Svatos and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

Svatos and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2020] AATA 1413 (14 May 2020)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/5432

Re:Brenda Svatos

APPLICANT

Australian Capital TerritoryAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

Date:14 May 2020  

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision of 16 July 2019 of the Territory and, in substitution, determines that Ms Svatos be allowed an extension of time under s 62(3) to lodge her request for reconsideration to 27 July 2018.

........................................................................

Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – power to reconsider determinations pursuant to section 62 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – extension of time relevant considerations discussed – decision under review set aside and substituted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Cases

Armitage and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 5659
Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria (No 4) [2007] FCA 1449
Banks v Comcare Australia [1996] FCA 1490
Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541
Comcare v A'Hearn [1993] FCA 498
Re Hunter Valley Developments Pty Limited v Minister of Home Affairs and Environment [1984] FCA 176
Jackamarra v Krakouer [1998] HCA 27
Karam and Comcare [2020] AATA 64
Lazos and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 4542
Maric v Comcare (1993) 40 FCR 244
Muller and Child Support Registrar [2019] AATA 4356
Nalder and Child Support Registrar [2019] AATA 5518
Noonan and Comcare [2019] AATA 515
Phillips v Australian Girls’ Choir Pty Ltd & Anor [2001] FMCA 109
Prestige Technical Training Institute Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2019] AATA 460
Rahimzadeh and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 3201
Saffioti and Comcare [2018] AATA 43
Thompson and Comcare [2019] AATA 714
Weston and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2020] AATA 113

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

14 May 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Brenda Svatos claims to have been injured during her employment within the ACT Education Directorate in 2017. However, she was out of time in seeking reconsideration by Comcare of her claim under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act). She has applied to the Tribunal to set aside a decision to refuse her an extension of time to seek reconsideration of Comcare’s original decision.

  2. On 1 March 2019 the Australian Capital Territory (the ACT or the Territory) became a licensee under the Act, and thus the respondent in these proceedings in substitution for Comcare.

  3. Due to restrictions in place following the outbreak of novel coronavirus in early 2020, the hearing of this application was conducted by telephone. A statement of Ms Svatos dated 1 November 2019 was tendered, but she was not called to give evidence.

    BACKGROUND

  4. In early 2017 Ms Svatos was the business manager at Monash Primary School in Canberra. On 25 July 2017, she signed a Comcare Workers’ Compensation Claim Form in which she alleged she was suffering from mixed anxiety/depression due…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Svatos and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 1413
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms Svatos for an extension of time to seek reconsideration of a Comcare determination that declined her claim for compensation for mixed anxiety and depression, allegedly arising from workplace bullying. The Australian Capital Territory (the Territory) opposed the application, arguing prejudice due to the delay and the weakness of Ms Svatos's underlying claim. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) was required to determine whether to grant an extension of time under section 62 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (the Act).

The Tribunal considered several legal issues. Firstly, it had to assess whether Ms Svatos had provided a sufficient explanation for the delay in seeking reconsideration of Comcare's decision. This involved evaluating the impact of her alleged mental health condition and difficulties with her legal representatives on her ability to pursue her claim in a timely manner. Secondly, the Tribunal was required to weigh the prejudice that the Territory might suffer due to the delay against the factors favouring the grant of an extension, particularly the potential merits of Ms Svatos's claim. The Tribunal also considered the general approach to granting extensions of time for claims involving mental health conditions and the length of the delay.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal acknowledged that prejudice to the respondent is a material factor against granting an extension but is not automatically fatal. It found that the evidence regarding the unavailability of a key witness for the Territory was not conclusive and that any prejudice might have arisen regardless of Ms Svatos's delay. The Tribunal also noted that the delay was less than three months and that the psychological evidence, while not extensive, suggested a degree of incapacity on Ms Svatos's part. Applying these considerations, the Tribunal concluded that the factors favouring the grant of an extension outweighed the prejudice to the Territory.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the reviewable decision of 16 July 2019 and substituted a determination allowing Ms Svatos an extension of time to lodge her request for reconsideration to 27 July 2018. This outcome meant that the Territory was required to consider Ms Svatos's request for reconsideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

