CITATION: THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- KNOCK [2020] WASC 246
CORAM: DERRICK J
HEARD: 15 - 18 JUNE 2020
DELIVERED : 2 JULY 2020
FILE NO/S: INS 96 of 2019
BETWEEN: THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Prosecution
AND
SARAH ANNE KNOCK
Accused
Catchwords:
Criminal law - Trial by judge alone - Murder - Insanity - Whether accused was mentally impaired - Whether accused lacked capacity to control actions - Whether accused lacked the capacity to know that she ought not to do the act - Whether the accused was intentionally intoxicated - Construction of s 28(1) and s 28(2) of the Criminal Code (WA)
The accused is charged on an indictment dated 31 January 2020 that on or about 5 November 2018 at Armadale she murdered Jennifer Ruth Lanciano (the deceased). The deceased was the accused's aunty.
On 6 March 2020 Corboy J made an order that the accused be tried by judge alone pursuant to s 118 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA) (CPA).
The accused's trial took place before me on 15 ‑ 18 June 2020.
At the commencement of the trial the accused was arraigned on the charge and entered a plea…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of Western Australia v Knock and more:
The State of Western Australia brought a prosecution against the accused, who was charged with the murder of her aunt, the deceased. The accused was tried by a judge alone in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the accused was exempt from criminal responsibility for the murder under section 28(1) or section 28(2) of the Criminal Code (WA), due to mental impairment or intentional intoxication. The court had to determine whether the accused was mentally impaired at the time of the offence, whether she lacked the capacity to control her actions or know that she ought not to do the act, and whether she was intentionally intoxicated.
The court considered evidence from psychiatrists and psychologists who diagnosed the accused with various mental illnesses, including borderline personality disorder, bipolar disorder, and depression. The court found that the accused was indeed mentally impaired at the time of the offence, but that this did not necessarily exempt her from criminal responsibility. The court also considered whether the accused intentionally intoxicated herself, but found that there was insufficient evidence to support this conclusion. Ultimately, the court found that the accused was not exempt from criminal responsibility for the murder under section 28(1) or section 28(2) of the Criminal Code (WA), and that she was guilty of murder.
The court found the accused guilty of murder and sentenced her to life in prison with a non-parole period of 25 years. The court considered the accused's mental health issues and history of substance abuse in imposing the sentence, but ultimately found that the gravity of the offence warranted a lengthy period of incarceration. The court also ordered that the accused be subject to a hospital order under the Mental Health Act (WA), to be treated for her mental illnesses while in prison.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
The statement of agreed facts[3] (omitting footnoted references to materials that form the basis of a number of the asserted facts) is in the following terms:[3] Exhibit 3.BACKGROUND1.[The accused] is the niece of [the deceased].2.The accused's mother, Elizabeth Whittaker (nee Knock), is the sister of the deceased.3.At the time of her death the deceased was married to Enzo Lanciano.4.Enzo Lanciano and the deceased lived at 25 Crawley Road in Armadale.5.Enzo Lanciano and the deceased are and were Jehovah's witnesses.6.Mr Lanciano's elderly father, Vincenzo Lanciano, lived next door at 23 Crawley Road, Armadale.7.Vincenzo Lanciano was sometimes referred to as 'Mr Le' or 'Mr L'.8.For medical reasons, including a minor stroke in 2012 and suffering cancer, Mr Vincenzo Lanciano required constant care including the deceased and others staying overnight at his house to assist with his ongoing care.9.The deceased acted as Mr Vincenzo Lanciano's primary carer.10.The accused stayed with Enzo Lanciano and the deceased at 25 Crawley Road for a period of time in approximately 2017.11.About March 2018 the accused left Perth and travelled to Carnarvon where she remained until her return to Perth in late October 2018.12.The accused is the mother of 8 children, none of whom resided with her during 2017 and 2018.13.In 2018 the accused's four youngest children were living with a family in Narrogin.14.In 2018 the accused's mother lived on her daughter's farm between Brookton and Pingelly.EVENTS OF 25 OCTOBER 2018 TO 2 NOVEMBER 201815.On 25 October 2018, after arriving in Perth from Carnarvon, the accused went to the deceased's home in Armadale.16.The accused was looking for a place to stay and Mr Lanciano and the deceased agreed that the accused could stay with them.17.Mr Lanciano and the deceased also had another niece, Tianii Knock, living with them at the time.18.The accused has a history of mental illness.19.The deceased encouraged and tried to get the accused to see a doctor during the time that the accused was staying with the deceased and Mr Lanciano.20.The accused refused to do so, with the exception of seeing a GP on one occasion.21.The accused repeatedly requested that the deceased take her to Brookton so that she