Reurich v Sureway Employment and Training Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Reurich v Sureway Employment and Training Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 680

File number: NSD 2015 of 2017
Judge: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 17 May 2018
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for extension of time – where no reasonable explanation for substantial delay in making application – where there is a risk of prejudice to respondents – where evidence unclear as to whether applicant had an arguable case – whether extension of time should be granted – application refused.  
Legislation: Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) ss 46PO(1), 46PO(2), 46PO(3)
Cases cited:

Eliezer v University of Sydney (2015) 239 FCR 381

Tang v AHG Services (NSW) Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1532

Vergara v Living and Leisure Australia Ltd [2013] FCA 775

Date of hearing: 18 April 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 51
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the First, Second, Fifth and Sixth Respondents: Ms A Sharp
Solicitor for the First, Second, Fifth and Sixth Respondents: Bartier Perry

ORDERS

NSD 2015 of 2017
BETWEEN:

PETER GEORGE REURICH

Applicant

AND:

SUREWAY EMPLOYMENT AND TRAINING PTY LTD

First Respondent

LISA NELSON

Second Respondent

EMMA BROWN (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 MAY 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s application for an extension of time under s 46PO(2) of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) (AHRC Act) be dismissed.

2.The amended originating application under the AHRC Act be dismissed.

3.The applicant pay the first, second, fifth and sixth respondents’ costs of the proceeding.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MARKOVIC J:

  1. The applicant, Peter George Reurich, seeks an extension of time pursuant to s 46PO(2) of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) (AHRC Act) to make his application under that Act.

  2. Mr Reurich lodged a complaint with the Australian Human Rights Commission (Commission) against Sureway Skills Training Pty Ltd alleging unlawful discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) (DD Act) which was terminated by the Commission on 11 May 2016. Pursuant to s 46PO(2), in the absence of further time being allowed by the court, Mr Reurich had until 10 July 2016 to make his application to this Court or the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

  3. Mr Reurich lodged the originating application commencing this proceeding on 16 November 2017 which was 18 months and 5 days after the termination by the Commission of Mr Reurich’s complaint and 16 months and 6 days after the last day permitted by s 46PO(2) of the AHRC Act for the making of such an application. With the leave of the Court Mr Reurich subsequently filed an amended originating application in which he corrected the name of the first respondent.

  4. Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reurich v Sureway Employment and Training Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 680
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Reurich v Sureway Employment and Training Pty Ltd involved an application by Mr Reurich for an extension of time to lodge a complaint with the Federal Court of Australia, following a termination of his complaint by the Australian Human Rights Commission. The respondents, Sureway Employment and Training Pty Ltd and others, opposed the application, citing the substantial delay and potential prejudice to their case. The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether the delay in filing the application was justified and whether granting an extension would cause undue prejudice to the respondents.

The court found that Mr Reurich had not provided an adequate explanation for the delay in lodging his application, despite acknowledging the 60-day period following the termination notice from the Commission. The court emphasised that Mr Reurich's explanation, which included personal difficulties and memory issues, did not sufficiently account for the significant delay, particularly after receiving advice from Justice Connect in June 2017 that he was out of time. The court also noted that while there was some risk of prejudice to the respondents due to the resignation of certain employees, this factor was not heavily weighed given the limited evidence on efforts to locate potential witnesses.

Consequently, the court ruled that Mr Reurich's application for an extension of time should be refused. The court concluded that the lack of a satisfactory explanation for the delay, coupled with the potential prejudice to the respondents, did not warrant the exercise of discretion in favour of Mr Reurich. Additionally, the court dismissed Mr Reurich's amended originating application and ordered him to pay the costs of the proceeding to the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s application for an extension of time under s 46PO(2) of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) (AHRC Act) be dismissed.

