Collins and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2017] AATA 2564 (6 December 2017)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number: 2017/0169
Re:Eric Collins
APPLICANT
AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President Bernard J McCabe
Member D K Grigg
Date:6 December 2017
Place:Brisbane
The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
...............................[Sgd]......................................
Deputy President Bernard J McCabe
CIVIL AVIATION – conditional class 2 medical certificate – medical standards - examination of medical evidence – imposition of safety pilot condition for public safety – likelihood that applicant would become incapacitated during flight – held applicant does not meet the medical standard relevant at the time – decision of the respondent affirmed
LEGISLATION
Civil Aviation Act 1988
CASES
Bolton v Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2013] AATA 941
Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21
Miller and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2012] AATA 92
Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952
Neal v Secretary, Department of Transport (1980) 3 ALD 97
Re Window and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 525
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Bernard J McCabe & Member D K Grigg
6 December 2017
BACKGROUND
Mr Collins is a 77-year-old farmer and the owner of a Cessna 182 which he uses for private flying primarily between his home in Tully and a property at Lakeland Downs. He has been flying regularly since 1992. Mr Collins told the Tribunal that he currently flies approximately 50 hours per year primarily between his 2 properties which involves a 1-hour flight time.[1] He also drives freight trucks.
[1] The Tribunal notes that the medical certificate application form completed by Mr Collins on 10 November 2014 indicated that he had flown 60 hours in the previous 6 months, which equates to 120 hours per annum: Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 8, page 16, MRS Online Medical Examination Report completed by Mr Collins on 10 November 2014. The medical certificate application form completed by Mr Collins on 30 November 2015 indicated that he had flown 28 hours in the previous 6 months, which equates to 56 hours per annum: Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 22, page 43, MRS Online Medical Examination Report completed by Mr Collins on 30 November 2015.
In 2007 Mr Collins had surgery to repair his mitral valve[2] and every year he is examined by a cardiac specialist to satisfy the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (“CASA”) that he is medically safe to fly. Mr Collins says he has a full heart check every 12 months and has had no issues and that no one has ever suggested to him that there was an increased chance of a stroke because of the mitral valve repair.
[2] Exhibit 1, T 6, page 12, Report of Dr Jacobs dated 3 October 2014.
On 7 October 2014 Dr Michael O’Rourke, Cardiovascular Specialist, reviewed Mr Collins’ electrocardiogram (“ECG”) results taken on 3 October 2014, and reported that Mr Collins was “doing very well with the biological mitral…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Collins and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] AATA 2564
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was to determine whether Mr Collins met the medical standards prescribed by the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations (CASR) for the issuance of a conditional class 2 medical certificate. This involved assessing the likelihood that Mr Collins would become incapacitated during flight due to a medical condition, and whether this risk posed a threat to public safety. The court was required to weigh the applicant's interest in exercising his pilot's licence privileges against the stringent requirements of air safety.
The court reasoned that the assessment of "likely" in the context of air safety cannot be based on mere statistical probability. Instead, it requires a careful balancing of air safety imperatives with the applicant's desire to fly. The court noted that even a small risk can necessitate action to mitigate it, particularly when public safety is at stake. Drawing on established principles from cases such as *Hall* and *Windows*, and referencing the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) Manual of Civil Aviation Medicine, the court considered that an annualized risk of incapacitation exceeding 1% is generally considered unacceptable in international aviation. The court found that while the precise risk level was not prescribed by CASR, the risk of incapacitation for Mr Collins was real, not fanciful or remote, and significantly different from that of the general aviator population. The court acknowledged that the consequence of incapacitation, such as a stroke in flight, would be catastrophic.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21 (“Hall”) Deputy President RP Handley said at paragraph 45:"As the Tribunal stated in Re Windows (supra), the assessment of what is "likely" cannot be based on statistical likelihood. In this context, it is a matter of weighing up the requirements of air safety with the applicant's interest in the safe exercise of the privileges and performance of the duties associated with holding a private pilot's licence…When issues of air safety are under consideration, a small risk may be sufficient to trigger the need to take appropriate action to address the risk. This was the case here" The CASR do not specifically prescribe any particular level of risk. The Tribunal noted this in Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952, and, after referring to Re Window and Hall, said:[65]Whether Mr Mulholland has a high risk or a low risk of losing consciousness while flying an aircraft is simply irrelevant. The fact is that he has a risk of incapacitation which is significantly different to the remainder of the aviator population who do not suffer from syncope or any other safety-relevant medical condition. In our view the risk of incapacitation is real and not an imaginable or fanciful risk nor is it a remote risk. Mr Ribbans, Counsel for Mr Collins, conceded that the consequence of a stroke inflight would have a catastrophic result and the fact of stroke would be a safety-relevant condition, however he submits that Mr Collins only has a risk. Therefore,Mr Collins submits, if the “risk of a stroke is the condition” you can take into account the risk of it occurring while inflight. Mr Collins says it is at the low end of the range. To determine this question involves making an assessment of the risk. Is the risk that Mr Collins will have a recurrent stroke real or remote? There is a generally accepted guideline in international aviation that a 1% annualized risk of incapacitation is the acceptable level of risk. This rule is set out and explained in the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) Manual of Civil Aviation Medicine. ICAO is a United Nations agency established in 1944 which governs the Convention on International Civil Aviation, the Chicago Convention, of which Australia is a Member State. Article 37 of the Chicago Convention provides that:Each contracting State undertakes to collaborate in securing the highest practicable degree of uniformity in regulations, standards, procedures, and organization in relation to aircraft, personnel, airways and auxiliary services in all matters in which such uniformity will facilitate and improve air navigation.To this end the International Civil Aviation Organization shall adopt and amend from time to time, as may be necessary, international standards and recommended practices and procedures dealing with:…(d) Licensing of operating … personnel;…and such other matters concerned with the safety, regularity, and efficiency of air navigation as may from time to time appear appropriate