Turay v Assistant Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Turay v Assistant Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1487

File number(s): NSD 447 of 2018
Judge(s): FARRELL J
Date of judgment: 3 October 2018
Catchwords: MIGRATION – review of the decision of the Assistant Minister for Home Affairs – visa cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – decision not to revoke visa cancellation – whether the Assistant Minister was required to consider whether non-refoulement obligations were “another reason” to revoke the cancellation of a visa under s 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Migration Act – whether the Assistant Minister mischaracterised the applicant’s claim as a claim based on non-refoulement obligations – whether the Assistant Minister failed to consider whether harms which were not subject to non-refoulement obligations were “another reason” to revoke the cancellation of the visa – whether the Assistant Minister failed to consider relevant, material and significant evidence – whether the Assistant Minister’s decision was legally unreasonable – application dismissed  
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36, 65, 197C, 198, 499, 501, 501CA

Convention against Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, opened for signature 10 December 1984, 1465 UNTS 85 (entered into force 26 June 1987)

Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, opened for signature 30 March 2007, 2515 UNTS 3 (entered into force 3 May 2009)

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, opened for signature 19 December 1966, 999 UNTS 171 (entered into force 23 March 1976)

Persons With Disabilities Act (Sierra Leone)

Cases cited:

Ali v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 650

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2003) 236 FCR 593; [2003] FCAFC 184

BCR16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 248 FCR 456; [2017] FCAFC 96

Coker v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 929

Greene v Assistant Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 919

Le v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 237 FCR 516; [2015] FCA 1473

McCutcheon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 828

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v BHA17 [2018] FCAFC 68

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Le (2016) 244 FCR 56; [2016] FCAFC 120

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSRS (2014) 309 ALR 67; [2014] FCAFC 16

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; [2013] HCA 18

Ogbonna v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 620

YNQY v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 1466

Date of hearing: 10 July 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 65
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Tully (Pro Bono)
Solicitor for the Applicant: Salvos Legal (Humanitarian)
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr T Reilly
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

NSD 447 of 2018
BETWEEN:

MOHAMED TURAY

Applicant

AND:

ASSISTANT MINISTER…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turay v Assistant Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1487
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Turay v Assistant Minister for Home Affairs involved the applicant, Mr Turay, who sought judicial review of the Assistant Minister's decision to not revoke the cancellation of his visa under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Assistant Minister was required to consider whether non-refoulement obligations were "another reason" to revoke the visa cancellation under section 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Migration Act. The court also had to determine whether the Assistant Minister mischaracterised the applicant's claim, failed to consider whether harms not subject to non-refoulement obligations were "another reason" to revoke the cancellation of the visa, and whether the Assistant Minister failed to consider relevant, material, and significant evidence. Finally, the court had to decide whether the Assistant Minister's decision was legally unreasonable.

