SZNNE v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZNNE v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2010] FCA 194

Citation: SZNNE v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2010] FCA 194
Appeal from: [2009] FMCA 1271
Parties: SZNNE and SZNNF v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number: NSD10 of 2010
Judge: KATZMANN J
Date of judgment: 9 March 2010
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36(2), 48B, 91R, 417, 425(1), 429A, 474, 476(1)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 24(1), 25(1AA), 27, 43(3)(d)
Federal Court Rules O 62, r 40C
Cases cited: Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172 cited
Branir v Owston Nominees (No 2) (2001) 117 FCR 424 cited
Chan Yee Kin v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379 cited
Coulton v Holcombe (1986) 162 CLR 1 cited
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia (2001) 205 CLR 507 cited
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI [2009] HCA 39, (2009) 259 ALR 429
Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth (2003) 211 CLR 476 cited
SZJTK v Minister of Citizenship & Citizenship [2008] FCA 1712 followed
VUAX v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 158 cited
Date of hearing: 3 March 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 55
The first appellant appeared in person with the assistance of an interpreter
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Sparke Helmore

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD10 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZNNE
First Appellant

SZNNF
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

KATZMANN J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 MARCH 2010

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is dismissed.

2.The appellants pay the first respondent’s costs, fixed in the sum of $2,175.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD10 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZNNE
First Appellant

SZNNF
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

KATZMANN J

DATE:

9 MARCH 2010

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The two appellants are a married couple from Gujarat in India.  Without meaning any disrespect, where it is necessary for me to distinguish between them in these reasons I shall refer to them as the husband and the wife.  They are aggrieved by a decision denying them protection (class XA) visas.  The decision was first made by a delegate of the first respondent (Minister), then affirmed on review by the Refugee Review Tribunal (Tribunal).  On 18 December 2009 a Federal Magistrate dismissed their applications for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZNNE v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 194
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, a married couple from Gujarat, India, appealed against the refusal of their applications for a protection (class XA) visa. They claimed persecution due to the husband’s membership in the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) and alleged attacks on him by Muslim extremists. The Federal Magistrate dismissed their applications for judicial review, which they now appeal. The central legal issue was whether the appellants met the statutory criteria for a protection visa under the Migration Act, specifically whether the husband had a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons including his membership in the VHP. The court examined the consistency and credibility of the husband’s claims and the evidence presented to support them.

