SZMSJ v Minister for Immigration & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZMSJ v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2009] FMCA 102
MIGRATION – Review of Refugee Review Tribunal decision – refusal of a protection visa – applicant claiming political persecution in Nepal – applicant’s claims of past harm not believed – corroborative evidence of past harm rejected because the applicant was not believed – applicant’s credibility partially intact because significant elements of his evidence was accepted – Tribunal erred in failing to take the corroborative evidence into account in considering the applicant’s claim of past harm – jurisdictional error found.
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36, 422B, 424A
Re Minister for Immigration; Ex parte S20/2002 (2003) 198 ALR 59
SZDGC v Minister for Immigration [2008] FCA 1638
WAGU v Minister for Immigration [2003] FCA 912
WAIJ v Minister for Immigration [2004] FCAFC 74
Applicant: SZMSJ
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP
Second Respondent: REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 2329 of 2008
Judgment of: Driver FM
Hearing date: 13 February 2009
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 20 March 2009

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J Young
Solicitors for the Applicant: Simon Diab & Associates
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Cleary
Solicitors for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

  1. A writ of certiorari shall issue, quashing the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal signed on 31 July 2008 and handed down on 12 August 2008.

  2. A writ of mandamus shall issue, requiring the Refugee Review Tribunal to redetermine the review application before it according to law.

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
SYDNEY

SYG 2329 of 2008

SZMSJ

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction and background

  1. This is an application to review a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”).  The decision was handed down on 12 August 2008.  The Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the applicant a protection visa.  The applicant is from Nepal and had claimed persecution by the Maoists.  The following statement of background facts relating to the applicant’s claims and the Tribunal decision on them is derived from the applicant’s written submissions filed on 9 February 2009 and the Minister’s written submissions filed on the same day. 

  2. The applicant is a citizen of Nepal.  The applicant arrived in Australia on 3 November 2007.

  3. The applicant applied for a protection visa on 10 December 2007 under s.36 of the Migration Act 1958 (“the Migration Act”).

Applicant’s claims

  1. The applicant claims Maoists/Communists will harm him if he returns to Nepal because of his involvement with a newspaper as a journalist.  He claims that he cannot get protection in Nepal as the Maoists control the authorities[1]. The most significant incident of past persecution claimed by the applicant was that in January 2005, he was kidnapped by a group of Maoists and detained at their camp for 5 days.

Decision of the delegate

[1] Court Book (CB) 164

  1. On 15 February 2008 a delegate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZMSJ v Minister for Immigration & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FMCA 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of SZMSJ v Minister for Immigration & Anor, the applicant, a citizen of Nepal, sought protection from the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) after claiming to have left his country due to past persecution and a fear of future persecution by Maoists in Nepal due to his work as a journalist and his anti-communist stance. The Tribunal found that while the applicant's account was generally supported by independent country information, it did not accept the applicant's claims as credible due to inconsistencies and implausible explanations for his actions. The Tribunal found that the applicant's fear of persecution was not genuine and rejected his claims of past harm, holding that the applicant had made these claims to assist his application for a protection visa.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal's assessment of the applicant's credibility and the consequent rejection of his claims for protection were legally sound. The applicant argued that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the evidence and had erred in rejecting his claims of past harm and fear of future persecution. The court had to determine if the Tribunal's decision was made according to law and if the reasoning was logically consistent and supported by the evidence.

The court found that the Tribunal's decision was legally sound. The court agreed with the Tribunal's assessment that the applicant's actions were inconsistent with his claims of fearing persecution from Maoists. The court held that the Tribunal was correct in its approach to assessing credibility and in rejecting the applicant's claims as implausible. The court noted that the Tribunal had considered the relevant legal principles, including the need for the applicant to establish his claims on the balance of probabilities and the need for the Tribunal to assess the applicant's credibility in light of all the evidence. The court found that the Tribunal's decision was not flawed and that the applicant's claims had been properly rejected.

Consequently, the court quashed the Tribunal's decision and ordered a redetermination of the applicant's review application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

A writ of certiorari shall issue, quashing the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal signed on 31 July 2008 and handed down on 12 August 2008.

2.

