John Hoore and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

[2014] AATA 292 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/2992

Re

John Hoore

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr R Bartsch, Member
Dr W Isles, Member

Date 13 May 2014
Place Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the decision dated 31 May 2013 to cancel Mr Hoore's medical certificates.

The Tribunal remits the matter to the respondent for reconsideration with the direction that at the time of the reviewable decision the extent to which the applicant did not meet the medical standards for a Class 1 or Class 2 medical certificate is not likely to endanger the safety of air navigation if the following conditions are imposed:

(i)That the applicant can operate as a pilot in command only in the capacity of a flight instructor, and then only when a qualified pilot is occupying the other control seat of the aircraft and is appropriately qualified, endorsed and rated to fly the particular exercise, manoeuvre or sequence. This specifically excludes the ab-initio training of student pilots.

(ii)Flights are permitted only under visual meteorological conditions (VMC) by day.

(iii)No instrument flight training, simulated forced landings or engine failures, aerobatic, or stalling sequences are permitted.

(iv)Flights permitted only in fully dual control fitted aircraft with side-by-side seating.

(v)No passengers are to be carried.

(vi)That the applicant wears a seat belt with torso restraint at all times during flight.

(vii)That the trainee pilot be made aware of, and agree to, these imposed conditions prior to undertaking any training with the applicant.

................................................

Mr R Bartsch, Member

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – Conditions for commercial and private pilot license – cancellation of Class 1 and 2 medical certificates – medical standard for issuing Class 1 and 2 medical certificates – safety of navigation – safety relevant condition - malignant melanoma with spread to lymph nodes - special conditions - decision under review set aside and remitted with directions

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether Tribunal has jurisdiction to review decision – expired medical certificates - operative effect of Tribunal’s decision – applicant’s interests affected

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION - application of regs 67.180 and 67.195 of the Civil Aviation Safety Regulation 1998 – whether the question posed by reg 67.180(2)(e)(ii) must answered favourably to the applicant before the question of imposing conditions pursuant can be considered - no evident basis for construing in such a restrictive manner – broad interpretation consistent with statutory purpose

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Act 1988; s 9A

Civil Aviation Regulation 1988; regs 5.04, 11.056,
Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998; regs 67.010, 67.150, 67.155, 67.180, 67.195

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975; s 27(1)

CASES

Civil Aviation Safety Authority v Ovens [2011] FCAFC 75

Re McHattan and Collector of Customs (NSW) (1977) 1 ALD 67
Re White and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2008] AATA 543; (2009) 105 ALD 33
Serong and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2006] AATA 1123; (2006) 93 ALD 673
Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2006] AATA 452

Taggart and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2012] AATA 690

REASONS FOR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Hoore and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 292
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves John Hoore and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) concerning the cancellation of Hoore’s Class 1 and 2 medical certificates. The dispute arose due to Hoore’s diagnosis of malignant melanoma that had spread to lymph nodes, raising concerns about his fitness to pilot an aircraft safely. The matter was heard by the Civil Aviation Tribunal, which was tasked with determining whether CASA’s decision to cancel the certificates was justified and whether it had the jurisdiction to review the decision, particularly in light of the expired medical certificates.

The primary legal issues involved interpreting the regulations concerning medical standards for issuing Class 1 and 2 medical certificates and whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review CASA’s decision, especially given that the medical certificates had expired. Additionally, the court had to determine if the statutory requirements under the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 mandated a specific sequence of inquiries before considering the imposition of conditions.

The Tribunal found that there was no evident basis to construe the regulations in a restrictive manner that would require a favourable answer to a specific question before considering conditions. It held that a broad interpretation was consistent with the statutory purpose, which emphasizes safety. The Tribunal also determined that it had jurisdiction to review CASA’s decision, as Hoore's interests were still affected by the decision’s operative effect. The Tribunal found that although the risk of a seizure while flying was lower due to the reduced flight hours, the potential consequences of such an event were severe enough to warrant the cancellation of the certificates.

