The OWNERS-UNIT Plan 14971 v Territory Planning Authority (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

THE OWNERS-UNIT PLAN 14971 V TERRITORY PLANNING AUTHORITY (Administrative Review) [2025] ACAT 43

AT 129/2024

Catchwords:               ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – Controlled activity order under S424 Planning Act 2023 – failing comply with Crown lease – undertaking development without approval – units plan – direction to Owners Corporation to provide unrestricted public access to basement car parks of mixed use building complex

Development approval under S197 of Planning and Development Act 2007 amending development approval under S162 – approved drawing showing parking spaces designated as "Public" – no provision for mandatory visitor parking for residential use as required by Codes
Construction of development approvals and consents – public character restricting consideration of other documents – proper approach to construction of approved drawing – whether parking spaces designated as “Public” accessible by members of the public other than visitors – non-compliance with Codes precludes approval under S119 (1) Planning and Development Act – parking spaces for visitors only – controlled activity order set aside

List of Legislation: ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008

Planning and Development Act 2007
Planning Act 2023
Unit Titles Act 2001
Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011

List of Cases:              Allandale Blue Metal v Roads and Maritime Services [2013] NSWCA 103

Bowler v Hilda P/L (in liq) [2001] FCA 342

Haridemos and ACTPLA [2012] ACAT 74
Hecar Investments No 6 P/L v Lake Macquarie MC (1984) 53 LGRA 322
Hunter Industrial Rental Equipment P/L v Dungog SC [2019] NSWCA 147
Modog v North Sydney City Council NSWLEC 1160
Pselletes v Randwick CC [2009] NSWCA 262
Springrange P/L v ACTPA [2010] ACTCA 17
Warehouse Group (Australia) Pty Ltd v Woolworths Ltd [2003] NSWCA 270

Westfield Management Ltd v Perpetual Trustee Co Ltd [2006] NSWCA 425

List of Text /Papers:   Herzfeld and Prince, Interpretation (Lawbook, 3rd ed, 2024)

Tribunal:Senior Member R Arthur

Date of Orders:  21 March 2025

Date of Reasons for Decision:      11 June 2025

Date of Publication:  20 June 2025

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AT 129/2024

BETWEEN:

THE OWNERS-UNIT PLAN 14971

Applicant

AND:

TERRITORY PLANNING AUTHORITY

First Respondent

NG LANDHOLDINGS NO. 15 PTY LTD

Party Joined

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member R Arthur

DATE:21 March 2025

CORRECTED ORDER

The decision under review is the decision of the Respondent, the Territory Planning Authority, made on 24 October 2024 to issue to the Applicant, The Owners - Units Plan 14791, a controlled activity order under S 427 of the Planning Act 2023 ("the Act") directing the Applicant to:

  1. Provide unrestricted public access to the basement car parks of Blocks 3 & 4 Section 7 Reid, known as 'Metropol'. This is to comply with Form 4, clause 3 (f), and Form 5, clause 3 (j) of Units Plan Number 14791, and in accordance with the approved plans of Development Application (DA) number 201833533/197M.Unrestricted public access means the public must be able to enter and exit the basement car park using the building's lift and entrances, without needing a security…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The OWNERS-UNIT Plan 14971 v Territory Planning Authority (A... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ACAT 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of The OWNERS-UNIT Plan 14971 v Territory Planning Authority (Administrative Review) involved a dispute concerning the interpretation and compliance of a Controlled Activity Order (CAO) issued by the Territory Planning Authority. The Order required unrestricted public access to basement car parks. The applicant, represented by John Bird, sought a review of the CAO, while the Authority, represented by John Larkings, defended the CAO. NG 15, represented by Andrew Greinke, also participated in the proceedings.

The primary legal issue before the court was the interpretation of the CAO and the approved plans associated with the development application, specifically whether the CAO's requirement for unrestricted public access to the basement car parks was valid and enforceable under the relevant planning legislation. The court had to determine if the CAO was voidable due to its inconsistency with the approved plans and the planning codes.

