Vergara v Living and Leisure Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Vergara v Living and Leisure Australia Ltd [2013] FCA 775

Citation: Vergara v Living and Leisure Australia Ltd [2013] FCA 775
Parties: CLAUDIO VERGARA v LIVING AND LEISURE AUSTRALIA LIMITED, JOHN SCHRYVER, PETER KING and ROBERT WALTERS PTY LTD
File number: VID 164 of 2013
Judge: DAVIES J
Date of judgment: 8 August 2013
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application for leave to file claim out of time – No reasonable explanation for delay in filing – No real prejudice to respondents – Whether in the interests of justice to grant extension – Application refused.
Legislation: Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth)
Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)
Cases cited: Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen (1984)
3 FCR 344
Bahonko v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology [2006] FCA 1325
Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria (No 4) [2007] FCA 1449
Ingram-Nader v Brinks Australia Pty Ltd (2006) 151 FCR 524
Wedesweiller v Cole (1983) 47 ALR 528
Douglas v Allen (1984) 1 FCR 287
Hickey v Australian Telecommunications Commission (1983) 47 ALR 517
Lucic v Nolan (1982) 45 ALR 411
Lindsay v Rose, Registrar of Immigration Review Tribunal (1996) 44 ALD 570
ActewAGL Distribution v Australian Energy Regulator (2011) 195 FCR 142
Jandruwanda v Regency Park College of TAFE [2003] FCA 1455
Date of hearing: 8 August 2013
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 24
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the First, Second and Third Respondents: E Holt
Solicitor for the First, Second and Third Respondents: Herbert Smith Freehills
Counsel for the Fourth Respondent: N Harrington
Solicitor for the Fourth Respondent: Lander & Rogers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 164 of 2013

BETWEEN:

CLAUDIO VERGARA
Applicant

AND:

LIVING AND LEISURE AUSTRALIA LIMITED
First Respondent

JOHN SCHRYVER
Second Respondent

PETER KING
Third Respondent

ROBERT WALTERS PTY LTD
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

DAVIES J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 AUGUST 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s application for an extension of time under s 46PO(2) of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) is refused.

2.The applicant pay the respondents costs of the application.

3.The applicant pay the respondents costs of the proceeding.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 164 OF 2013

BETWEEN:

CLAUDIO VERGARA
Applicant

AND:

LIVING AND LEISURE AUSTRALIA LIMITED
First Respondent

JOHN SCHRYVER
Second Respondent

PETER KING
Third Respondent

ROBERT WALTERS PTY LTD

JUDGE:

DAVIES J

DATE:

8 AUGUST 2013

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. There are two applications before the Court:

    ·

    An application by the applicant (“Mr Vergara”) for an extension of time under


    s 46PO(2) of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) (“Human Rights Commission Act”) in which to make an application to the Court alleging unlawful discrimination and breach of contract…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vergara v Living and Leisure Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 775
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Vergara v Living and Leisure Australia Ltd involved an application by Mr Vergara for an extension of time to bring an application alleging unlawful discrimination against Living and Leisure Australia, Mr Schryver, and Mr King. The application was made to the Federal Court under section 46PO(2) of the Human Rights Commission Act, which grants the Court the power to extend the time for bringing such an application. The main issues for the Court to consider were the explanation for the delay in bringing the application, any prejudice to the respondents due to the delay, and whether Mr Vergara had an arguable case.

The Court considered the factors guiding the exercise of discretion to extend time, including the explanation for the delay, any prejudice to the respondents, and whether Mr Vergara had an arguable case. The Court was not satisfied that Mr Vergara had provided an acceptable reason for the delay, and found the additional delay of nearly three months to be inexcusable and unjustifiable. The Court also noted that although there was a factual foundation for the claims of racial discrimination, the Court was not persuaded that it should grant the extension of time. Consequently, the Court refused Mr Vergara’s application for an extension of time.

Robert Walters argued that the claim against it was incompetent because it was not a respondent to the complaint made by Mr Vergara to the Commission. The Court agreed with Robert Walters and found that section 46PO(1) of the Human Rights Commission Act only allows an application to be brought against a respondent to the terminated complaint. Since Robert Walters was not a respondent to the terminated complaint, the Court held that it did not have jurisdiction to hear a claim against it for unlawful discrimination. The Court also noted that even if Mr Vergara had sought to pursue a claim for racial discrimination against Robert Walters, that claim would have been incompetent.

