Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria (No 4) [2007] FCA 1449

DISCRIMINATION LAW – application pursuant to s 46PO of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) – allegation of unlawful discrimination – racial discrimination – disability discrimination – complaint made to Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission – complaint terminated as lacking in substance – whether allegations of religious or political discrimination also before Court – whether allegations pursuant to the Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic) also before the Court

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to extend time for filing application – discretion of court – principles to be applied in exercising discretion – whether merits of applicant’s claim sufficient to warrant exercise of discretion – whether any reasonable prospect of success

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth), s 11
Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), ss 5, 6, 42, 122
Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic), s 211
Evidence Act 1958 (Vic), s 21A
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 31A(2)
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth), ss 32(3)(c)(ii), 46H, 46PH, 46PO, 46PR, Sch 2,
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 78B
Nurses Act 1993 (Vic), ss 22, 25, 48, 49, 51, 65, 66, 67
Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth), ss 9(1), 9(1A), 17, 18A
Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic), s 148

Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria (No 2) [2007] FCA 351 referred to
Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria [2004] VCAT 1663 referred to
Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria [2005] HCATrans 864 referred to
Bahonko v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology [2006] FCA 1325 applied
Bahonko v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology [2006] FCA 1492 cited
Bahonko v Sterjov [2007] FCA 115 applied
Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen (1984) 3 FCR 344 cited
Scherbakova v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology [2000] FCA 1566 cited
Walton v Gardiner (1993) 177 CLR 378 cited

STANISLAWA BAHONKO v NURSES BOARD OF VICTORIA AND FORMER MINISTER FOR HEALTH/CURRENT MINISTER FOR EDUCATION BRONWYN PIKE
VID 855 OF 2006

MIDDLETON J
14 SEPTEMBER 2007
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 855 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

STANISLAWA BAHONKO
Applicant

AND:

NURSES BOARD OF VICTORIA
First Respondent

FORMER MINISTER FOR HEALTH/CURRENT MINISTER FOR EDUCATION BRONWYN PIKE
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MIDDLETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 SEPTEMBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The description of the second respondent be amended to “Former Minister of Health/Current Minister for Education”.

2.The applicant’s motions, notices of which were dated 22 September 2006, 3 October 2006, 31 October 2006, 27 February 2007 and 28 May 2007, be dismissed.

3.The application for leave to file the application and claim pursuant to s 46PO of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) out of time be refused.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 855…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1449
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria (No 4) concerns an application by Ms Bahonko seeking leave to file a proceeding out of time against the Nurses Board of Victoria. The Federal Court was required to determine whether Ms Bahonko should be granted leave to file her application outside the statutory time limit, as well as several other motions. Ms Bahonko alleged that she faced discrimination and harassment in her workplace, leading to her dismissal from her position at Moorfields Aged Care facility. She also claimed that her dismissal was a result of her protected characteristics, including her race and disability. The court had to consider whether Ms Bahonko's claims were within its jurisdiction and whether the additional material provided by Ms Bahonko could assist in demonstrating a pattern of discriminatory behaviour.

The court found that Ms Bahonko's claims regarding discrimination based on political opinions and religious beliefs were not within the jurisdiction of the Federal Court in this proceeding. However, the court found that the claims based on descent and ethnic origin were within its jurisdiction and should be considered on their merits. The court rejected the argument that the additional material provided by Ms Bahonko should be struck out as it may assist in demonstrating a pattern of discriminatory behaviour. The court also found that it did not have jurisdiction to hear a matter arising under the Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic) as Ms Bahonko had not filed a complaint with the relevant Commission or sought a review by VCAT.

The court dismissed Ms Bahonko's motions and denied her application for leave to file her proceeding out of time. The court found that Ms Bahonko had not provided sufficient justification for the delay in filing her application, and that granting leave would not be in the interests of justice. The court also found that the respondents had not acted unreasonably in their decision to terminate the complaint, and that the decisions of the Nurses Board of Victoria were not subject to review by the Federal Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The description of the second respondent be amended to “Former Minister of Health/Current Minister for Education”.

2. The applicant’s motions, notices of which were dated 22 September 2006, 3 October 2006, 31 October 2006, 27 February 2007 and 28 May 2007, be dismissed.

3. The application for leave to file the application and claim pursuant to s 46PO of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) out of time be refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