The court found that the CAO was based on a misinterpretation of the approved plans and the planning codes. The court held that the subjective intentions of the decision-maker were irrelevant and that the approval authority lacked the power to approve a proposal that was not code-compliant. The court concluded that the CAO should be set aside as it was based on grounds that did not exist, and that the signs indicating restricted access to the basement car park should remain in place as they served an important purpose in discouraging unauthorized access.

The court ordered the CAO to be set aside, effectively reversing its effect. The court also considered the implications of this decision on the approved plans and the requirement for visitor parking spaces. The court held that the proper construction of the plans was objective and not dependent on the subjective opinion of the decision-maker or a prospective purchaser. The court found that the approved plans and the CAO were inconsistent, and that the CAO should be set aside to ensure compliance with the planning codes.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The matter was heard over two days. The OC was represented by John Bird of counsel, the Authority was represented by John Larkings of counsel, and NG 15 was represented by Andrew Greinke of counsel.The evidence The applicant relied on:(a)Its Application to the Tribunal for review with 8 attachments[21](b)Witness Statement of Rachel Smith dated 24 February 2025[22](c)Bundle of evidence lodged in the Tribunal on 26 February 2025[23](d)Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design Report, May 2018[24](e)Development Approval number 201833533S197 H dated 12 September 2019[25][21] Exhibit A1[22] Exhibit A2[23] Exhibit A3[24] Exhibit A4[25] Exhibit A5 The Authority relied on:(a)Tribunal Documents, with index to enlarged versions of photos.(b)Supplementary Tribunal Documents (10 documents).(c)Bundle of documents in reply.[26](d)Witness statement of Paul Wang dated.[27](e)Witness statement of Richard Davies dated.[28][26] Exhibit R1[27] Exhibit R2[28] Exhibit R3 NG 15 relied on:(a)Metropol Carpark Proposal.[29] (b)Each of the documents relied on was given a provisional exhibit number, but ultimately were admitted into evidence without objection. The Tribunal Documents were accepted into evidence at the outset.(c)Witnesses Smith and Davies gave oral evidence and were cross-examined.The issue[29] Exhibit PJ1 The CAO required the OC to:“[p]rovide unrestricted public access to the basement car parks… to comply with Form 4, clause 3 (f), and Form 5, clause 3 (J) of Units Plan Number 14791, and in accordance with the approved plans of Development Application (DA) number 201833533/197M”. The architectural drawing DA 099 was issued in a number of revised versions, the last of which – Revision 8 – was dated 12 May 2021 and accompanied development application No 20133533S197M. It was approved on 24 May 2021.. It consisted of a single page diagram showing the layout of car spaces in Basement Level 1 separated by access aisles and included the locations of storage cages and the location of lifts, stairs, and other features of the basement. Each of the car spaces and storage cages was coloured. Drawing DA099 (Revn 8) is reproduced in full at Appendix A to these reasons. In the top right corner of the page were two tables: Beside the tables was a stamp: Sheet 38 of units plan 14791[30] shows the location of Unit 563 as corresponding with the six car spaces coloured blue shown in the top left corner of drawing DA 099. That Sheet and Sheet 39 show the locations of 26 unit subsidiaries annexed to Unit 563 as corresponding with the remainder of the car spaces coloured blue on the drawing. The blue coloured spaces total 132.[30] Tribunal Documents 1451 The storage cages are shown on Sheets 37, 38 and 39 as unit subsidiaries annexed to various residential units. The remainder of Basement Level 1 including the access aisles, the ramps mechanical facilities, lifts, stairs and so on are common property under the control, management and administration of the OC. Resolution of the dispute between the parties turns, initially, on the significance of DA 099 and its status as an approved plan.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant and Mr Davies also referred to other indications throughout the assessment process which indicated the thinking of the various assessment officers consistent with the expectation that visitor parking spaces were required. In my view those pieces of the evidence go to the intention of the approval authority and cannot be taken into account in determining what the words of the approval mean, not what the maker of the words intended them to mean. The subjective intention of the decision-maker is not relevant.Voidable decision Counsel for NG 15 suggested, at various points[65] associated with the submission that ‘public’ should be given its ordinary meaning, that the question whether the approval was given in error was not for this tribunal to determine. I have not accepted that submission because it does not give proper effect to the operation of section 119(2). The Authority does not have power to approve a proposal which is not code-compliant, and this Tribunal on merits review is equally unable to do so. It can, however, construe the terms so as to ensure that they are within power