Tregidga v Pasma Holdings Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tregidga v Pasma Holdings Pty Limited [2021] FCA 721  

File number: NSD 1803 of 2017
Judgment of: REEVES J
Date of judgment: 28 June 2021
Catchwords: ADMIRALTY – where applicants made claim for damages against maritime electrical contractor arising from fire on board vessel – whether there was a breach of contract or breach of statutory guarantee or negligence with regard to the fire – whether respondent was liable for damage caused to vessel – whether applicants were owners of the vessel at the time of fire – whether applicants were parties to contracts relating to the electrical works conducted on the vessel – whether applicants were “consumers” for the purposes of s 60 of the Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the ACL) – whether the applicants were entitled to pursue a claim against the respondents under s 60 of the ACL without being parties to the contract – whether duty of care in tort was owed to the applicants by the respondent – whether scope of the duty of care owed by the respondent extended to taking steps to prevent fire – whether scope of duty of care affected by terms of contracts – whether there was a breach of duty of care – determination of causation – application dismissed
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth))

Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW)

Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld)

Shipping Registration Act 1981 (Cth)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Air Tahiti Nui Pty Ltd v McKenzie (2009) 77 NSWLR 299; [2009] NSWCA 429

Alameddine v Glenworth Valley Horse Riding Pty Ltd (2015) 324 ALR 355; [2015] NSWCA 219

BH Australia Constructions Pty Ltd v Kapeller (2019) 100 NSWLR 367; [2019] NSWSC 108

Bradshaw v McEwans Pty Ltd (1951) 217 ALR 1

Council of the Shire of Sutherland v Heyman (1985) 157 CLR 424

Council of the Shire of Wyong v Shirt (1980) 146 CLR 40

Tomko v Palasty [2007] NSWCA 258

Graham Barclay Oysters Pty Limited v Ryan (2002) 211 CLR 540; [2002] HCA 54

Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd (2011) 243 CLR 361; [2011] HCA 11

Lederberger v Mediterranean Olives Financial Pty Ltd (2012) 38 VR 509; [2012] VSCA 262

Lets Go Adventures Pty Ltd v Barrett [2017] NSWCA 243

Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705; [2001] NSWCA 305

Perre v Apand Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 180; [1999] HCA 36

Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales v Dederer (2007) 234 CLR 330; [2007] HCA 42

Schellenberg v Tunnel Holdings Pty Limited (2000) 200 CLR 121; [2000] HCA 18

Sullivan v Moody (2001) 207 CLR 562; [2001] HCA 59

Valve Corporation v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2017) 258 FCR 190; [2017] FCAFC 224

Voli v Inglewood Shire Council (1963) 110 CLR 74

Wilson v Darling Island Stevedoring and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tregidga v Pasma Holdings Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 721
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tregidga v Pasma Holdings Pty Limited involved a claim for damages against a maritime electrical contractor arising from a fire on board a vessel. The applicants, Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins, sought to establish liability for the damage caused by the fire, alleging that the respondent, Pasma, breached contract or statutory guarantees or was negligent. The court was required to determine if Pasma was liable for the damage, whether the applicants were the owners of the vessel at the time of the fire, if they were parties to the contracts relating to the electrical works, and if they qualified as "consumers" under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). Additionally, the court needed to consider whether Pasma owed a duty of care to the applicants and if there was a breach of that duty.

The Federal Court dismissed the applicants' originating application, finding that Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins did not establish that Pasma was liable for the damage caused by the fire. The court found that Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins remained the legal and equitable owners of the vessel, Allure Cruises Pty Limited was the contracting party with Pasma, and that the applicants qualified as "consumers" under the ACL. However, the court concluded that Pasma was not under a duty to take action to prevent the fire and that the applicants did not prove on the balance of probabilities that the fire was caused by Pasma's negligence or breach of statutory guarantee.

The applicants' originating application filed on 11 October 2017 was dismissed, and the applicants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the proceeding. If either party wished to seek a different order as to costs, they were required to submit written submissions and supporting affidavit material. The court's decision was based on the evidence and submissions presented, and the final orders were made in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants’ originating application filed on 11 October 2017 is dismissed.

2. The applicants pay the respondent’s costs of the proceeding to be taxed failing agreement.

3. If any party wishes to seek a different order as to costs, then order 2 is vacated and the following orders will apply.

4. By close of business on 5 July 2021, that party is to prepare and submit to my chambers a set of submissions, limited to four pages, and any supporting affidavit material.

5. By close of business on 12 July 2021, the opposing party is to prepare and submit to my chambers a set of submissions in response, limited to four pages, and any supporting affidavit material.

