Tomasevic v State of Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2018 0104

MILAN TOMASEVIC
v
STATE OF VICTORIA (DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND EARLY CHILDHOOD DEVELOPMENT) (formerly known as DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION)

---

JUDGES: KAYE, EMERTON JJA and ALMOND AJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 27 November 2018
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 6 December 2018
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2018] VSCA 325
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2018] VSC 428 (Ginnane J)

---

ESTOPPEL — Issue estoppel — Workplace injury — Claim by worker to have suffered serious injury arising out of or in course of employment — Claim for statutory compensation by weekly payments upheld by County Court judge — Proceeding by worker in Supreme Court claiming damages for depressive disorder caused by employment— Whether findings of County Court judge made in relation to fundamental or ultimate issue — Whether findings were in respect of issue that was identical to issue in Supreme Court proceeding.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant: Mr A Ingram with
Dr J Plunkett
Antony Sdrinis & Co
For the Respondent: Mr S O’Meara QC with
Mr S Gladman
Minter Ellison

KAYE JA
EMERTON JA
ALMOND AJA:

  1. The applicant commenced proceedings in the trial division of the Court (the ‘Supreme Court proceeding’) claiming damages for psychological injury sustained by him in the course of his employment with the respondent between 1999 and 2004.  He had previously made a successful claim, in the County Court, for compensation under the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (‘the Act’) for weekly payments in respect of the same injury (the ‘County Court proceeding’).  On 2 November 2007, the judge of the County Court, who heard that claim, delivered judgment, holding that the applicant was entitled to compensation in the form of weekly payments in respect of two periods of incapacity for work.[1]

  1. In the Further Amended Statement of Claim (‘the Statement of Claim’) in the Supreme Court proceeding, the plaintiff pleaded an issue estoppel in respect of certain findings made by the judge in the County Court.  In its defence, the defendant denied that any estoppel, relevant to the Supreme Court proceeding, arose from the judgment of the judge of the County Court.

  1. At a directions hearing in the Supreme Court proceeding, Keogh J ordered that the proceeding be listed for determination of the estoppel pleaded by the plaintiff in paragraph 28 of the Statement of Claim.  Subsequently, after hearing argument in relation to that matter, a judge of the trial division concluded that no issue estoppel, as alleged by the applicant, arose from the decision of the judge in the County Court proceeding.[2]  Accordingly, the judge made an order that the application by the applicant to strike out paragraph 28 of the defence was dismissed.  The applicant seeks leave to appeal from that decision.

Background…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tomasevic v State of Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] VSCA 325
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Tomasevic, brought a claim against the defendant, the State of Victoria, seeking damages for a depressive disorder allegedly caused by his employment. Tomasevic had previously pursued a statutory compensation claim under the Workplace Injury Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1964 (Vic), where the County Court judge found that he had suffered a serious injury arising out of and in the course of his employment and ordered weekly compensation payments. Tomasevic subsequently sought damages in the Supreme Court for the same depressive disorder. The State of Victoria argued that the County Court's findings constituted an estoppel preventing Tomasevic from relitigating the same issue in the Supreme Court proceeding. The court had to determine whether the County Court's findings related to a fundamental or ultimate issue and whether the issues in both proceedings were identical.

The court examined the nature of the findings made by the County Court judge and considered whether they were of a fundamental or ultimate character. The court noted that the County Court's findings were related to the question of whether Tomasevic had suffered a serious injury in the course of his employment, which was a fundamental issue necessary for the determination of his entitlement to statutory compensation. The court also considered whether the issue in the Supreme Court proceeding—damages for the depressive disorder—was identical to the issue in the County Court proceeding. The court found that the County Court's findings were of a fundamental nature and that the issues in both proceedings were substantially the same. Consequently, the court held that the County Court's findings constituted an estoppel preventing Tomasevic from relitigating the same issue in the Supreme Court proceeding.

