employed for more than two years as a pilot flying single-engine aeroplanes out of Airlie Beach in Queensland. In the early hours of 10 March 2013 he was with friends when he was punched in the right side of his head. He says that he did not lose consciousness and that he can recall the entire event. That may not be correct as his Designated Aviation Medical Examiner (DAME) reported to CASA on 21 March 2013 that he was unable to recall approximately 30 seconds at the time of the incident[2]. Immediately after the incident Mr Bolton noticed what appeared to be an indentation in his skull and he had a headache. He was taken by ambulance to the Proserpine Hospital where a skull fracture was diagnosed. He was transferred to the Townsville Hospital and admitted later that day. [2]Exhibit 1, page 42. Mr Bolton is adamant that it was the punch that caused the fracture and that his head did not hit the ground[3]. Dr Ernest Somerville, a consultant neurologist engaged by CASA, points to a reference in the triage note from the Proserpine Hospital which suggests that Mr Bolton was unsure, on his arrival at that hospital after the injury, whether he had been punched in the right side of the head or whether he had been punched and then fallen onto his right side[4]. Ultimately, it seems to me not to matter how the fracture was caused; what matters is the severity of it. I note that that triage note was not, so far as I am aware, in the evidence in the proceedings. It may have been part of the medical records obtained on summons but that material was not tendered in the proceedings. [3]Exhibit 5, paragraph 8.[4]Exhibit 9, page 1. A CT scan undertaken at the Townsville Hospital reported as follows[5],Findings: There is a depressed, comminuted fracture of the right temporal and parietal bones. The depressed segment has a combined AP diameter of 5 cm and a caudal diameter of 4 cm. There are 3-4 major fragments depressed by up to 1 cm.A thin underlying extradural haemorrhage is demonstrated at the posterior margin of the fracture measuring approximately 0.5 cm in depth. No subdural or subarachnoid blood is demonstrated. There is no apparent cerebral oedema or definite cerebral contusions.Conclusion: Depressed right temporoparietal skull fracture with at least 4 major fragments and central depression of up to 1 cm. Minimal associated extradural haemorrhage.On 13 March 2013 the depressed fracture was elevated surgically. The procedure was performed without complication and Mr Bolton was discharged on 15 March 2013.[5] Exhibit 1, page 41. Since the surgery Mr Bolton has remained well, he has not experienced any headaches and has had no episodes of vertigo or any symptoms to suggest any type of epileptic event[6]. He has noticed no problems with concentration, mood, personality or memory function since the surgery. He has successfully undertaken three of the examinations required for his Air Transport Pilot Licence.[6]Exhibit 2, page 2. The statutory setting

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For his part, Mr Bolton contends that he has recovered from his injury and now meets medical standard 1 and medical standard 2. The decision, he says, ought be set aside and a decision made that the medical certificates not be cancelled.The medical evidence For some time now the Tribunal, in common with most of the courts and tribunals of this country, has had published Guidelines for Persons Giving Expert and Opinion Evidence (the Guidelines). The Guidelines have the aim of ensuring that those who give expert or opinion evidence do so as independent experts, seeking to assist the Tribunal, rather than as advocates for the cause of the party calling that expert. If followed, the Guidelines ought ensure that the factual assumptions that underlie the opinions expressed are demonstrated, not left to speculation. None of the reports relied upon by the parties to these proceedings came close to satisfying the Guidelines. Mr Bolton relied upon the report of Dr John Cameron, a consultant neurologist. In addition to his specialist medical qualifications Dr Cameron has a postgraduate Diploma in Aviation Medicine and is a DAME. As it happens, CASA was intending to obtain a report from Dr Cameron for the purposes of these proceedings. His report did not, as it ought, annex the letter of instruction from Mr Bolton's solicitors, it did not list the documentary material considered by him and it did not contain the declaration of duty required by paragraph 14 of the Guidelines, that is, the acknowledgement by the witness of the overriding duty to provide impartial assistance to the Tribunal. Dr Cameron examined Mr Bolton on 23 October 2013 and arranged for an EEG. Dr Cameron's opinions were expressed in this way[11]:[11]Exhibit 2, pages 