Bush and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

Bush and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2022] AATA 2821 (26 August 2022)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2021/3837          

Re:Brendan Bush

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J Sosso

Date:26 August 2022

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and, in substitution, the Applicant is issued with Class 2 medical certificate for 12 months, subject to the following conditions:

(a)      it is limited to rotary wing aircraft only;

(b)      no passengers are to be carried;

(c)the medical certificate, and subsequent certificates, are limited to a maximum of 12 months;

(d)the Applicant provides CASA with a 24-hour Holter Monitor reading 6 months and no longer than 7 months after his Class 2 DAME examination;

(e)upon any renewal of his Class 2 medical certificate, the Applicant shall provide CASA with;

(i)a Cardiologist’s report on his Ebstein’s Anomaly condition dealing with any progression of the condition for the period since his last Class 2 DAME examination;

(ii)a Cardiac Stress ECG taken no longer than one month before completing his renewal DAME examination; and

(iii)a 24-hour Holter Monitor reading taken at least 6 months and no longer than 7 months before the date of that Cardiologist’s report.

...............[SGD].........................................................

Deputy President J Sosso

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – Class 1 and 2 medical certificates – Applicant born with and suffers from Ebstein’s Anomaly – ablations to treat atrial flutter – no episodes of syncope – conflicting medical opinion – safety-relevant condition – whether Applicant should be issued a Class 2 medical certificate subject to conditions – decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth)

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth)

CASES

Bolton and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2013] AATA 941

Collins and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2017] AATA 2564

D’Amico and Comcare [2018] AATA 54

Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952

Window and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 525

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Administrative Appeal Tribunal, ‘Guideline on Persons Giving Expert and Opinion Evidence’ (30 June 2015)

Convention on International Civil Aviation, opened for signature 7 December 1944 (entered into force 4 April 1947)

International Civil Aviation Organisation, ‘Manual of Civil Aviation Medicine’ (3rd Edition, 2012)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J Sosso

26 August 2022

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 10 May 2021, Dr Patricia Beresford, a Delegate of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA), in accordance with reg. 11.060 of the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) (the Regulations), refused to grant Mr Brendan Bush (the Applicant) a Class 2 Medical Certificate – Exhibit 1 T3 pp. 7 – 13. The Applicant seeks a review of this decision.

  2. The Applicant was born in October 1992 and is currently 29 years of age – Exhibit 1 T1 p. 1. The Applicant works on his family’s cattle stations, the largest comprising 64,000 acres and the smallest 30,000 acres, which are all located in Queensland. He lives on Maytoe Station, Alpha, and wants to be able to fly a Robinson…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bush and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2821
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr. Bush, sought review of a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) concerning his eligibility for a Class 1 and Class 2 medical certificate. Mr. Bush suffers from Ebstein's Anomaly, a congenital heart condition, and has undergone ablations to treat atrial flutter. The central dispute revolved around whether his condition posed a safety risk that would preclude him from holding a medical certificate, particularly a Class 2 certificate for private aviation.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr. Bush's medical condition, specifically Ebstein's Anomaly and associated atrial flutter, rendered him medically unfit to hold a Class 2 medical certificate. This involved assessing conflicting medical opinions regarding the safety implications of his condition and whether any potential risks could be adequately managed through specific conditions imposed on the certificate.

The Tribunal considered extensive oral and written evidence, including reports from various medical professionals. It noted that while Mr. Bush had a congenital heart abnormality and experienced atrial flutter, the flutter itself was not incapacitating and he continued to live a normal life during episodes. The Tribunal acknowledged that ablations had been performed to address the rogue electrical circuitry causing the flutter. Ultimately, the Tribunal set aside the original decision and substituted it with a decision to issue Mr. Bush a Class 2 medical certificate for 12 months. This certificate was subject to several conditions, including limitations to rotary wing aircraft only, no passenger carriage, and ongoing medical reporting requirements such as Holter monitor readings and cardiologist reports.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant, Mr Bush, was born with a congenital heart condition known as Ebstein's Anomaly, which involves an abnormality in the tricuspid valve. This valve was repaired when Mr Bush was younger, but it remains less than 100% efficient. The right side of his heart, which is responsible for pumping deoxygenated blood to the lungs, is enlarged due to the condition, but this does not cause any significant disability. The primary issue arises from a rogue electrical circuit in the right atrium that causes atrial flutter, a form of arrhythmia. Despite experiencing atrial flutter, Mr Bush has reported no episodes of syncope or incapacitation.

Over the years, Mr Bush has undergone several medical procedures to manage his condition. The first ablation, performed in 2014, was not successful, but the second ablation in 2019 proved effective. A third ablation was conducted in November 2020, following which Mr Bush has not experienced any further arrhythmias. The most recent episode of atrial flutter occurred in June 2020, which he resolved by seeking medical attention. At the hospital, he underwent cardioversion, a procedure to restore normal sinus rhythm using electrical paddles. Mr Bush has managed his condition well, continuing with his daily activities without significant interruption, although he is aware of the irregular heartbeats during episodes of flutter.

