Anthony Taggart and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

[2012] AATA 690

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/2854

Re

Anthony Taggart

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President J W Constance
Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date 8 October 2012
Place Melbourne

The decision under review is affirmed.

...........[sgd].............................................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – medical standard for the issue of class 1 and 2 medical certificates – transient global amnesia – safety-relevant condition - degree of functional incapacity or a risk of incapacitation - with safety pilot condition – safety of air navigation - decision under review is affirmed

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 9A, 20AB(1)

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth) r 5.04

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) rr 11.056, 67.015, 67.150, 67.155, 67.180

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Hall, J.C, How to Dissect Surgical Journals: Xv-Review Articles; ANZ  J.Surg.81 (2011) 831-834

International Civil Aviation Organization, Manual of Civil Aviation Medicine, 3rd ed, 2012

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J W Constance
Miss E A Shanahan, Member

A. INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Taggart is seeking a review of the decision of the Authority refusing to issue him a class 1 medical certificate and imposing a restrictive condition on a class 2 certificate. As the holder of a pilot’s licence, Mr Taggart requires a medical certificate (with or without conditions) issued by the Authority to enable him to operate an aircraft.

  2. For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be affirmed.

    B.  EVIDENCE AND FINDINGS OF FACT

  3. Unless stated otherwise the following findings of fact are based on the evidence of Mr Taggart.

  4. Mr Taggart is 61 years old.  He holds a commercial pilot’s licence and has done so for at least 20 years.  Prior to February 2012 Mr Taggart held successive class 1 medical certificates issued by the Authority for 20 years.  His total aeronautical experience is approximately 2600 hours.

  5. Mr Taggart practises as a Chartered Accountant.  In addition he earns income from conducting survey flights.  He also uses his licence as an unpaid volunteer, air-lifting patients for medical treatment as part of the Angel Flight scheme.

  6. On 16 October 2011 Mr Taggart tripped and struck his forehead on the corner of a wall.  The blow broke the skin and caused an injury which was painful to touch.  However Mr Taggart did not lose consciousness and did not suffer a headache as a consequence of the incident.  He did not seek medical treatment and was able to continue his planned activities on the day.

  7. On 18 October 2011 Mr Taggart suffered an episode of some confusion which he described as follows:

    We – we rise at 5:30 every morning to walk our dogs. We did that. Everything proceeded normally. I was to attend a funeral on that day at about 10 o’clock, so I took the opportunity to do some work at home instead of going into my office. And so at about half past 8 or so I had had breakfast and I had done some exercises, as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anthony Taggart and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 690
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Civil Aviation Tribunal involved Anthony Taggart, who sought a review of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority's decision to refuse him a class 1 medical certificate and to issue him with a class 2 medical certificate subject to a "with safety pilot" condition. The dispute centered on whether Taggart's episode of transient global amnesia posed a risk to the safety of air navigation, and if the imposed restriction was adequate.

The primary legal issues that the tribunal had to address were whether Taggart met the relevant medical standards for a class 1 medical certificate, and if not, whether his condition posed a significant risk to air navigation safety. Additionally, the tribunal needed to determine if Taggart met the medical standard for a class 2 medical certificate and whether the "with safety pilot" condition sufficiently mitigated the risk to air navigation safety.

The tribunal found that Taggart suffered from transient global amnesia, a condition that could impair his ability to pilot an aircraft safely. They concluded that the risk of recurrence or the manifestation of epilepsy within the 12 months following the initial incident warranted denying a class 1 medical certificate. However, given that it had been over a year since the episode and there was no indication of recurrence or epilepsy, the tribunal affirmed the decision to issue Taggart a class 2 medical certificate with a "with safety pilot" restriction. The tribunal also highlighted the importance of Angel Flight's service while expressing concerns about the safety implications of Taggart's medical condition.

