United Petroleum Pty Ltd v Istanikzai

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

United Petroleum Pty Ltd v Istanikzai [2023] FCA 149    

File numbers:

VID 525 of 2021
VID 703 of 2021

Judgment of: ANDERSON J
Date of judgment: 2 March 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — application for stay of proceeding — where two related proceedings issued in the Federal Court of Australia (Federal Court Proceedings) as well as a related representative proceeding issued in the Supreme Court of Victoria — where the respondents seek a stay of the Federal Court Proceedings pending an outcome of the representative proceeding in the Supreme Court of Victoria — whether the interests of justice would be best served by granting a stay of the Federal Court Proceedings — where the interests of justice militate against granting a stay —where the applications are dismissed with costs
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Civil Procedure Act 2010 (Vic)

Cases cited:

Apotex Pty Ltd v Les Laboratoires Servier (No 6) [2012] FCA 745

Burrup Fertilisers Pty Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) v Oswal [2011] FCA 424

Clorox Australia Pty Ltd v International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd (2005) 66 IPR 506

FA Faulding & Co Ltd v Bristol-Myers Squibb Co (1997) 40 IPR 511

Jefferson Ltd v Bhetcha [1979] 2 All ER 1108

Oswal v Burrup Fertilisers Pty Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) [2011] FCAFC 117; 85 ACSR 531

Rochfort v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd [1972] 1 NSWLR 16

Shaw v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy of the Australian Financial Security Authority [2022] FCA 775

Sterling Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd v The Boots Company (Australia) Pty Ltd (1992) 34 FCR 287

Union Steamship Co of New Zealand Ltd v The Caradale (1937) 56 CLR 277

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 73
Date of hearing: 23 February 2023
Counsel for the Applicants Mr P H Wallis KC with Mr B J Murphy
Solicitor for the Applicants K & L Gates
Counsel for the Respondents Mr B J May
Solicitor for the Respondents Levitt Robinson Solicitors

 

ORDERS

VID 525 of 2021
BETWEEN:

UNITED PETROLEUM FRANCHISE PTY LTD ACN 127 764 989

First Applicant

UNITED PETROLEUM PTY LTD ACN 085 779 255 AS TRUSTEE FOR UNITED PETROLEUM UNIT TRUST

Second Applicant

AND:

FAHIM ISTANIKZAI

First Respondent

FHM United Pty Ltd ACN 639 802 798

Second Respondent

VID 703 of 2021
BETWEEN:

UNITED PETROLEUM FRANCHISE PTY LTD

First Applicant

UNITED PETROLEUM PTY LTD ACN 085 779 255 AS TRUSTEE FOR UNITED PETROLEUM UNIT TRUST

Second Applicant

AND:

JAYDEEP DEVJIBHAI BHATTI

First Respondent

JIGARKUMAR BHARATBHAI PATEL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ANDERSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 MARCH 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Respondents’ interlocutory applications each dated 28 October 2022 be dismissed.

2.The Respondents pay the Applicants’ costs of these applications.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

ANDERSON J:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read United Petroleum Pty Ltd v Istanikzai and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 149
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of United Petroleum Pty Ltd v Istanikzai involves a dispute between United Petroleum, a company operating a network of petrol stations and convenience stores, and several former franchisees, including Mr Istanikzai. The primary issue in the case was whether the court should grant a stay of proceedings in two related Federal Court actions and a representative proceeding in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The respondents sought a stay of the Federal Court proceedings pending the outcome of the representative proceeding in the Supreme Court of Victoria, arguing that the interests of justice would be best served by doing so. The court was required to decide if the interests of justice would indeed be best served by granting a stay of the Federal Court proceedings.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the principles and factors relevant to the exercise of its discretion to stay proceedings. The court noted that the overarching purpose of the civil practice and procedure provisions is to ensure efficiency and cost-effectiveness in the use of court resources. The court examined the overlap of issues between the proceedings, finding that the claims made by United against Mr Istanikzai for breach of the franchise agreement and breach of equitable obligations of confidence in relation to confidential information had nothing in common with the issues in the representative proceeding. The only claim with an overlap of issues was the misrepresentation claim, which the court considered insufficient to warrant a stay of the proceedings. The court concluded that the interests of justice did not militate in favour of granting a stay of the proceedings.

Consequently, the court dismissed the respondents' applications for a stay of the Federal Court proceedings and ordered the respondents to pay the applicants' costs of the applications. The court's decision underscores the importance of considering the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of court resources, as well as the specific issues and claims at stake in determining whether to grant a stay of proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Respondents’ interlocutory applications each dated 28 October 2022 be dismissed.