The matter of Bush and Civil Aviation Safety Authority has a complex procedural history involving multiple stages and levels of judicial review. Initially, the Applicant sought a Class 2 medical certificate from the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to operate a helicopter, given his congenital heart condition known as Ebstein’s Anomaly. This initial application was denied by CASA, prompting the Applicant to seek a review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT reviewed the decision and ultimately decided against the Applicant, leading to the Applicant's appeal to the Federal Court of Australia. The Federal Court dismissed the Applicant's appeal, and the Applicant has now sought further judicial review of the Tribunal's decision, bringing the matter before the Federal Court of Australia again. The case involves detailed medical evidence and expert opinions regarding the safety implications of the Applicant's heart condition. The procedural journey has included submissions, hearings, and various expert testimonies aimed at determining whether the Applicant’s condition qualifies him for a Class 2 medical certificate under the applicable aviation safety regulations.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant seeks a review of this decision.THE EVIDENCEIntroduction The Tribunal received oral evidence at the Hearing from the Applicant, Dr Whight, Dr Habersberger, Mr Anthony Tomkins, Dr Roger Allan, Mr Andrew Thom and Dr Beresford. In addition, the Tribunal has been presented with copious written evidence, including reports and statements from a number of medical professionals. Before turning to the evidence, it is helpful to set out the submissions made by Mr McKeown at the Hearing concerning the Applicant’s heart condition. Whilst Mr McKeown was advancing the Applicant’s case, nonetheless, he provides a useful summing up of the medical background of the Applicant which is of assistance when assessing the evidence that was provided to the Tribunal – Transcript (Tr.) 7.3.2022 pp. 15 – 18:“…So, he’s got this congenital heart condition. It’s called Ebstein anomaly and this involves the tricuspid valve, which you’ve seen from the – and have had the benefit of the picture that I sent you, sits on the right-hand side of the heart between the atrium, which is at the top of the heart, and the ventricle at the bottom of the heart. Now, both sides have an atrium and a ventricle and we’ll deal with the detail about that. Now, there are four chambers of the heart; the left and the right atrium and the left and right ventricle. This particular valve, he was born with an abnormality in that valve and that valve had to be repaired later, and it was repaired. It’s still not 100 per cent efficient but it’s in a range which is totally acceptable in its working order. Now, the right-side of the heart is responsible for the pumping of blood, we call blue blood, from the veins of the body to the lungs and the left-side pumps the now oxygenated blood, red blood, to the arteries of the body and, of course, it’s under pressure. The right and the left side of the heart are made up of these two chambers, as I mentioned, the atrium on top and the ventricle on the bottom and on the right side the atrium fills with blue blood to pump through the tricuspid valve to the ventricle, which pumps to the lungs via the pulmonic value. Part of the Ebstein anomaly is the existence of the enlarged right atrium and ventricle and it becomes enlarged, you’ll hear, because of the performance of the tricuspid valve. You’ll hear how they both are quite large compared to the left side. With the tricuspid valve repair completed, there remains a bit of a regurgitation back into the atrium but not enough to cause a disability but enough to require Mr Bush to take an anticoagulant. I’m confident when I say that the issue with Mr Bush is not so much the regurgitation of the tricuspid value, or his enlarged atrium and ventricle on the right side, the issue is a rogue electrical circuity going off in the right atrium causing a flutter. However, it’s not an incapacitation and you’ll hear from the experts how the experience – and from the applicant has no incapacitating effect, or direct effect, upon the applicant when he is in flutter and, Deputy President, this flutter goes on for hours. We’re not talking a short period, you will hear. There are two nodes in the heart. The first is the sinus node, which sits up the top of the atrium. Sort of between the right and the left, but more so on the right, and this generates a pulse, sometimes referred to as the natural pacemaker. It’s a cluster of specialised cells located in the top of the right atrium. It sends a pulse to both atriums. So, both sides are going off together. It sets the heartbeat speed and responds to stimuli like exercise. If there is a rogue circuit in the muscles of the atrium, this circuit can cause the atrium to contract unevenly and, out of time, thereby causing this flutter. It’s arrhythmia. It is just a term for an out of beat heart. If a heart is beating normally, then, of course, it’s said to have a sinus rhythm. The other node, the atrioventricular node, known as the AV node, and you’ll see them in that picture that I’ve given you of the nodes. The AV node is primarily a delaying or filtering node. So, it delays the pulse from the sinus node. I’m reminded of my early days working as a powder man at Mount Newman, more decades ago than I care to dwell upon. But we would blow up shelves, 50 foot shelves, and maybe do three at time and we’d light the fuse at