The court found that it was open to the Assistant Minister to reason as he did, that despite Mr Turay's positive efforts towards rehabilitation, the support he would have in the community, and his expressed intention concerning how he would seek contact with his son, there was an ongoing likelihood that Mr Turay would reoffend in a manner that involved domestic or other violence. The court held that the Assistant Minister was not required to consider non-refoulement obligations as "another reason" to revoke the visa cancellation, and that the Assistant Minister did not mischaracterise Mr Turay's claim. The court further found that the Assistant Minister did not fail to consider whether harms not subject to non-refoulement obligations were "another reason" to revoke the visa cancellation, and that the Assistant Minister's decision was not legally unreasonable. As a result, the application was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The applicant must pay the respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The particulars to ground 1 are as follows:a.In his reasons for decision (at [95]), the respondent was concerned that there was no evidence that the applicant had undertaken the required rehabilitation specifically for alcohol or drugs to assist him to abstain from such substances in the community.b.The respondent had available before him:i.Evidence that the applicant had completed an EQUIPS Domestic Abuse Program (certificate dated 12 December 2016) and an EQUIPS Foundation Program (certificate dated 5 April 2017).ii.Evidence that these programs review, among other matters, lifestyle choices, risk factors related to an individual’s offending and emotional dysregulation or disinhibitors including alcohol and drug abuse (Corrective Services, Compendium of Offender Behaviour Change Programs in New South Wales dated June 2016 at pp 10, 12 & 39).iii.A personal submission dated 27 November 2017 in which the applicant had represented (at [42]) that, during the EQUIPS Domestic Abuse program, he “spoke about the use of alcohol and drugs and how badly they affect you.”iv.Evidence in the form of a completed New South Wales Corrective Services Pre-Release Home Visit Assessment dated 28 March 2017 (at p 5) which identified substance use/addiction programs and services available to the applicant as including the EQUIPS Addiction program, a variety of drug and alcohol services available in the area, and supervision which could include referrals to suitable services for assessment and/or interventions.c.This evidence was relevant, material and significant to assessing the applicant’s representations which the respondent failed to consider.Evidence In written submissions filed on behalf of Mr Turay, his pro bono counsel, Mr Tully, emphasised that Mr Turay’s representations filed with the Department stated that he was actively participating in courses to address his behaviour. In the submissions, Mr Tully relied on the following documents all of which are recorded as being included as “evidence or material” for Mr Turay in the attachment to the Assistant Minister’s reasons. The materials are(1)The “Request for Revocation of a Mandatory Visa Cancellation under s501(3A)” form which Mr Turay signed on 9 February 2017. At page 3 of the form (at CB 81) under the heading “Reasons for Revocation”, Mr Turay said (emphasis added):Family who remain supportive of me would be devastated if I were to be deported. I want to be an active parent in my son’s life.I have no family, no support in my country of birth.I have been actively participating in courses in order to address my behaviour which resulted in my incarceration. This is my first offence, I am not a repeat offender.I have a full-time job I intend to return to upon release. I also have an address I can reside at, providing parole approve it.(2)In his “Personal Circumstances Form” (at CB 90) completed on the same date, Mr Turay said (as written):CRIMINAL HISTORY AND RISK OF REOFFENDINGDo you believe that there are any factors that help to explain your offences which should be taken into account by the decision-maker?Although I do not intend to use this as an excuse the main contributing factor would be my problem with [Ms C’s] mother, made worse if I had consumed alcohol. I have completed a Domestic Abuse Program. I have been diagnosed with and being treated for post-traumatic stress disorder. I have learned that I need to start talking about my past traumas and learn how to deal with them in a more positive manner, this will be after release through STARRS – an organisation that specialises in this area. I have learned that alcohol only makes issues worse.