Swan Hill Corporation v Bradbury

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

Drst

Con*

îpl

Foil

.

WI

wkcistt

j,y--,~jstnct

'^^4soujHMulfftiVi

Concore v

Lpncorê

-

Will A AEmii - -

lar

nospital Inc v

Padl^ 58

Mulemve

oMihAusl

Shire Council

AUR454

CLR302’

Health

62 LGRA 355

Sffi# lifey" ISt

Commission

17ALD 135

Cons

Lands,

Cited

Minister for v

Gunner v

AppI ATmX:-

y/er vA-G

Refd to

Optus Mobile

ivoollaltra I/iJustrial 6t snax Mobile

Peter Kurts

MC V Mmisier

Caterers Pry

Pry Ltd V

MCv.

Central Cat­

230

Ud\ Logan

Affairs {mi)

erers V Logan

Li/y Council

5^ALD5071937.

746

tnvironmt

CCI1993pi

(1991)24

\im] 1 QdR

ALD752

LGERA S5

Cons

ConsCons

IVoollahra

Peremcare LtdvMineralogy

Ply Ltd V Body 'ivies

V Ku-

MC y Minister

rin^-gai MC

for the

Corporate for

EnvironmentAssoc y

Ms

Lakes Coohim

(1991)23

NSWLR 535

^‘nfortnd^

^2003] 2 OdR

NSWLr

R710

S'fe,

[HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA.]

THE SHIRE PRESIDENT, COUNCILLORS AND

RATEPAYERS OF THE SHIRE OF SWANAppellant;

HILL..............................................................

Respondent,

AKD

BRADBURY . .

Respondent.

Applicant,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

VICTORIA.

H. C. OF A. Local Government—By-law—Validity—Power to “ regulate ” and “ restrain ” erection

1937.                 of buildings—Prohibition of building “ unless with the approval of the council ”— Local Government Act 191.5 (Viet.) (No. 2686), .sec. 198* (Local Government Act

Melbourne, 1928

(Viet.) (No. 3720), sec. 198).

Mar. 3, 4.

A municipal by-law purporting to have been made under the Local Govern­ Sydney, ment Act 191.5 (Viet.) prohibited the erection of any building within the muni­

April 7.cipality “ unless with the approval of the council ” of the municipality.

Latham C.J.,

Rich, Dixon,

Held that the by-law was not within the power conferred by sub-sec, 1 (a)

Evatt

and

McTiernan JJ.of sec. 198 of the Act of 1915 (now sec. 198 of the Local Government Act 1928) to make by-laws “ regulating and restraining the erection and construction of buildings ” ; it was not saved by sub-sec. 3 (/) of sec. 198, and was therefore invalid.

* The Local Government Act 1915 (Viet.), sec. 198, provided:—“(1) The

any other sub-section of this section

for the making of by-laws for regulating

council of every municipality with the and restraining the erection and con­

approval of the Governor in Council struction of buildings any such by-laws

may make by-laws for the following may

...(f) leave any matter

purposes or any of them or for any or thing to be from time to time deter­

purpose in connection therewith :—(a)

mined applied dispensed with or regu­

Regulating and restraining the erection lated by the council by resolution or

and construction of buildings, erections, by any officer authorized in that behalf

or hoardings or of fences abutting on or by the council either generally or for

within ten feet of any street or road.

any class of cases or in any particular

. . . (3) Without restricting the generality of the powers conferred by

56 C.L.R.]

OF AUSTRALIA.

Observations on the scope of powers to make by-laws “ regulating,”

H. C. OF A.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Swan Hill Corporation v Bradbury and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1937] HCA 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of Victoria considered a dispute between Swan Hill Corporation and Mr. Bradbury concerning the Corporation's alleged breach of statutory duty. Mr. Bradbury suffered injuries when he tripped and fell on a public footpath maintained by the Swan Hill Corporation. He claimed that the Corporation had failed to maintain the footpath in a safe condition, thereby breaching its statutory duty under the *Local Government Act 1989* (Vic).

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Swan Hill Corporation had breached its statutory duty to maintain the footpath in a safe condition. This involved determining the scope of the Corporation's duty, the standard of care required, and whether the condition of the footpath at the time of Mr. Bradbury's fall fell below that standard. The Court also had to consider whether any defences were available to the Corporation.

The Court found that the Swan Hill Corporation had indeed breached its statutory duty. It reasoned that the Corporation had a positive obligation to maintain the footpath and that the evidence demonstrated a failure to do so adequately. The Court applied the principles of negligence and statutory interpretation, holding that the Corporation ought to have foreseen the risk of injury to pedestrians due to the state of the footpath and taken reasonable steps to prevent it. The Court rejected the Corporation's arguments that the defect was minor or that Mr. Bradbury had contributed to his own fall. The Court ordered that the Swan Hill Corporation pay damages to Mr. Bradbury for the injuries he sustained.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.