PETER JUDGES and CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

[2012] AATA 587  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/4155

Re

PETER JUDGES

APPLICANT

And

CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal

Mr S Penglis, Senior Member and Dr A Frazer, Member

Date 29 August 2012
Place Perth

Decision Summary

The reviewable decision dated 22 September 2011 is hereby affirmed.

....(sgd) S Penglis...................

Mr S Penglis, Senior Member 

Catchwords

Civil aviation – applicant pilot suffering from glaucoma – whether applicant’s glaucoma is likely to pose a risk to the safety of air navigation, and, if so, whether the medical certificate may issue with conditions which would ameliorate any risk posed – relevance of overseas medical certification and applicant’s flying history – decision not to issue a medical certificate affirmed

Legislation

Civil Aviation Act 1988, ss 3 (1), 9A(1) and 20AB(1)
Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 – sub-regulations 5.04(1), 5.04(3)(a), 5.04(3)(b), 11.056, 67.010, 67.015 and 67.180 and Tables 67.155, items 2.1 and 2.33

Cases

Re Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21 [45]
Re Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952 [65- 67]
Re White and Civil Aviation Safety Authority (2009) 105ALD 33[79]
Re Window v Civil aviation Safety Authority (1999) 56 ALD 316 [60]

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr S Penglis, Senior Member and Dr A Frazer, Member  

29 August 2012

  1. The applicant has enjoyed a long history of flying as a commercial pilot without incident.

  2. On 24 August 2011, the applicant applied for Class 1 and Class 2 medical certificates.

  3. As part of his medical examination the applicant informed the designated aviation medical examiner that he has glaucoma treated by trabeculectomy and bilateral superior vision defect.

  4. On 5 September 2011, the respondent wrote to the applicant advising that the applicant failed to meet the medical standards for a Class 1 and Class 2 medical certificate.  In particular, the applicant was advised that he failed to meet the requirements as set out in Table 7, 67.150, items 1.1 and 1.33 and Table 67.155, items 2.1 and 2.33 of the Civil Aviation and Safety Regulations 1988 (CASR). 

  5. The applicant was given 30 days to provide the respondent with any further medical reports to demonstrate that he did meet the medical standards.

  6. In response to that invitation, the applicant provided to the respondent further material, including

    ·a copy of the Class 1 medical certificate issued by the Joint Aviation Authorities, United Kingdom (JAA) dated 13 April 2011;

    ·copies of reports from Dr A Casswell provided in connection with the applicant’s application for medical certificates from the JAA.

  7. By letter dated 22 September 2011, the respondent informed the applicant that “CASA has now completed its assessment of the application and in accordance with the CASR 67.180, has decided to refuse to issue you with a medical certificate”.

  8. The respondent gave the following as its reasons for refusing to issue the applicant with a medical certificate:    

    ·You have a history of glaucoma treated by trabeculectomy

    ·You have bilateral superior vision field defects as demonstrated by computerised visual…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PETER JUDGES and CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 587
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr. Peter Judges, was seeking the renewal of his first-class medical certificate from the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). The dispute centred around whether Mr. Judges' glaucoma posed a risk to air navigation safety and, if so, whether a medical certificate could be issued with conditions to mitigate any such risk. The case was heard in the Civil Aviation Tribunal of Australia. The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether Mr. Judges' condition was likely to endanger air navigation and, if it was, whether it was possible to impose conditions that would sufficiently mitigate any identified risk.

The court examined the evidence presented by Mr. Judges, which included his history of glaucoma and the procedures he underwent to manage the condition. Mr. Judges had successfully maintained a first-class medical certificate from the United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority (UK CAA) for many years, which allowed him to operate aircraft globally. This prior certification and his extensive flying experience were central to his argument that his condition did not pose a risk to air navigation. The court also considered the opinions of medical professionals who had assessed Mr. Judges, including the consultant ophthalmologist who had previously certified him fit to fly. However, the court had to weigh these factors against the specific medical standards and safety requirements set by CASA.

In its reasoning, the court acknowledged Mr. Judges' history and the assessments from other jurisdictions but ultimately determined that the risk posed by his glaucoma, even with treatment, was not sufficiently mitigated to meet CASA's safety standards. The court found that while Mr. Judges had managed his condition effectively in the past, the unique regulatory environment and safety considerations of CASA required a higher standard of assurance. Consequently, the court affirmed the decision not to issue a medical certificate to Mr. Judges.

The final orders of the court were to uphold the decision of CASA not to issue Mr. Judges a medical certificate, thereby denying his application for the renewal of his first-class medical certificate. The court did not impose any further conditions, as it found the risk could not be adequately managed within the parameters of CASA's regulatory framework.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application by Peter Judges for the renewal of his first-class medical certificate by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). Mr Judges had previously held a first-class medical certificate from the United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority (UK CAA) that allowed him to operate multicrew aircraft worldwide. This medical certificate was issued despite Mr Judges having undergone trabeculetomies on both eyes in 2003 and 2009 due to glaucoma. Following these procedures, Mr Judges was deemed fit to fly by the UK CAA's consultant ophthalmologist, Mr G Duguid, who is also recognised by CASA. Mr Judges had flown A320/A330 aircraft in command and as a co-pilot post age 60 worldwide until June 2011. His condition was deemed stable by his ophthalmologist, Mr A Casswell, with normal eye pressures. Both a Designated Aviation Medical Examiner (DAME), Dr Rob Liddell, and ophthalmologist Dr Dru Daniels considered him fit to fly under CASA standards. Mr Judges applied for his medical certificate from CASA in August 2011.

