Re: THUNDERDOME RACETIMING AND SCORING PTY LTD and ZEDBACK PTY LTD
And: DORIAN INDUSTRIES PTY LTD; IAN CHATWIN and NORMAN GRANT TILLETT
No. V G280 of 1990
FED No. 423
Practice and Procedure
(1992) 109 ALR 196
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Olney J.(1)
CATCHWORDS
Practice and Procedure - security for costs - interlocutory injunction granted on "usual" undertaking as to damages - injunction later discharged by consent - application withdrawn - assessment of compensation pursuant to undertaking as to damages - application for security for costs by party seeking compensation - power of Court to order security - whether applicant for security is in the position of a respondent.
Federal Court Act 1975, s.56
Federal Court Rules, Order 28; Order 62, Rule 3
High Court Procedure Act 1903 (Repealed)
High Court Rules, 1928 (Repealed), Order XXVIII, Rule 17
King v Commercial Bank of Australia Limited (1920) 28 CLR 289
Lines v Tana Pty Ltd (1987) VR 641
Tomlinson v Land and Finance Corporation (1884-5) 14 QBD 539
Maatschappij Voor Fondsenbezit v Shell Transport and Trading Co. (1923) 2 KBD 166
Stanley-Hill v Kool (1982) 1 NSWLR 460
Bell Wholesale Co. Pty Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 52 ALR 176
HEARING
MELBOURNE
#DATE 19:6:1992
Counsel for the applicants and
cross-respondents: Mr D. Shavin and Mr M. Goldblatt
Solicitors for the applicants and
cross-respondents: Kahn and Clahr
Counsel for the respondents and
cross-claimant: Mr J. Fajgenbaum QC and Mr Lucarelli
Solicitors for the respondents
and cross-claimant: Barton and Partners
ORDER
1. As to the respondents' notice of motion filed 26 March 1992, order
that:
(a) Paragraphs 1 and 2 be dismissed, costs reserved with liberty to apply;
(b) Paragraph 3 be dismissed and any costs of the applicants thrown away by reason of the respondents not pursuing the claim for relief be taxed and paid by the respondents.
2. As to the applicants' notice of motion filed 18 May 1992, by
consent order that:
(a) The respondents have leave to amend paragraphs 37 to 42 and 45 to 46 of the amended points of claim filed on 13 March 1992;
(b) Any costs thrown away by the amendment be paid by the cross-claimant to the cross-respondents;
(c) The costs of the motion be reserved.
3. There be no order pursuant to Order 62 Rule 3(3) as to the time
for the payment of the costs ordered against the respondents on 25 March 1992 and against the cross-claimant pursuant to order 1(b) above.
4. The Court directs that:
(a) The Respondents file and serve amended points of claim on or before 3 July 1992;
(b) Any amended defence to the amended points of claim be filed and served on or before 31 July 1992;
(c) Any reply be filed and served on or before 14 August 1992;
(d) Lists of discoverable documents…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Thunderdome Racetiming and Scoring Pty Ltd v Dorian Industri... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1992] FCA 423
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff, as the party seeking compensation for costs incurred in relation to the injunction, was required to provide security for those costs, as if it were the defendant. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff, in its capacity as the applicant for compensation, occupied the position of a respondent under the relevant rules of court that governed security for costs.
The court held that the plaintiff, in seeking compensation for costs associated with the injunction, was not in the position of a respondent for the purposes of the rules concerning security for costs. The court reasoned that the purpose of the security for costs rule was to protect defendants from being compelled to advance costs to plaintiffs who might be unable to pay them. However, in this case, the plaintiff was not seeking to recover costs from the defendant but was instead seeking compensation for costs already incurred in relation to the injunction. The court concluded that the plaintiff's application for security for costs was therefore inappropriate. The court dismissed the defendant's application for security for costs and ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs associated with the application.
In light of the court's decision, the orders included dismissing the defendant's notice of motion and requiring the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs. The court also directed the defendant to amend its points of claim and set timelines for the exchange of documents and further directions.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. As to the respondents' notice of motion filed 26 March 1992, order
that:
(a) Paragraphs 1 and 2 be dismissed, costs reserved with liberty to apply;
(b) Paragraph 3 be dismissed and any costs of the applicants thrown away by reason of the respondents not pursuing the claim for relief be taxed and paid by the respondents.
2. As to the applicants' notice of motion filed 18 May 1992, by
consent order that:
(a) The respondents have leave to amend paragraphs 37 to 42 and 45 to 46 of the amended points of claim filed on 13 March 1992;
(b) Any costs thrown away by the amendment be paid by the cross-claimant to the cross-respondents;
(c) The costs of the motion be reserved.
3. There be no order pursuant to Order 62 Rule 3(3) as to the time
for the payment of the costs ordered against the respondents on 25 March 1992 and against the cross-claimant pursuant to order 1(b) above.
4. The Court directs that:
(a) The Respondents file and serve amended points of claim on or before 3 July 1992;
(b) Any amended defence to the amended points of claim be filed and served on or before 31 July 1992;
(c) Any reply be filed and served on or before 14 August 1992;
(d) Lists of discoverable documents be exchanged on or before 28 August 1992;
(e) Mutual inspection of documents be given on or before 4 September 1992;
(f) The matter be listed for further directions on 11 September 1992 at 9.30 am.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court through various motions and applications. Initially, the respondent filed a notice of motion on 26 March 1992, which the court dismissed with costs reserved. Subsequently, the applicant filed another notice of motion on 18 May 1992, which was granted by consent order. This order allowed the respondent to amend certain paragraphs of their amended points of claim, with costs to be borne by the cross-claimant. The court also set further procedural directions for the exchange of documents, inspection, and further hearings. The matter did not reach a final hearing in this instance.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court has the power to order security for costs in this case.
2. Whether the applicant for security is in the position of a respondent.
3. How to assess the compensation pursuant to the undertaking as to damages.
Held
1. The court held that it has the power to order security for costs in this case. The application for security for costs was dismissed, but the court reserved its costs with liberty to apply.
2. The court held that the applicant for security is not in the position of a respondent in this case. The applicant for security is the party seeking compensation pursuant to the undertaking as to damages.
3. The court held that the compensation pursuant to the undertaking as to damages should be assessed in accordance with the terms of the undertaking. The court ordered the respondents to file and serve amended points of claim, and set out a timetable for the exchange of documents and further directions.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the issue of whether it had the power to order security for costs. The court noted that it had previously granted an interlocutory injunction on the "usual" undertaking as to damages, and that the injunction had later been discharged by consent. The application for security for costs had been withdrawn, and the court found that it had the power to order security for costs in this case. The court also noted that the applicant for security was not in the position of a respondent, as the applicant was the party seeking compensation pursuant to the undertaking as to damages.
The court then turned to the issue of how to assess the compensation pursuant to the undertaking as to damages. The court noted that the undertaking had specified the terms for the assessment of compensation, and that the court should follow those terms. The court ordered the respondents to file and serve amended points of claim, and set out a timetable for the exchange of documents and further directions. The court found that the binding legal principle established by this decision was that the terms of the undertaking as to damages should be followed in assessing compensation, and that the court has the power to order security for costs in appropriate circumstances.