…Have you completed any courses or programs that will help you to avoid further offending and to make a positive contribution to the community? Please provide evidence e.g. course completion certificatesHealth Training Package – TAFEGMAW Welding – TAFEEQUIPS DOMESTIC Abuse Program – Dept Corrective Services.(3)Paragraph [42] of Mr Turay’s letter to the Department dated 27 November 2017 (CB 328). The letter was written in response to sentencing remarks contained in records sent to Mr Turay for comment on 2 November 2017. It is useful to set out the context in which [42] of the letter occurs (as written):Steps to improve myself since offences40.In the sentencing remarks the judge suggested that it would be hard for me to rehabilitate, as a domestic violence offender. It hit hard to be described this way. I have worked so hard to prove that this isn’t true, that I will never reoffend. I truly believe that I will never reoffend.41.In prison, I completed a number of EQUIPS programs, including the EQUIPS Foundation program, the Domestic Abuse program and the Aggression program. The programs involved a lot of teamwork and a lot of time reflecting on our actions that led us to our programs. The programs were 120 hours in total.42.The EQUIPS Domestic Abuse program went for 40 hours in total. I spent a lot of this time talking about the incidents with [Ms C] and her mum that led to me being in jail. We spoke about the use of alcohol and drugs and how badly they affect you. I haven’t used drugs or had alcohol since I’ve been in prison and I don’t want to if I am released. I feel so much between without alcohol and drugs. I respect myself now.43.I got a lot out of the program. My teachers taught me how to recognise and control my emotions and the stress I was feeling because I didn’t have control over how often I could see [my son]. I learnt that you always need to be a team with your partner and respect and support each other.44.I haven’t tried to contact [Ms C] while I’ve been in prison and detention because I respect her and understand the reasons why she doesn’t want contact with me. If I am released, I will not contact [Ms C] or her family. I will take the right approach and go through the family court system to try to arrange access to see [my son] again.45.I know that it will take time for [Ms C] to trust me with [my son]. I am willing to see him at a supervised centre for as long as it takes to get her trust back.46.The EQUIPS Aggression program also went for 40 hours in total. I spent a lot of time with the teachers discussing my offences and identifying why I used aggressive behaviour. During the program, I realised that I became angry and aggressive because I was hiding my struggles with trauma and PTSD. I was also hanging around with people who were bad influences on my behaviour – I need to stay away from people like that.…(4)A letter dated 29 November 2017 from Salvos Legal to the Department in which the EQUIPS programs undertaken by Mr Turay are discussed (at CB 318 and 319). Certificates of completion of the EQUIPS Domestic Abuse Program and EQUIPS Foundation Program were attached with that letter (CB 113 and 114). The EQUIPS programs undertaken by Mr Turay are discussed under a heading “The risk to the Australian community should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct”. Having regard to Mr Tully’s written and oral submissions in relation to this ground it is useful to set out relevant parts of that letter which appear at CB 318-321 (emphasis added):Mr Turay instructs us that since his imprisonment, he has taken major steps toward addressing his mental health and behavioural problems that underpinned his offending, demonstrating a newfound commitment to rehabilitating and heavily redressing his risk of re-offending. He has greatly improved his mental health, completed intensive offender behaviour change programs and enrolled in courses to improve his employment prospects in the community. He has also stopped drinking alcohol, using drugs and socialising with people who negatively affect his behaviour. He is medicated for his mental health problems and is compliant with his medication regime. Given this intervention, we submit that Mr Turay had demonstrated that he no longer poses a risk to the Australian community.Offender behaviour change programsMr Turay instructs that he completed three intensive EQUIPS (Explore, Question, Understand, investigate, Practice