Virgin Enterprises Ltd v Agripower Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Virgin Enterprises Limited to registration of trade mark application 1332725(1,36,42) - VIRGIN GREEN - filed in the name of Agripower Australia Limited.

Delegate:

Nicole Worth

Representation:

Opponent: Andrew Fox of Counsel, instructed by Addisons Lawyers

Applicant: James Maxwell of Peter Maxwell & Associates

Decision:

2013 ATMO 79

Section 52 opposition – s60, 43, 58 and 59 grounds – s60 partially established - Applicant given opportunity to delete relevant services –– no award of costs

Background

  1. This is an opposition brought by Virgin Enterprises Limited (‘the Opponent’) pursuant to section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) to the registration of trade mark application number 1332725 in the name of Agripower Australia Limited (‘the Applicant’).

  2. Relevant details of the opposed application are as follows:

Trade Mark:  VIRGIN GREEN (‘the Trade Mark’)

Priority date:                    23 November 2009

Owner:                Agripower Australia Limited

Goods & Services:          Class 1: Diatomaceous earth and preparations containing, based on or made from diatomaceous earth in this class; fertilizers, fertilizer additives and fertilizing preparations; chemicals and chemical substances used in industry, science, agriculture, horticulture and forestry; absorbents in this class; desiccants in this class; preparations to aid water retention and to improve soil and soil salinity; phosphates; preparations containing diatomaceous earth to control moisture; cement bonding agents; preparations for filtration purposes; chemicals and preparations for filtering water, beverages, food and pharmaceuticals; diatomaceous earth and preparations containing, based on or made from diatomaceous earth for carbon sequestration, storage and capture, and to aid carbon sequestration, storage and capture.

Class 36: Carbon trading services; carbon brokerage services; trading of emission reduction credits; services related to trading of carbon credits and emission reduction units; investment and financial services in relation to investment schemes for the trading of carbon credits and emission reduction units; carbon offsetting services; management of carbon dioxide, greenhouse gas abatement and emission reduction offsets, allowances and units; carbon credit schemes; information, advisory and consultancy services relating to all of the aforementioned services.

Class 42: Advisory and consultancy services in the field of carbon offset and sequestration; technical and scientific services in relation to carbon offsetting, carbon trading and carbon sequestration; scientific, industrial and technological research in relation to carbon offsetting and carbon sequestration; carbon offsetting services.

  1. The application was examined and accepted for possible registration. Acceptance of the application was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 25 March 2010. On 23 June 2010 the Opponent filed a Notice of Opposition to the registration nominating most of the grounds available under the Act to oppose a registration.

  2. The parties served and filed evidence (described below) after which the matter came for hearing before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 20 June 2013. The Opponent was represented by Andrew Fox of Counsel, instructed by Karen Hayne of Addisons Lawyers. The Applicant was represented by James Maxwell of Peter Maxwell & Associates.

Evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Virgin Enterprises Ltd v Agripower Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ATMO 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Virgin Enterprises Ltd (the Opponent) and Agripower Australia Ltd (the Applicant) were parties to proceedings before Nicole Worth. The dispute concerned the admissibility of certain evidence filed by the Applicant, specifically paragraphs 1, 15, and 16 of a declaration by Peter Prentice, a director of the Applicant, and its accompanying exhibit. The Opponent objected to these paragraphs, arguing they contained assertions about Mr. Prentice's knowledge gained through his position with the Applicant.

The court was required to determine whether the disputed paragraphs of Mr. Prentice's declaration were admissible as evidence. The Opponent's objection was based on the assertion that Mr. Prentice's knowledge was derived from his role as director, but the basis for this objection was not clearly articulated.

The court reasoned that the statement in question, asserting Mr. Prentice's familiarity with the Applicant's products, services, trade marks, and business activities in Australia, was a reasonable assertion given his position as director. The court noted that a similar statement had been made in previous evidence (Prentice 1) without objection. Consequently, the court considered it reasonable to allow the inclusion of the disputed paragraphs, finding no clear basis for their exclusion.

The court ordered that the disputed paragraphs of Mr. Prentice's declaration be admitted as evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence served and filed in these proceedings is as follows:Evidence in support·Statutory declaration of Karen Anne Hayne, lawyer with Addisons Lawyers, with exhibits KAH-1 to KAH-186 dated 15 December 2011 (‘Hayne 1’)·Statutory declaration of Karen Anne Hayne with exhibits KAH-A to KAH-III dated 21 December 2011 (‘Hayne 2’)·Statutory declaration of Mark James, Intellectual Property Manager of the Opponent, with exhibits MJ-1 to MJ-4 dated 29 September 2011·Statutory declaration of Michael Odai, General Counsel and Chief Operating Officer of Virgin Green Fund (“a member of Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin Group of Companies”), with exhibits MO-1 to MO-9 dated 12 December 2011Evidence in answer·Declaration of Peter Prentice, director of the Applicant, with exhibits 1 to 3 dated 31 August 2012 (‘Prentice 1’)Evidence in reply·Statutory declaration of Karen Anne Hayne with unserved and unfiled confidential exhibit KAH-A and exhibits KAH-B to KAH-E (‘Hayne 3’), undated, filed 6 December 2012.Further evidence of Applicant·Declaration of Peter Prentice with exhibit 1 dated 28 May 2013 (‘Prentice 2’) At the hearing the Opponent clarified that it would not be reading certain parts of its evidence, those parts being paragraphs 98 and 99 of Hayne 2 and paragraphs 3, 4 and 5 of Hayne 3. This material relates to an exhibit (confidential exhibit KAH-A), the confidentiality of which was in dispute and so it had not been served or filed, although the Opponent indicated that it may do so at the hearing pending the Applicant’s submissions. At the hearing the Opponent confirmed it would not seek to serve or file confidential exhibit KAH-A. On this basis the parties agreed that certain parts of the Applicant’s further evidence need not be read, those parts being paragraphs 6 to 11 and 13 to 14 of Prentice 2 (which is a 16 paragraph declaration accompanied by a single exhibit). The Opponent further indicated that it did not object to paragraph 12 of Prentice 2, which constitutes a correction to Prentice 1, and to give paragraph 12 context the Opponent did not object to paragraphs 1 to 5 either (save for the last sentence of paragraph 1). The material that the Opponent did object to in Prentice 2 comprises the final sentence of paragraph 1 and paragraphs 15 and 16. The final sentence of paragraph 1 makes an assertion about the knowledge Mr. Prentice has gained by virtue of his position as director of the Applicant, specifically “As a result of my responsibilities and position with my Company, I have become very familiar with the products and services which my Company markets in Australia, the labels and trade marks which those products and services bear and the history and extent of my Company’s business activities in Australia”. The basis of the Opponent’s objection is not clear to me. However given this statement is also made in Prentice 1, and appears a reasonable assertion given Mr. Prentice is the director of the Applicant, I consider it reasonable to allow its inclusion.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established