the first shelf on the bottom and the explosive fuse would go up to the next shelf but we didn’t want the next shelf blowing up at the same time as the lower shelf, so we’d put a detonator on the explosive Cordtex line to delay that a fraction enough to make sure the lower bench went off first, or the next bench and then the next bench.The AV node does the same because the atrium contracts, pushes blood into the ventricle below and if they both went off together, the ventricle would be contracting when it wasn’t full of blood. So, the atrium pushes blood into the ventricle and there’s a pause and that’s the AV node pausing just long enough to allow the ventricle to then fill with blood from the atrium and so then the ventricle goes off, it contracts. This is important to when we get into the details of this case, Deputy President, as to what’s going incapacitating when we have an atrium flutter.The AV, I should say, is also – you’ll be pleased to hear, as I certainly was when I read it, a secondary pacemaker in the event the sinus node fails to pulse. You should hear the right atrium flutter, or arrhythmia, is not immediately life-threatening, and that’s our case, and it’s not immediately incapacitating. When it is in flutter, the ventricle continues to beat, pushing blood into the lungs because the AV node is filtering out these pulses that are coming in flutter too quickly. A flutter is something that’s distinct from a defibrillation. They’re not the same. They both cause an arrhythmia. Now, arrhythmia is the collective word, you know, as I said before, of a heartbeat that’s not beating properly, such as a lawyer refers to his solicitor or a barrister. Mr Bush doesn’t suffer from atrial fibrillation. He’s only suffering from flutter. He’s experienced atrial flutter at time, a good time, and it doesn’t cause any issues for him you’ll hear. The difference, the flutter is an out of sequence heartbeat, whereas defibrillation is more of a quiver than a full heartbeat and the experts, I trust, will explain this in more detail if asked. Defibrillation, actually, is more common in society than a flutter but both are generally well tolerated without incapacitation. Now, Deputy President, there’s a procedure known as an ablation. DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Sorry, what was that, Mr McKeown?MR McKEOWN: There’s a procedure known as an ablation, a-b-l-a-t-i-o-n. In Mr Bush’s case, he’s had a few. He’s had three. In an atrial flutter, you get this rogue electrical beat. Like a signal, I should say, a rogue electrical signal and the ablation comes in through the veins and up into the heart and it attempts to burn and, therefore, neutralise the area which is causing this rogue circuitry. So, that’s the ablation, Deputy President. Then we have the cardioversion. So, the ablation is a procedure that’s carried out with some sort of prophylactic hoax because when you have an ablation, you don’t necessarily have a flutter at the time that you – you don’t have a flutter at the time, you’re actually having the ablation. Whereas the cardioversion, that is the mechanism by which the heart is put back into sinus rhythm. So, he suffers this atrial flutter. You’ll hear evidence from him, I’m anticipating, where he gets himself to the hospital and they – what we call, I call it paddle. It’s the two paddles that you see in films where they put on the heart and they shock the heart and the heart then reverts back to normal sinus rhythm. So, that rogue atrial circuitry is neutralised by the shock of the paddles and the heart goes back into sinus rhythm. There’s no rush about this. It happens. They do it because there’s no problem being an atrial flutter all the time, so they give the applicant with the paddles and he goes back into a normal heartbeat. The respondent, you will hear, says ‘Oh my God, anytime he’s in atrial flutter, he’s no good’ when, in fact, he carries on a normal life during that time that he’s in flutter; walks, drives, exists normally. But he feels the heart beating out of rhythm and so it’s fixed up. His last cardioversion was in February 2020. Following this, he had his last ablation, which was November 2020. In November 2020, he has his last ablation and he’s had no treatment of the heart and he’s had no arrhythmia since June of 2020 and you’ll hear evidence about the June one. The June one, he goes off – to cut to it, he goes off and the heart goes out of beat and he goes off to the hospital and resolves it.DEPUTY PRESIDENT: When was his last flutter?MR McKEOWN: June 2020. He wakes up in the morning and it gone. They test him and say, okay, you’re right to see (indistinct). Because when he goes to the Claremont Hospital, you’ll hear, which is his nearest hospital, they won’t put him on the paddles if there’s no surgeon. He volunteered to me the other day that he hoped that they would if he feels flat tired but they won’t if he’s not flat tired, put him on the paddles. He has to go off to a hospital where there’s a surgeon to do the job and when they put him on the paddles, they give him a twilight, they knock him out, and then shock his heart into rhythm, into proper sinus rhythm.So, the first ablation was done in 2014 and that wasn’t successful. The second was in 2019, and that was successful, and the 2020 November ablation, which per se is successful, given the 15 months that have elapsed. But, interestingly, the medical evidence will show you that the 2019 ablation was confirmed in the ablation done in 2020…”Set out below is a summary of the evidence presented to the Tribunal.The Applicant