and Succeed) programs while he was in prison – EQUIPS Foundation (a general offender program), Equips Aggression and Equips Domestic Abuse. We understand that these courses have been specifically developed and implemented by Corrective Services NSW to rehabilitate and reduce reoffending. Two of his completion certificates are annexed and marked Annexure F.The enclosed excerpts of the Corrective Services NSW ‘Compendium of Offender Behaviour Change Programs in New South Wales’ published in June 2016, annexed and marked as Annexure G, provide the following information about each program:ŸThe EQUIPS Foundation program is a 40-hour general therapeutic offender program that “aims to reduce re-offending by addressing criminogenic needs for general offence types”.ŸThe EQUIPS Aggression program is a 40-hour program that is “designed to increase participants’ ability to manage difficult life events and minimise aggressive behaviour. It is based on a strong cognitive behaviour therapy approach and is linked to mindfulness and values. It targets both expressive and instrumental aggression”.ŸThe EQUIPS Domestic Abuse program is a 40-hour program that “has a strong emphasis on inviting perpetrators to accept responsibility for their offending behaviour. It also encourages them to increase their level of accountability to the wider community”.As Mr Turay has explained in his statement dated 27 November 2017, he learnt a lot from each of the programs. In particular, he learnt to recognise and control his emotions, to walk away from stressful situations that would otherwise trigger aggressive behaviour and to use mindfulness techniques and exercise to improve his wellbeing and reduce aggression. Mr Turay instructs that he uses the techniques he learnt in the EQUIPS programs on a daily basis to manage his significant levels of stress in detention.We submit that Mr Turay’s successful completion of three EQUIPS programs demonstrates his self-directed commitment to rehabilitating and reducing his risk of re-offending. As a result of his participation in these programs, Mr Turay has significantly decreased his risk of re-offending and causing harm to the Australian community.…Mental Health...Drug and alcohol useMr Turay now acknowledges that his behaviour and mental health issues were negatively impacted by his drug and alcohol use. Mr Turay instructs that he has not used alcohol and drugs since the start of his term of imprisonment, some two years ago. Given his relatively recent insight into the dysfunction that alcohol and drug use wreaked upon his life, he has no desire to resume consumption of alcohol and drugs should [he] be released into the community. Mr Turay further instructs that he would be willing to consider drug and alcohol courses if he felt that he was struggling to abstain from alcohol in the community. He understands that his family’s wellbeing and his own mental health are incompatible with alcohol and drugs and those goals are his top priorities.We submit that Mr Turay’s risk of re-offending will be significantly reduced with the support of his brother [name redacted] who he will live with if he is released from detention. Had Mr Turay’s visa not been cancelled, he would have served the remainder of his sentence in the community, under their support and supervision of Corrective Services and [name of brother].In the enclosed Corrective Services NSW ‘Pre-Release Home Visit Assessment Form’ dated 28 March 2017, which is annexed and marked as Annexure L, we note that [name of brother] has been assessed as a suitable supporter to assist Mr Turay in his transition back into the community. Corrective Services made this finding on the basis that Mr Turay’s brother is aware of Mr Turay’s past issues with drugs and alcohol, his offending behaviour and his obligations whilst on parole, is supportive of the offender in addressing his offending behaviour and willing to fully co-operate with Corrective Services.(5)The New South Wales Corrective Services Pre-Release Home Visit Assessment referred to in item b.iv of the first ground relevantly provides as follows:Programs and services37.Based on the information provided in Part A, in the attached reports and on OIMS, what programs and services are available in the area for the offender?Substance use/Addiction: In addition to EQUIPS Addiction program, there are a variety of drug and alcohol services available in the area and supervision could include referrals to suitable services for assessment and or interventions.…

