Nalder and Child Support Registrar (Child support)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Nalder and Child Support Registrar (Child support) [2019] AATA 5518 (18 July 2019)

DIVISION:Social Services & Child Support Division

EXTENSION APPLICATION

NUMBER:2019/SC016364

APPLICANT:  Ms Nalder

OTHER PARTY:  Child Support Registrar

DATE DECISION MADE:                18 July 2019

APPLICATION:

An extension application made on 1 May 2019 asking the AAT to consider the application for AAT first review of a decision of the Child Support Registrar on 11 February 2019 despite the period for applying for review having ended.

DECISION:

The extension application is refused.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – application for extension of time – no satisfactory explanation for the delay – little merit – extension of time refused

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)-16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

  1. Ms Nalder and Mr [A] are the parents of [Child 1] (born February 2001).  There has been a child support assessment in place since 4 July 2018 with collection by the Department of Human Services, Child Support (the Child Support Agency) since 7 December 2018.  Ms Nalder is the parent liable to pay child support under the assessment.

  2. On 7 December 2018 Mr [A]made an application to the Child Support Agency to extend the child support assessment for [Child 1] past her 18th birthday. 

  3. On 11 December 2018 the Child Support Agency made the decision to extend the child support assessment for [Child 1] past her 18th birthday until 27 September 2019.

  4. On 30 January 2019 Ms Nalder objected to this decision and as her objection was not made within the prescribed period she applied for an extension of time on 4 February 2019 (the first extension of time application).

  5. On 11 February 2019 the Child Support Agency refused to grant the extension of time application (the refusal decision) and Ms Nalder was notified of the refusal decision by post in correspondence dated 11 February 2019.

  6. On 1 May 2019 Ms Nalder lodged an application with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for an extension of time for review of the refusal decision (the second extension of time application).

  7. The matter was considered on 18 July 2019 on the papers (consistent with the Tribunal’s ‘Child Support Review Directions’).  The Tribunal had before it a bundle of papers provided by the Child Support Agency.

  8. The statutory provisions relevant to this review are contained in the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (the Act) and the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (the Assessment Act).

  9. The issue which arises in this case is whether or not to grant Ms Nalder’s request for an extension of time to review the refusal decision.

  10. Part VIIA, Division 2 of the Act sets out the procedures for applying to the Tribunal for a review of a decision made by the Child Support Agency as well…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nalder and Child Support Registrar (Child support) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 5518
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered an application for an extension of time made by Ms Nalder. Ms Nalder sought to have the AAT review a decision made by the Child Support Registrar on 11 February 2019, which refused her earlier application for an extension of time to object to a child support assessment. The original child support assessment had been extended for Ms Nalder's daughter past her 18th birthday.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant Ms Nalder's application for an extension of time to seek a review of the Registrar's refusal decision. This required the Tribunal to consider the relevant provisions of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, particularly concerning applications made outside the prescribed time limits. The Tribunal was required to determine if it was proper to grant an extension, balancing factors such as the reasons for the delay, the merits of the substantive application, and any prejudice to the parties or the public.

The Tribunal reasoned that Ms Nalder's application was approximately 44 days late. While Ms Nalder claimed the delay was due to waiting for her daughter's school attendance records to demonstrate she was no longer in full-time education, the Tribunal found this explanation unsatisfactory. It noted that Ms Nalder had contacted the school earlier and that the Child Support Agency had already determined there was no merit to her objection, as the daughter was enrolled in Year 12 and her 18th birthday fell within the school year. The Tribunal applied the principles from *Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen* [1984] FCA 186, which caution against granting extensions unless it is proper to do so, and considered the lack of merit in the substantive objection and the unsatisfactory reasons for the delay.

Ultimately, the Tribunal refused Ms Nalder's application for an extension of time. It concluded that, on balance, it was not proper to grant the extension, given the unsatisfactory explanation for the delay, the lack of merit in the underlying objection, and the potential prejudice to the general public in deviating from statutory timeframes.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Ms Nalder, who is the parent liable for paying child support under an assessment made by the Child Support Agency. The child in question, [Child 1], was born in February 2001 and the child support assessment has been in place since 4 July 2018. On 7 December 2018, Mr [A], the other parent, applied to the Child Support Agency for an extension of the child support assessment past [Child 1]'s 18th birthday. The Child Support Agency subsequently decided to extend the assessment until 27 September 2019. Ms Nalder objected to this decision on 30 January 2019, but as her objection was not lodged within the prescribed period, she applied for an extension of time on 4 February 2019. The Child Support Agency refused this extension application on 11 February 2019.

