Glover and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Glover and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2024] AATA 3597 (10 October 2024)

Division: GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):       2023/4834

Re: Peter Glover

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President I Hanger AM KC 

Date:10 October 2024

Place:  Brisbane

Pursuant to section 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal orders that the decision of 16 June 2023 be set aside and the matter remitted to the respondent for consideration to take into account my finding that the applicant can meet the safety relevant standards with the imposition of the following conditions:

(a)he should not carry passengers unless he has a co-pilot who can take over in the event of an emergency;

(b)his flight should be limited to attending to his farms;

(c)it should be along an agreed flight path with stops at agreed points; and

(d)his medical condition should be monitored quarterly by his treating doctors and a report thereon be provided to the respondent within one week of his medical appointment

..........................[SGD]......................

Deputy President I Hanger AM KC

Deputy President I Hanger AM KC

10 October 2024

  1. By notice dated 16 June 2023, the respondent affirmed the decision to refuse to reissue the applicant’s Class 2 Aviation Medical Certificate dated 16 June 2023. The applicant seeks review of that decision.

  2. The respondent raised a preliminary issue about the Tribunal’s jurisdiction to deal with this matter or utility in dealing with it, given the passage of time since the applicant underwent a medical examination for the purpose of issuing a Class 2 Medical Certificate on 26 May 2022. The respondent noted that if the tribunal decided that a Class 2 Medical Certificate ought to be issued, it could not be issued with an expiry date later than 26 May 2023 or more than one year from the expiry of the old certificate. The respondent submitted that it was appropriate in the circumstances for the tribunal to dismiss the application under section 42B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). The applicant argued that given the delays inherent in the tribunal’s processes, it may be that the applicant could never get a matter heard. I urged the parties to find a way around this problem and to their credit, the following direction was made with consent:

    Upon the undertaking of the applicant to complete an updated Class 2 Medical Application, if the Tribunal sets aside the decision dated 16 June 2023, the parties agree the Tribunal will remit the decision to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority for reconsideration in accordance with any directions or recommendations of the Tribunal.

  3. The matter proceeded on that basis.

    THE LAW

  4. Section 9A of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) (The Act) provides that in exercising its powers and performing its functions, the respondent must regard the safety of air navigation as the most important consideration.

  5. The issuing of medical certificates is governed by Part 67 of the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations1998

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Glover and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3597
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr. Glover against a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to refuse to issue him a Class 2 Medical Certificate. Mr. Glover, a 79-year-old pilot with an unblemished record, sought the certificate to continue flying his light aircraft, primarily between his two farms located a significant distance apart. CASA's refusal was based on Mr. Glover's significant medical history, including prostate cancer with metastatic pulmonary metastases and coronary artery disease, which it deemed to be "safety relevant conditions" posing a remote risk of sudden incapacity while flying.

The primary legal issue before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal was to determine whether Mr. Glover's medical conditions presented a risk to aviation safety that could not be mitigated. This involved interpreting the meaning of "likely" in the context of aviation safety regulations, which, as established in precedent, does not refer to statistical likelihood or a greater than 50% chance, but rather a "substantial or real and not remote" risk. The Tribunal also had to consider whether any identified risks could be adequately managed through the imposition of conditions on the medical certificate.