The principal question to be determined is whether leave ought to be granted to Ms Bahonko to file this proceeding out of time.THE FACTUAL BACKGROUND It is useful to set out the background to the complaint of Ms Bahonko. In early 2003, Ms Bahonko commenced work at Moorfields Aged Care facility at Box Hill (‘Moorfields’). Whilst working at Moorfields, Ms Bahonko approached the Director of Nursing, Ms Riley, with concerns about the workplace. After this consultation, Ms Bahonko claimed she started to be “systematically harassed, stalked, subjected to various set ups and abuses”. In August 2003, Ms Bahonko commenced a second job part time at another Uniting Church Aged Care facility at Bodalla (‘Bodalla’). Whilst in that position, Ms Bahonko was told by the Director of Nursing “not to show outside religious terms”. This was apparently in response to her wearing a Virgin Mary on a chain visible outside her uniform. In around November 2003, Ms Bahonko stated that she was “stalked” by Ms Turnbull (CEO of Moorfields) and was “subjected to harassment and unlawful practices and the working condition as at Moorfields”. On 9 March 2004, Ms Bahonko claimed she was emotionally and verbally assaulted and openly told that she had no rights. She immediately ceased working at Bodalla. On 6 May 2004, an incident occurred at Moorfields which resulted in Ms Bahonko being escorted off the premises by the police. It appears that some time before the incident, a complaint was made by a patient about Ms Bahonko. While that complaint remained unresolved, it seems that another two complaints were made against Ms Bahonko, complaining of inappropriate communication and aggression. All three complaints remained unresolved at the time of the incident on 6 May 2004. By virtue of the complaints being unresolved, Ms Riley and Ms Turnbull decided to ask Ms Bahonko to stand down from her duties at Moorfields, pending an investigation into the outstanding complaints. There are two different versions of events of what occurred on 6 May 2004. One version is that Ms Riley, along with Ms Wood, the Quality Manager at Moorfields, approached Ms Bahonko to ask her to leave the workplace. According to an incident report completed on the day, Ms Bahonko at first agreed to leave, but when Ms Riley asked her to give the keys to the drug trolley, she refused. Some discussion ensued as to what stage Ms Bahonko was in administering medication to the resident patients. Ms Riley began to explain to Ms Bahonko that her actions with the medication were against “safe practice”. Ms Bahonko apparently put her keys back in her pocket, sat down, and made some private phone calls. At this stage, Ms Wood contacted Ms Turnbull about how to manage the situation, who instructed her to contact the police to have Ms Bahonko removed. It seems that Ms Riley again asked Ms Bahonko to hand over the keys and leave the premises, which was refused, and the police were contacted. After the police arrived, Ms Bahonko asked them to check her pre-prepared medication. The police asked her to hand over the keys and leave the premises, at which point Ms Bahonko apparently began disposing of the pre-prepared medication. The police physically approached her and escorted her from the premises. Ms Riley completed a report of the incident on the day, and also completed a medication incident report, which provided that Ms Bahonko had not adhered to the procedural and safe practice guidelines in preparing the medication on 6 May 2004.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MIDDLETON J
Ms Bahonko also raised claims against the respondents under the Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic) for alleged discrimination on the basis of impairment, political beliefs or activity, race and religious belief and activity. ConclusionsScope of the proceeding I accept the respondents’ submissions that in so far as Ms Bahonko alleged that the respondents discriminated against her on the basis of her political opinions and religious beliefs, those claims are not within the jurisdiction of this Court in this proceeding. Jurisdiction is not a mere technicality or matter of legal form to which s 46PR of the HREOC Act can apply: see Bahonko v RMIT [2006] FCA at 70 per Weinberg J. As mentioned above, in relation to Ms Bahonko’s complaint of discrimination on the grounds of religion and political opinions filed with the Commission, the Commission decided not to continue to inquire into the alleged acts or practices because, pursuant to s 32(3)(c)(ii), the allegations were lacking in substance. The Commission stated that this aspect of the claim was finalised and if Ms Bahonko disagreed with its decision on this aspect, she may apply for review of the decision by this Court or the Federal Magistrates Court under the ADJR Act. No application before me on this basis was brought or pursued. The application before me is pursuant to s 46PO of the HREOC Act. However, assuming in favour of Ms Bahonko that the descent and ethnic origin grounds are substantially the same as the race and disability grounds alleged in the complaint, it appears that the grounds set out in the application other than religious belief and political opinions are within the jurisdiction of the Court and the merits must be considered. I do not consider it appropriate to strike out those paragraphs of Ms Bahonko’s material that goes beyond the decisions of the NBV on 24 May 2004 and 14 October 2004, for which the NBV contended. The argument was based on the requirement in s 46PO(3) that the unlawful discrimination alleged in an application in this Court must:·be the same as, or the same in substance as, the unlawful discrimination the subject of the terminated complaint; or ·arise out of the same, or substantially the same, acts or practices that were the subject of the terminated complaint. Therefore, whilst the original complaint was somewhat limited in the incidents referred to, it may be that the additional material can assist in demonstrating a pattern of behaviour or practice. It is clear that one key aspect of Ms Bahonko’s claims is that all the events are connected and demonstrate a web of discrimination and she attempts to draw conclusions about the specific decisions of the NBV the subject of the complaint by reference to other material. In relation to Ms Bahonko’s submissions on the Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic), it must be noted that Ms Bahonko does not seek any relief in her application under that Act. Therefore, even if the Court had jurisdiction to hear a matter arising under that Act, no such matter arises in this proceeding against the NBV or the Minister. There is certainly no evidence that the procedures required to be followed in that Act were followed. Ms Bahonko did not file a complaint with the Commission (as that term is defined in that Act) or that such complaint was referred to VCAT. Further, and in any event, this Court has no jurisdiction to review a decision of the Commission (as defined in that Act) or VCAT, which is properly the subject of the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of Victoria: see s 148 of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic); s 211 of the Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic); and Scherbakova v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology [2000] FCA 1566 per Weinberg J.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MIDDLETON J