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view it was open to the Assistant Minister to reason as he did at [96] that despite Mr Turay’s positive efforts towards rehabilitation, the support that he would have in the community and his expressed intention concerning how he would seek contact with his son, he may become frustrated should Ms C and her family not agree that he should have contact and to have concerns about Mr Turay’s capacity to resist those pressures where it had not been tested in the community. In light of his past conduct in the community and its triggers there was no lack of evidence or lack of logical basis for the finding at R[97] that there was an ongoing likelihood that Mr Turay will reoffend in a manner that involves domestic or other violence. As Ms C and Mr Turay are the parents of a child with whom Mr Turay wishes to maintain contact, that trigger would be ongoing. It was not necessary for the Assistant Minister to act on the basis that his relationship with Ms R would be ongoing. Mr Turay made no representation that he intended to have no other domestic relationships in the future. Domestic violence had been found (by courts) to be a feature of the two relationships which Mr Turay identified in his representations. The Assistant Minister was entitled to speculate as to what might happen in future domestic relationships by reference to what has occurred in the past: see the authorities cited in Ogbonna at [46]. I accept Mr Reilly’s submission that, having found that there was an ongoing risk of reoffending, it was logically and rationally open to the Assistant Minister to consider that the protection of the Australian Community outweighed the considerations in Mr Turay’s favour: see R[106]. The cases of Mr Ogbonna and Mr Turay are plainly distinguishable having regard to the findings made with respect to the risk of reoffending by the respective decision-makers. In my view, Mr Tully’s submission that an “outcome focussed” assessment of the reasonableness of the Assistant Minister’s decision requires a finding of jurisdictional error is, in this case, no more than an invitation to engage in impermissible merit review.CONCLUSION As none of the grounds of the application have been made out, the application should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In written submissions filed on behalf of Mr Turay, his pro bono counsel, Mr Tully, emphasised that Mr Turay’s representations filed with the Department stated that he was actively participating in courses to address his behaviour. In the submissions, Mr Tully relied on the following documents all of which are recorded as being included as “evidence or material” for Mr Turay in the attachment to the Assistant Minister’s reasons. The materials are(1)The “Request for Revocation of a Mandatory Visa Cancellation under s501(3A)” form which Mr Turay signed on 9 February 2017. At page 3 of the form (at CB 81) under the heading “Reasons for Revocation”, Mr Turay said (emphasis added):Family who remain supportive of me would be devastated if I were to be deported. I want to be an active parent in my son’s life.I have no family, no support in my country of birth.I have been actively participating in courses in order to address my behaviour which resulted in my incarceration. This is my first offence, I am not a repeat offender.I have a full-time job I intend to return to upon release. I also have an address I can reside at, providing parole approve it.(2)In his “Personal Circumstances Form” (at CB 90) completed on the same date, Mr Turay said (as written):CRIMINAL HISTORY AND RISK OF REOFFENDINGDo you believe that there are any factors that help to explain your offences which should be taken into account by the decision-maker?Although I do not intend to use this as an excuse the main contributing factor would be my problem with [Ms C’s] mother, made worse if I had consumed alcohol. I have completed a Domestic Abuse Program. I have been diagnosed with and being treated for post-traumatic stress disorder. I have learned that I need to start talking about my past traumas and learn how to deal with them in a more positive manner, this will be after release through STARRS – an organisation that specialises in this area. I have learned that alcohol only makes issues worse.…Have you completed any courses or programs that will help you to avoid further offending and to make a positive contribution to the community? Please provide evidence e.g. course completion certificatesHealth Training Package – TAFEGMAW Welding – TAFEEQUIPS DOMESTIC Abuse Program – Dept Corrective Services.(3)Paragraph [42] of Mr Turay’s letter to the Department dated 27 November 2017 (CB 328). The letter was written in response to sentencing remarks contained in records sent to Mr Turay for comment on 2 November 2017. It is useful to set out the context in which [42] of the letter occurs (as written):Steps to improve myself since offences40.In the sentencing remarks the judge suggested that it would be hard for me to rehabilitate, as a domestic violence offender. It hit hard to be described this way. I have worked so hard to prove that this isn’t true, that I will never reoffend. I truly believe that I will never reoffend.41.In prison, I completed a number of EQUIPS programs, including the EQUIPS Foundation program, the Domestic Abuse program and the Aggression program. The programs involved a lot of teamwork and a lot of time reflecting on our actions that led us to our programs. The programs were 120 hours in total.42.The EQUIPS Domestic Abuse program went for 40 hours in total. I spent a lot of this time talking about the incidents with [Ms C] and her mum that led to me being in jail. We spoke about the use of alcohol and drugs and how badly they affect you. I haven’t used drugs or had alcohol since I’ve been in prison and I don’t want to if I am released. I feel so much between without alcohol and drugs. I respect myself now.43.I got a lot out of the program. My teachers taught me how to recognise and control my emotions and the stress I was feeling because I didn’t have control over how often I could see [my son]. I learnt that you always need to be a team with your partner and respect and support each other.44.I haven’t tried to contact [Ms C] while I’ve been in prison and detention because I respect her and understand the reasons why she doesn’t want contact with me. If I am released, I will not contact [Ms C] or her family. I will take the right approach and go through the family court system to try to arrange access to see [my son] again.45.I know that it will take time for [Ms C] to trust me with [my son]. I am willing to see him at a supervised centre for as long as it takes to get her trust back.46.The EQUIPS Aggression program also went for 40 hours in total. I spent a lot of time with the teachers discussing my offences and identifying why I used aggressive behaviour. During the program, I realised that I became angry and aggressive because I was hiding my struggles with trauma and PTSD. I was also hanging around with people who were bad influences on my behaviour – I need to stay away from people like that.