2. The Respondents pay the Applicants’ costs of these applications.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is well established that the Court’s powers under s 23 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (Act) and r 1.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) are broad, and include the power to order a stay of proceedings.BACKGROUND TO PROCEEDINGS The respondents provided the following background to the proceedings, which I adopt. United Petroleum and UP (collectively, United) are companies within a group trading under the “United” brand (United Group). United Petroleum operates a range of petrol stations and convenience stores across Australia, through a network of businesses operated by franchisees and commission agents (United Network). Mr Istanikzai, Mr Patel, and Mr Bhatti are former franchisees who operated United Petroleum sites. In or about April 2017, the United Group acquired the intellectual property to a franchise known as ‘Pie Face’ that sold pies and other bakery products (Pie Face Franchise). United Petroleum then began installing the Pie Face Franchise into sites throughout the United Network. On or about 17 April 2020, FNH, of which Mr Istanikzai is the sole director, entered into a franchise agreement with United Petroleum for a site at Cranbourne South, Victoria. Mr Istanikzai was a party to the franchise agreement in the capacity of guarantor. Prior to the commencement of FNH’s franchise agreement, United Petroleum installed Pie Face into the site at Cranbourne South. On or about 25 February 2021, United Petroleum terminated FNH’s franchise agreement. On or about 29 May 2018, Mr Patel and Mr Bhatti entered into a franchise agreement (in their capacities as trustees for the JJ Unit Trust) with United Petroleum for a site at Wallan, Victoria. Both `Mr Patel and Mr Bhatti were also parties to the franchise agreement as guarantors. During the term of Mr Patel and Mr Bhatti’s franchise agreement, United Petroleum installed Pie Face into the site at Wallan. On or about 26 January 2021, United Petroleum terminated Mr Patel and Mr Bhatti’s franchise agreement. In April and July 2021, Mr Istanikzai accessed the email account associated with the Cranbourne South site. On or about 20 June 2021, ABC News published an article entitled “Under the Pump” (ABC Report) and a news broadcast (ABC Broadcast) containing allegations against United Petroleum by several former franchisees. Mr Patel and Mr Bhatti were filmed as part of the ABC Broadcast, and made (or had attributed to them) a number of statements regarding the financial viability of their franchise following the installation of Pie Face, which included the ability to properly pay workers award wages under United’s business model. These representations were described by United in the Bhatti Proceeding as the “ABC Representations”. The ABC Broadcast also showed turning pages of the franchise agreement for the Wallan site, and a moving image of a document entitled “Wastage Audit by Reason – Wallan” for September 2020 (September Wastage Report). On 2 July 2021, Mr Istanikzai sent an email from a private email account to various recipients, including other United Petroleum franchisees in Victoria (Mr Istanikzai’s July Email). Mr Istanikzai’s July Email stated, inter alia:As we all know that none of the sites can afford to pay the Fair Work award wages with the current business model of United, most of the sites are hardly covering the daily costs. They made the system that only benefits United, the amount of work and responsibilities are too much and it’s increasing day by day but the benefits and rewards all stays [sic] the same.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Shaw v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy of the Australian Financial Security Authority [2022] FCA 775, Cheeseman J cited Burrup and Apotex, and held at [24] – [25]:In exercising the available discretion, each case turns on its own facts. As Bennett J observed in Apotex (at [16]), little direct assistance is gained from analysing other cases, save than to observe that some general principles apply when two proceedings form the basis for an application for a stay of one of them, including the right of an applicant to have its proceedings determined. The burden is on the applicant contending for the stay to show that it is just and convenient to interfere with the other party’s ordinary rights. The Court will look to the factors that, generally, balance the advantages and disadvantages to each party and to the Court. A stay will be appropriate where there are two separate proceedings between the same parties with related subject matter and where the hearing of one of the proceedings may dispose of the need for the second. Another factor which is relevant for the Court to consider in exercising the discretion to temporarily stay one proceeding until another is determined is the risk of inconsistent findings in the two proceedings in respect of related or overlapping subject matter. The Court may exercise its discretion where the interests of justice would be served by a stay of the proceedings: Clorox Australia Pty Ltd v International Consolidated Business Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1135; 66 IPR 506, 507 to 508 at [5] (Sundberg J).The overarching purpose of the civil practice and procedure provisions in s 37M of the FCA Act must also be borne in mind. While the authorities concerning the exercise of the Court’s discretion to stay proceedings have generally focussed on s 23 of the FCA Act, s 37M is also relevant. In exercising its discretion, the Court will consider the efficiency and costs implications involved in the duplication of proceedings, including with respect to the efficient use of the administrative resources available to the Court: Porter at [30]; Apotex at [8] to [10].CONSIDERATIONOverlap of Issues The Amended Concise Statement in the Istanikzai Proceeding summarised above, discloses that the claims made by United against Mr Istanikzai for breach of the franchise agreement and breach of equitable obligations of confidence in relation to confidential information, have nothing in common with the issues that arise for the determination in the Representative Proceeding. The only claim in which there is an overlap of issues is in respect of the misrepresentation claim alleged in paragraph [21] which is in the following terms:21.The email sent by Istanikzai represented that:(a)none of United’s franchisees and commission agents can afford to operate their sites while paying award wages because of United’s business model; and(b) most of United’s franchisees and commission agents are hardly covering their daily costs. (Istanikzai Representations)