6. The costs of the proceeding will then be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 14 June 2019, the issue of liability in this proceeding was ordered to be dealt with first as a separate question. For the reasons that follow, I do not consider Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins have established, on the balance of probabilities, that Pasma is liable for the damage caused by the fire on board the Miss Angel. That is to say, I do not consider they have established that Mr Tilton’s negligence caused that fire. Their originating application must therefore be dismissed.FACTUAL BACKGROUND In the second half of 2015, Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins decided to establish a business sailing tourists from Cairns to the Great Barrier Reef. To that end, on 30 September 2015, they registered a company called Allure Cruises Pty Limited , of which they were the sole directors and shareholders. At the same time, the Trekins Family Trust was settled, of which they were the principal beneficiaries, and they caused Allure to be appointed as the trustee of that Trust with the intention that their tourism business would be operated by the Trust through Allure as its trustee. In October 2015, Mr Tregidga travelled to Turkey to find a suitable vessel which could be brought into commercial survey in Australia. He eventually located, and decided to purchase, the Miss Angel. She had been built in Bodrum, Turkey in 2004 and was of traditional Turkish design. Consequently, Mr Tregidga was aware that she would require extensive works to bring her up to the requisite Australian commercial survey standard. With that matter in mind, during October 2015, Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins met in Cairns with Mr Russ Larkin and Mr Steven Larkin of Russ Larkin & Associates Pty Ltd. Steven Larkin is an Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) certified surveyor. He advised them on the works required to bring Miss Angel to the requisite standard mentioned above. Among other things, he advised that they would need to engage an AMSA certified electrical surveyor to attend to the upgrade to its electrical system. Steven Larkin told them he could not provide that certification himself because he was not AMSA certified for electrical surveys and he was not a licensed electrician. On 23 October 2015, Allure entered into an agreement to purchase the Miss Angel. Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins loaned the monies to Allure necessary to complete that purchase. Those monies were transferred to Turkey in stages and the sale was eventually completed on 3 December 2015 when a bill of sale was executed transferring the Miss Angel to Allure. At about the same time, the vessel was insured with Pantaenius, a company specialising in maritime insurance. Having completed the purchase, Mr Tregidga’s plan was for Miss Angel to set sail for Australia before Christmas 2015. However, he encountered two difficulties. The first was that, under Turkish law, the Miss Angel could not be removed from Turkey while it was owned by a foreign company unless Mr Tregidga produced certain documentation, which he was not able to do before the planned departure date. The second was that Miss Angel could not be imported into Australia as a commercial vessel unless she met the requisite AMSA survey standard and that could not be achieved without the extensive works mentioned above first being undertaken.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In their Further Amended Statement of Claim (FASC) (at [4A]), Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins alleged that, as at 8 June 2016, they were the owners of the Miss Angel. In the corresponding paragraph of its defence, Pasma denied that allegation and claimed that instead Allure was the owner.The evidence This issue essentially revolves around an email that Mr Tregidga sent to Pantaenius on 23 December 2015, shortly before the Miss Angel set sail for Australia, informing it of the change in ownership of the vessel and the circumstances in which that had occurred. That email relevantly stated:UrgentPlease note that we have had to make the purchase of Miss Angel under our names due to requirements of Turkish authorities, as follows:…We have bought this for our company, Allure Cruises Pty Ltd. Miss Angel will revert to the Company ownership once we return to Australia. Cathy and I are the only Directors of Allure Cruises.Will the current cover still suffice or will you need to reissue in our individual names? If so, can you please action urgently this morning and email to us as we are departing Turkey tomorrow and will not be contactable until after Boxing Day.… Pasma also relied upon a number of “contemporaneous documents”, including the agreement mentioned earlier that Allure entered into with BSE on 28 April 2016 to undertake works on the vessel and the invoice also mentioned earlier that Pasma submitted to Allure for the works it carried out on the vessel up to the time of the fire. For their part, Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins relied, among other things, on the accounting records in evidence which recorded that their loan to Allure of the funds necessary to purchase Miss Angel had been forgiven.The contentions Pasma contended that Mr Tregidga’s email evidenced a transfer by Allure “to it[s] directors on the basis of a promise to retransfer”. Further, it contended that the “contemporaneous documents” referred to above showed that all the dealings with the vessel after she arrived in Australia were conducted by Allure and it should therefore be inferred that the ownership of the vessel had been transferred from Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins to Allure prior to the fire. As well, in oral submissions, Pasma contended that the alleged promise arose in part from the serious context in which it was provided, namely by an insured to an insurer about the ownership of insured property. It also contended that this promise resulted in the grant to Allure of an equitable interest in the Miss Angel. In their oral and written submissions, Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins contended that the indication that Mr Tregidga gave to Pantaenius in his email of 23 December 2015 was not a contractually enforceable promise, nor a declaration of trust, but rather was a statement of future intentions with respect to the ownership of the Miss Angel which, by the time of the fire, had not come to fruition. Further, they pointed to the evidence that the Miss Angel remained at all times registered and insured in their names and that the loan they had made to Allure to purchase the vessel had been forgiven. As well, they contended that there was no evidence of any bill of sale or other document evidencing the transfer of the Miss Angel from them to Allure. As to Allure’s dealings with the Miss Angel after she arrived in Australia, they contended they were all consistent with the original intention that Allure should operate the tourism business as trustee of the Trust and were not indicative of any transfer of the vessel from them to Allure. Finally, even if Allure were the equitable owner of the vessel, they contended that they still retained the legal ownership and, as such, were still owed a duty of care such that they were entitled to sue in tort for any damage caused to it by another person’s negligent conduct.Consideration and disposition

