Haridemos & Ors & Act Planning and Land Authority; (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

HARIDEMOS AND ORS & ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY

(Administrative Review) [2012] ACAT 74

AT 12/42

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW: Controlled Activity Order – failure of respondent to issue Controlled Activity Order in terms sought by applicants – whether Bonner Shops Pty Ltd is in breach of a clause in its Crown lease – whether Woolworths supermarket exceeds the limit on area of a supermarket specified in clause 3(c) of Crown lease - whether the Woolworths liquor store is part of the supermarket – whether the areas of the plant rooms, office, stairway to first floor and loading area are to be attributed to the supermarket –interpretation of registered Crown leases – distinction between “use” and “purpose” – purpose of ancillary or subordinate uses - discretion available in deciding whether or not to make a Controlled Activity Order –whether Controlled Activity Order would serve any planning  purpose or public interest – whether making Controlled Activity Order would be a proportionate response

List of legislation:     Building Act 2004

Planning and Development Act 2007

, ss.339, 350, 351, 360,
361 & 408, and Part 11.3


List of Regulations: Territory Plan 2008

CZ4 Local Centre Zone Development Table

Parking and Vehicular Access General Code

List of Cases:            Argos Pty Ltd v Minister for the Environment and Sustainable Development [2012] ACTSC 102

Authentic Systems Pty Ltd & Department of Environment and Planning [1993] ACTAAT 47

Bogiatzis & Ors and Minister for Urban Services& Anor [2002] ACTAAT 21
Canberra Cruises & Tours v Minister for Urban Services [1999] ACTAAT 14

Chamwell Pty v Strathfield Council (2007) 151 LGERA 400
Council of the City of Newcastle v Royal Newcastle Hospital (1957) 96 CLR 493
Gakhar and ACTPLA [2003] ACTAAT 55
Jewel Food Stores v Minister for the Environment, Land and Planning (1995) 122 FLR 269
Lunardello & Minister for Urban Services [2001] ACTAAT 27

Nb and Nb Marsh Pty Ltd and Minister for Planning [2003] ACTAAT 11
Peter Kohlsdorf Golf Distributors Pty Ltd v Liangis Investments Pty Ltd & Anor [2003] ACTAAT 29

Shire of Perth v O’Keefe [1964] HCA 37;
Springrange Pty Ltd v ACTPLA [2010] ACTCA 17
Foodbarn Pty Limited v Solicitor General (1975) 32 LGRA 157

Warringah Shire Council v Raffles [1979] 2 NSWLR 299

Young Men’s Christian Association Inc & ACT Planning and Land Authority [2011] ACAT 78

Texts & Papers:        Building Code of Australia 2009
National Capital Plan

Report of the Legislative Assembly Select Committee on ACT Supermarket Competition Policy (24 August 2012)

Tribunal:                  Dr Don McMichael , Presiding Member

Mr Graeme Trickett, Senior Member

Date of Orders:  1 November 2012
Date of Reasons for Decision:         1 November 2012

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AT 12/42

BETWEEN:   CHRISTOPHER HARIDEMOS

First Applicant

ALEX VIZADIS

Second Applicant

AND: ACT PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Dr Don McMichael,  Presiding Member
  Mr Graeme Trickett,  Senior Member

DATE:  1 November 2012

ORDER

1.

The Tribunal orders that the decision under review is confirmed.




………………………………..

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Haridemos & Ors & Act Planning and Land Authority; (Administ... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] ACAT 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants sought to have the Crown Approval Order (CAO) varied by including a requirement that the Crown lease provision that the supermarket be limited to 1,500m2 Gross Floor Area (GFA) be complied with. They argued that the supermarket exceeded 1500 m2 in area and that the CAO should be varied accordingly. The respondent argued that the supermarket was within the specified area and that the CAO should not be varied.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the supermarket exceeded 1500 m2 in area and if so, whether the respondent’s CAO should be varied as sought. The Tribunal found that there had been a relatively small breach of the lease condition, but that the lack of clarity in the lease condition meant that making such an order would be a disproportionate response. The Tribunal also concluded that given the present state of flux and uncertainty about the policy that will ultimately be adopted by Government in relation to supermarket size in the ACT, there was no significant planning purpose that would be served by making the order sought by the applicants, nor was there any overriding public interest that would be served by doing so.