The Tribunal set aside CASA's decision and remitted it back with directions. The Tribunal was satisfied that Mr. Hoore did not meet the medical standards for a Class 1 or 2 medical certificate, but it also recognized the importance of considering conditions that might mitigate the risk. The decision highlighted the need for CASA to provide more detailed documentation and consideration of potential conditions that could allow Mr. Hoore to safely continue his aviation career.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns Mr. John Hoore, an individual diagnosed with malignant melanoma that has spread to lymph nodes, but with no evidence of distant metastatic spread. Mr. Hoore had been issued with Class 1 and 2 medical certificates by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). However, CASA subsequently cancelled these certificates due to Mr. Hoore's medical condition, which they deemed to be a safety relevant condition. Mr. Hoore challenged CASA's decision, arguing that he could meet the required medical standards if certain conditions were imposed on his pilot license. The medical evidence from Dr. Andrew Spillane and Associate Professor Pooshan Navathe provided details on Mr. Hoore's diagnosis, prognosis, and the associated risks, including the possibility of brain metastases and seizures.

The matter came before the Civil Aviation Tribunal as a challenge to CASA's decision to cancel Mr. Hoore's medical certificates. This constituted a review of CASA's decision under the Civil Aviation Safety Regulation 1998. The Tribunal assessed the evidence provided by both parties and the arguments presented regarding the appropriate medical standards and the possibility of imposing conditions to allow Mr. Hoore to maintain his pilot license. The Tribunal's role was to determine whether the decision to cancel Mr. Hoore's medical certificates was justified and whether any conditions could be imposed to mitigate the identified risks.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent states that the applicant does not meet the standards outlined above in sections 1.1 or 2.1 of the Tables.MEDICAL EVIDENCE The medical diagnosis of the applicant is not in dispute. The report of 19 March 2013 provided by Dr Andrew Spillane, Associate Professor of Surgical Oncology, summarises the situation well:Mr Hoore has been diagnosed with malignant melanoma. The primary tumour was situated on the right earlobe. It was Breslow thickness 5.5mm, Clark's level 5, had no ulceration and a mitotic rate of 32 per mm2 (in the original punch biopsy). He has subsequently had an amputation of the earlobe and a sentinel node biopsy of 3 lymph nodes in the neck. This has demonstrated two lymph nodes containing metastatic melanoma out of the three lymph nodes removed. He has subsequently had a staging CT scan of his brain, chest, abdomen and pelvis. This does not show any evidence of distant metastatic spread of the melanoma. He is now considering whether to have further neck and parotid gland surgery.This is a very serious melanoma with a high risk of recurrence. His 10 year survival would be of the order of 20% - 30%. The risk of a recurrence would be highest in the next 2 - 5 years. Associate Professor Pooshan Navathe, Principal Medical Officer with CASA, presented the medical case for the respondent. While agreeing that there was currently no evidence of metastases, he pointed out the prognosis from Dr Spillane, which stated a high risk of recurrence and a 10-year survival rate of 20-30 per cent.[1] He also referred to a table, which is reproduced, in his statement.[2] It does not reference the study from which it is derived, but shows the results of nine studies that list the percentage of brain metastases caused by different primary tumours. The risk of brain metastases following a diagnosis of malignant melanoma, varied from 4 to 16 per cent.[3] No other information such as the staging of the tumours and time from diagnosis for the appearance of metastases was provided. A/Prof Navathe also pointed out that the risk in Mr Hoore's case would be at the higher end of the spectrum because of the advanced histologic staging of the tumour, the spread to lymph nodes and its location on the head and neck. [1] Report of A/ Prof Spillane.[2] Statement of A/Prof Navathe at p 23.[3] Statement of A/Prof Navathe at [81]. A/Prof Navathe further referenced a study that indicated seizures were a presenting symptom in 19 per cent of cases of brain metastases.[4] He listed the following possible presenting symptoms for brain metastases:[4] Statement of A/Prof Navathe at [75].·Seizures·Memory loss, poor judgment, difficulty solving problems·Decreased coordination·Vision Changes - double vision, decreased vision·General ill feeling or lethargy·Headache -- new or more severe than usual·Numbness, tingling pain and other changes in sensation·Personality changes·Rapid emotional changes or strange behaviours·Speech difficulties·Vomiting with or without nausea·Fever·Weakness of a body area