The court found that the husband’s claims were inconsistent and lacked credibility. Key points of inconsistency included discrepancies in the husband's accounts of his living situation, his contact with his children, and his experiences with the police. The Tribunal and the delegate had questioned the husband on these points, noting that his responses were often contradictory or lacking in detail. The court upheld the delegate’s and the Tribunal’s findings that the husband’s claims were not credible. Given these inconsistencies and the husband’s failure to provide convincing evidence, the court concluded that the appellants did not meet the criteria for a protection visa.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent’s costs in the sum of $2,175. The decision emphasized the importance of consistency and credibility in refugee claims, highlighting that the appellants’ claims did not meet the required standard for a protection visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the first respondent’s costs, fixed in the sum of $2,175.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The two appellants are a married couple from Gujarat in India. Without meaning any disrespect, where it is necessary for me to distinguish between them in these reasons I shall refer to them as the husband and the wife. They are aggrieved by a decision denying them protection (class XA) visas. The decision was first made by a delegate of the first respondent (Minister), then affirmed on review by the Refugee Review Tribunal (Tribunal). On 18 December 2009 a Federal Magistrate dismissed their applications for judicial review. This is an appeal from that decision.Background The appellants arrived in Australia on 21 August 2008. On 30 September 2008 they lodged their applications with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. On 20 December 2008 a delegate of the Minister refused the applications. On 15 January 2009 the appellants applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision. In his application for a protection visa, which the document records him completing (in English) without assistance, the husband claimed that he became a member of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) in 1992, and that in December 1992 he had to protect his area from “Muslim mobs” when the Babri Masjid (mosque) at Ayodhy (sic) was demolished. He alleged that since then Islamic fundamentalists – inspired by Pakistan’s Inter Service Intelligence directorate (sic) - increased communal violence in Gujarat. He further claimed that, as a member of the VHP, he was involved in its community activities, and that work brought him to the attention of Muslim extremists. He also reported that in February 2002 “Muslim mobs” torched two rail cars carrying VHP activists in Godhra in Gujarat and asserted that they burned down his house and place of business. He advised that he was arrested and interrogated upon suspicion that he was a Hindu radical and arrested again on 1 February 2008 after a demonstration. He expressed the fear that, as a member of the VHP, he was at risk of detention and torture and would not be able to cope with aggressive interrogation techniques, let alone torture, because of his fragile state of mind. He claimed that the continuing violence and attacks on him and the police aggression prompted him to seek asylum in Australia. The wife relied on her husband’s claims to support her application. Sections 36(2), 91R(1) and 91R(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Migration Act) set out the qualifications for a protection visa. In short, the husband was required to prove that:(a)he had a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion;(b)he was unable or, owing to such fear, unwilling to avail himself of the protection of his own country;(c)the reason(s) is(are) the essential and significant reason(s) for the persecution;(d)the persecution involves serious harm to him; and (e)the persecution involves systematic and discriminatory conduct. “Serious harm” is defined in s 91R(2) to include (amongst other things) a threat to the person’s life or liberty. A fear is “well-founded” when there is a real substantial basis for it: Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559 at 572. There is, however, no balance of probabilities test. What an applicant must show is that the chance of persecution is neither remote nor far-fetched: Chan Yee Kin v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Minister’s delegate interviewed the husband by telephone with the assistance of an interpreter in the Gujarati language. He did not consider him truthful and was not satisfied that he had been a member of the VHP since 1992 or that he feared being harmed in India because of his association with the group. He referred to a number of differences between the account that appeared in his visa application and the account given at the interview, the husband’s failure to answer “very basic questions” about the formation and leadership of the group of which he claimed to be a member for 16 years, his “very limited and simplistic” explanation of the objectives of the organisation and his inability to supply “any level of details” about the activities in which he purported to have been engaged. He queried, too, his claim that he feared harm in India because of his involvement with the VHP, having regard to the fact that he said that he had lived at the same address in Gujarat all his life and continued to operate his agricultural business right up until the time he left India. He also felt that, if he genuinely feared harm, he would have tried to leave India much sooner than he did, noting that he had held a valid passport since 2006. Finally, and in any event, he saw no reason why he could not have moved to another part of India.The Tribunal’s decision The Tribunal arrived at the same conclusion for similar reasons. It found that the husband (who, with his wife, gave evidence by video link through a Gujarati interpreter) was not a credible witness on some key aspects of his claims. It could not be satisfied that he left India because of a fear of persecution as he asserted in his application and his evidence before the Tribunal, concluded that the appellants did not meet the statutory criteria for the grant of a protection visa and, accordingly, affirmed the decision under review. The Tribunal accepted that there had been clashes and riots between Muslims and Hindus in India. However, it was not satisfied of the truth of any of the husband’s personal claims. It noted that there were numerous inconsistencies between the accounts he had given in his application for a protection visa, what he had told the Departmental delegate in the interview and his oral evidence before the Tribunal. Those inconsistencies included:(a)Stating in his application that his house had burned down in 2002 and he was forced to leave his home, yet telling the delegate that he had lived at the same address all his life and had continued his farming business until he left India in 2008;(b)Listing the birth dates of his two sons in his application but telling the Tribunal that he did not know how old his children were as he was not educated;(c)Advising the delegate that he had had no contact with his children after his home was burned down in 2002 when the birth date of the youngest son was listed in his application as 7 July 2004 and then, after the delegate reminded him of this, claiming that the birth date recorded in the application was incorrect;(d)Informing the delegate that he had had no contact with his children after his house burned down in 2002 and did not know where they were, but testifying before the Tribunal that they were living with a maternal uncle and that he last saw them in their uncle’s home on 15 August 2008;(e)Giving in his application as his reason for seeking protection his fear of continued violence and aggressive interrogation by the police, yet telling the delegate that he had suffered no harm since 2002 and had no difficulties with the authorities in India.(f)Giving inconsistent evidence about his imprisonment.(g)Telling the Tribunal that he went to the police immediately after the 2002 attack but changing his evidence after the Tribunal queried how he could do so with a fractured leg, and then ultimately claiming not to remember whether he had been arrested and imprisoned at all at that time.(h)Asserting in his application that he had been arrested on 1 February 2008 but professing no memory about the arrest in his evidence before the Tribunal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established