2. The amended originating application under the AHRC Act be dismissed.

3. The applicant pay the first, second, fifth and sixth respondents’ costs of the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Respondents oppose Mr Reurich’s application for an extension of time. BACKGROUND Mr Reurich lodged a complaint with the Commission in which:(1) at p 4 he noted that his complaint was about both an organisation and an individual. Under the heading “Organisation” he nominated “Sureways Vincentia” and under the heading “Individual” he nominated Miss Lisa “and another supervisor and others” and stated that he did not know their last names;(2)under the heading “What is the complaint about?” he noted that he had been discriminated against because of his disability and, by checking the relevant boxes, referred to his assistance animal, harassment, that he was discriminated against because of his age, that his human rights had been breached by a Commonwealth government body and that he had been treated unfairly because of another reason, including victimisation; and(3)under the heading “Details of the complaint” Mr Reurich noted that the alleged events were said to have happened at “11.00 am Friday 5th 2015” and included a description of the events the subject of his complaint. The Commission provided a copy of Mr Reurich’s complaint to Sureway on 24 July 2015 and Sureway provided its response to the Commission on 18 September 2015. By letter dated 11 May 2016 addressed to Mr Reurich, a delegate of the president of the Commission informed Mr Reurich of her decision to terminate his complaint under s 46PH(1)(i) of the AHRC Act “against Sureway Skills Training Pty Ltd, alleging disability discrimination and victimisation under the [DD Act]” because she was satisfied that there was no reasonable prospect of the matter being settled by conciliation. That letter thereafter stated:The AHRCA says that after a complaint is terminated, the person affected by the alleged discrimination may apply to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCCA) or the Federal Court of Australia (FCA) to have the allegations decided by the court. Information about the court or the court process is available from a court registry or from their websites at and must apply to the FCCA or the FCA within sixty (60) days of the date on the Notice of Termination.(original emphasis) A notice of termination dated 11 May 2016 was enclosed with the Commission’s letter. It identified Mr Reurich as the complainant and Sureway Skills Training Pty Ltd as the respondent and relevantly stated that:This complaint alleging unlawful discrimination and victimisation under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), has been terminated under section 46PH(1)(i) of the [AHRC Act] as I am satisfied there is no reasonable prospect of the matter being settled by conciliation. As noted above at [3], on 16 November 2017 Mr Reurich lodged the originating application with the Court in which, under the heading “Extension of time”, Mr Reurich states (as written):The Applicant asks for an extension of time to lodge this application because I am late as I have suffered great depression and Anxiety and was confused about the Termination (can be verified by emails I have continually asked the Human Rights commission about it) and when I did seek to sort it I was told by Self representation people from Justice connect that I should not proceed. However I do want to seek justice the bullying as what happened to me is still happening to me others and even today I am being discriminated against by Sureway by the treatment they continue to dish out to myself and boofhead my assistance Dog . My Psychologist believes I have autism or asperses syndromes and yet I have been seeking employment with some success but mostly short lived because of no Sureway case workers to consult or support me because of the restrictions unfairly even illegally exercised on me.EVIDENCE

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As noted above at [3], on 16 November 2017 Mr Reurich lodged the originating application with the Court in which, under the heading “Extension of time”, Mr Reurich states (as written):The Applicant asks for an extension of time to lodge this application because I am late as I have suffered great depression and Anxiety and was confused about the Termination (can be verified by emails I have continually asked the Human Rights commission about it) and when I did seek to sort it I was told by Self representation people from Justice connect that I should not proceed. However I do want to seek justice the bullying as what happened to me is still happening to me others and even today I am being discriminated against by Sureway by the treatment they continue to dish out to myself and boofhead my assistance Dog . My Psychologist believes I have autism or asperses syndromes and yet I have been seeking employment with some success but mostly short lived because of no Sureway case workers to consult or support me because of the restrictions unfairly even illegally exercised on me.EVIDENCE Mr Reurich relies on an affidavit affirmed by him on 19 February 2018 in support of his application for an extension of time. In that affidavit he relevantly said that he was aware of the 60 day rule so he “cannot explain why [he] did not get a grip as [he] knew the importance of the time limit”. He also said:1.However this is why I am so perplexed that I either over looked the Termination email or missed it in my emails because it was sent to me believe; or was my brain not functioning as I do know that it was foremost in my mind to react immediately to a Termination and start the Application soon as possible IF I had Known2.My life is extremely busy and unordered at tht time ;Cars breaking down fixed and eventually blew up ; two weeks on pedal bike before getting a new wheels (OLD CAR) ; chasing work ;actually getting work employment then computer crashed a number of time I think 3 times in the last few years ;I have proof from my IT man whom repaired it 'and payment records and email3.About that time of the Termination I actually sent a email for a meeting with my psychologist Tamara complaining that brain was not working properly and I was forgetting important things and not remembering properly due to stress of my job and other factors perhaps? Annexure "A2"4.Also I was receiving emails from the Human Rights Commission apologising to me for the length of time these complaints were taking asking me to be patient and I was also sending extra information to enlighten them. It became all to confusing for me Mr Reurich’s affidavit included the following annexures:(1)an email dated 5 May 2016 from Mr Reurich to Tamara Lee who, according to Mr Reurich, is his psychologist, in which he wrote:Job going OKmemory is stretched; I forget things and have to check my self to much stress had been bad but better now; boos tell s me to not ring tradies; I give them the shits; I have taken this on board; he wants me to do more Quantities and track jobs so I have come up my tracking thing in attachment ; almost 4 weeks ;Can you fit me in as I have this JBC court thing and I may need another letter from you or affidavit about my integrity and perhaps I should see that head shrink soon; I can possibly afford him now; Boof loves going to work and the bosses and the office girls love him (2)an email dated 21 June 2017 from Justice Connect to Mr Reurich in which Alexandra Farmer, a senior lawyer in Justice Connect’s self-representation service, said:I refer to our telephone conversation today.For the Self Representation Service to properly assess your potential claims against the two employment agencies, it is important that we review any documents you have from them - either correspondence they have given or sent to you or the FOI-documents you have referred to. At the moment we have only reviewed your complaint material.As discussed, it would be best if we could also review of copy of the reply Sureways provided to the AHRC. The AHRC notice of termination in that matter indicates Sureways' reply was provided to the AHRC on 18/09/2015 and that the AHRC sent you a copy of the reply on 16/10/2015. I note you said you don't recall receiving that reply but maybe if you check your emails from around that time (if you still have them) you might find it there. Alternatively you could contact the AHRC to check whether they would be willing to re-send you a copy.If you are able to send through these further documents, we'll have another look and advise what assistance, if any, we can provide.Please remember that the time limitations to make a human rights application to the federal courts to determine both the Sureways and Campbell Page matters have elapsed and you will need to seek and extension of time in both if you decide to proceed. For this reason it is important not to delay any further.(emphasis added)In relation to Ms Farmer’s email, Mr Reurich deposed that:Justice Connect refused to help me file because I was late ;however this is about the time I realised something was amiss and I sent Hein from Human Rights commission email requesting the Termination email as I could not find it on my computer ;must have deleted it by accident So I tried to correct the mistake June/July for both … and Sureway

