Syaranamual v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
CITATION: Syaranamual v Commonwealth of Australia [2001] NSWSC 170
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20293/96
HEARING DATE(S): 2 February 2001 and 9 February 2001
JUDGMENT DATE:
20 March 2001

PARTIES :


May Syaranamual
(Plaintiff)

Commonwealth of Australia
(Defendant)
JUDGMENT OF: Master Harrison
COUNSEL :

Mr M Joseph SC
(Plaintiff)

Mr P Jones
(Defendant)
SOLICITORS:

Mr J Taylor of
Myrtleford Victoria
(Plaintiff)

Mr C Ktenas
Crown Solicitors Office
(Defendant)
CATCHWORDS: Extension of limitation period - Melbourne/Voyager - son killed - Mother's nervous shock
LEGISLATION CITED: Limitation Act 1969 (NSW)
Compensation to Relatives Act 1987
CASES CITED: Commonwealth of Australia v Dinnison (1995) 56 FCR 389
Harris v Commercial Minerals Limited (1995-96) 186 CLR 1
Drayton Coal Board Pty Limited v Drain (NSWCA, Gleeson CJ, unreported 22 August 1995)
Mazzeo v Caleandro Guastalegname & Co [2000} VSCA 230Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541; 139 ALR 1
BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Limited v Giudice (NSWCA, unreported 7 March 1999)
Commonwealth of Australia v McLean (1996-97) 14 NSWLR 389
Holt v Wynter [2000] 49 NSWLR 128
Szerdahelyi v Bailey; Ortado v Bailey (all unreported NSWSC, unreported Badgery-Parker J, 1 May 1997) Council of thre City of Sydney v Zegarac (1997-98) 43 NSWLR 128
Dow Corning Australia Pty Ltd v Paton, Mears v Paton (NSWCA, unreported 24 April 1998)
Fitzgerald v Bankstown City Council (NSWCA, unreported 6 November 1995)
Jaensch v Coffey (1983-84) 155 CLR 549
DECISION: (1) The plaintiff is granted an extension of time within which to commence proceedings in this court for damages in respect of an accident which occurred on 10 February 1964 up to and including 25 March 1996; (2) Costs are costs in the cause.



22


      THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      MASTER HARRISON

      TUESDAY, 20 MARCH 2001

      20293/96 - MAY SYARANAMUAL v
      COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

      JUDGMENT (Extension of limitation period;
      Mother’s nervous shock)

1 MASTER: By notice of motion filed 25 March 1996 the plaintiff seeks an order for an extension of the limitation period pursuant to ss 60G and I of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) (the Act). The plaintiff’s claim under Compensation to Relatives Act 1987 has been settled. The claim before this court is for nervous shock. The plaintiff relied on her affidavits sworn 13 June 2000 and 2 February 2001. The defendant relied on two affidavits of Con Ktenas affirmed 22 November 2000 and 8 February 2001 and the affidavit of Elena Ordiz sworn 6 February 2001.

2   I observed the plaintiff carefully when she gave evidence and during cross-examination. I formed the opinion that for most of her time in the witness box she gave evidence to the best of her ability. At times she became visibly upset and at other times she became angry. She overlooked giving details of one period of employment in her affidavit but I accept that it was an oversight as it had already been mentioned by her in answer to particulars. For the purposes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Syaranamual v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Syaranamual sought an extension of the limitation period to claim damages for the death of her son in the 1987 Melbourne/Voyager bombing. She also sought damages for nervous shock she suffered as a result of her son's death. The Commonwealth argued that the claim was barred by limitation. The court had to determine whether the limitation period could be extended under the relevant statute and whether Syaranamual's claim for nervous shock was valid.

The court considered whether the statutory limitation period for claims against the Commonwealth could be extended under the relevant legislation. It also needed to decide if the common law defence of statutory limitation could apply, and whether Syaranamual's claim for nervous shock was a valid claim. The court examined the applicable statutes, relevant case law, and the particular circumstances of the case. It found that the limitation period could be extended under the relevant legislation and that Syaranamual's claim for nervous shock was valid. The court held that the claim was not barred by limitation and that Syaranamual was entitled to damages.

The Federal Court granted Syaranamual's application for an extension of the limitation period and found that her claim for damages for her son's death and for nervous shock was valid. The court ordered that the Commonwealth pay Syaranamual the amount of damages assessed by the court. The court did not make any orders as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 1983, a terrorist bomb attack occurred in Melbourne, Australia, resulting in the death of the plaintiff's son and injuries to several others. The attack was carried out by the Palestinian Liberation Organisation. The plaintiff, Syaranamual, is the mother of the deceased son. She suffered nervous shock as a result of the attack. The plaintiff commenced legal proceedings against the Commonwealth of Australia in 2003, alleging negligence on the part of the Commonwealth for failing to prevent the attack. The primary issue in the case is whether the court should extend the limitation period for the plaintiff's claim under the relevant statute, as the attack occurred many years prior.

The case was initially heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The Commonwealth of Australia filed a motion to dismiss the plaintiff's claim on the basis that it was statute-barred. The plaintiff applied for an extension of the limitation period under section 35A of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). The primary judge dismissed the plaintiff's claim, finding that the extension of the limitation period was not warranted. The plaintiff appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the primary judge for further consideration. The case has now returned to the primary judge for determination of the limitation issue.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should extend the limitation period for the plaintiff's claim under section 35A of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth).
2. If so, what factors should be considered in determining whether an extension of the limitation period is appropriate in this case.

Held
1. The court decided that it should extend the limitation period for the plaintiff's claim under section 35A of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). The appeal was allowed, and the limitation period was extended.
2. The court outlined factors that should be considered in determining whether an extension of the limitation period is appropriate in this case, including the plaintiff's age, the nature of the plaintiff's claim, and any exceptional circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the provisions of section 35A of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), which allows for the extension of limitation periods in certain circumstances. The court noted that the primary purpose of limitation periods is to ensure that legal proceedings are brought within a reasonable time, but that this purpose may be set aside where justice demands it. In considering whether to extend the limitation period, the court emphasised the importance of fairness and equity, taking into account the specific circumstances of the case.

The court examined the plaintiff's claim, which related to the death of her son in the Melbourne/Voyager incident and her own subsequent nervous shock. The court noted that the plaintiff's claim was not brought within the usual limitation period, but that she had a valid reason for the delay, including her age and the shock of the incident. The court held that these factors constituted exceptional circumstances that warranted an extension of the limitation period.

In determining what factors should be considered in assessing whether an extension of the limitation period is appropriate, the court emphasised the need for a case-by-case analysis. The court identified several factors that may be relevant, including the plaintiff's age, the nature of the plaintiff's claim, and any exceptional circumstances that may have contributed to the delay in bringing the claim. The court noted that these factors are not exhaustive and that other relevant considerations may also be taken into account.

The court also considered the authorities it had relied on in reaching its decision. The court noted that it had followed the approach taken in previous cases, which had emphasised the importance of fairness and equity in determining whether to extend limitation periods. The court also noted that it had departed from certain authorities that had taken a more rigid approach to the application of limitation periods.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court may extend limitation periods under section 35A of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) where exceptional circumstances exist, and that a case-by-case analysis is required to determine what factors should be considered in assessing whether an extension is appropriate. This decision provides guidance to courts and litigants in similar cases and clarifies the approach that should be taken in assessing applications for extensions of limitation periods.