In conclusion, the tribunal affirmed the Civil Aviation Safety Authority's decision to refuse a class 1 medical certificate to Taggart and to issue him a class 2 medical certificate with the specified condition. The tribunal emphasized that any future application for a medical certificate would be subject to reassessment by the Authority, with appropriate conditions to be determined at that time.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Dr Navathe gave evidence that one of the reasons for deciding whether conditions can ameliorate the risk to the safety of air navigation in respect of class 1 and class 2 medical certificates is as follows:The lower level of assumed risk that can be tolerated in view of the potential consequences to fare paying passengers. This includes that most operations would be in controlled airspace, subject to air traffic control direction, and busy air lanes/airports. This is reflected in the lower level numerical risk numbers as well as lower tolerance for uncertainty acceptable for charter or regular public transport operations.[24] Whilst we accept that this may have been one of the reasons for deciding to issue the class 2 medical certificate we do not agree that it is a valid reason and it is not a reason which this Tribunal is prepared to adopt. On the facts before us, we can see no justification for, or logic in, the proposition that the degree of risk to the safety of air navigation can vary according to whether or not the pilot is flying for reward.[24] Exhibit R1 para.89. The evidence of Mr Taggart confirmed the concerns which we have. Mr Taggart said that his failure to obtain a class 1 certificate has prevented his operating his aeroplane for the purposes of earning income from aerial surveying, an activity which he has previously pursued. The lack of a class 1 certificate would prevent his taking on board fare paying passengers should he wish to do so. However, provided he has been accompanied by a safety pilot, Mr Taggart has been able to operate his aeroplane to convey passengers under the Angel Flight scheme. Under this scheme Mr Taggart has conveyed ill patients and accompanying persons from country Victoria to airports in and around Melbourne. He has also transported patients from country areas to Sydney. In our view the risk to the safety of air navigation, whether it be to the passengers in his aircraft, to those in other aircraft in the vicinity or to people on the ground, is no less because the passengers are not required to pay a fare to travel in the aircraft. For the same reasons as stated in relation to the application for the issue of a class 1 medical certificate, we are not satisfied that the imposition of “with safety pilot” restriction on a class 2 medical certificate reduced the risk to the safety of air navigation to an acceptable level. However as it is now only a few days before the expiration of 12 months from the time Mr Taggart suffered the episode of transient global amnesia and there is no indication of its recurrence or of the existence of epilepsy, we will affirm the decision under review.F. COMMENT Notwithstanding our decision that the decision under review will be affirmed, it is open to the Authority to decide to issue either a class 1 or a class 2 certificate should Mr Taggart again apply. Any conditions which may be appropriate to impose will be determined at the time the Authority decides upon any further application by Mr Taggart and are not matters for this Tribunal. Similarly, the tests which Mr Taggart may be required to undertake are matters for the Authority’s decision at the time. However, in view of the evidence of Mr Taggart it is appropriate that we comment upon the conditions which should be considered when the Authority decides to issue a medical certificate subject to a condition that the holder of the certificate be accompanied by a safety-pilot.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be affirmed.B. EVIDENCE AND FINDINGS OF FACT Unless stated otherwise the following findings of fact are based on the evidence of Mr Taggart. Mr Taggart is 61 years old. He holds a commercial pilot’s licence and has done so for at least 20 years. Prior to February 2012 Mr Taggart held successive class 1 medical certificates issued by the Authority for 20 years. His total aeronautical experience is approximately 2600 hours. Mr Taggart practises as a Chartered Accountant. In addition he earns income from conducting survey flights. He also uses his licence as an unpaid volunteer, air-lifting patients for medical treatment as part of the Angel Flight scheme. On 16 October 2011 Mr Taggart tripped and struck his forehead on the corner of a wall. The blow broke the skin and caused an injury which was painful to touch. However Mr Taggart did not lose consciousness and did not suffer a headache as a consequence of the incident. He did not seek medical treatment and was able to continue his planned activities on the day. On 18 October 2011 Mr Taggart suffered an episode of some confusion which he described as follows:We – we rise at 5:30 every morning to walk our dogs. We did that. Everything proceeded normally. I was to attend a funeral on that day at about 10 o’clock, so I took the opportunity to do some work at home instead of going into my office. And so at about half past 8 or so I had had breakfast and I had done some exercises, as I do every morning. And – and then about half past 8 I sat down in my office and started to work on a client’s file. And my wife went to – my wife went down to Coles to get some groceries and I think it was about half past 9 or quarter to 10, when she returned and I recall that I was – I had been doing this accounting work and I was getting a little bit confused as to where I was and what I was doing. From there, my wife was concerned so she rang the doctor, Bill Walker, and we got in the car and drove across to Bill. I saw Bill and he called in another – another doctor from the clinic who I had not seen before and haven’t seen since. And they recommended that we go to Monash emergency department. So we got back in the car and I recall driving to – I wasn’t driving myself. My wife was driving but I recall the trip to Monash. We went into the emergency room. We checked in and then I sat with my wife in the emergency room watching all the people coming and going. Trying to figure out what they were doing and why they were there. And I think it was at about 3 o’clock in the afternoon that I was then taken from the waiting room into a ward. And then at about 5 o’clock – his name is Dr Wang I think – came and started doing tests and talking to me and by that time I was ready to go home.[1][1] Transcript 23.8.12 pp.50-51. The clinical notes of the Emergency Department of the Monash Medical Centre record, in part:This morning wife left him at home at 0700 hours, came back at 1000am found patient to be confused, pacing around asking same questions, not oriented to place/time. … Patient has no recollection of events this morning. … Wife said cognition returning to normal around 3pm this afternoon.[2][2] Exhibit A4 p.173.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANZ J
We recognize and applaud the work of Angel Flight and its volunteers, including Mr Taggart, in assisting those who live away from the services available in our capital cities. It is not our intention to restrict the invaluable service being provided. However, in our view it is important that the Authority be made aware of the issues raised by the evidence given in this application.G. CONCLUSION The decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority made 18 June 2012 to affirm a determination made 11 April 2012 to refuse to issue Mr Taggart with a class 1 medical certificate and to issue him with a class 2 medical certificate with a “with safety pilot” restriction will be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANZ J