The Tribunal decided that the decision under review should be confirmed. The applicants’ request to vary the CAO was denied. The Tribunal found that there had been a relatively small breach of the lease condition, but that the lack of clarity in the lease condition meant that making such an order would be a disproportionate response. The Tribunal also concluded that given the present state of flux and uncertainty about the policy that will ultimately be adopted by Government in relation to supermarket size in the ACT, there was no significant planning purpose that would be served by making the order sought by the applicants, nor was there any overriding public interest that would be served by doing so.

The Tribunal orders that the decision under review is confirmed. The applicants’ request to vary the CAO is denied.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Tribunal orders that the decision under review is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants sought to have the CAO varied by including a requirement that the Crown lease provision that the supermarket be limited to 1,500m2 GFA be complied with. The issues before the Tribunal were whether or not the “supermarket” exceeded 1500 m2 in area and if so, whether the respondent’s CAO should be varied as sought.Background In January 2010, Woolworths Ltd wrote to Mr D Nikias of Nikias Properties offering to enter into an agreement to lease, for the purposes of a supermarket, portion of commercial premises to be built in Bonner. The offer included reference to the lease area being based on what was described as “a standard 2000 supermarket and liquor building” of approximately 1900m2 lettable area, conforming to the Woolworths Design Brief. Lettable area was defined to exclude any licensed area, plant room, switch room, loading dock, loading bay area, truck standing apron or similar area but would include 200m2 for office and amenities. On 29 February 2010, agreement to enter into a lease “for a 1900m2 supermarket” at Bonner shops was sought by Woolworths Regional Manager from Woolworths Property Committee, which was given on 16 March 2010. An Agreement for Lease was signed soon afterwards, apparently on 19 March 2010 by Woolworths representative Peter J Horton, though the copy available to the Tribunal is not signed by a representative of Bonner Shops Pty Ltd. The Agreement included the following Recitals:A.The Landlord may become the Crown lessee of the Land.B.Subject to becoming the Crown lessee of the Land, the Landlord proposes to undertake the Landlord’s Works on the Land.C.The Landlord has agreed to grant and the Tenant has agreed to take the Lease of the Premises, subject to the terms and conditions in this deed. The Agreement included a Reference Schedule which identified among other things the Approximate Lettable Areas as being(a)Supermarket premises: 1,500m2 lettable area(b)Liquor premises: 200m2 lettable area(c)Office premises: 200m2 lettable areaThe Agreement was accompanied by a number of documents described as Lease Annexures including three identified as “Centre Based Lease Conditions Gross Lease” for each of Standard Supermarket, Standard Liquor and Standard Office. In each case the leases are described as an “interdependent lease” of each of the interdependent premises which in turn are identified as particular areas or shops on the subleasing plan for the subject land. The subject land was acquired by Bonner Shops Pty Ltd. under a Crown lease dated 30 April 2010, which was registered on 9 July 2010. DA201018526 was lodged on 24 December 2010 and an amended application was lodged on 24 February 2011. The amended DA was approved with conditions on 11 March 2011 and presumably the shops were built soon thereafter. The Bonner shops were to have been constructed in accordance with plans certified by Mr Graham Moss (T441-T446). As will be discussed later, there were some minor differences between the plans certified by Mr Moss and the building as built. The shops comprise a rectangular mainly one storey building but with a small second floor at its southern end, oriented north-south between Mabo Boulevard and Bill Ferguson Circuit, Bonner. There is a covered loading area (generally identified in the plans as a Loading Dock) at its southern end.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal concludes that given the present state of flux and uncertainty about the policy that will ultimately be adopted by Government in relation to supermarket size in the ACT, there is no significant planning purpose that would be served by making the order sought by the applicants, nor is there any over-riding public interest that would be served by doing so. We also consider that despite finding that there has been a relatively small breach of a lease condition, to make such an order would be a disproportionate response, given the lack of clarity in the lease condition in question.Decision The decision under review is confirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established