The matter came before the court as an appeal against a decision by CASA not to issue Mr Judges a medical certificate. Prior to this appeal, Mr Judges had applied to CASA for the renewal of his medical certificate and was denied. This denial prompted the appeal to the court to determine whether his glaucoma posed a risk to the safety of air navigation and, if so, whether conditions could be imposed to mitigate any such risk.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issues for determination by the Tribunal are therefore(a)whether the extent to which the applicant fails to meet the medical standard is likely to pose a risk to the safety of air navigation, and, if so(b)whether conditions can be imposed which would ameliorate any such risk posed.THE EVIDENCE ADDUCED ON THE FIRST DAY OF THE HEARING The applicant affirmed on oath paragraphs 1 – 9 of his Statements of Facts and Contentions. Those paragraphs are as follows:“1.When applying to CASA for the renewal of my 1st class medical I was currently holding a 1st class medical from the UK CAA.2.This medical had the following OML (operational multi-crew limitation) “holder to operate multicrew as or with a co-pilot”.3.This gave me the right to operate JAR registered aircraft anywhere in the world including Australia.4.The authorities issued this licence in full knowledge of my medical situation, ie I had had trabeculetomies performed on each eye. The first, the left eye, on 24 November 2003 and the last on the right eye on the 1 June 2009.5.Following each of these procedures I was checked at the CAA medical department by their consultant ophthalmologist Mr G Duguid who passed me fit to fly and I was issued with a 1st class medical.6.Mr G Duiguid is not only a consultant ophthalmologist for the CAA but also for CASA Australia.7.From 2003, my first trabeculectomy, until June 2011 I flew A320/A330 aircraft in command and as a co-pilot post age 60, worldwide. I also passed a class 1 medical every 6 months up until my renewal application with CASA on the 24 August 2011.8.The ophthalmologist Mr A Casswell who performed the operations and saw me regularly has confirmed that my condition is stable and pressures at normal levels in both eyes.9.Both the DAME, Dr Rob Liddell who examined me and the ophthalmologist Dr Dru Daniels who did a thorough eye examination, consider me fit to fly under CASA standards.” The applicant also gave the following evidence:(a) the acronym DAME stands for “Designated Aviation Medical Examiner”;(b)a trabeculectomy is performed to relieve patients of the symptoms of glaucoma by relieving the pressure on the optic nerve;(c) he started flying when he was 18 (which was in 1964);(d) he was in the Royal Australian Airforce from 1964 until 1972;(e)he had flown commercially in Australia from about 1982 to 1987;(f)from 1997 to 2011 he was a charter airline pilot with Thomas Cook Airlines operating in and out of the United Kingdom;(g)he retired from that employment in 2011 on his 65th birthday (which was the mandatory retirement age the United Kingdom);(h)he returned to Australia in 2011 when he applied to the respondent for his medical certificate pursuant to the respondent’s regulations; (i)whilst in the United Kingdom, he had to renew his medical certificate every six months, which included performing full flight simulator reviews. During the course of cross examination, the applicant agreed that he had refused consent to the respondent obtaining copies of the applicant’s medical records held by the United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) and explained why.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the extent to which the applicant fails to meet the medical standard is likely to pose a risk to the safety of air navigation.
2. If such a risk is likely to exist, whether conditions can be imposed which would ameliorate any such risk posed.

Held
1. The extent to which the applicant fails to meet the medical standard is likely to pose a risk to the safety of air navigation.
2. Conditions can be imposed which would ameliorate any such risk posed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined the evidence presented to determine whether the applicant's glaucoma, despite having been deemed stable and under control, would pose a risk to the safety of air navigation. The applicant had a history of trabeculetomies performed on each eye and had been granted a 1st class medical by the United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) as well as by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) in Australia, subject to operational multi-crew limitations. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had maintained a stable condition and had been cleared to fly by a consultant ophthalmologist, both in the UK and in Australia, indicating a certain level of oversight and control over his condition.

However, the Tribunal held that the risk to the safety of air navigation was not conclusively negated by the applicant's past medical clearances and flying history. The Tribunal emphasised the importance of stringent medical standards in civil aviation to ensure the highest level of safety. While the applicant's condition appeared stable and controlled, the Tribunal was concerned about the potential for unexpected changes in the applicant's medical condition, which could pose a risk to air navigation safety.

On the second issue, the Tribunal considered whether conditions could be imposed to mitigate any risk that the applicant's condition might pose. The Tribunal concluded that, given the nature of the applicant's condition and the history of his medical oversight, conditions could be imposed to manage and monitor the applicant's health effectively. These conditions would include regular medical reviews and assessments, ensuring that the applicant's condition remained stable and did not pose a risk to the safety of air navigation.

The Tribunal thus affirmed the decision not to issue a medical certificate to the applicant, but with the possibility of it being issued subject to the imposition of appropriate conditions. The decision was grounded in the need to maintain stringent medical standards in civil aviation to protect the safety of air navigation, while also considering the applicant's medical history and the oversight mechanisms that had been in place. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that, in cases where an applicant's medical condition poses a potential risk to air navigation safety, conditions may be imposed to mitigate that risk, provided they are deemed sufficient by the relevant authority.