The Tribunal reasoned that while Mr. Glover's conditions, particularly the prostate cancer and its treatment, presented a risk, this risk was not substantial. The Tribunal gave significant weight to the opinions of Mr. Glover's treating doctors, who had direct knowledge of his condition and considered it not unsafe for him to fly, despite acknowledging the prostate cancer was not stable. This was contrasted with CASA's expert opinion, which relied on reports without direct patient interaction. The Tribunal found that the risk of sudden incapacitation was remote and could be mitigated by imposing conditions on the licence, such as requiring flights to be conducted in a manner that minimised risk to people on the ground, particularly given Mr. Glover's stated intention to fly between his remote properties. The Tribunal concluded that the errors in Mr. Glover's application form did not demonstrate consciously misleading conduct.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside CASA's decision and remitted the matter to CASA with a direction to grant Mr. Glover a Class 2 Medical Certificate subject to appropriate conditions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Having regard to the context and purpose of the legislation and the regulations, the word ‘likely’ cannot be given its ordinary meaning to describe the probability of an event occurring. As noted in Window and Civil Aviation Safe Authority [1999] AATA 525 at [60] it: “is not a matter which can be assessed on statistical likelihood and certainly does not mean ‘more likely than not’, ‘odds on’ or ‘a more than 50% chance of a thing happening’. To adopt those latter three meanings would, in our view, be to place too little weight on the protection of public safety and too much on an individual's entitlements”. The respondent’s submission that ‘likely’ in this context means a ‘substantial or real and not remote change’ is consistent with the authorities.[3][3] See also Bush and Civil Aviation Safety Authoritty [2022] AATA 2821.THE EVIDENCE The applicant is a 79-year-old widower and retired farmer who owns his own light aircraft. He still has a farm at Berrybank in Western Victoria which is currently tenanted. He lives at Yamba which is on the north coast of New South Wales. He predominantly flies between those two points. It is a seven-hour journey with one or two stops. He is required to stop for fuel In Echuca, Narromine or Gunnedah. He also does some recreational flying and occasional trips to other parts of the country. He flies about 90 hours a year at present and has logged a total of about 1900 flying hours. There is no suggestion that he has ever had a safety or regulatory incident. In cross-examination, the applicant was taken to the application for aviation medical certificate dated 26 May 2022, which appears to be incorrectly filled.[4] For example, the form incorrectly notes the applicant’s last echocardiogram was conducted on 20 May 2019.[5] In cross-examination, the applicant accepted that he ‘had a whole series of stress tests… all the way up until 2022’.[6] There were a number of errors in the forms the applicant signed. The respondent argued that his incorrect completion of the relevant form was a ground for refusing to issue a certificate pursuant to Regulation 67.180 CASR. The form required to be filled out was a complex technical form and it would appear that it was probably completed by the designated aviation medical examiner (DAME) but signed by the applicant. I am not satisfied that he was guilty of any consciously misleading conduct.[4] Transcript, p. 49, lines 1– 5[5] Exhibit 1, T85, pp. 263 [6] Transcript, p.49, lines 25-30. The applicant has a significant medical history. He has been treated for heart disease, and various cancers. The respondent submits that his health, or his prognosis, is such that he suffers from ‘safety relevant conditions’ and he should not be issued with the certificate he seeks. The case for the applicant is that while he has had significant medical conditions and continues to have them, his condition is presently stable and does not warrant refusal subject to conditions of a certificate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Patrica Beresford is employed by the respondent as a senior medical officer in the aviation medicine department. She made the decision under review. Her role is to determine whether a pilot met the medical standard specified, that is, if they had a diagnosis covering any of the organ systems listed in the medical standard. If they had such a diagnosis, she had to determine whether the risk afforded by the condition might impact aviation safety and whether there was any way to mitigate that risk to aviation safety.[22] She thinks the applicant does not meet the required medical standard.[22] Transcript, Day 2 p. 52CONCLUSION In reaching this conclusion, I make no criticism of any of the excellent, fair and professional medical witnesses. They have made every effort to assist the Tribunal. This case is largely about risk management. The two eminent doctors who have and are treating the applicant are satisfied that but for his prostate cancer, his condition is stable. There is also no doubt that the prostate cancer is not stable and without treatment, will get worse. The greatest safety relevant issue is the cognitive effects of the androgen deprivation ADT, rather than the prostate cancer itself. At present, he has refused treatment. While his treating doctors do not suggest that they have specialist knowledge of aviation medicine, they do express the opinion that it is not unsafe for him to fly. They have the advantage of actually knowing and treating the applicant. That knowledge is to be contrasted with the knowledge of the respondent’s experts who do not know the applicant and rely on the medical reports of individuals who have treated the applicant. It is possible that the applicant’s various conditions may adversely affect his operation of an aircraft. It is a risk, but it is not a substantial risk. The attitude of the respondent through its experts is that the risk is unacceptable. However, one must consider the purpose of the risk assessment process. In doing that and in considering the risk of an adverse event causing loss of control and a crash, one must also consider the consequences. The pilot may kill himself. He may kill passengers. He may kill people on the ground. He may cause damage to property. These also must be taken into account in the risk assessment process. The grant of a licence is a privilege, but it is a privilege much enjoyed by its holder. The applicant has flown for many years with an unblemished record. He obviously values the licence greatly and uses it particularly to fly between his two farms which are a long way apart. Given the remote location of these properties, any risk can be mitigated by requiring the applicant to fly between them in such a way that, if he crashes, he will be an insignificant risk to people on the ground. That observation would apply as well to smaller airports. Even if he crash-landed, the possibility of hurting someone other than himself or passengers is remote. If he chooses to fly, knowing the slight risk of an adverse event occurring, then he has voluntarily undertaken the risk of killing himself. My assessment of him is that he has common sense. He is carefully monitored by his doctors quarterly. The chances of a serious adverse event instantly disabling him while flying is not substantial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.