…(4)A letter dated 29 November 2017 from Salvos Legal to the Department in which the EQUIPS programs undertaken by Mr Turay are discussed (at CB 318 and 319). Certificates of completion of the EQUIPS Domestic Abuse Program and EQUIPS Foundation Program were attached with that letter (CB 113 and 114). The EQUIPS programs undertaken by Mr Turay are discussed under a heading “The risk to the Australian community should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct”. Having regard to Mr Tully’s written and oral submissions in relation to this ground it is useful to set out relevant parts of that letter which appear at CB 318-321 (emphasis added):Mr Turay instructs us that since his imprisonment, he has taken major steps toward addressing his mental health and behavioural problems that underpinned his offending, demonstrating a newfound commitment to rehabilitating and heavily redressing his risk of re-offending. He has greatly improved his mental health, completed intensive offender behaviour change programs and enrolled in courses to improve his employment prospects in the community. He has also stopped drinking alcohol, using drugs and socialising with people who negatively affect his behaviour. He is medicated for his mental health problems and is compliant with his medication regime. Given this intervention, we submit that Mr Turay had demonstrated that he no longer poses a risk to the Australian community.Offender behaviour change programsMr Turay instructs that he completed three intensive EQUIPS (Explore, Question, Understand, investigate, Practice and Succeed) programs while he was in prison – EQUIPS Foundation (a general offender program), Equips Aggression and Equips Domestic Abuse. We understand that these courses have been specifically developed and implemented by Corrective Services NSW to rehabilitate and reduce reoffending. Two of his completion certificates are annexed and marked Annexure F.The enclosed excerpts of the Corrective Services NSW ‘Compendium of Offender Behaviour Change Programs in New South Wales’ published in June 2016, annexed and marked as Annexure G, provide the following information about each program:ŸThe EQUIPS Foundation program is a 40-hour general therapeutic offender program that “aims to reduce re-offending by addressing criminogenic needs for general offence types”.ŸThe EQUIPS Aggression program is a 40-hour program that is “designed to increase participants’ ability to manage difficult life events and minimise aggressive behaviour. It is based on a strong cognitive behaviour therapy approach and is linked to mindfulness and values. It targets both expressive and instrumental aggression”.ŸThe EQUIPS Domestic Abuse program is a 40-hour program that “has a strong emphasis on inviting perpetrators to accept responsibility for their offending behaviour. It also encourages them to increase their level of accountability to the wider community”.As Mr Turay has explained in his statement dated 27 November 2017, he learnt a lot from each of the programs. In particular, he learnt to recognise and control his emotions, to walk away from stressful situations that would otherwise trigger aggressive behaviour and to use mindfulness techniques and exercise to improve his wellbeing and reduce aggression. Mr Turay instructs that he uses the techniques he learnt in the EQUIPS programs on a daily basis to manage his significant levels of stress in detention.We submit that Mr Turay’s successful completion of three EQUIPS programs demonstrates his self-directed commitment to rehabilitating and reducing his risk of re-offending. As a result of his participation in these programs, Mr Turay has significantly decreased his risk of re-offending and causing harm to the Australian community.…Mental Health...Drug and alcohol useMr Turay now acknowledges that his behaviour and mental health issues were negatively impacted by his drug and alcohol use. Mr Turay instructs that he has not used alcohol and drugs since the start of his term of imprisonment, some two years ago. Given his relatively recent insight into the dysfunction that alcohol and drug use wreaked upon his life, he has no desire to resume consumption of alcohol and drugs should [he] be released into the community. Mr Turay further instructs that he would be willing to consider drug and alcohol courses if he felt that he was struggling to abstain from alcohol in the community. He understands that his family’s wellbeing and his own mental health are incompatible with alcohol and drugs and those goals are his top priorities.We submit that Mr Turay’s risk of re-offending will be significantly reduced with the support of his brother [name redacted] who he will live with if he is released from detention. Had Mr Turay’s visa not been cancelled, he would have served the remainder of his sentence in the community, under their support and supervision of Corrective Services and [name of brother].In the enclosed Corrective Services NSW ‘Pre-Release Home Visit Assessment Form’ dated 28 March 2017, which is annexed and marked as Annexure L, we note that [name of brother] has been assessed as a suitable supporter to assist Mr Turay in his transition back into the community. Corrective Services made this finding on the basis that Mr Turay’s brother is aware of Mr Turay’s past issues with drugs and alcohol, his offending behaviour and his obligations whilst on parole, is supportive of the offender in addressing his offending behaviour and willing to fully co-operate with Corrective Services.(5)The New South Wales Corrective Services Pre-Release Home Visit Assessment referred to in item b.iv of the first ground relevantly provides as follows:Programs and services37.Based on the information provided in Part A, in the attached reports and on OIMS, what programs and services are available in the area for the offender?Substance use/Addiction: In addition to EQUIPS Addiction program, there are a variety of drug and alcohol services available in the area and supervision could include referrals to suitable services for assessment and or interventions.…