2-3.Mr. Bolton has made a complete recovery from this depressed skull fracture.He has no symptoms to suggest any neurological consequence of this head injury, particularly epilepsy at this time.His MRI imaging of his brain shows no underlying gliosis[[12]] or hemosiderin deposit[[13]] to suggest potential risk for developing post-traumatic epilepsy.He has normal neurocognitive functioning on my assessment on 23 October 2013.Depressed skull fractures in some articles have been shown to be associated with a slightly increased incidence of post-traumatic epilepsy while in other studies, depressed skull fractures alone are not associated with increased risk of post-traumatic epilepsy.This man did develop a small, extradural haemorrhage associated with this skull fracture. The operative notes in particular noted that there was no dural tear and no evidence of underlying contusion on CT imaging at the time.This man’s small haemorrhage was contained in the extradural compartment and there was no evidence that he suffered any underlying brain injury in this event.I note also that this man suffered no impaired consciousness at the time of the assault. He had total recollection of events throughout the incident and after. His [Glasgow Coma Score] was 15. He had no focal neurological findings.Overall, I would assess that this man's risk of suffering post-traumatic epilepsy in this particular case is no more than that of the general population. I believe he is medically fit to return to flying but this obviously will have to be determined by CASA.I arranged for him to have an EEG, the study was normal and the results are enclosed.[12]Scarring.[13]The release of iron from the blood.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In any event, Dr Somerville concluded as follows[17]:Mr Bolton is at increased risk of seizures as a result of the head injury. The two characteristics of the injury that increase his risk are the depressed skull fracture and the extradural haematoma. However, there was brief, if any, loss of consciousness, very little, if any, post-traumatic amnesia and no cortical injury clinically or on imaging. Epidemiological studies group patients with common characteristics and their ability to subdivide these groups is generally limited by numbers of subjects. The studies above would include Mr Bolton in the categories of skull fracture, depressed skull fracture and extradural haematoma. However, this group would include patients with much more severe head injuries. Multivariate analysis attempts to exclude those other factors, so that the risk factor being examined does indeed account for most of the increased risk on its own. In Mr Bolton's case, the most pessimistic estimate would give him a 2.5% risk of a seizure occurring in the first 12 months and 0.8% risk in the 2nd 12 months.The impact of this increased risk on Mr Bolton’s safety to fly depends not only on its size but the likelihood that if a seizure occurs, it will happen while operating an aircraft and consideration of the consequences of a seizure while flying.[17]Exhibit 9, pages 2-3.Consideration The first question that arises is whether Mr Bolton fails to meet the medical standard. Am I satisfied that he has no safety-relevant condition of the type described in item 1.1 of table 67.150 of the CASR and the equivalent item in table 67.155 and that he is not suffering from safety-relevant effects of a head injury? The evidence of Dr Cameron satisfies me that he does not have any such condition and that he is not suffering from safety-relevant effects of a head injury. There is, in my view, no evidence that Mr Bolton has any safety-relevant condition. The term "condition" is not defined. Given that "safety-relevant" is defined in reg 67.015 of the CASR by reference to "a medically significant condition" it must be used in the sense of a state of health. The evidence of Dr Hastings and Dr Somerville (and that of Dr Navathe) does not suggest that Mr Bolton has any condition, medically significant or otherwise, rather it is to the effect that, as a consequence of his injury, he has a higher than normal risk that he has such a condition. The case of Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority[18], referred to in CASA's Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, was an entirely different case. Mr Mulholland had experienced occasions of loss of consciousness brought about by a temporally insufficient flow of blood to the brain. What was controversial in the case was the cause of the condition; the condition itself was not in issue.[18] [2007] AATA 1952 The same is true of "safety-relevant effects of a head injury". Mr Bolton sustained a head injury but there is no evidence that he is suffering from any effects of that injury.