The following issues arise for determination.(1) Does Mr Taggart meet the relevant medical standard for the issue of a class 1 medical certificate?(2) If not, is the extent to which he does not meet the standard likely to endanger the safety of air navigation?(3) Does Mr Taggart meet the relevant medical standard for the issue of a class 2 medical certificate?(4) If not, is the extent to which he does not meet the standard likely to endanger the safety of air navigation?E. CONSIDERATION OF THE ISSUESIssue 1: Does Mr Taggart meet the relevant medical standard for the issue of a class 1 medical certificate? On the basis of the evidence of Mr Taggart, the Monash Medical Centre records, Dr Bower, Dr Cher, Dr Cameron and Dr Navathe we are satisfied on the balance of probabilities that on 18 October 2011 Mr Taggart suffered an episode of transient global amnesia. We accept the following evidence of Dr Navathe as to the nature of the condition of transient global amnesia:Transient global amnesia (TGA) manifests with a paroxysmal, transient loss of memory function. Immediate recall ability is preserved, as is remote memory, however, patients experience a striking loss of memory for recent events and an impaired ability to retain new information. Many patients are anxious or agitated and may repeatedly ask questions concerning transpiring events. Upon mental status examination, language function is preserved, which indicates a preservation of semantic and syntax memory. Attention is spared, visual-spatial skills are intact, and social skills are retained. Symptoms typically last less than 24 hours. As the syndrome resolves, the amnesia improves, but the patient may be left with a distinct lapse of recollection of events during the attack. The typical age of occurrence is older than 50 years.[19][19] Exhibit R1 para 71. We are satisfied that the condition of transient global amnesia is medically significant and safety-relevant as it is likely to reduce the ability of Mr Taggart to exercise the privileges, and to perform the duties imposed on him by the licence he holds. We accept the evidence of Dr Cameron that if Mr Taggart suffered the condition whilst piloting an aircraft he would not know where he had come from or where he was going. He would also have problems assessing fuel reserves and keeping separation from other aircraft. Further we are satisfied that within the 12 months immediately after the initial incident there is a risk that Mr Taggart may suffer a recurrence of transient global amnesia or may, if this diagnosis was incorrect, display evidence of epilepsy. On this basis we are satisfied that he does not meet criterion 1.1 in Table 67.150. We have reached this conclusion on the basis that the suffering of an episode of transient global amnesia within the previous 12 months and the accompanying risks of recurrence or showing overt epilepsy is an abnormality and/or a latent disability that produces a risk of incapacitation. We will set out our reasons for concluding that there is a risk of recurrence of transient global amnesia or the manifestation of epilepsy later in these reasons.Issue 2: Is the extent to which Mr Taggart does not meet the medical standard for the issue of a class 1 medical certificate likely to endanger the safety of air navigation?