whether on merits review of the approval itself or, as in these proceedings, when the validity of the approval is in question.Effect on the CAO[65] In particular at Transcript of proceedings dated 13 March 2025, page 141 line 24 to page 142 line 10 The implications of this finding for the controlled activity order is that the grounds on which it is based have been shown not to exist. Consequently, the only members of the public who are entitled to enter and exit the basement car park using the building's lift and entrances, without needing a security tag or using the driveway entrances/exits of the basement car park, are those members who also have the visitor characteristics which I have set out above. The arrangements which the CAO sought to disturb presently enable such visitors access by means of the intercom system, meeting the requirements of MUHDC Rule 83 a) – in that access for visitors to parking is located outside of the security barriers at the lifts. Limb b) of Rule 83 is an alternative which does not come into play if limb a) of the criterion are met. The arrangement certainly meets Criterion 83. Accordingly, the preferable if not correct decision is to set the controlled activity order aside, and I will make an order to that effect. I am conscious that this will also reverse the effect of the order to remove the signs. Although mentioned at various times by the Tribunal and the parties, whether there was in fact dispute about the signs was left open at the end of the day. However, dispute or not, I consider it appropriate for the signs to remain in place. As I understand it they are on common property, and are unobtrusive, but they serve an important purpose in dissuading members of the public other than visitors from entering the basement. In particular, it seems that there is no suggestion that the signs themselves require development approval.[66]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The proper construction is as objectively established above. It is not dependent on the subjective opinion of the decision-maker or a prospective purchaser. It can be discerned from consideration of DA 099 (and its counterparts) only – if that is the only document permissible to consider for the purposes of the lease.Consideration of further documents Although I think it is not necessary to look at any further material beyond DA 099 in order to reach the conclusion I have made, doing so would simply confirm that conclusion. The qualification on the stamp – that the approval is in respect of nominated amendments only – necessarily entails an understanding of what amendments were nominated requiring investigation of the underlying notice of decision and the application. It is clear from the notice of decision alone that what was sought (relevantly to parking) was approval for “changes to storage and car park allocations”. That connotes a reallocation of some spaces from one category to another, but not the allocation of all spaces in one category to a new category which is not one or other of the other existing categories. Even if the specific changes could not be identified (given the observations in evidence that the “clouding” method of identifying changes to drawings was not entirely reliable) a counting of the spaces in each category would confirm that the code requirements for each category had been satisfactorily met. Further, since this controversy involves both the applicant NG 15 for approval and the approval authority, it would be appropriate to go behind the approval decision and to have regard to the communications between the delegate of the authority and the representatives of NG 15[63] as to the reason why clarification of the number of visitor spaces was sought, as was done in Pselletes,[64] to show that the balcony shown on the approved plan had in fact been withdrawn from the application before approval.[63] Referred to during cross-examination of Mr Davies, transcript of proceedings dated 13 March 2025 at page 83 lines 46-47, page 84 lines 1-5[64] See above The applicant and Mr Davies also referred to other indications throughout the assessment process which indicated the thinking of the various assessment officers consistent with the expectation that visitor parking spaces were required. In my view those pieces of the evidence go to the intention of the approval authority and cannot be taken into account in determining what the words of the approval mean, not what the maker of the words intended them to mean. The subjective intention of the decision-maker is not relevant.Voidable decision Counsel for NG 15 suggested, at various points[65] associated with the submission that ‘public’ should be given its ordinary meaning, that the question whether the approval was given in error was not for this tribunal to determine. I have not accepted that submission because it does not give proper effect to the operation of section 119(2). The Authority does not have power to approve a proposal which is not code-compliant, and this Tribunal on merits review is equally unable to do so. It can, however, construe the terms so as to ensure that they are within power whether on merits review of the approval itself or, as in these proceedings, when the validity of the approval is in question.Effect on the CAO[65] In particular at Transcript of proceedings dated 13 March 2025, page 141 line 24 to page 142 line 10