Decision

Reasons for decision

There seem to me to be factual issues that require resolution, including but not limited to the nature of the interaction between Mr Reurich and Sureway and the reason for Sureway issuing the June Letter which banned Mr Reurich from attending Sureway’s premises and prescribed the way in which Mr Reurich was to interact with Sureway staff in relation to its provision of services. Those are issues which cannot be resolved on the material available to the Court on this application. CONCLUSION While there seems to be a factual dispute between Mr Reurich and Sureway which, if resolved in Mr Reurich’s favour, may well be a foundation for his claims of unlawful discrimination under the DD Act, I am not persuaded that I should exercise my discretion and grant the extension of time sought by Mr Reurich. First, this Court does not have jurisdiction to determine the claim against Ms Nelson, Mr Roberts and Ms Gain. Secondly, there is a risk of some prejudice to the Respondents occasioned by the delay, although this factor does not carry much weight given the lack of evidence in relation to efforts taken to locate potential witnesses. But finally and critically, I am not satisfied that Mr Reurich has provided an adequate explanation for the lengthy delay in making his application after the expiration of the 60 day period following the termination of his complaint to the Commission. The lack of adequate explanation is exacerbated by there being no explanation proffered for the period of delay following his communication with Justice Connect in June 2017 until November 2017 when Mr Reurich finally made his application to the Court. Mr Reurich’s application for an extension of time pursuant to s 46PO(2) of the AHRC Act is refused and should be dismissed. The practical effect of a refusal to extend time is that Mr Reurich cannot prosecute his application and the proceeding is at an end. Accordingly, I will also make an order that the amended originating application filed by Mr Reurich be dismissed. The Respondents seek an order that Mr Reurich pay their costs of the proceeding. Given the conclusion I have reached, I will make that order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At [14] Jagot J said that, while she had the power to extend the time for making an application to the Court, there had to be some material sufficient to persuade her that the discretion to do so should be exercised in the applicant’s favour. Her Honour noted that while the delay was not particularly long, it was also not a short delay. In light of the 60 day period available, Jagot J was not persuaded, in all of the circumstances, that the discretion should be exercised in favour of the applicant.CONSIDERATIONDelay Mr Reurich was aware of the 60 day time limit. His explanation for the delay seems to be that he overlooked the termination notice from the Commission and/or because his “brain was not functioning”. He also submitted that perhaps relevant reminder emails went into his junk mail box and he did not know to check there. He described his life as extremely busy and disordered at the time. That Mr Reurich’s life was busy and disordered is no more than a manifestation of the “daily exigencies” of his life. The fact that Mr Reurich may have overlooked the termination notice from the Commission, perhaps because he was busy or because of the disorder in his life is not, in my opinion, an acceptable explanation for the delay. Mr Reurich knew that he had made a complaint to the Commission. It was incumbent on him to follow up and monitor communications from the Commission about it. On 5 May 2016 Mr Reurich described his memory as “stretched” and said that he forgot things. At that time he sought out an appointment with Tamara Lee, who he described as his psychologist. But, even if I accept this evidence and that Mr Reurich was having some memory difficulty in early May 2016, it does not explain the delay following the 60 day period after receipt of the notice of termination. As is evident from the email from Ms Farmer at Justice Connect referred to at [12(2)] above, by 21 June 2017 Mr Reurich was well and truly aware of the fact that his complaint had been terminated by the Commission and, indeed, that he was already out of time in making an application to the Federal Circuit Court or this Court. Thus, even if I was satisfied that Mr Reurich had an acceptable explanation for his delay up until that point in time, which I am not, he has provided no explanation for the further delay of nearly five months up until the date he lodged his application with this Court. In my opinion, Mr Reurich has not provided a satisfactory explanation for the significant delay in making his application to the Court.Prejudice The Respondents submitted that they have suffered prejudice as a result of Mr Reurich’s delay in commencing the proceeding. That prejudice is said to be caused by two things: first, because certain employees relevant to the claim, Ms Brown, Ms Weeks and Ms Jackson, have resigned from Sureway during the period of the delay and Sureway does not have current addresses for those former employees; and secondly, because the passing of time will have caused the memories of relevant witnesses to fade.