Due to restrictions in place following the outbreak of novel coronavirus in early 2020, the hearing of this application was conducted by telephone. A statement of Ms Svatos dated 1 November 2019 was tendered, but she was not called to give evidence.BACKGROUND In early 2017 Ms Svatos was the business manager at Monash Primary School in Canberra. On 25 July 2017, she signed a Comcare Workers’ Compensation Claim Form in which she alleged she was suffering from mixed anxiety/depression due to repeated bullying during her employment by the Directorate.[1] She stated that she first noticed her symptoms/injury on 14 February 2017. The Tribunal was taken to documents suggesting that there had been workplace conflict between Ms Svatos and the school principal, HSVK.[1] The use of italicised text in this decision generally indicates direct quotation In about April 2017 Ms Svatos had engaged solicitors, United Legal, to act on her behalf in relation to her workers’ compensation claim. On 21 August 2017, Dr Ash Takyar, Consultant Psychiatrist, examined her for the purposes of her claim. In a medical report dated 31 August 2017, he described Ms Svatos’s condition in these terms:…a moderate to severe grade adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood…She reported symptoms commencing around February 2017 in the context of what she experienced as a barrage of commentary around performance issues and criticism of her work. On 29 September 2017, Comcare issued a determination declining liability to pay compensation to Ms Svatos pursuant to s 14 of the Act for adjustment reaction with mixed emotional features. The letter conveying the determination included this statement:If you/your employer disagree with this determination you/they have the right for it to be reviewed. Please refer to the attached Notice of Rights or see 'Assistance and Further Information Options' at the end of this letter.That Notice of Rights advised that she could seek a reconsideration of the determination within 30 days of receiving it. In October 2017 correspondence passed between United Legal and Comcare concerning Ms Svatos’s claim. In her statement of 1 November 2019, Ms Svatos says:Throughout the time that I had United Legal as my solicitors, I experienced great difficulty in making contact with Mr Montagnimo [sic], or getting anyone to respond to my calls or emails.Following receipt of Comcare's letter declining my claim, I attempted to contact Mr Montagnimo, but was not successful.On 19 January 2018 I received an email from Stacey Bell, Paralegal at United Legal concerning my claim, advising me of the need to keep a diary with respect to my claim.In early April 2018, I was advised by Mr Montagnimo that United Legal had engaged a barrister to advise in respect of my claim. At no time was I advised by anyone at United Legal that a reconsideration of Comcare's decision had not been requested on my behalf, and that I was now out of time to request a reconsideration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While prejudice to the respondent … occasioned by the delay is a material factor militating against the grant of an extension (Hunter Valley Developments at [20]), it is not automatically fatal to such a grant. In the full circumstances of this case, and on balance, the Tribunal considers that this consideration should not outweigh other factors favouring the grant of an extension, for the following reasons.As counsel for Ms Svatos pointed out, the email advising of HSVK’s indisposition offers no medical insight into his condition, and in particular does not explain whether his condition is physical or psychological, or whether it is likely to be temporary or ongoing. It is therefore not clear whether HSVK might yet be available to give evidence in the future. Similarly, it is difficult to say whether any prejudice to the ACT by virtue of him being indisposed has been occasioned by Ms Svatos’s delay. The Tribunal notes that, had Ms Svatos lodged her request for reconsideration in May 2018, and had Comcare affirmed the earlier determination, it is reasonably likely that the Tribunal would have been conducting a merits review hearing at about this time, when HSVK would have been indisposed and the ACT prejudiced through no fault of Ms Svatos. It may also be presumed that evidence could be led from other participants in the affairs of the school at that time – for example, Ms Jankovic, the then Deputy Principal – in support of the ACT’s case.CONCLUSION In cases where an applicant has sought an extension of time of less than three months, the Tribunal has generally granted such an extension, unless the applicant’s substantive case is very weak (for example, Armitage and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 5659; Weston and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2020] AATA 113; Lazos and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 4542; Rahimzadeh and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 3201; Muller and Child Support Registrar [2019] AATA 4356; Nalder and Child Support Registrar [2019] AATA 5518; Prestige Technical Training Institute Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2019] AATA 460). An exception to this pattern occurred in Karam, where Senior Member Fairhall considered conflicting psychological evidence about the applicant’s degree of incapacity and concluded that he had not provided a satisfactory explanation for the delay there of 84 days. I would take a different approach in the present case, where the delay is shorter and the psychological evidence, though less extensive, does suggest a measure of incapacity on Ms Svatos’s part. Accordingly, the Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision of 16 July 2019 of the Territory and, in substitution, determines that Ms Svatos be allowed an extension of time under s 62(3) to lodge her request for reconsideration to 27 July 2018. The effect of this decision is that the Territory must now consider the request of reconsideration made by Ms Svatos on that day.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Territory also submitted that there was no compelling evidence that Ms Svatos’s mental ill health prevented her from prosecuting her claim in a timely way. Clinical notes from her GP’s surgery refer, on 28 November 2017, to her Gradually recovering from anxiety/depression and, on 4 May 2018, to her Recovering from bullying. The Tribunal was referred to Karam and Comcare [2020] AATA 64 where Senior Member Fairall refused an extension of time where he was not satisfied that the applicant’s fragile mental state was such as to deprive him of the capacity to deal with the procedures necessary to engage his rights of review (at [29]).Ms Svatos rested on her rights to seek reconsideration The ACT submitted that Ms Svatos rested on her rights by not proceeding with her claim after dispensing with her original solicitors. She did so, counsel asserted, because she was cognisant of her right to seek review of Comcare’s determination (as she admitted in her statement), but failed to act either after April 2018 or even after July 2018 when she failed to respond to Comcare’s demand that she provide further information about her request for reconsideration.The Territory is, and would be, prejudiced in the circumstances With the passage of time since the original injury arose in early 2017, the Territory would face difficulties in obtaining relevant evidence in relation to the injury, it was submitted. Witness statements would be important given that the reasonable administrative action exclusion in s 5A of the Act would be likely to feature in any reconsideration of Ms Svatos’s claim. An issue of “presumptive prejudice” has potential to arise whenever there is significant delay in prosecuting a claim. This was referred to by McHugh J in Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541 in these terms (at 551): The longer the delay in commencing proceedings, the more likely it is that the case will be decided on less evidence than was available to the parties at the time that the cause of action arose. In the present proceedings, the ACT alleged actual prejudice, in that it appeared that there would be difficulty in obtaining evidence from HSVK, who was totally unfit for work as of February 2020. It was also observed by counsel for the Territory that his client would be prejudiced by the fact that any mental injury which Ms Svatos may in fact have suffered through employment has not been treated or managed by Comcare/the ACT in a timely way after being sustained.Ms Svatos’s case is prima facie weak It was contended that Ms Svatos’s case, if it were allowed to proceed, is a weak one. Her claim for a mental injury occurred against the backdrop of informal counselling of her by the school in relation to perceived inadequacies in her work performance. The Tribunal was taken to a letter of April 2017 by the chair of the school board, complaining about Ms Svatos’s financial management practices and competency. The Tribunal was also taken to an email dated 14 February 2017 to HSVK from the deputy principal, Ms Jankovic, outlining a list of apparent Concerns with Ms Svatos’s performance.