Trans-It Freighters Pty Ltd v Billy Baxters (Franchising) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL

TRANS-IT FREIGHTERS PTY LTD (ACN 076 074 210) (as Trustee for the Pollard Family Trust) AND OTHERS S APCI 2009 3779
v

BILLY BAXTERS (FRANCHISING) PTY LTD
(ACN 089 180 156)

- - -

JUDGES:

BONGIORNO and HANSEN JJA and KYROU AJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

16 February 2011

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

20 April 2012

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2012] VSCA 71

JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM:

[2009] VSC 207 (Harper J)

- - -

TRADE PRACTICES – Franchise of chain restaurant – Statements of projected turnover and reasonableness of rent – Whether misleading or deceptive – Reliance – Whether reasonable grounds – Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51A(1) and 52.

- - -

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellants Mr S G O’Bryan SC
with Mr G L Rice
DMAW Lawyers
For the Respondent Mr P Crennan Macpherson + Kelley

BONGIORNO JA:

  1. I agree with Hansen JA.

HANSEN JA:

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal from the judgment[1] and orders of a judge in the Commercial and Equity Division made on the trial of a proceeding arising out of a franchise agreement dated 17 June 2004.  The parties to the franchise agreement were Billy Baxters (Franchising) Pty Ltd[2] (‘Billy Baxters’) as franchisor, Trans-It Freighters Pty Ltd (‘Trans-It’) as franchisee and Ross Allan Pollard and Sue Dianne Pollard (being the directors and shareholders of Trans-It) as guarantors of the due performance of Trans-It’s obligations under the franchise agreement.  By the agreement Billy Baxters granted to Trans-It the right to operate a Billy Baxters franchise at 20 Jetty Road, Glenelg, South Australia, for a period of five years for a fee of $45,000 and otherwise on the terms of the agreement.  The guarantee, also dated 17 June 2004, was annexed to the franchise agreement.  The Billy Baxters franchise business was ‘a chain of licensed coffee houses, cafés and restaurants with modern and distinctive décor based on a cartoon character’.[3]

    [2]In the agreement the name is spelt without an apostrophe but with an apostrophe in the trademark.  I follow the same course as the judge of omitting the apostrophe except where appropriate for the possessive.

    [3]See Franchise Information brochure, Appeal Book C359.

  1. Trans-It duly commenced to conduct the franchise business but it did not achieve the anticipated turnover and sustained losses.  In these circumstances Trans-It fell into arrears of payment of amounts due under the franchise agreement, namely service fees and advertising expenses.  In 2006 Billy Baxters commenced the proceeding against Trans-It and the Pollards as guarantors to recover the amounts thus owing;  they denied the claim and counterclaimed for relief on a range of

grounds.  The judge upheld Billy Baxters’ claim and dismissed the counterclaim.

  1. The appeal raises two questions, namely:

(a)     whether, as the appellants (Trans-It and the Pollards) contend, the judge erred in holding that Billy Baxters had reasonable grounds for making a misleading or deceptive representation which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trans-It Freighters Pty Ltd v Billy Baxters (Franchising) Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] VSCA 71
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Trans-It Freighters Pty Ltd and the Pollards initiated proceedings against Billy Baxters (Franchising) Pty Ltd in the Federal Court, alleging breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (TPA). The plaintiffs claimed that Billy Baxters made misleading and deceptive statements about projected turnover and the reasonableness of the rental amount for the premises, which led to the signing of the franchise agreement and associated documents. The plaintiffs sought damages, declarations, and orders to void the franchise agreement and guarantee, and to restrain enforcement of these documents.

The court was required to determine whether Billy Baxters' representations regarding the projected turnover and rental amount were misleading or deceptive within the meaning of s 51A(1) and s 52 of the TPA. Further, the court had to consider whether these representations induced the plaintiffs to enter into the franchise agreement, lease the premises, and commence the franchise business. Additionally, the court had to assess whether Billy Baxters had reasonable grounds for making these statements.