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Hoore suggested that his likely flight time hours as an instructor was another factor to be taken into any risk analysis. He claimed that he would work only perhaps 100 hours per year. A/Prof Navathe agreed with his proposal that as there were no special conditions related to actual flying that increased the risk of having a seizure, then the risk of onset of a seizure is a temporal one. Thus by flying only 100 hours in a year, the risk of an adverse event occurring in those hours would be commensurately reduced as compared to, for example, a pilot that flew 900 or 1000 hours annually. CONCLUSION The medical diagnosis of malignant melanoma with spread to lymph nodes but no distant metastases is not disputed. Both parties agree that there is a possibility of metastatic spread, including to the brain, which could have serious consequences in a pilot. There could be sudden loss of consciousness and/or seizures, as well as more subtle but unrecognised diminution in cognition. Although Mr Hoore points out that the studies quoted by CASA do not entirely address his situation, they do nevertheless provide us with some sense of the probability of an adverse outcome. This is substantial and real and is not remote. The applicant does not meet the medical standards set out in sections 1.1 and 2.1 of Tables 67.010 and 67.155 of the CASR respectively. Consideration must now be had as to whether the imposition of a condition or conditions pursuant to reg 11.051 of the CASR can be made that would allow the Tribunal to be satisfied that the extent to which Mr Hoore fails to meet the medical standard is not likely to endanger the safety of air navigation. Mr Hoore questioned CASA's decision making and risk assessment procedures, but they were able to explain a robust process performed by well-qualified experts, albeit not necessarily well documented. There was little mention of certificate conditions in the CASA documentation, and it is possible that due consideration was not afforded to these aspects in the process of suspending Mr Hoore's medical certificates. Mr Hoore's evidence about the rarity of a flight instructor ever having to take over the controls during advanced instructional sequences is accepted. The argument of having a second pilot continuously present who, by nature of the training being undertaken, is well prepared and capable to take-over as pilot in command is compelling. However, CASA's concern about the distraction and possible physical interference with flight controls by a fitting or unconscious flight instructor does carry weight. On this point, it is noteworthy that in White the respondent submitted, and the applicant did not dispute, that the nature of the incapacity that might be caused by a seizure event was also relevant in any risk assessment. In that case the Tribunal found that such an event would lead to a degree of incapacity totally destructive of the applicant’s ability to control an aircraft in flight. The expert medical witness in his oral evidence pointed out that the risks involved in a seizure are not subtle, but produce an active incapacity. It was stated: “even a safety pilot might not be able to wrench the applicant's hands off the controls.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court first addressed the issue of jurisdiction, clarifying that the Tribunal can review CASA's decision to cancel Mr. Hoore's medical certificates despite their expiration. This is because the Tribunal's jurisdiction extends to reviewing decisions under the Civil Aviation Act 1988, regardless of the certificates' expiration. The court emphasised that the decision concerns the procedure rather than the certificates' validity, thus not affecting Mr. Hoore's interests in relation to his medical certificates and pilot license.

Regarding the interpretation of regulations 67.180 and 67.195, the court found that these should be interpreted in a broad manner consistent with the statutory purpose of ensuring the safety of navigation. The court rejected a restrictive interpretation that would require a favourable answer to the question posed by regulation 67.180(2)(e)(ii) before considering imposing conditions. Instead, the court supported a broader approach that aligns with the statutory objective of maintaining safety in aviation.

Finally, the court concluded that the Tribunal could set aside CASA's decision and remit the matter with directions to consider imposing conditions on Mr. Hoore's pilot license. This decision was based on the medical evidence and arguments presented, particularly the possibility of metastatic spread and the risks associated with Mr. Hoore's medical condition. The court found that CASA had not adequately considered the potential for imposing conditions that could allow Mr. Hoore to meet the required medical standards while ensuring the safety of air navigation. The court's decision thus ensures that the statutory purpose of maintaining safety in aviation is achieved through a fair and comprehensive review process.