In conclusion, the Court refused Mr Vergara’s application for an extension of time and found that the claim against Robert Walters was incompetent. The Court held that Mr Vergara had not provided an acceptable reason for the delay in bringing the application, and that it would not be fair and equitable to grant him an extension of time. The Court also found that the claim against Robert Walters was incompetent because it was not a respondent to the terminated complaint.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Court has the power under s 46PO(2) of the Human Rights Commission Act to grant the extension of time and the principals guiding the exercise of discretion to extend time are well established. The three main matters for the Court to take into account are:·the explanation for the delay; ·any prejudice to the respondents, including any prejudice to them in defending the proceedings occasioned by the delay; and·whether the applicant has an arguable case: Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen (1984) 3 FCR 344 at 348-9 per Wilcox J; Bahonko v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology [2006] FCA 1325 at [21]-[24] per Weinberg J; Bahonko v Nurses Board of Victoria (No 4) [2007] FCA 1449 at [47]-[48] per Middleton J.The background to the proposed application for unlawful discrimination Mr Vergara is a chartered accountant who, at the relevant time, was employed by the fourth respondent (“Robert Walters”), a labour supply firm. Between March and May 2009 Mr Vergara provided accountancy services to the first respondent (“Living and Leisure Australia”) under a labour supply contract between Robert Walters and Living and Leisure Australia. On 27 May 2009, Mr Vergara’s placement with Living and Leisure Australia was terminated following a direction by Living and Leisure Australia to Robert Walters. Mr Vergara complained to the Commission that he was unlawfully discriminated against whilst working at Living and Leisure Australia when he was subjected to racially-based name calling by the second and third respondents (“Mr Schryver” and “Mr King” respectively). He also claimed that he was treated unfairly by the summary termination of his placement without notice or explanation. He claimed that the termination was the direct result of asking for the name calling to stop. The Complaint was made against Living and Leisure Australia, Mr Schryver and Mr King. Mr Vergara did not complain to the Commission about Robert Walters. Living and Leisure Australia, Mr Schryver and Mr King jointly responded to the Complaint, in which they explained that the name calling was intended to be an “inclusive and friendly” nickname for Mr Vergara which had stemmed from Mr Schryver mishearing Mr Vergara’s first name. They disputed that the name calling constituted an act of racial discrimination or racial hatred. They also disputed the reason that Mr Vergara gave for the termination of his placement. They stated that the reason that Mr Vergara’s placement had been terminated was that complaints had been made on 18 or 19 May 2009 and 26 May 2009 about inappropriate conduct by Mr Vergara towards an employee of Living and Leisure Australia, Ms Ewin. They denied any nexus between the name calling about which Mr Vegara complained and the termination of his placement. The Commission facilitated conciliation discussions with the parties, but as the parties could not agree on appropriate terms of resolution, the Complaint could not be resolved. Accordingly, the President by her delegate terminated the Complaint pursuant to s 46PH(1)(i) of the Human Rights Commission Act. The notice of termination, issued on 23 May 2012, informed Mr Vergara about his right to make application to the Federal Court or the Federal Magistrates’ Court (as it was then known) alleging unlawful discrimination by one or more respondents to the Complaint and that the application must be made within sixty days of the date on the notice of termination.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Robert Walters argued that the claim against it is incompetent because it was not a respondent to the Complaint that Mr Vergara made to the Commission. In the course of argument Mr Vergara was asked to clarify whether his claim against Robert Walters was for racial discrimination or for breach of contract or both. Mr Vergara indicated that he only sought to pursue the breach of contract claim against Robert Walters. This was not made clear in the application but to put the matter beyond doubt, the Court has no jurisdiction in respect of a racial discrimination claim against Robert Walters. Section 46PO(1) of the Human Rights Commission Act only allows an application to this Court or to the Federal Circuit Court alleging unlawful discrimination “by one or more of the respondents to the terminated complaint”. As Robert Walters was not a respondent to the terminated complaint, s 46PO(1) precludes an application being brought against it for unlawful discrimination: Jandruwanda v Regency Park College of TAFE [2003] FCA 1455 at [11] per Selway J.Conclusion Although I am not satisfied that the delay in making the application has occasioned prejudice to the respondents and although I am satisfied that there is a factual foundation for the claims of racial discrimination, I am not persuaded that I should grant the extension of time. It is material to the exercise of the Court’s discretion that Mr Vergara has not provided any acceptable reason for not commencing the proceeding promptly after the conclusion of the Ewin proceedings. The additional delay of nearly three months is inexcusable and unjustifiable. In the circumstances, where it was within the control of Mr Vergara to make this application at the least nearly three months earlier than he did, it would not be fair and equitable to grant him an extension of time. Accordingly, Mr Vergara’s application is refused.APPLICATION BY ROBERT WALTERS TO STRIKE OUT THE CLAIM AGAINST IT As Mr Vergara has been refused an extension of time in which to make the application, it is not necessary now to strike out the claim against Robert Walters. However, for the reasons given, had Mr Vergara sought to pursue a claim for racial discrimination against it, that claim was incompetent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established