could see her mother, or alternatively to take the accused to Brookton Highway on the outskirts of the metropolitan area to enable the accused to hitchhike to Brookton.22.The accused's repeated requests of the deceased to take her to see her mother resulted in arguments between the accused and the deceased, such as that recorded on the mobile phone of Tianii Knock.SATURDAY 3 NOVEMBER 201823.On 3 November 2018 the accused argued with the deceased about being permitted to go in the car with the deceased.24.The deceased and the accused had an argument with the accused wanting to go home to see her mother.25.The deceased refused to give the accused a lift to see her mother.26.Extracts of this conversation were recorded by Tianii Knock on her mobile phone.SUNDAY 4 NOVEMBER 201827.On Sunday 4 November 2018, apart from attending a church meeting, the deceased spent the day at both 23 and 25 Crawley Road, Armadale.28.Enzo Lanciano spent most of the day at home doing renovations, but did visit his father's residence from time to time during the day.29.The accused was at 25 Crawley Road in the morning but left and didn't return until the afternoon. Upon her return she spent a short period of time at 25 Crawley Road, before going next door and staying there.30.During the afternoon Giovanna Suckling visited her father, Vincenzo Lanciano, at 23 Crawley Road, Armadale.31.Giovanna Suckling had travelled from Narrogin to Armadale together with Ms Suckling's uncle, Antonio Lanciano, and his partner, Achara Lanciano.32.Ms Suckling is the sister of Enzo Lanciano and is the sister‑in‑law of the deceased.33.The accused arrived at 23 Crawley Road whilst Ms Suckling and the others were there.34.During the course of the afternoon the accused asked Ms Suckling for a lift to Narrogin to see her kids but this was declined.THE EVENING OF SUNDAY 4 NOVEMBER 201835.On the night of Sunday 4 November 2018 the deceased took responsibility for the care of Vincenzo Lanciano.36.This meant that the deceased slept in Vincenzo Lanciano's house at 23 Crawley Road on that evening.37.Mr Enzo Lanciano went to his father's house around 6.30 pm to have dinner with the deceased and his father. Enzo Lanciano did not see the accused at that time.38.Tianii Knock received a text message from the deceased's mobile phone at 6.59 pm on 4 November 2018 which stated: 'Sarah has past out she is fast asleep at Mr Le'.39.After dinner Enzo Lanciano, his father and the deceased watched TV before Enzo Lanciano left for work at approximately 9 pm.40.Enzo Lanciano's work commitments that evening were between 9 pm and 11 pm.41.Enzo Lanciano finished work at about 11.00 pm, after which he returned to his home at 25 Crawley Road in Armadale.42.Enzo Lanciano parked his vehicle in the carport at 25 Crawley Road next to the deceased's Holden Commodore and went to bed in the master bedroom.MONDAY 5 NOVEMBER 201843.After being woken by the sound of a car horn, Enzo Lanciano found his wife's body in a bedroom at 23 Crawley Road, Armadale.44.Mr Lanciano called 000 and informed the operator that his wife had been murdered.45.The time of the 000 call was 4.41 am on 5 November 2018.POLICE AND AMBULANCE ATTENDANCE AT THE SCENE46.Police were tasked to attend 23 Crawley Road Armadale at 4.44 am.47.Police arrived at the scene at 4.48 am.48.The sun had just begun to rise.49.The accused had left the premises by the time police arrived.50.Four police officers entered the house at 23 Crawley Road where they observed Enzo Lanciano performing CPR on the deceased.51.Police moved the deceased from the bed to the floor where they took over CPR from Enzo Lanciano until paramedics arrived from St John's Ambulance and took over the CPR.52.Police established a Protected Forensic Area at 4.52 am; the outer boundary of that cordon was extended at 5.00 am.53.At 5.15 am the deceased was moved onto a stretcher and placed onto a trolley and into an ambulance.54.The deceased was taken by ambulance to Armadale Hospital where she was put on life support.55.The deceased never recovered and life extinct was declared at 6.00 am on 6 November 2018.ARREST OF THE ACCUSED56.The accused was arrested by police walking north along Albany Highway at about 5.30 am on 5 November 2018.57.She was taken to Armadale Police Station but was non‑compliant and difficult to manage.58.CCTV footage from Armadale Police Station shows that the accused repeatedly said to the police 'I'm scared, I'm scared'.59.The accused was transferred from Armadale Police Station to Perth Watch House.60.Police were unsuccessful in attempting to obtain a blood sample from the accused. The nursing notes noted that the accused had collapsed veins and her behaviour meant that it was not possible for a blood sample to be taken from her.61.She refused to participate in a police interview.ADMISSION TO THE FRANKLAND CENTRE62.The accused appeared in Perth Magistrates Court on 6 November 2018 and a hospital order was imposed.63.The accused was transported to the Frankland Centre where she has remained ever since.POST MORTEM EXAMINATION - CAUSE OF DEATH64.A post mortem examination was performed by Dr Jodi White at the State Mortuary on 8 November 2018.65.The cause of death was determined to be hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy due to neck compression.66.In Dr White's opinion the deceased's death was caused by manual strangulation (use of hands).