Timbercorp Finance Pty Ltd (in liq) v Tomes

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2015 0105

TIMBERCORP FINANCE PTY LTD
(IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 054 581 190)
Applicant
v
JOHN CHARLES TOMES Respondent

---

JUDGES: SANTAMARIA and McLEISH JJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 26 November 2015
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 26 November 2015
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2015] VSCA 322

---

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Security for costs – Application for leave to appeal – Group proceedings under pt 4A of the Supreme Court Act 1986 – Proposed appellant in liquidation – Secured and unsecured creditors – Ability of proposed appellant to meet adverse costs order – Priority of legal costs over creditors – Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 556(1) – Liquidator’s lien for care, preservation and realisation of assets – Whether lien confined to liquidator’s personal expenses – Stewart v Atco Controls Pty Ltd (in liq) (2014) 252 CLR 307 – Timing of application – No sufficient risk of failure to meet costs order – Security for costs refused.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors

For the Applicant

Mr D J Batt QC with
Dr C O Parkinson
Mills Oakley Lawyers
For the Respondent Mr A Herskope with
Mr M D Tehan
JBT Lawyers

SANTAMARIA JA:

1  I invite McLeish JA to deliver the first judgment in this matter.

McLEISH JA:

2  The respondent to this application for leave to appeal, Mr John Charles Tomes, seeks an order for security of its costs of the application and any appeal.

3  The application for leave to appeal (and any appeal) is brought by Timbercorp Finance Pty Ltd (in liq) (‘Timbercorp’) and is listed to be heard on 30 November 2015.  At the same time, another application for leave to appeal, brought by Timbercorp against different respondents, will also be heard.

4 Both applications for leave to appeal are brought in respect of orders made by a judge in the Trial Division by way of answer to a preliminary question in two proceedings brought by Timbercorp against the respective respondents. By those orders, it was declared that the respondents are not precluded from raising their pleaded defences to Timbercorp’s claims in those proceedings. Timbercorp had contended that the respondents were so precluded, by reason of their participation as group members within the meaning of pt 4A of the Supreme Court Act 1986 in a group proceeding heard and determined under those provisions.[1]

5  The judge in the Trial Division held that the principles of Anshun estoppel[2] did not apply to group proceedings under pt 4A, or that, if they did, they were not attracted in the present cases. The judge further held that the raising of the defences pleaded by the respondents did not constitute an abuse of process.

6  The preliminary question which was heard and determined in the Trial Division was the subject of a hearing lasting three days concluding on 4 May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Timbercorp Finance Pty Ltd (in liq) v Tomes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] VSCA 322
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Timbercorp Finance Pty Ltd (in liq) v Tomes, the applicant sought security for costs in a proceeding involving a group of companies, as well as costs in the application. The applicant argued that the liquidation of one of the companies, and the priority of the liquidator’s lien over available assets, created a risk that the applicant would not be paid if ordered to pay costs. The respondent, Timbercorp, sought an order for security for costs and argued that the applicant had delayed in making the application and that the risk of non-payment was minimal. The Court considered whether the applicant had acted promptly and whether there was a sufficient risk that the respondent would be unable to meet a costs order. It also considered the costs of the application itself. The Court held that the application for security for costs should be dismissed as there was no sufficient risk that the respondent would be unable to meet a costs order. The Court also held that the applicant should pay the costs of the application on the standard basis, as the applicant was not driven to make the application by any failure of the respondent to provide information.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the present case, it cannot be said, notwithstanding the expedition with which the application for leave has been able to be brought to hearing, that Mr Tomes was prompt in seeking security for costs. On the other hand, it may fairly be said that Timbercorp’s financial position was not so plainly evident in the present case as it was in Façade Treatment. While Timbercorp was obviously known to be in liquidation, the evidence as to its current financial position, upon which Mr Tomes ultimately relies, was not publicly available until about 25 September 2015. Notwithstanding that earlier financial information was available, it cannot be said in the circumstances that such delay as Mr Tomes has allowed to occur would of itself stand as a significant obstacle to the grant for an order for security of costs.Conclusion38 In the end, the primary considerations upon which this application falls to be determined are Timbercorp’s financial position and such responsibility as Mr Tomes should bear for the timing of the making of the application. 39 In my opinion, it has not been shown that there is a sufficient risk that Timbercorp would fail to meet a costs order in favour of Mr Tomes to warrant the making of an order for security for costs. In the result, I would refuse the application. SANTAMARIA JA:40 I agree with McLeish JA, for the reasons he gives, that the application for security for costs should be dismissed.41 (Discussion re costs.)THE COURT:Costs42 Timbercorp seeks an order for the costs of the application, on the standard basis until 16 November 2015 and thereafter on an indemnity basis. The ground for that application is an offer it made on 13 November 2015 to give security to Mr Tomes in the amount of $15,000 if his application for security was discontinued. It was submitted that, despite the fact that the offer was made at 5:00pm on a Friday and was only open until 2:00pm on the following Monday, Mr Tomes was in possession of the relevant financial information and should have realised that the application would fail and accepted the offer.43 Mr Tomes submits that it was not until Mr Shepard’s affidavit was produced on 18 November 2015, and its meaning in respect of the lien was adumbrated at the hearing of this matter, that the relevant financial circumstances were fully revealed. On that basis, he submits that he was driven to make the application for security, and seeks an order that Timbercorp pay his costs, alternatively that there be no order as to costs.44 In my opinion there should not be any order in favour of Timbercorp on an indemnity basis. Notwithstanding the delay to which reference has been made on the part of Mr Tomes, the questions which he raised as to Timbercorp’s financial position were not finally addressed until Mr Shepard made clear his intentions in respect of the liquidators’ lien in his affidavit of 18 November 2015, which was foreshadowed in correspondence on 17 November. By then, the offer had already expired. 45 At the same time, however, Mr Tomes was on notice from 11 November that $5.6 million (later revised to $5.3 million) was available to meet Timbercorp’s costs and expenses free of the claims of secured creditors. As indicated, this meant that, prima facie, a costs order in his favour would be met. It therefore cannot be said that he was driven to make the application as a result of the failure of Mr Shepard to explain more clearly his intentions regarding the lien. It would be wrong in the circumstances to deprive Timbercorp of its costs in successfully defending the application.46 Mr Tomes should therefore pay Timbercorp’s costs of the application on the standard basis. - - -

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.