Decision

Reasons for decision

When providing this decision to the parties, they are at liberty to apply to the Tribunal for any variation in the wording of the conditions imposed.DECISION The decision under review is set aside and, in substitution, the Applicant is issued with Class 2 medical certificate for 12 months, subject to the following conditions:(a)it is limited to rotary wing aircraft only;(b)no passengers are to be carried;(c)the medical certificate, and subsequent certificates, are limited to a maximum of 12 months;(d)the Applicant provides CASA with a 24-hour Holter Monitor reading 6 months and no longer than 7 months after his Class 2 DAME examination;(e)upon any renewal of his Class 2 medical certificate, the Applicant shall provide CASA with;(i)a Cardiologist’s report on his Ebstein’s Anomaly condition dealing with any progression of the condition for the period since his last Class 2 DAME examination;(ii)a Cardiac Stress ECG taken no longer than one month before completing his renewal DAME examination; and(iii)a 24-hour Holter Monitor reading taken at least 6 months and no longer than 7 months before the date of that Cardiologist’s report.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether the Applicant's Ebstein's Anomaly constitutes a safety-relevant condition under the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations, the Tribunal carefully considered the medical evidence and the arguments presented by both parties. The Applicant's Ebstein's Anomaly, a congenital heart condition involving an abnormality of the tricuspid valve, was deemed to be a safety-relevant condition due to the potential for arrhythmias, specifically atrial flutter, which could impact the Applicant's ability to safely operate an aircraft. The Tribunal relied on the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations and relevant medical guidelines to assess the safety implications of the condition.

The Tribunal then addressed whether the Applicant should be issued a Class 2 medical certificate subject to specific conditions to mitigate any potential risks associated with his medical condition. Given the nature of the Applicant's condition and the absence of recent episodes of syncope or other incapacitating symptoms, the Tribunal found that a Class 2 medical certificate could be issued, provided that stringent conditions were imposed. These conditions were intended to ensure that the Applicant's condition did not pose a risk to the safety of air navigation.

In determining the conditions to be imposed on the Applicant's Class 2 medical certificate, the Tribunal considered the specific risks associated with his medical condition. The Tribunal concluded that the certificate should be limited to rotary wing aircraft only, as this type of aircraft might present different operational challenges compared to fixed-wing aircraft. Additionally, the Tribunal decided that the Applicant should not be permitted to carry passengers to eliminate any potential risks associated with his condition. The certificate was also limited to a maximum of 12 months to ensure regular and updated medical assessments.

The Tribunal further considered whether the conditions imposed on the Applicant's Class 2 medical certificate should be limited to rotary wing aircraft only. The decision to limit the certificate to rotary wing aircraft was based on the specific operational characteristics of these aircraft and the need to closely monitor the Applicant's condition in this context. The Tribunal found that this limitation was necessary to ensure the safety of air navigation while accommodating the Applicant's medical condition.

Regarding the Applicant's entitlement to carry passengers under the conditions of his Class 2 medical certificate, the Tribunal concluded that the risk associated with the Applicant's condition warranted a prohibition on carrying passengers. This decision was based on the potential impact of the Applicant's condition on his ability to respond to in-flight emergencies, thereby ensuring the safety of all individuals on board.

The Tribunal also considered whether the duration of the Applicant's Class 2 medical certificate should be limited to a maximum of 12 months. This limitation was imposed to ensure that the Applicant's medical condition is regularly reviewed and that any changes in his health status are promptly addressed. The 12-month duration was deemed appropriate to balance the need for regular medical assessments with the practicalities of aviation operations.

In terms of medical monitoring, the Tribunal decided that the Applicant should be required to provide a 24-hour Holter Monitor reading to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) within a specified timeframe before his Class 2 DAME examination. This requirement ensures that up-to-date information on the Applicant's cardiac function is available to CASA, enabling them to make informed decisions regarding the safety of issuing and renewing the medical certificate.

The Tribunal also determined that upon renewal of the Applicant's Class 2 medical certificate, he should provide a Cardiologist's report and a Cardiac Stress ECG. These reports are essential for assessing the progression of the Applicant's Ebstein's Anomaly and ensuring that any changes in his condition are identified and managed appropriately. Additionally, the Tribunal required the Applicant to provide a 24-hour Holter Monitor reading at a specified time before the date of the Cardiologist's report to ensure that the Cardiologist's assessment is based on the most current medical data.

In conclusion, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review and issued a new Class 2 medical certificate to the Applicant, subject to specific conditions designed to mitigate the risks associated with his Ebstein's Anomaly. The Tribunal's decision was based on a careful consideration of the medical evidence and the safety requirements outlined in the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations. The conditions imposed on the certificate aim to ensure the safety of air navigation while accommodating the Applicant's medical condition.