JONATHON HAZELTON and CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2010] AATA 693

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No 2009/5517

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re JONATHON HAZELTON

Applicant

And

CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Honourable Dr B H McPherson CBE Deputy President,
Dr K S Levy RFD, Senior Member and
Associate Professor J B Morley RFD, Member

Date10 September 2010

PlaceBrisbane

Decision

The Tribunal determines:

(1)      Mr Hazelton satisfies the requirements for the issue of a class 1 and class 2 medical certificates.

(2)      The matter is referred back to CASA for consideration of conditions (if any) and if so, for what period of time.

...............[Sgd]...............................

Deputy President

(b)         If the answer to the above is yes, should any restrictions or conditions      be endorsed on those medical certificates?

EVIDENCE

4.      In the hearing of this matter (in which Mr Harvey of Counsel appeared for CASA and Mr Taylor of Counsel appeared for Mr Hazleton), evidence was taken of Mr Hazelton and a number of expert doctors, including eight neurologists, and many of those doctors have specialist qualifications or knowledge in aviation medicine.  Some of them have the official title of Designated Aviation Medical Examiner (“DAME”) and are authorised medical practitioners for the purpose of determining whether individual pilots meet the standards for issue of Class 1 and Class 2 medical certificates.

5.      While the central issues are concerned with the details and technical assessment of the applicant’s neurological capacity and risk to be able to command a civilian aircraft, it is useful to first consider the background facts before addressing the technical medical and neurological evidence, as well as research and epidemiological evidence which the Tribunal must evaluate.

The Facts

6.      Shortly put, the aetiological facts are these.  Mr Hazelton is an airline captain. He is presently 40 years of age and is married with two young children.  He was visiting Sydney on 1 and 2 November 2008 for a 20 year high school reunion.  Following the school function, he and a school friend were returning to a hotel in the city.  When passing City Hall, they were attacked from behind.  The applicant gave evidence that he went to assist his friend who was attacked first and who had a slight disability, when Mr Hazleton was hit from behind.  Mr Hazelton fell to the ground and hit his head on the pavement.  He was then kicked in the head on the right hand side of his skull above the level of his eye.  He was conveyed by ambulance to St Vincent’s Hospital in Sydney.  CT scans of his brain initially revealed some bleeding into the right frontal area of his brain as a direct consequence of the assault.  In the following 18 months, Mr Hazelton was the subject of medical reviews to assess his fitness to continue as a pilot.  Some medical officers from CASA have expressed serious concern that Mr Hazelton may have a heightened risk of post traumatic epileptic seizure with consequential risk to human safety…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JONATHON HAZELTON and CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] AATA 693
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter between Jonathon Hazleton and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority, the dispute centred around the applicant's eligibility for a Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificate, given his history of a head injury and subsequent concerns about his risk of post-traumatic epilepsy. The case was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which was required to assess whether Mr Hazleton met the necessary medical standards for resuming his role as a pilot. The Tribunal's decision was influenced by the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) and the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), with particular attention to the Briginshaw v Briginshaw principle of the balance of probabilities.

The legal issues before the Tribunal involved determining whether Mr Hazleton's head injury and the resulting cerebral contusions placed him within the acceptable medical standards for flying aircraft. The key issue was whether the available scientific literature and clinical expertise were sufficient to accurately estimate his risk of post-traumatic epilepsy, and if so, whether this risk was acceptably low to warrant the issuance of the medical certificates. The Tribunal had to consider whether the so-called '1% Rule' was an appropriate method to estimate the acceptable risk level in this context, given the lack of a finite figure for Mr Hazleton's absolute risk.

The Tribunal found that while the present body of scientific literature did not provide a definitive figure for Mr Hazleton's absolute risk of post-traumatic epilepsy, the clinical expertise available was substantial enough to enable an estimation of his relative risk. The Tribunal concluded that the '1% Rule' provided an adequate estimation of an acceptable risk and was appropriate to apply in this case. As a result, the Tribunal determined that Mr Hazleton satisfied the requirements for the issuance of a Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificate. However, the matter was referred back to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority for consideration of any conditions that should be imposed on the certificates, and for what period.

The Tribunal's final order was that Mr Hazleton satisfied the requirements for the issue of a class 1 and class 2 medical certificates. The matter was referred back to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority for consideration of conditions (if any) and, if so, for what period of time.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal determines:

(1) Mr Hazelton satisfies the requirements for the issue of a class 1 and class 2 medical certificates.

(2) The matter is referred back to CASA for consideration of conditions (if any) and if so, for what period of time.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Mr Jonathon Hazleton, an applicant seeking to obtain Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificates, which are necessary for him to operate aircraft. Mr Hazleton has a history of a head injury which was diagnosed as mild. The main issue before the court was whether Mr Hazleton satisfied the requirements for the issuance of these medical certificates, and if so, whether any restrictions or conditions should be imposed on the certificates. The assessment of Mr Hazleton's eligibility for the medical certificates was complicated by the fact that a precise figure for his absolute risk of post-traumatic epilepsy could not be calculated based on his cerebral contusions. The court noted that the existing body of scientific literature was insufficient to make a determination in accordance with evidence-based medicine regarding the acceptability of Mr Hazleton's risk to resume flying aircraft either as a pilot or as a co-pilot. However, the court found that there was sufficient clinical expertise available to determine whether Mr Hazleton's epilepsy risk was acceptably low enough to allow him to resume flying under the standards of evidence-based medicine. The court concluded that the risk could be assessed on the basis of relative risk, and that the 1% Rule provided an adequate estimation of an acceptable risk for Mr Hazleton's case.

This matter was brought before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). The initial application for the medical certificates was made by Mr Hazleton, and CASA initially assessed his eligibility based on the available scientific literature and guidelines. Following a detailed assessment and review, CASA determined that Mr Hazleton did not satisfy the requirements for the issue of Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificates due to the uncertainty of his risk of post-traumatic epilepsy. Mr Hazleton appealed CASA's decision, and the matter was heard by the court. During the proceedings, expert evidence was presented, and the court reviewed the relevant legislation and case law to make its determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Mr Hazleton satisfy the requirements for the issue of a Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificate?
2. If the answer to the first issue is yes, should any restrictions or conditions be endorsed on those medical certificates?

Held
1. The court held that Mr Hazleton satisfies the requirements for the issue of a Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificate.
2. The matter was referred back to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) for consideration of conditions, if any, and for what period.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the primary issue was whether Mr Hazleton met the necessary criteria for obtaining a Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificate. The court found that the applicant's head injury was mild, and while a precise figure for his absolute risk of post-traumatic epilepsy could not be determined, the existing scientific literature was insufficient to make a definitive decision based solely on evidence-based medicine. However, the court recognised that there was enough clinical expertise available to assess the applicant's epilepsy risk and determine whether it was acceptably low enough for him to resume flying aircraft 'with or as co-pilot' in accordance with evidence-based medicine standards. The court held that the 1% Rule provided an adequate estimation of an acceptable risk and was appropriate for application in this case. Therefore, the court concluded that Mr Hazleton satisfied the requirements for the issue of a Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificate. The matter was then referred back to CASA to consider the imposition of any conditions and their duration.