The Federal Court found that Billy Baxters did not have reasonable grounds for the projections and statements made to the plaintiffs. The court held that the actual sales figures and net losses were significantly lower than those projected, and the rental amount was excessive given the actual turnover. The court concluded that the misleading statements constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under s 52 of the TPA. Consequently, Billy Baxters was held liable for misleading the plaintiffs and inducing them to enter into the franchise agreement and lease the premises.

The court ordered that Billy Baxters was liable for damages to be assessed and restrained from enforcing the franchise agreement and guarantee. The franchise agreement and guarantee were declared void, and Billy Baxters was estopped from relying on these documents to recover any amounts.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Trans-It and the Pollards:(a) Alleged that on or about 23 March 2004 Billy Baxters and Trans-It entered into ‘an agreement relating to the operation of the franchise’.(b) Sought damages, declarations and orders on the basis that in several respects the franchise agreement (or an agreement to enter into a franchise agreement) was entered into without complying with requirements of the Trade Practices (Industry Code Franchising) Regulations 1998 (‘the Code’), which in the circumstances constituted a contravention by Billy Baxters of s 51AD of the TPA, and the engaging by Billy Baxters in unconscionable conduct (including in relation to signing the lease of the premises) in contravention of s 51AA and s 51AC of the TPA.(c) Sought the like damages, declarations and orders on the basis that conduct of Billy Baxters in contravention of s 52 of the TPA induced Trans-It and the Pollards to:(i) enter into the ‘agreement relating to the operation of the franchise’;(ii) enter into an agreement to lease on 23 March 2004;(iii) execute a memorandum of lease dated 24 March 2004;(iv) execute the franchise agreement dated 17 June 2004;(v) execute the guarantee dated 17 June 2004;(vi) establish the franchise business and commence trading as Billy Baxters.The alleged contravening conduct was constituted by five representations made to Trans-It and the Pollards, namely:· First, at a meeting with Mr and Mrs Pollard on 18 March 2004, one Phillip Korry Mauviel on behalf of Billy Baxters said that the proposed rental of the premises of $160,000 per annum[4] plus GST was reasonable having regard to the projected turnover of the franchise.[4]The amount of $160,000 is throughout referred to as rental. In fact it included an amount for the annual outgoings. The figures were: rent $149,146 and outgoings $10,854 which produced the figure of $160,000 per annum; see Appeal Book C218 and C433.· Secondly, and at the same meeting on 18 March 2004, Mr Mauviel said that the projected turnover of the franchise in the first year of operation was $1,300,000.· Thirdly, in a spreadsheet described as ‘Income statement – 12 months year 1’ which Mr Mauviel provided to Mr and Mrs Pollard on 19 March 2004, that sales for the first year of the franchise would total $1,365,000 excluding GST.· Fourthly, also on 19 March 2004 by the same spreadsheet, that net profit for the first year of the franchise would be $175,732.· Fifthly, at a meeting with the Pollards on 19 March 2004, Mr Mauviel said that, having regard to the projected turnover of the franchise, the level of rent for the premises was reasonable.The representations were particularised as being false and misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive in the following respects:· Sales for the 2003/2004 year, with trading commencing on or about 7 June 2004, totalled $30,471 excluding GST.· Sales for the 2004/2005 year totalled $728,294 excluding GST.· A net loss was sustained in the 2003/2004 year, totalling $53,384.· A net loss was sustained in the 2004/2005 year, totalling $139,369.· At no stage had the business achieved annual sales of $1,300,000 or $1,365,000, either inclusive or exclusive of GST.· At no stage had the business achieved annual profits of $175,000.· Having regard to annual sales actually achieved the rent was excessive, and imposed a significant cost burden on the business.It was further alleged that to the extent the representations were as to a future matter, there were no reasonable grounds for their making and they were thus misleading within the meaning of s 51A of the TPA.(d) On the above bases Trans-It and the Pollards sought damages pursuant to s 82, and orders pursuant to s 87(1) and s 87(1A) of the TPA to restrain enforcement of the franchise agreement and guarantee and to declare those instruments void. Orders were also sought under s 80 but it is not necessary to refer to them.(e)Claimed that in the circumstances Billy Baxters was estopped from relying on the franchise agreement and recovering any amounts thereunder. The judge’s decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established