A writ of mandamus shall issue, requiring the Refugee Review Tribunal to redetermine the review application before it according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal dealt with the applicant’s claims of past harm in the following terms[11]:[11] CB168-170Essentially the applicant claims that he left his country and cannot return there because he was, and will be, persecuted by Maoists in Nepal because of his work as a journalist there, including that he reported about Maoist atrocities, and because he is anti communist. He claims he was kidnapped, threatened and mistreated by Maoists, including in January 2005. He claims that he will face further persecution because of his activities as a journalist if he returns to Nepal and that his fear of harm is now heightened by recent political changes as the Maoists now form part of the government and are taking revenge. The applicant claims that he cannot get protection from the harm that he fears in his country because the government cannot maintain law and order and because the Maoists are now part of the government and are controlling every organ of the government and committing human rights abuses.The Tribunal agrees that independent country information, including independent country information produced by the applicant, supports, in a general way, the applicant’s claims that in Nepal sometimes there is persecution by Maoists of those who oppose them and that there is not always protection available against that harm. Clearly however the Tribunal must determine whether the applicant before it has a genuine fear founded upon a real chance of persecution for a Convention reason if he returns to his country.The Tribunal accepts that: "applicants for refugee status face particular problems of proof as an applicant may not be able to support his statements by documentary or other proof, and cases in which an applicant can provide evidence of all his statements will be the exception rather than the rule." The Tribunal also accepts that: "if the applicant's account appears credible, he should, unless there are good reasons to the contrary, be given the benefit of the doubt". (The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees' Handbook on Procedures and Criteria for Determining Refugee Status, Geneva, 1992 at para. 196). However, the Handbook also states (at para 203): "The benefit of the doubt should, however, only be given when all available evidence has been obtained and checked and when the examiner is satisfied as to the applicant's general credibility. The applicant's statements must be coherent and plausible, and must not run counter to generally known facts". It is for the Tribunal not only to consider inconsistencies but also to determine what evidence it finds credible (Nicholson J. in Chen Xin He v MIEA, 23 November, 1995 (unreported) at p.11). The Tribunal does not have to accept uncritically all statements and allegations made by an applicant. (Beaumont J in Randhawa v MIEA, 124 ALR 265 at p.278). "The mere fact that a person claims fear of persecution for reasons of political opinion does not establish either the genuineness of the asserted fear or that it is well-founded or that it is for reasons of political opinion.[it is] for the Applicant to persuade the reviewing decision-maker that all of the statutory elements are made out." (MIEA v Guo and Anor (1997) 144 ALR 567 at 596).[The] Tribunal accepts and finds that the applicant is a citizen of Nepal and is who he claims to be; the applicant produced his passport to the Tribunal and a copy is placed on the Tribunal file. The Tribunal finds that the applicant left Nepal and went to Thailand on 28 September 2005 and returned from Thailand to Nepal on 30 October 2005. He left Nepal again and returned to Thailand on 27 February 2006 where he stayed until 10 September 2007 when he returned again to Nepal. He obtained his visa for Australia in Bangkok on 24 August 2007 and worked in Thailand during his visit there in 2006/2007 from a short time after his arrival there. The Tribunal finds that the applicant remained living in Nepal from 10 September 2007 until 29 October 2007. He then left Nepal again on 29 October 2007 and went to Thailand from 29 October 2007 until 2 November 2007 and then entered Australia on 3 November 2007. The Tribunal makes these findings based on the entries in the applicant’s Nepalese passport issued 5 September 2004 which he produced to the Tribunal at the hearing and also on his oral evidence to the Tribunal.Although the Tribunal has some doubts about the matter, the Tribunal finds that the applicant worked as journalist for a newspaper in Nepal as he claims for the period he claims.The Tribunal does not accept as true that the applicant left Nepal at any time because he feared/fears harm there from Maoists as he claims for the reasons that he claims. The Tribunal finds that the applicant went to Thailand in 2005 to visit a friend and for tourism/a holiday as he mentioned in his evidence to the Tribunal. In the Tribunal’s view if he feared harm in Nepal from Maoists because of his activities as a journalist or because of his political opinion, or if he desisted in his activities as a journalist because he feared harm from Maoists as he claimed, he would not have then returned to Nepal in 2005 to live essentially in the same area in and around Kathmandu where he told the Tribunal that he had lived previously and then resume his writing about the Maoists a few months after he returned to Nepal. Also if the applicant left Nepal in February 2006 because he feared harm there for the reasons that he claimed he would not have returned there again in September 2007 and lived again in Kathmandu for six weeks or so, especially given that at that time he had a visa to come to Australia; it is clear that he had his visa to come to Australia in August 2007 before he returned to Nepal from Thailand for the second time.In the Tribunal’s view the explanations given by the applicant as to why he would return twice to a country if he feared harm there, namely that he kept on ignoring the Maoists even though he was abused by them and that he was trying to appease people, are not plausible given the seriousness of the harm that the applicant claims he feared/fears in his country. Nor in the Tribunal’s view is his explanation for returning to Nepal in September 2007 plausible; he told the Tribunal that the Maoists were part of the government then and his parents told him things were alright so he felt he could return. On that occasion however he remained in Nepal for over six weeks even though he said he feared harm from Maoists and had a visa for Australia. The Tribunal does not consider that these facts are consistent with the applicant’s claims that he left Nepal because he feared harm there from Maoists/communists. The Tribunal does not accept as plausible that the applicant was able to remain in Nepal for over six weeks when he returned there in 2007 because those from whom he feared harm did not know he was there; he had entered the country using his own passport and returned to stay in the same area around Kathmandu, even if not the same address; he told the Tribunal that he always stayed with his cousin in Kathmandu and that the places he stayed were half an hour apart by bus. The Tribunal does not accept as true that the applicant left his country and/or fears to return there because he feared/fears harm from Maoists in Nepal due to his activities as journalist or because of his political opinion or imputed political opinion. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant was kidnapped, threatened, detained or ill treated by Maoists in Nepal at any time for the reasons that he claims and does not accept that he will be harmed, threatened or detained by Maoists/communists if he returns there. The Tribunal finds against the applicant in relation to these matters as it does not accept that he is telling the truth about being threatened, kidnapped harmed or mistreated in Nepal; the Tribunal finds that the applicant has made these claims to assist his application for a protection visa. Given the Tribunal’s findings about the applicant’s credibility, it finds that the Notice document dated 7 January 2005 referring to the alleged kidnapping on 5 January 2005is not reliable evidence of the facts contained in that document. The Tribunal notes the comments in WAGU v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 912 at [36] per French J: “Corroborative evidence may be rejected as of no weight because it is dependent upon and can be shown to be undermined by findings as to the tendering party’s credibility.” (emphasis added)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.