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that the answers to the questions posed in Issues 4(d) and (d) and Issues 5(a) and (b) (see at [17] above) are:(a)Issue 4(d) – No(b)Issue 4(e) – No(c)Issue 5(a) – The cause of the fire is unknown(d)Issue 5(b) – An answer is not called for.OVERALL CONCLUSION To sum up, for the reasons set out above, I have concluded that:(a)Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins were the legal and equitable owners of the Miss Angel as at the time of the contract/agreement with Pasma and as at the time of the fire on 8 June 2016 (see at [26] above);(b)Allure Cruises Pty Ltd was the contracting party with Pasma (see at [53] above);(c)Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins are “consumers” for the purposes of the ACL and as such are entitled to seek damages under s 267(4) of the ACL for any proven breach of the statutory guarantee in s 60 of the ACL (see at [68] and [79] above);(d)as owners of the Miss Angel, Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins are entitled to seek damages in tort for any proven breach of the duty of care owed to them by Pasma (see at [69] above);(e)Pasma is unable to rely upon the terms and conditions referred to in its invoice rendered on 13 June 2016 or the terms of the Slipway Contract between Allure and BSE to avoid any liability that may arise under (c) or (d) above (see at [77] above);(f)in the circumstances, Pasma was not under a duty to take action to prevent injury or harm being occasioned to the Miss Angel arising from defects in the vessel’s electrical system while it was carrying out the works on that system (see at [163] above); and(g)Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins have not established, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Tilton’s negligence, or breach of the guarantee under s 60 of the ACL, was the cause of the fire on the Miss Angel (see at [218] above). These conclusions make it unnecessary to consider Issues 6 and 7. It follows that the originating application filed by Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins on 11 October 2017 must be dismissed. I will hear from the parties on the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In their oral and written submissions, Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins contended that the indication that Mr Tregidga gave to Pantaenius in his email of 23 December 2015 was not a contractually enforceable promise, nor a declaration of trust, but rather was a statement of future intentions with respect to the ownership of the Miss Angel which, by the time of the fire, had not come to fruition. Further, they pointed to the evidence that the Miss Angel remained at all times registered and insured in their names and that the loan they had made to Allure to purchase the vessel had been forgiven. As well, they contended that there was no evidence of any bill of sale or other document evidencing the transfer of the Miss Angel from them to Allure. As to Allure’s dealings with the Miss Angel after she arrived in Australia, they contended they were all consistent with the original intention that Allure should operate the tourism business as trustee of the Trust and were not indicative of any transfer of the vessel from them to Allure. Finally, even if Allure were the equitable owner of the vessel, they contended that they still retained the legal ownership and, as such, were still owed a duty of care such that they were entitled to sue in tort for any damage caused to it by another person’s negligent conduct.Consideration and disposition For the following reasons, I consider Pasma’s contentions with respect to this issue must be rejected. First, neither its context, nor its contents, permits Mr Tregidga’s email to Pantaenius of 23 December 2015 to be construed as a promise by him and Ms Jenkins to transfer ownership of the Miss Angel to Allure. Instead, that communication was, as Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins correctly contended, a statement of their future intentions concerning the ownership of the Miss Angel which was neither contractually binding on them, nor constituted a declaration of trust. Secondly, there is simply no evidence which would support an inference being drawn that this statement of future intentions was acted on prior to the fire. No bill of sale or similar document that would ordinarily evidence the transfer of the ownership of a vessel such as the Miss Angel has been produced (see ss 36 and 37 of the Shipping Registration Act 1981 (Cth)). To the contrary, the Miss Angel remained registered and insured in the names of Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins and the loan Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins made to Allure to purchase the vessel was forgiven. Finally, and relatedly, Allure’s dealings with the Miss Angel after it arrived in Australia do not provide that evidence. All those dealings were consistent with the original intention that Allure, as trustee of the Trust, should operate the tourism business. They say nothing about the ownership of the Miss Angel. For these reasons, the answer to the question posed in Issue 1 above is that Mr Tregidga and Ms Jenkins remained the legal and equitable owners of the Miss Angel as at the time of the contract with Pasma and at the time of the fire.2. THE CONTRACTING PARTIES ISSUEThe issue as pleaded