On 1 May 2019, Ms Nalder lodged a second extension application with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), requesting an extension of time to review the Child Support Agency's refusal decision. Ms Nalder claimed that she had been waiting for [Child 1]'s attendance record from the school to demonstrate that [Child 1] was no longer in full-time education. The AAT considered Ms Nalder's reasons for the delay, finding that she was unlikely to have been unaware of the significance of failing to apply to the AAT within the prescribed 28-day period. The AAT was not satisfied with the explanation provided by Ms Nalder for the delay in applying for the review. The AAT also found that Ms Nalder's objection had little merit as [Child 1] was enrolled in high school until 27 September 2019. The AAT concluded that Ms Nalder's application for an extension of time had little merit and that there would be some prejudice to the general public if the extension was granted due to the statutory timeframe and the unsatisfactory reasons for the delay.

Ms Nalder applied to the Child Support Agency on 7 December 2018 for an extension of a child support assessment for her child past the child's 18th birthday. The Child Support Agency granted the application on 11 December 2018. Ms Nalder objected to the decision on 30 January 2019, well outside the 28-day period for review, and applied for an extension of time to lodge the objection. The Child Support Agency refused the extension application on 11 February 2019. Ms Nalder then applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for an extension of time to review the refusal decision. The AAT considered the application on 18 July 2019. The AAT found that Ms Nalder's explanation for the delay in objecting to the decision was unsatisfactory and that there was little merit to her argument. The AAT also found that granting the extension application would cause some prejudice to the wider public given the statutory timeframe and unsatisfactory reasons for the delay. Accordingly, the AAT refused the extension application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Tribunal should grant Ms Nalder's request for an extension of time to review the refusal decision.
2. What reasons Ms Nalder provided for the delay in applying for an extension of time.
3. Whether the application for review has merit.
4. Whether there is any prejudice to the other party, the Child Support Agency, if the Tribunal were to hear the application.
5. Whether there would be any prejudice to the general public if an extension of time was granted.

Held
1. Whether the Tribunal should grant Ms Nalder's request for an extension of time to review the refusal decision. The Tribunal concluded that it is not proper to grant Ms Nalder's request for an extension of time, and therefore the extension application was refused.
2. What reasons Ms Nalder provided for the delay in applying for an extension of time. The Tribunal found that Ms Nalder did not provide a satisfactory explanation for the delay in applying for an extension of time.
3. Whether the application for review has merit. The Tribunal concluded that there is little merit to Ms Nalder's application for review.
4. Whether there is any prejudice to the other party, the Child Support Agency, if the Tribunal were to hear the application. The Tribunal found that there would be little prejudice to the Child Support Agency if the application were to be heard.
5. Whether there would be any prejudice to the general public if an extension of time was granted. The Tribunal concluded that there would be some prejudice to the general public if an extension of time was granted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Nalder and Child Support Registrar (Child support), the Tribunal was tasked with deciding whether to grant Ms Nalder's request for an extension of time to review a refusal decision made by the Child Support Agency. The Tribunal examined several factors, including the reasons provided for the delay in applying for an extension, the merits of the substantive application, potential prejudice to the Child Support Agency, and any prejudice to the general public if an extension were granted. Ultimately, the Tribunal refused Ms Nalder's request for an extension of time to review the refusal decision.

The Tribunal found that Ms Nalder's application for an extension of time was approximately 44 days late. Ms Nalder claimed she was waiting for her daughter's attendance record from the school to demonstrate that the child was no longer in full-time education. However, the Tribunal was not satisfied with this explanation, as it was unlikely Ms Nalder would still be waiting for this evidence after contacting the school on February 13, 2019. Furthermore, Ms Nalder had been aware of the significance of failing to apply for review within the prescribed 28-day period, as outlined in the notification of the refusal decision provided by the Child Support Agency.

The Tribunal also considered the merits of Ms Nalder's application for an extension of time to object to the decision to extend the child support assessment for her child past her 18th birthday. The Child Support Agency found there was no merit to Ms Nalder's objection, as the child was enrolled at school until September 27, 2019. The Tribunal agreed that there was little merit in Ms Nalder's application, and even if the Tribunal had granted the second extension application, it was unlikely to grant the first extension application.

The Tribunal also considered potential prejudice to the other party, the Child Support Agency, if the Tribunal were to hear the application. The Tribunal found that there would be little prejudice to the Child Support Agency if the application were heard, as the timeframe that had passed was not significant. However, the Tribunal found that there would be some prejudice to the general public if an extension of time was granted, given the statutory timeframe and the unsatisfactory reasons for the delay.

In conclusion, the Tribunal found that Ms Nalder had not provided a satisfactory reason for the delay in her second extension application, and there was little merit to her argument. The Tribunal also found that there would be some prejudice to the wider public if the second extension application were granted. Therefore, the Tribunal refused Ms Nalder's request for an extension of time to review the refusal decision.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when deciding whether to grant an extension of time for review, the Tribunal will consider factors such as the reasons for the delay, the merits of the substantive application, and any prejudice to the other party and the wider public. If the reasons for the delay are unsatisfactory, and there is little merit to the substantive application, it is unlikely the Tribunal will grant an extension of time, even if there is little prejudice to the other party. In this case, the Tribunal refused the extension application because Ms Nalder did not provide a satisfactory reason for the delay, and there was little merit to her application.