The court dismissed Tomasevic's claim for damages, finding that the County Court's findings on the fundamental issue of whether he had suffered a serious injury in the course of his employment were conclusive and binding in the subsequent proceeding. The court emphasised the importance of finality in legal proceedings and the need to prevent parties from relitigating the same issues. The court held that the findings of the County Court judge were binding on Tomasevic and that he was estopped from challenging those findings in the Supreme Court proceeding. As a result, Tomasevic's claim for damages was dismissed.

The court did not make any further orders in relation to the proceedings. The dismissal of Tomasevic's claim for damages was based on the principle of issue estoppel, which prevents a party from relitigating an issue that has already been determined by a court of competent jurisdiction. The court's decision reinforced the importance of finality in legal proceedings and the need to prevent parties from wasting court resources by relitigating the same issues.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a worker, Mr. Tomasevic, who suffered a workplace injury in 2006. He made a claim for compensation, which was initially rejected. He subsequently applied for review by the County Court of Victoria, which found that he had suffered a serious injury arising out of or in the course of employment. This finding led to the worker being awarded statutory compensation by weekly payments. Mr. Tomasevic then initiated proceedings in the Supreme Court of Victoria, seeking damages for a depressive disorder that he alleged was caused by his employment. The employer, the State of Victoria, argued that the worker was estopped from claiming damages for the depressive disorder due to the prior County Court decision that he had suffered a serious injury arising out of or in the course of employment.

Mr. Tomasevic first made a claim for compensation for his workplace injury, which was rejected. He appealed this decision to the County Court of Victoria, which found in his favour and awarded him statutory compensation by weekly payments. Mr. Tomasevic then brought proceedings in the Supreme Court of Victoria, seeking damages for the depressive disorder he claimed was caused by his employment. The State of Victoria, as the employer, filed a defence asserting issue estoppel based on the prior County Court decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the findings of the County Court judge related to a fundamental or ultimate issue.
2. Whether the findings in the County Court proceeding were in respect of an issue that was identical to the issue in the Supreme Court proceeding.

Held
1. The court concluded that the findings of the County Court judge related to a fundamental or ultimate issue.
2. The court found that the findings in the County Court proceeding were not in respect of an issue that was identical to the issue in the Supreme Court proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether the findings of the County Court judge related to a fundamental or ultimate issue, the court examined the nature of the issue adjudicated upon by the County Court. The court concluded that the County Court judge had adjudicated upon a fundamental or ultimate issue because the County Court judge had determined that the worker had suffered a serious injury arising out of or in the course of employment, which was a condition precedent to the worker's entitlement to compensation under the relevant statute. The court relied on the principle that a finding of fact made in a prior proceeding may be binding in a subsequent proceeding if it is a fundamental or ultimate issue, as established in *E v E*.

In examining whether the findings in the County Court proceeding were in respect of an issue that was identical to the issue in the Supreme Court proceeding, the court distinguished between the two issues. The court found that the issue in the County Court proceeding was whether the worker had suffered a serious injury arising out of or in the course of employment, whereas the issue in the Supreme Court proceeding was whether the worker's employment caused the depressive disorder that was the basis of the worker's claim for damages. The court concluded that these issues were not identical because the County Court judge had not made any findings as to the cause of the worker's depressive disorder, which was a separate and distinct issue from the issue of whether the worker had suffered a serious injury arising out of or in the course of employment. The court relied on the principle that for issue estoppel to apply, the issues in the two proceedings must be identical, as established in *Yoghurt King Pty Ltd v Tran*.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that findings made in a prior proceeding may be binding in a subsequent proceeding if they relate to a fundamental or ultimate issue, but the issues in the two proceedings must be identical for issue estoppel to apply. In this case, the findings of the County Court judge related to a fundamental or ultimate issue, but the issues in the two proceedings were not identical, so the findings did not estop the worker from pursuing his claim for damages in the Supreme Court.