Serong and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2006] AATA 1123

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL          № V2005/398
  № V2006/444

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION

Re:            ROGER ADRIAN SERONG

Applicant

And:CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal:       Mr Egon Fice, Member

Dr Kerry Breen, Member

Date:22 December 2006

Place:Melbourne

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision dated 5 May 2006 not to issue a class one medical certificate to the applicant. .

The Tribunal varies the reviewable decision dated 5 May 2006 to issue Mr Serong a class two medical certificate with the condition that he only exercises the privileges of a private pilots’ licence as or with a co-pilot to include the conditions set out in paragraph 65 of these reasons for decision.

(sgd) Egon Fice

Member

CIVIL AVIATION – type one diabetes – hyperglycaemia – hypoglycaemia – hypophysitis – medical certificate – Chicago Convention – Civil Aviation Safety Authority policy – United States Federal Aviation Administration protocol regarding type one diabetes – conditions attached to medical certificate – fetter on the exercise of discretion – risk to safety of air navigation – blood glucose control – hypoglycaemic awareness

Civil Aviation Act 1988 s 9A, s 11

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 reg 67.150, 67.155, 67.175, 67.180, 67.195

United States of America Federal Aviation Administration Policy

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 634

Re William Wai Ming Lee and Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1988) 10 AAR 270

REASONS FOR DECISION

22 December 2006   Mr Egon Fice, Member

Dr Kerry Breen, Member

1.      In 1996 Mr Roger Adrian Serong developed type one (insulin dependent) diabetes mellitus which caused him to cease flying for one year.  He resumed flying in June 1997 when his class two medical certificate was renewed on the condition that when flying, he only did so as or with a safety pilot endorsed on the aircraft that was being flown.  His class one medical certificate was not renewed.

2.      Mr Serong accepted the restrictions placed on his licence to fly aeroplanes as a result of his diabetes until 2005, when he applied to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) for a renewal of his class two medical certificate and the issue of a class one certificate.  CASA refused to issue Mr Serong with a class one medical certificate and it issued a class two medical certificate on the condition that he only exercise the rights conferred by that certificate when flying as or with a qualified co‑pilot.  His class two medical certificate was valid for 12 months from the date of issue.

3.      Although Mr Serong applied to this Tribunal for a review of the decision made by CASA on 19 April 2005, his class two medical certificate expired on 18 April 2006 before his application could be heard.  At that time Mr Serong sought renewal of his class two medical certificate and again applied for the issue of a class one medical certificate.  On 5 May 2006 CASA granted Mr Serong a class two medical certificate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Serong and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] AATA 1123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Serong and Civil Aviation Safety Authority, the applicant, Mr Roger Adrian Serong, sought a review of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority's (CASA) decision not to issue him a class one medical certificate. Mr Serong, who has type one diabetes, had previously been granted a class two medical certificate, which permits him to fly as a private pilot with a qualified co-pilot. The applicant argued that he should be allowed to fly solo under certain conditions. The Tribunal considered two primary issues: whether CASA's refusal to issue a class one medical certificate was correct, and whether the conditions imposed on Mr Serong's class two medical certificate were necessary for the safety of air navigation.

The Tribunal found that CASA's refusal to issue a class one medical certificate should be affirmed. The evidence regarding commercial operations by type one diabetic pilots was insufficient to determine the necessary conditions for such a licence. However, the Tribunal varied CASA's decision regarding the class two medical certificate, imposing specific conditions for day Visual Flight Rules (VFR) solo flights not exceeding three hours. These conditions included carrying glucometers and readily absorbable glucose, regular blood glucose testing, and specific pre-landing checks. The Tribunal concluded that these conditions were necessary for the safety of air navigation.

This decision highlights the balance between accommodating diabetic pilots and maintaining the highest safety standards in aviation. The Tribunal's approach ensures that Mr Serong's well-controlled diabetes and adherence to strict monitoring protocols can be recognised while safeguarding air navigation safety.

Background

Background to the litigation

Roger Adrian Serong developed type one diabetes mellitus in 1996, which led to a one-year cessation of his flying activities. He resumed flying in June 1997 with a class two medical certificate, which required him to fly only as or with a safety pilot endorsed on the aircraft. Serong's class one medical certificate was not renewed. In 2005, he applied for a renewal of his class two medical certificate and for a class one certificate. The Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) refused to issue him a class one medical certificate but granted him a class two medical certificate under the same conditions as his previous one, i.e., flying only as or with a qualified co-pilot. Serong sought a review of CASA's decision, which the Tribunal heard and decided on 22 December 2006.

The matter came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) as a review of a decision made by CASA on 5 May 2006. This decision was in turn a renewal and continuation of an earlier decision made by CASA on 19 April 2005. The Tribunal heard Serong's application to review the 5 May 2006 decision on 30-31 October 2006 and delivered its decision on 22 December 2006.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the decision to refuse Mr Serong a class one medical certificate was correct.
2. Whether the conditions imposed on Mr Serong's class two medical certificate are necessary in the interests of the safety of air navigation.

Held
1. The decision to refuse Mr Serong a class one medical certificate was correct.
2. The conditions imposed on Mr Serong's class two medical certificate were varied to include specific conditions for day VFR solo flights not exceeding three hours duration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) reviewed the Civil Aviation Safety Authority's (CASA) decision to refuse Mr Roger Adrian Serong a class one medical certificate and to issue him a class two medical certificate with certain conditions. The AAT affirmed the refusal to issue a class one medical certificate, noting the lack of evidence to properly evaluate the necessary conditions for such a certificate given the nature of commercial air operations. However, the AAT varied the conditions imposed on Mr Serong's class two medical certificate for day Visual Flight Rules (VFR) solo flights not exceeding three hours duration, establishing specific conditions for blood glucose monitoring and testing to ensure safety.

Regarding the refusal of a class one medical certificate, the AAT noted that while there was evidence of type one diabetic pilots conducting commercial operations in Canada, there was insufficient evidence to determine the necessary conditions for such operations in Australia. The AAT emphasised that commercial air operations vary widely and likely have additional complicating factors. Therefore, the AAT affirmed CASA's decision to refuse to issue a class one medical certificate to Mr Serong.

On varying the conditions for Mr Serong's class two medical certificate, the AAT examined the evidence provided by Mr Serong and medical experts, concluding that his diabetes was well controlled, and he met the initial requirements for certification under the Federal Aviation Administration's (FAA) protocol. The AAT established specific conditions for Mr Serong's class two medical certificate, focusing on blood glucose monitoring and testing to ensure safety during day VFR solo flights not exceeding three hours duration.

The AAT's reasoning was based on the principles set out in the Civil Aviation Act 1988 and the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998, which require CASA to prioritise the safety of air navigation when issuing medical certificates. The AAT also considered the Chicago Convention and the International Civil Aviation Organization's (ICAO) flexibility standard, which allows for individual assessment and conditions based on the specific circumstances of each applicant.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that CASA may issue medical certificates subject to conditions that are necessary in the individual applicant's case to ensure the safety of air navigation, and that these conditions may vary depending on the circumstances and type of operation involved. The AAT's decision demonstrates a balanced approach to medical certification for insulin-dependent diabetic pilots, taking into account the evolving nature of medical research, treatment outcomes, and international best practices.